Edith's Sandwich Counter is one of the most popular deli's in NYC and recently they have expanded from their original location in Brooklyn to another spot in West Village. This location has minimal seating inside and would be better for a quick grab-and-go. We got their chicken schnitzel and it was amazing. Huge portions with fresh veggies and lots of chicken. Their famous cold brew slushee was also a must-try. Definitely have to come back and try their other sandwiches. read more

Edith's - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Next time, I'll give their sandwiches a try, though I'm admittedly a loyalist when it comes to corned beef on Rye-Katz Deli Baby! This one also looked a little too greasy for my taste. That said, I did try the frozen Honey Deuce. It's definitely on the sour side and could use a splash of vodka, in my opinion. You officially have the Supreme Touch! read more

Edith's - Frozen Honey Deuce - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

It truly pains me to write this review, but as a customer, this is something I would want to know. I visited Edith's today to pick up a to-go order. Upon entering the restaurant, I immediately noticed what appeared to be fresh diarrhea on the ground outside near the entrance. At the same time, I noticed a large dog being rubbed by the young woman handling the to-go orders. When I inquired about my order, she immediately washed her hands before handing me my food. While I appreciate that she washed her hands, I left the restaurant feeling genuinely uncomfortable and concerned about the potential for cross-contamination. As a healthcare provider, I am particularly conscious of basic hygiene and food-safety practices, and I shouldn't have to leave a restaurant doing mental gymnastics about whether the person handling my food had potentially come into contact with an animal or contaminated area. I called the restaurant afterward and spoke with the manager, Wyatt, who told me he would have the area cleaned immediately. I appreciate his willingness to address the issue, but these are concerns that should ideally be addressed proactively, particularly in an establishment handling and serving food. I'm not writing this to be dramatic or unnecessarily critical. I genuinely wanted to enjoy my experience, but what I witnessed made me question the cleanliness and food-handling practices enough that I felt compelled to share it. I hope management takes this feedback seriously and reinforces appropriate sanitation and food-handling protocols with the staff. read more

I can only speak on the drinks here, but they are SO GOOD! I got the limited time yerba mate slush and the coffee slush and both were amazingggg. I'm not a huge coffee drinker but the slush was unbeatable. It was light, sweet, and perfect on a warm day. The yerba mate slush was so good too, I wish it were a permanent menu item! Since I only got drinks it was a pretty quick transaction, but there was a line mid day. read more

Edith's - menu - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've had Edith's a number of times in Williamsburg, but this was my first time trying the WV location. My friend & I split the chicken caesar wrap & smoked turkey hoagie. Caesar wrap: It has so much potential, but it didn't not do it for me. Granted I was starving so I did shovel it down. 1. The wrap was lightly coated with dressing so I had to request more - very dry off the bat. 2. The top portion had chicken, but underneath the wrap was basically all kale - like sooooo much kale I had to take some out. Can't remember if there was parmesan in there either? It was basically all kale w sprinkles of chicken Smoked turkey sandwich: I preferred this sandwich. It is quite literally the perfect beach sando. Turkey was packed it in, meat was flavorful & seemed like good quality. I also loved the toppings - pickles & pickled red onions were my faves! My one callout is that it was just a taddddd bit more saucey than I would have liked. Don't get me wrong, I love sauce, but it was to the point that the bread was getting soggy and dripping everywhere. read more

Edith's - Chicken Caesar Wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Very busy as we all know, but that staff were fabulous. I got an everything bagel and scallion cream cheese- you could tell the cream cheese had the scallions added in house, it was really nice. Bagel wasn't a New York style bagel (I don't think anyway) so it was a nice change. The coffee tahini slushie was a bit rich for me. I would have liked a smaller size, but it was a nice flavor read more

Edith's - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Got the BEC&L on crispy flatbread, side of totkes, and a cookie. The sandwich was crispy on the outside, the eggs were fluffy, and the components worked well. I think it definitely could use a bit more seasoning. The totkes are good since it's just fried potatoes. The chocolate chip cookie was decent, especially if you like a thin cookie. It is very pricey for a sandwich, but it's good for sure. Overall 4.3/5 read more

I wanted to like this so badly but it was not at all worth the wait or the money ($16.50 for tuna!!)... wanted to go for something cold because it was so hot and while the Californian had some crisp lettuce it was bland and the tuna was too dry for me. I fear I can make better tuna at home. The challah was good and I appreciate the pickled peppers because that was like the only flavor that was there. They also told us at the register that they were out of the summer special that my cousin had really wanted to try and it would've been more helpful if they posted a sign outside saying that. Id come back on a weekday to try the tuna melt because I'd assume the cheese would give more flavor but honestly not sure if it's worth the trip/wait. read more

Edith's - The Californian - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

I came to Edith's to try their sandwiches after hearing such great things about their items! I was especially curious about their Sephardi Wrap and Tuna Melt, so that is what we ordered. The shop is diner styled where you order at the front and find a free seat to eat at. Service was incredibly kind and they also checked in on us too! I think the food just was not to my flavor unfortunately. The bread on the tuna melt was way too buttery for me, and the tuna + cheese was cold. Is that standard? I'm not super familiar with other tuna melts, but I was surprised. I do like how the tuna salad was heavy on tuna and lower on mayo though! The Sephardi wrap was interesting, but I think the wrap itself was maybe too crispy where it was a little hard. The dish itself was heavier than I expected. Overall, this is a great place to try but just didn't match my flavor profile. read more

Edith's - A Perfect Tuna Melt - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We got the matcha slushie and the coffee slushie but matcha not really worth- just tasted like flavorless slush. I'd recommend the coffee slushie more. I didn't really like the Sephardi wrap but if you're into cheesy breakfast wraps, I think you'd like it. The pastrami chopped cheese was good. read more

See all

FANTASTIC. I got the coffee slush (what I came here for), totkes, and chicken tahini Cesar salad wrap. Knocked it out of the park. The wrap was STUFFED. Filling but not greasy. The staff is fantastic, the cashier is so patient and gave great recommendations. The slushy is sooooo yummy and you get a punch card for a free one when you hit 8. Great diner feel to the open kitchen. Definitely recommend and want to come back to try more goodies. read more

See all

Edith's is worth the trip for the bagels alone, but the PEC&L takes it to another level. The pastrami, egg, cheese, and crispy latke combo on a fresh bagel is ridiculously good! Everything stayed intact until the last bite! Definitely one of those sandwiches you keep thinking about afterwards. Cozy vibe, friendly staff, and genuinely memorable food. I'll absolutely be back for another PEC&L. read more

Edith's - PEC&L - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Okay loved both sandwiches! The cesear wrap has a tahini dressing but it wasn't too over powering. The turkey Sammy was def a little richer so it was nice to split each one. My go to turkey Sammy is usually Court St. but this one is pretty comparable (clean turkey still #1 tho) read more

Edith's - Tahini Chicken Caesar Wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Sourdough bagel stuffed with japanese-style tamagoyaki, and a shakshuka inspired bagel sandwich spotted in NYC! The secret to their fluffy egg omelette is that every bagel sammy is made with an individual omelette made in cast-iron tamagoyaki pans from Japan. Their West Village location gives off a buzzy deli vibe, with limited bar and window seating. It was packed when I went on the weekend, so it's more of a grab-and-go spot. I placed my order online in advance to skip the line. Definitely need to go back to try their sandwiches and wraps. ＊Middle Eastern $12.85 A saucy and herby bagel sandwich inspired by shakshuka. Made with fluffy tamagoyaki, cheese, za'atar, shakshuka sauce and scallion aioli spread. It was messy to hold and bite into, but totally worth it. I went with their signature chicago-style everything bagel, which has a subtle kick compared to a regular everything bagel. ＊PEC&L $16.85 They offer BEC, SEC, and P(astrami)EC, all served with a latke and tamagoyaki! The PEC&L was a bit bland on its own, but I liked that the smoked pastrami wasn't overly salty. BUT the sandwich was DIVINE once dipped in their house special sauce! read more

See all

Literally the best sandwich I ever had that I didn't make myself. Friendly people, especially Saint, and a very cool vibe. They should have tables outside because the place is tiny. read more

Edith's - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I'm glad we grabbed a sandwich from Edith's before heading to the airport. I grabbed breakfast for lunch and got the bacon, egg, and cheese in a wrap. I loved the totkes and the special sauce that came with the wrap was sweeter. I loved their miscellaneous hot sauce bucket, cute spot with great service. My sister enjoyed her tuna melt too. read more

See all

The Iced Cafe Slushie is divine!! The savory sesame tahini complements the oat milk so well. This is the perfect drink for a hot day. It wasn't too sweet. We also tried the PEC & L which is savory and amazing on the Chicago's everything bagel. The staff are great. It does get crowded especially on the weekend so I recommend ordering online for pickup or coming early. read more

See all

Thank god Edith's opened up in WV which is much much closer to me than their original Brooklyn location. I've been wanting to try them for a long time and I love a culturally inspired breakfast-heavy menu. I came specifically for their breakfast sandwich on the Sephardi Breakfast Wrap served on malawach bread which is similar to roti in some ways, like a flaky, rich flatbread, and comes with these fluffy eggs and Middle Eastern spices seasoned chicken sausage (love chicken sausage) and cheese and it was just delightful and had a nice heat running throughout it. Of course had to get the Tahini Cold Brew Slush which was nice and had a subtle but not overpowering savory nutty sweetness which complemented well with the bitter cold brew, all in a finely slushy texture that was such a delight. Definitely a place I would go back to. I also had their pastrami sandwich which was heavy but so yummy. read more

I hired a photographer for a photo shoot in the West Village and we stumbled upon Edith's, perfectly set on a corner and absolutely calling my name. I was craving a breakfast sandwich, so the timing couldn't have been better. After a quick scan of the menu and a helpful Q&A with the woman behind the counter, I decided on the Scottsdale Wrap... and it did not disappoint. As a self-proclaimed potato lover, I was also interested to try totkes for the first time and was excited to try the zhug as well. The cheesy eggs added so much flavor and paired perfectly with the malawach wrap, and I swear they tucked an entire avocado in there too. Seating options include stools at the ordering counter with views of the cooks and the kitchen or a window-side counter with a great street view. I chose the latter and happily people-watched while I ate. The food felt fresh and light, yet still filling. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area. read more

See all

I have been a fan of Edith's on IG for a few years now - I live in CA but it's been patiently waiting on my NYC foodie list for quite some time now. I was in the city last week, and finally got my chance to try Edith's for the first time - I got the Rueben, the tuna melt, latke tots (with every dipping sauce of course) and the tahini cold brew coffee slush (in the 20 something degree weather mind you!). Everything was perfect, but the Rueben and the cold brew coffee slush stood out as excellent! The sandwiches are very rich and filling so you could prob eat half and be full, but of course I had to eat one of each half. I recommend that Edith's be on everyone's NYC Foodie list! read more

See all

4.5*s The Sephardi breakfast wrap is fantastic. The flakey malawach, the fluffy cheesy scrambled eggs, savory Alheira chicken sausage, zingy pickled Fresno peppers, and herby harissa mayo with a touch of spice. The latke was crispy and fun but missing something flavor wise. The iced coffee slushy was not too sweet, but I wanted more flavor or a bigger caffeine boost. Probably much better when it's warm out than when I had it and was fighting the winter winds. Staff was fun and friendly in the tight space. People please eat and go when there's people waiting! Just based on the Sephardi wrap I would totally come back to try all their other popular items; BEC&L, chicken tahini caesar wrap, The Edith pastrami etc. read more

Edith's - Sephardi Breakfast Wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Tried The Edith's, thought it was good but little saucier than the photo. Latkes - served cold :/ read more

Edith's - The Edith - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

TLDR: Small interior but a hearty meal for a good price. But you can skip the Tahini Latte Ordered: Pastrami on Rye 4.5/5 - So because my partner in crime did not know what to do about sauerkraut, we did in fact get in on the side (I had some to accompany my sandwich). With that I do think that it is an essential. With that said this was probably the best pastrami on rye i've ever had?? They've done this thing where they completely reinvented the classical sandwich. For starters the bread is toasted. Second, the pastrami is almost chopped and then the cheese is infused with it making it meld into one instead of having separate layers like a traditional sammie. Also for all things considered this was a good price for $18. Iced Tahnini Latte: 3/5 - Honestly, it was just okay? I really didn't get much flavor from it. Also if you are a texture person this will throw you off. So overall I'd say it probably wasn't worth the hype. Service: 5/ 5 - They were very nice, accommodating and patient. Vibe: 4/5 - Its a cute place but its just small, basically standing room only. I wish I could give you a tip on where to go to to have this other than being on the street but I don't. With that said I think its worth to try and huddle inside to eat because the sandwich can get messy. Overall I'd be super stoked to try this place again! read more

Edith's - Tahini Latte - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Food was good, not great. Don't believe the hype here. Waited 15-20 min to order which wasn't bad but the inside of the restaurant waiting for your food was absolute chaos. Waited 32 min total from ordering to getting food. People who showed up after me god their food well before me, seemingly no order at all. Also they charged $15 for this sorry grilled cheese. read more

Edith's - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

This was my first breakfast stop when I landed in New York and it ended up being such a good choice. A friend who lives nearby recommended it, and honestly when I looked online the food seemed pretty average. I was not expecting much. Once I got there the staff suggested their breakfast sandwiches, and OMG they were on another level! The flatbread was so unique and light. It was unlike anything I have ever had before. The sandwich was flavorful and way better than they look in photos. I also loved the casual and cozy vibe inside. Service was friendly and helpful which made the experience even better. I would definitely recommend trying this place, especially if you want something different from the usual breakfast spots. read more

See all

My company caters one lunch a week, and this week's treat was Edith's. Pretty beast. They were all cut in halves, which was clutch as I could try a couple. Nothing wrong with trying everything on the menu, word to Charlie Sheen. I went with a half pastrami and a half turkey sandwich. Pastrami was solid, but not touching Katz. I've never had a pastrami sandwich comparable to the OG. Turkey one was delectable though. If I had to do it over again, I would have just done a whole turkey sandwich. Hindsight is always 20/20 though, can't beat yourself up. I already do that enough. After demolishing both, the chicken cutlet sandwich was also looking at me CRAZY, but I've eaten enough office lunches to know that overeating will absolutely take me out for the 2nd half of the day and I needed to be productive. I'm a veteran of the game. IG @johnny.novo Tiktok @jnov__ Substack @johnnynovo read more

See all

Amazing sandwich's. One of the more unique and delicious BLTs I've ever had. They're super busy and it takes time but I get it. Thanks to all the hard work you all do to care of each order! You guys and gals rock. read more

In a trendy NYC area where a lot of places have lines and bougie clientele, a simple counter service style place is refreshing and lets you breathe a bit. Here steps in Edith's. Edith's isn't trying to be something new and fashionable. It's vintage, it's old, and it's because of its authenticity it's actually more en vogue than the newer places. Bagel with the seasonal lemon dill schmear was killer and the bacon sandwich was solid. Iced coffee slush was really good, tahini and texture were unique. Nice change from the nonstop high level espresso I've been drinking all trip. Definitely worth a stop in west village. read more

See all

I die for sandwiches! They do an incredible schnitzel sandwich! I tried the caesar wrap but asked for no croutons so the ratio of kale was a bit off (that one is on me though). Will be back to try their breakfast sandwiches those look bomb! read more

Service: 4.3/5 Food: 4.3/5 Price: $15-$30 Kinda bar vibes, though I'm pretty sure they sell no alcohol here. Lots of fun posters, art + details for the eyes to observe. Limited seating, which is surprising given their popularity, however, worked out fine for us as we went for dinner + had no hovering parties. A good portion of the menu is egg/breakfast-centric, so maybe it's different earlier in the day. Staff is friendly + playful-- we had 1 guy photobomb us. It seems like a tight-knit group. What I Ordered: - Chicken Schnitzel Club: FAT + well balanced - Sephardi Wrap: buttery, very wet + messy, spicy chilies - BEC + L: stacked, a little messy, I appreciate the toasted bagel - Salted Chocolate Chip Cookie: so thin + surprisingly chewy, a hint of caramel - Texas Toast Chocolate Babka: dark chocolate-y, rich read more

Sandwich shop! Went to their West Village location (they have another in Brooklyn) cause I was in the mood for a sandwich. It's a Jewish style sandwich counter, but like modern and chic vibes. Interior is retro and super cute, with counter/bar style seats and one or two tables; can fill up easily if you come during the weekend -- but when the weather is warm you can just pop a squat on the stairs of the brownstones nearby (it's a cute area) or hop a few blocks down to the piers. Sandwiches are good, fresh, and pretty decently sized. Also, I saw their coffee tahini slushie online, and needed to get it since I'm a frozen coffee feind; it was yummy and refreshing (not too sweet). I came again for their brekkie sando! Went with the pastrami egg and cheese and latke -- honestly every component was good and the secret sauce brought the acidity/brightness/briny-ness(?) that you would get from a sauerkraut or pickle to complete it, but definitely was expecting a little more for what I was paying. read more

See all

Sephardi wrap was so yummy. The bread was flaky and super yummy. The filling was really good as well. And I even liked the chicken sausage which I normally don't like. Super crowded for lunch on Sunday. Would definitely recommend. read more

Edith's - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've been looking forward to eating here for a while, so I was honestly pretty disappointed. I ordered the BECL, and the cashier suggested getting it on the wrap instead of a bagel, so I went with that recommendation. Not sure if that was the best choice, but that's what I ended up with. I also ordered a side of latkes (tokas), which I was really excited to try. Unfortunately, the food was pretty mid overall. The sandwich took about 25 minutes to come out and was fairly greasy. The wrap itself didn't have much flavor, and while there was a good amount of bacon (which was decent), the sandwich as a whole didn't really stand out. The dipping sauce definitely helped, but it wasn't enough to elevate it. The latkes were dry and somewhat flavorless, and the cheese sauce got cold and hardened after about 10 minutes, which made them even less enjoyable. The dryness really did it for me, the texture, the taste, everything was dry. I spent $30 on the 2 items. Overall, I really wanted to love this spot, but I didn't leave feeling like I'd be back. It's also hard to find a place to eat inside because it's so packed. Pretty disappointing experience. read more

first time.. But def not the last !! It was a cute lil diner style .. very busy & lively We went for the banana bread coffee slushie .. & wow !! It was delicious !! Definitely a dessert style Bev !! But it's soo good I can't wait to go back .. only thing is .. I wish it was a forever item & not a limited time special read more

First time here and will not be my last! Edith's has been on my list for quite some time so I'm glad I finally went today. The totkes with cheese are perfection. Perfectly popable, the cheese is a must! They are crunchy but soft on the inside like a good latke should be. The breakfast sandwich was also very good. As for the tahini chicken crunch wrap I would say I enjoyed it BUT have a major bone to pick with the embarrassing ratio of chicken. I split the sandwich with a friend and she mentioned not having a lot of bites of chicken. I counted. I had 1 maybe 2 max bites of chicken. Don't call it a chicken sandwich if that's the ratio. I'm sure it was just a fluke but seems like a pretty big fluke. You can even see it in the picture I took. So I will be back but not for the chickenless chicken sandwich. read more

See all

I'm actually still dreaming about the coffee slush and PEC&L Malawah wrap that I ate! I had seen this place all over my insta and knew I had to make it a point to go and visit when I was in NYC again. Overall 10/10 and will be back every time I'm in the city read more

Edith's - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We ordered breakfast there - they were pretty busy so it was about a 15-20min wait. if you are in a hurry I would order ahead for pickup. We got the iced cafe slushie - this was very refreshing and I would get it again. For breakfast we got the bacon egg cheese on a toasted plain bagel - 10/10, this was delicious and very filling!!! I love the bagel - not too much bread and toasted perfectly. The scottsdale wrap had a lot of egg and avocado but was kind of mushy and mess to eat. Food was not oily like other breakfast places. Total was around $40. I would def come back! Good quality! There is very limited seating. read more

It took me by surprise! The only downfall was that i visited 11:30am when it was like the busiest but other than that, the service was efficient, and the food was so food- tuna melt bread was very chewy and this most famous breakfast wrap was surprisingly so good- these can be pretty heavy with their infamous ice cafe slush but everything that i tried was like 4.8/5 and ill give 5/5 for that cafe slushie! read more

Edith's - A Perfect Tuna Melt, Sephardi Breakfast Wrap, Iced Cafe Slushie - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

fire food and fire drinks! i love their slush collab series, always creative and consistently brings you in. their bacon egg cheese latke sandwich is amazing, whatever cheese in their is so good and it melts with the sandwich perfectly. the sandwich is also massive and is super filling with tons of crispy quality bacon and basically a cheese omelet on it as well. overall great twist on a new york classic. service here is speedy and kind, got my food within 5 minutes of ordering. ambiance is a classic deli feel, small and intimate. overall loved eveyrhting, the matcha slush had great matcha flavor and i enjoyed the blueberry cardamom add on as well, it was different in the best way. read more

Edith's - BEC&L - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Edith's is the kind of neighborhood bagel and coffee shop that, if you lived in the West Village, you'd go to weekly without thinking about it. There are places in a neighborhood, and then there are places that are the neighborhood. This is one of them. The place moves fast, but Matthew, taking orders, still makes his way around the counter, checking in on guests no matter how busy it gets. That kind of care shows. I had the BEC&L. Excellent and loved the random hot sauce packets on top. Small, creative touch. Already looking forward to the next visit. read more

Edith's - Totally random hot sauces. - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York