First review! Let me preface this review by saying that I do not typically criticize restaurants, but Eleven was definitely a bit of a let-down for how highly rated it seems. After all, though my dining companion and I came later on a Monday night, the dining room seemed busy and remained full for much of our time here.
Our experience at Eleven definitely took off to a promising start. The hostess allowed us to book the Chef's Table for two, even though it typically is intended to seat 4-6 people. While it did not give us a particular insightful view of the kitchen, it was definitely offset in a nice cozy alcove with plenty of space to accommodate our voracious appetites!
Unfortunately, our server was not especially friendly or enthusiastic, so we did not get much advice for the appetizers we decided to order before venturing to the Chef's Tasting.
Half-Dozen Oysters | Not too shabby. We were not given any details about the origin of these oysters, so I can only comment that the ELEVEN hot sauce was a very spicy version of cocktail sauce!
Seared Scallops | The scallops themselves had a nice consistency, if a bit rubbery, but they sat on a strange stew of peas and ham that I did not especially enjoy. The heartiness of the flavor seemed to overwhelm the typical delicacy of seared scallops and we left much of it on the plate.
Chef's Tasting Course #1: Seared Hudson Valley Foie Gras | Since California's ban on foie gras, I have not had it nearly as often, so I was really looking forward to this appetizer. Yet, though I can normally be convinced to love seared foie gras dish at any price point, I can honestly say that this is one of the worst preparations I have ever tasted. The foie gras itself was far too well-done; of my admitted generous portion, only the very center had the soft, buttery consistency that defines the dish, while the outer portions were a little too much like...liver. It also sat on a strangely incongruent piece of rough breading that added little to the melding of flavors, but our server did not seem to appreciate my asking about what it had been. (Turns out--carrot cake!)
Chef's Tasting Course #2: Seared Salmon | While both my dining companion and I usually enjoy salmon in any form, this "seared" salmon had a nearly fried crisp that masked its usual flavor. This dish's saving grace was its bedding of rich polenta that paired surprisingly well with the stark vinegary greens on the side. It was paired rather oddly with a Pinot Noir.
Chef's Tasting Course #3: Jubilee Hilltop Ranch Strip Steak | When our server presented us this grass-fed steak and--exact words--"tater tots," we probably should not have expected too much from this simultaneously rare and stringy cut of meat. The tater tots far outshone the meat itself. Less said the better.
Yellowtail Sashimi | My dining companion was so unimpressed by the steak from the third course that he did not finish it. We did not want to create problems by sending it back, but we added an order for the yellowtail sashimi appetizer to close our meal on a better note. The three slices of slightly fishy yellowtail atop cucumber salad was definitely not the worst nouveau-sauced sashimi either of us have ever had, but again, it was not especially amazing either.
Tasting Menu Dessert for Her: Flourless Chocolate Cake with Bourbon Ice Cream | This dense, rich mass of chocolate was both well presented and delicious! :) Kudos to the pastry chef on this one.
Tasting Menu Dessert for Him: Brown Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches | My dining companion adores ice cream sandwiches, so he may have been a little biased, but I can agree that the combination of oatmeal raisin cookies, cold ice cream, and graham crumbles was indeed magical. Plus, the kitchen did remember to include a piece of chocolate with a message that I had called in earlier--so bonus points there.
Ambitious Dessert to Share: Creme Fraiche Brûlée | At the end of the meal, we both commented that dessert was by far the highlight--so much so that we had to try our luck at another. The creme brûlée and accompanying jelly macaron were both good but not wonderful. Perhaps another ice cream sandwich might have been better!
Ultimately, the Chef's Tasting Menu & Wine Pairing, while delicious in theory and in description, did not exhibit much innovation or character. We enjoyed elements of each course, but none of them stood out as being particularly memorable. Of the five wines we sampled between the two of us, only the first (2011 Semillon) seemed worth an individual order.
Had our service been more consistent or friendly, I would have been tempted to rate our dinner a 3.5 or 4; however, for how much we were both looking forward to our fine dining experience at Eleven, we just felt underwhelmed at every turn. Maybe we came on an off-night, or perhaps we are just spoiled by LA dining, but I would definitely not make Eleven a priority on future trips to Pittsburgh! read more