4.5 stars Yard Sale: Vegi combo's with meat are my go to. The tomato sauce is rich, flavorful, top grade. Not sure if I like their dough but works very well with the sauce. The chains name might be dated, but I've always enjoyed their pizza. read more

Holy cow! What a deal.... They offered their so-called "signature slice" but dude, it should be called "double slice" because basically it's two slices of pizza for only $7.45!! Then there was a large 20 ounce of Heineken for ONLY $5.00 today- ice cold glass! Your choice 16 or 20 ounces! The pizza Chef came out, served my pizza and asked me if I wanted some ranch dressing. Wow, what service and great ambience in a nice clean hip environment! So, I had the veggie pizza which was fantastic with onions, tomatoes, spinach, and more! My friendly server PRETTI deserves a gold medal for expert service and friendliness! This has got to be one of the best deals in Berkeley. Don't hesitate, don't be late, get in here bring a date. read more

See all

The pizza was average, the wings were disgusting and did not even look like wings. I wish I had taken pictures.

I had the cheese pizza and the sausage pizza. I liked the cheese slice more, and I think it had a garlic seasoning, which I liked. It had decently good flavor but was a bit on the salty side, and the ingredients aren't the greatest quality. read more

Extreme Pizza - Classic Cheese Pizza and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Berkeley, California

love the spice route and tandoori wings. love how they also have many variety of beers on tap and welcoming staff

Very tasty pizza. Dine in or take out. Their slices (actually two slices) are a great value. Friendly staff.

I had a very disappointing experience at Extreme Pizza. The entire process was extremely disorganized and confusing. My pizza was sitting there for about 10 minutes while the employees were trying to figure out which pizza belonged to which customer. What made it even more frustrating was that I was asked four separate times what pizza I ordered, even though the same employee had just rung me up about 15 minutes earlier and had already asked me twice before that. There seemed to be a major communication and language barrier, and the situation was handled very poorly. When I finally expressed that I was unhappy about my pizza sitting there for so long, the employee then tried to charge me $0.60 for cheese and peppers, apparently because of a mistake that had occurred during the ordering process. I did not feel that I should have been charged extra because of an error on their end. Overall, the experience was completely discombobulated, unprofessional, and frustrating. I understand that mistakes happen, but the lack of organization, repeated questioning, and the way the situation was handled made this a very poor customer-service experience. I hope management addresses these issues because customers should not have to deal with this kind of confusion after placing and paying for an order. read more

It's back and newly remodeled, super cute inside. Surfboard as backdrop for beer pulls. I always get railroad gage (meat slice). Listen for $8.50 total it's such a deal, 2 decent sized slices, now I work on Ashby so will go afterwork sometimes. Guys who work there are very nice and respectful. NOTE: Parking is usually available in front, unlike before when it was farther down Shattuck and very difficult. Very happy with this location, Oakland location closed years back, now it's Mama's Boy which I don't prefer. read more

Extreme Pizza has the friendliest workers, incredibly good prices and pretty decent pizza! The salads are huge and half the price of Mixt. I usually get the gluten free crust which is nice and thin, but I wouldn't recommend putting too many toppings on it because it isn't as sturdy as a regular crust. read more

Fast delivery, good price and cheesy, tasty pizza . There are better pizzas but for this price my pizza hit the spot!

I was working in Berkeley and saw that Extreme Pizza had just opened. I have eaten at other locations so decided to stop in. It has a very nice layout when you walk in. There are some tables and a bar. I ordered the Everest Pizza and it was absolutely delicious. There was plenty of sausage, pepperoni, salami and meatballs and the sauce had a very nice taste!. I also took some cheesecake to go and it was amazing. I didn't order a salad, but I saw a few being made and they looked very fresh! They also have calzones, wings and sub sandwiches . I saw there was beer but not sure what other alcohol they have. I met the owner and she was so sweet and welcoming and I will definitely come back to this location! read more

Extreme Pizza - Everest Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Berkeley, California

The pizzas are incredible. Since this Extreme Pizza opened on our block, we crave it. I've tried 8 different pizzas- all of which made me melt with joy. My husband is obsessed with the Yard Sale and newly the Double Dipsy sandwich! I have never eaten so much pizza in my life and I'm not sorry for it. We tell everyone- run! Don't walk. Try this place right away. The owners are kind and make you feel like family right away. Join for a Warriors game sometime! We will likely be there! read more

Went to the newly renovated location. Tried their twist and vegetarian pizza. Infact surprised to see soo many veggie pizza options. Very friendly staff and quick service. read more

See all

Super Bowl pizza was awesome here. Spice route is my favorite, amazing flavors and reasonable prices

This place has the most regular pizza. I give it a solid meh. The crust is like cardboard and the sauce is just ok. The wings are pretty good if they make them extra crispy. That is the only reason I gave them 2 stars and not 1. There are a thousand more places you could go for better pizza. read more

This place was recommended by a friend, so decided to give it a try. Got a medium Spice Route very flavorful pizza . Also got an order of the zip line knots which were to die for! Ended the meal with their big chewy cookie . Paul took care of us and had a really great experience. Everyone was welcoming and friendly. If you are in the area definitely recommend this place. read more

Extreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Berkeley, California

Great pizza with really flavorful sauce. Service is good as well and the food gets made quick. Prices are very reasonable as well. Definitely recommend. read more

Mr. Pestato Head Pizza i just stopped by this newly renovated pizza. New owner is super nice. Enjoyed the pizaa with great quality. They have wide variety of options. Vegetation options are also great. They have great location and clean environment. read more

Extreme Pizza - Mr. Pestato Head Pizza i just stopped by this newly renovated pizza. New owner is super nice. Enjoyed the pizaa with great quality. - Pizza Near Me - Berkeley, California

The new location is awesome. I hated the old extreme but these owners really care about food quality and great service! They have great vegetarian selections with their veggie wings and substitutions. They also have super affordable slices if you walk in. There's a good selection of beers on tap and hopefully more ciders soon! read more

Probably the best pizza in the area and for $7.95 a gigantic slice (the pizza is delicious and fresy) and $2.50 for their jumbo chocolate chip cookies (which were incredible and very fresh) you cannot beat the price and quality! read more

Extreme pizza is Extremely mediocre. It's is probably okay for small children, but for those who prefer actual flavor, you'll do better with frozen pizza from the supermarket. read more

I had to update my review! That was completely my mistake. The food came one time it was soo delicious! I love extreme pizza

The old Extreme Pizza location on Shattuck Avenue was a go-to for us, and we've missed it (and some of our favorite pizzas, including Railroad Grade, Green With Envy and the one that now goes under the name Mammoth-something). So it was nice to see that Extreme reopened last week in a new building on the same block. We stopped in for a late afternoon slice and beer. The pizza was as good as we remembered it. It's a small but neatly appointed shop with a nice bar, and the folks who served us, Annie and Preet, were great -- really friendly and attentive. It's nice to see Extreme back in Berkeley! read more

Extreme Pizza used to be one of our go to spots before the original location was closed when new apartments were being built. So glad to have it back in Berkeley after what feels like forever! The pizza was as good as I remember, and the staff were very friendly when I was picking up. Extreme Pizza has some really unique specialty pizzas that you just can't get at other places. I highly recommend giving them a go! read more

Good food and great customer service, me and my husband visited last night and enjoyed a great selection of pizza. Will definitely recommend! read more

Excellent customer service with friendly staff. Chicken pesto sandwich was so good the price and size felt like a deal. Was also somehow just as good left over the next day. Clean store and even with a small location they manage to make it feel spacious and comfortable. read more

Place closed down during Covid and now has new owners!!! It's way better Food is very unique and delicious. One of the better pizza places in Berkeley for sure read more

First of all, the food was delicious! The food was clearly high quality and packed with flavor. On top of the food, the service was amazing. Everyone was so kind and engaging. The kind woman working register went out of her way to make sure I got the most bang for my buck. Everyone should try this place! read more

Actually incredible service, undoubtedly the best in Berkeley. Super attentive and accommodating staff! So kind and so helpful. Pizza was great too! Lots of fun, inventive options. They have really affordable deals--perfect for students and anyone on a budget. Highly recommend supporting this family-run business! read more

Nice staff and solid pizza. I hope this place succeeds and the students in the area support this business. It's so sad seeing so many small restaurants close on this stretch of Shattuck! read more

great pizza and amazing customer service and they always keep the place clean and stream many sports games

pizza was crispy crust cooked right toppings fresh. service was friendly and efficient. place has casual vibe good for groups. solid pizza spot. read more

Me and my friends had the absolute best time here thanks to the delicious food at good prices, cute atmosphere, and above all outstanding service. The people working here were so so kind and welcoming. The pizza was just what we were looking for, just great classic American-style pizza. read more

Extreme Pizza on Shattuck is amazing! Run by the most friendly family couple in Preet & Paul. The pizza is phenomenal, & fairly priced! One of the few places left in Berkeley that you can get a QUALITY slice from without breaking the bank. Sides & salads are extremely unique & equally delicious. The Zip knots are a MUST for any savory fans! & I'm personally obsessed with their Flyin' High Thai Chicken salad for lunch! I can't say enough good, check it out for yourself... read more

Food was delicious and for a great price, everyone was really nice as well, the service was great

Went there with my family.Food was amazing with variety of options to choose from like pizza, subs, wings and salad. Even their dessert pizza was really good.Staff was really nice and helpful. Clean and beautiful environment. Can't wait to go back again!! read more

Location Location Location! What a cozy little vibe that turns up at the night time. Great place to watch the warriors game with a bunch of beers and great pies!! Recommend this place to everyone passing by. read more

This place is awesome! the pizza is fresh and delicious, and they have a great beer selection. the staff are super friendly and attentive. its like a Santa Cruz style spot in downtown Berkeley! laid back beachy vibes, good beer, and kind people. read more

I was visiting friends in Berkeley and decided to stop by and try out Extreme Pizza. As soon as I walked in I received excellent customer service. I ended up trying the Yard Sale 8" and their Zipline Knots. They have a variety of beers on tap, with a selection of non alcoholic beverages. Would highly recommend trying them out. read more

pretty solid new pizza place! they have a lot of interesting flavors and really good service. prices are also pretty reasonable. will definitely be back! read more