I love pizza! I love great customer service! I would recommend this restaurant location to everyone.

If you appreciate a phenomenal vodka sauce with the PERFECT balance of mouth watering flavors, this is the place to go! Always above and beyond with fantastic pizza, Milly's also has amazing pasta, salads and sandwiches that combine a premium portable dining experience with GREAT prices! read more

Milly's Pizzeria - Penne alla Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food is fresh and tasty. One time specific request not followed (make crust thin) but a little burnt. But overall good. Delivers fairly quickly. It's one of my go-to's. read more

Pizza used to be really good they fell off badly the taste isn't there anymore and the wings were just horrible smh i can see them closing real soon if they don't fix up!!!! read more

It's amazing. Food always great n the employees always friendly n courteous. You can't go wrong here everything from pizza to past to salads- they are all great! read more

We came at 11pm and the service was just as excellent! Nino was so friendly and he gave us fresh and tasty pizza!

Lunchtime in Bushwich! Ive ordered twice from this location and so far the original cheese pizza is great, the buffalo wings are nice and spicy the caesar salad is just right for the price must eat same day. The price is reasonable. I'd come back anytime for a quick grab-and-go, I wouldn't stay to eat. There are a lot of homeless people in the area that come in to ask for food or money this is the only reason I'm for the 4 stars. The area is not great but the pizza is worth the trip. The ambiance is neural. read more

Milly's Pizzeria - Regular Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great pizza but long delivery time. I didn't take a picture this time because I waited so long for my food that when it arrived I had missing wings and had to wait even longer for the wings to arrive to then eat my pizza and wings. I can't have one without the other lol. 4 stars because they were truly apologetic about the missing wings and they were extremely nice. Great customer service and great tasting pizza. They even close late which is a bonus for me. read more

Awesome pizza I totally recommend ordering you'll be a repeat customer try it... you won't be disappointed

The reviews on here really go both ways. So I said ok, lemme see what the real deal is with this place. Born and raised NYer and I know my pizza. Yo, deadass, you can trust that you're better off with a dollar slice than this place. For one, my man working there heated my slice yet somehow it was still not hot. I'm not one to complain, I'm not interested in eating a snot rocket, I just won't return to a place if I don't like it. Aside from that - the pizza was just total garbage. Regular slices are super small? Sauce is bad, cheese is bad.... I don't even know how you achieve this degree of bad, like I could do better with my toaster oven at home. This literally might be the worst pizza I've ever had in my 40 years eating pizza in NYC. Literally go ANYWHERE else. read more

Milly's Pizzeria - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I just love their food! Taste and decorations are unbelievably awesome and my stomach is always thanking them back. I have eaten practically every type of food; from chicken salad, Ranch pizza, Chicken Francess, vanilla vodka, chicken mozzarella cheese salad, and etc. them and my kids. read more

Milly's Pizzeria - Deliciozo wow - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Really gross and amateur. For one i walked in and the employee acted like he didn't see me and let this man cut me. But the pizza was super greasy and the cheese was like slipping off the pizza the sauce wasn't cooked. It was just gross wouldn't come back here. read more

Milly's Pizzeria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Good place to grab you a quick bite. The pizza here is pretty good. Just make sure to ask the gentleman to warm it up and make it "very hot". The workers here are nice. However, the neighborhood is sketchy and has only gotten worse since the pandemic. Bums and junkies are littered all over the place so make sure to stay on point. But I never had an issue coming here for the past decade or so. read more

This the spot. Best pizza in the area imo and at a very good price. Dudes that run the place are super chill. Eat here way too often. 10/10 recommend. read more

So my boyfriend and I are still on the fence. He hated it, I enjoyed parts of it. My first complaint, we ordered thru seamless at 1:40 on a Saturday afternoon. At 3:20 I get a call the from the delivery guy asking me to come down. This is bias of mine, but if I order delivery it should come to my door. I ordered because I was to lazy to put on pants. So I calmly told him the build has two elevators that would bring him to my floor. He came up we got the food, open the box to the Sicilian pizza and half the pizza is on the lid of the box. Rookie mistake! After scraping off the cheese from the box I got down on my slice. I thought it was perfect, the crust was seasoned well. My boyfriend thought it tasted like Ellos pizza. The garlic knots were hard as hell, like break a tooth, how do you have the balls to serve these garlic flavored marbles. The price was great, but if your looking for good old style pizza that will rock your world, spend a little more and go to Sal's. read more

Milly's Pizzeria - Rookie mistake, I don't like cardboard on my pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Milly's has always been solid and I love the guys who work there. Fast and affordable NY slices. Simple. No complaints.

I will never spend another dollar at Milly's Pizzeria at 834 Broadway in Brooklyn! My Sicilian pie was a dry crusted tasteless mess and the garlic knots were even worse. I placed it for delivery ave it arrived late and warmish===cold! Never again read more

Milly's Pizzeria - Sicilian pie barely fills half of the box and tasteles, dry garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best classic pie in the city. NY born-and-raised 100% baresi/napolitana principessa giornalista di Yelp says so. The cheese is so fresh it produces that kind of salty creamy milk that blends with the sauce and creates the perfect balance of tart, creamy, and savory. THE CRUST IS HEAD AND SHOULDERS ABOVE EVERY OTHER PLACE because it is flaky and buttery like Uno or something. Since I found this place on seamless I don't order from anyplace else, certainly have no appetite for hipster fuckery from Norbert's (::agitated cough::) We always order extra cheese with no oregano. It is sublime and transcendent. Also they deliver QUICK FAST. -Adriana con il buon capelli read more

I'm never one to get food delivered to my house, multiple restaurants have a hard time delivering on time. This review is based on going to this pizza shop in person. It's a small pizza shop but I honestly have little to no complaints about this shop. You get what you pay for and their food is pretty delicious. I decided to try a Fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp and it was pretty good. The only thing I would recommend would be for their Alfredo sauce to be a little thicker, but that's just my personal preference. The pasta was great flavor wise. read more

Milly's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

After the disaster that was Mike's Pizza, I knew full well I needed a solid pizzeria within ten minutes' walking distance. Milly's had some strong reviews, so I gave it a try. It's not in a great part of town, but is very clean and cool inside. There's nothing too fancy, a few Italian options (the chicken parm hero is well-reviewed, though I didn't get it), but it's mostly pizza, so that's what I went with. The pizza was very good! The definition of thin crust, but also sturdy, so you can fold it and go without it flopping on you - exactly like a good thin crust should be. Two plain slices and a bottled water came to $5, so no gripes about the price here either. This is looking like my new go-to pizzeria! read more

Milly's Pizza, Moses Pizza, I don't really care - this stuff is mad delicious! I'm only going to order my pizza from here from now on, it's just too perfect every time. I also got their fries, which are like the potato slices of God's gentlest angel. Stop playing silly little games with your tastebuds and get yourself a pizza from here. Feel free to message me later with thanks, gift card codes, haikus etc. read more

Save yourself! If I could give a zero-star rating I would. Milly's pizza was a decidedly yucky experience. My hand to God, my calzone was made with Pillsbury's dinner rolls instead of actual pizza dough. My wife's chicken parm hero was a greasy fried chicken cutlet on stale bread with a little bit of sauce and cheese. Neither of us could eat much of our order. Don't waste your money on this extremely bad "Italian-American" food! read more

Always get the pasta with meat sauce when hungover. So good. Pair it with a sprite and you're in business. read more

So I saw the owner replied saying that I "know they're better than this" - - except I really don't. All of the food I have ever gotten from Milly's, or seen when I've gone there, has fit my 2-star review. I've given them numerous chances, as they're the only pizza place within a five block radius, but it always turns out the same. I've tried the pizza. Bland, stale, old, basic, etc. I've tried the chicken tenders. They had tendons in them. Just... no. Nino, if you want good reviews here, you can't just come on to pacify the people who are upset by writing replies here. You have to actually serve food that is worth eating. read more

I have been eating here since it was Moses...The new management and name change to Milly's was a huge improvement. I'd get like a slice and go when it was Moses, but the Milly's team is so friendly and welcoming I started ordering different items from the menu (something I rarely do at a pizza slice joint). I am like addicted to the Ravioli, it's quick easy and inexpensive - and tastes great. I really am picky about my slices too - in the city I only eat it at few spots, like Joe's or Artichoke - I just won't eat crappy slices. Milly's is the best slice by far I've found in Bushwick and the only place I will buy it. Lastly I need to mention the staff at Milly's, they are friendly and engaging...you feel a part of the neighborhood when you are there. read more

I hate writing reviews like this, but I have to because the food was inedible. The pizza had no flavor and the texture of the cheese was questionable. Some.how the pizza was rubbery and the crust was hard at the same time. The garlic knots were hard and dry as if they were made earlier that day, then were thrown in the microwave. For the amount of butter and garlic they had on them, they still had no flavor. I would have been way more satisfied with a bag of Coolranch Doritos for dinner. I would have ingested the same amount of calories and my food would have had flavor. Stay away. read more

I created an account just to write this review.. So today I didn't want to cook and needed to feed myself and my Daughter and I ordered. Food came after an hour and was cold. I had to reheat the food myself. I ordered chicken fingers and french fries for my daughter and I had to take the fries that you can tell were fried a few times and were old and bake them to get some of the grease out and to make them crunchy again. The chicken tenders HAD NO TASTE WHAT SO EVER but she ate everything anyway.. Let's get into the EggPlant Parm that was for me. First off this came to me cold as well. It was def had a lot of cheese and that was because it was cover the eggplant that was not in complete slices but in small pieces. I said to myself ok well that looks good ( I didn't see under the cheese ) and the first thing that I did was take the bread which was good (only thing that was good) and dipped it into the sauce of the Eggplant parm and the first thing that I said to myself was NOPE, it's going to be horrible but you need to eat anyway. After serving myself the eggplant wasn't even crispy ( EGGPLANT PARM, is supposed to be crispy). The salad even looked nasty... Bottom Line.. I wish I would've ordered dominos or papa johns.. I can just imagine what their pizza must taste like. People here who say that the pizza is great really does not know what really good food is.. This place F**KING sucked read more

This place is an absolute nightmare! Ordered food via GrubHub. Food was delivered on time (only reason I don't feel bad about having to give this place one star) My penne ala vodka was cold and barely covered the bottom of the container they put it in. Despite the pasta being cold, the chicken was burnt and they couldn't even toast the bread. Halfway through my meal, I pull a piece of steel wool out of my mouth. Disgusted and horrified, I spent the next 20 minutes throwing up. Stay away from this place!! read more

Milly's Pizzeria - Found a piece of steel wool in my Penne. Absolutely disgusting!! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This review has nothing to do with delivery speed or friendliness of people that work there. This is strictly about their horrible disgusting putrid food. I am embarrassed as a native New Yorker about their quality of food. If any tourists came to New York and/or Brooklyn for their first time and thought to themselves "Hey, Lets try Millys, their reviews are good," i would be embarrassed to have them try Millys. Their pizza tastes a week old, to be nice. Their garlic bread is free for a reason, my dog didnt even want it. Their penne ala vodka is no where near how a true italian penne ala vodka should taste. They should be embarrassed they pass this off as italian food and I hope nobodys tries this awful place. GO TO L&B ASAP. IF YOU KNOW U KNOW read more

Well idk about all these negative reviews but my my my.. it makes my mouth water just thinking about their pizza. The sauce is authentic and the cheese is perfect! I'm always greedy so I asked for extra all the time when ordering on grubhub or on the phone (which I must say VERY) good customer service) & people we live in New York! Get over having to pay more for good quality! Also I work in the food business as well if your known to be a cheap stake that doesn't give tip to the delivery guys.. they will take very long to deliver your food! It's no secret that if you want good service, food, or anything in NYC pay up buddy. But definitely recommend this pizza! My friends all switched to this place after me raving about it all the time read more

2 stars for delivery being in time. Ordered a grandma pie, barely any sauce (just bread and cheese). So much parmesan on top it was barely edible. Really bad for an $18 pizza. read more

Milly's Pizzeria - "Grandma pie" just stale bread and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The mozz stix were good. The thin crust sicillian pizza is... weird. It's hard to describe: the crust is floury and flaky like focaccia or flour tortilla chips but really greasy. Kinda strange on pizza. The tomato sauce is very sweet. Overall tasted strange and not great. read more

Cheese tastes like play-doh and looks like it too. Came extra cold. Nothing like having to heat up your take out in the oven. Might as well get frozen. Crust is as tasteless as the sauce. Crust is dry. $12 I'm never getting back. read more

We got the pepperoni pizza and it was super greasy. Definitely not worth $17. However the delivery arrived early and the pizza was hot.

This place is the best since Tonys pizza on Dekalb, just found it a year ago i buy from there every friday i recommend the spagati and meat balls, and the stuffed shells and the ziti and chicken with broccoli in garlic sause, and the pizza is all ( A Plus) small place great food runned by great people read more

This place is mediocre at best. Ordered a few times all were pretty terrible. Their delivery people could use some hospitality training.

The problem with this pizza is the crust. The texture is completely wrong. It has a flakiness that makes me think there's butter in it. When you take a bite, it just kind of dissolves into flour. The reviewer who said the crust tastes like Pillsbury rolls hit the nail on the head. It's exactly like that. read more

Second time going for the same plate...that is penne a la vodka with shrimps for me and for my daughters penne a la vodka with grilled chicken. To take out..when home with the plates , pasta looked sticky., not saucy at all... the first time I had ordered these , we stayed at the shop, and ate it there..what a difference it made? Next time i would ordered to stay, just to make sure they are doing their best.. good service, they have many customers who seemed to be well known at the restaurant, my advice: pizza was better. read more

Love this place, it's your classic walk-in cheap pizza joint. The people that work there are AMAZING! Great atmosphere and wonderful vibe. Absolutely love the pizza too! read more

The cheese tastes like plastic !! Cheapest cheese ever ! Then again i did purchase a slice at 12 am but still not good, my mouth had a horrible after taste almost like petroleum. read more