This review is only based on their calzones, I do enjoy their pizza. Pros: The dough is amazing. Really good quality and tastes authentic like NY pizza dough. Cons: I ordered a garlic, pepperoni calzone and this made me realize how greasy their pepperoni is. It was literally pooling in my plate to the point that I could only eat a quarter of the entire calzone. Not only that, I think they put enough garlic in my calzone to ward off every vampire in cinema history. The grease and garlic were just overwhelming, and not in a good way. I will be sure to order different inside toppings in the future or ask for it light. I recommend getting light pepperoni in your calzone, or not at all. read more

See all

Came in on Wednesday after 2 and had their lunch special with one slice of pizza, salad and a drink. Awesome pizza and good salad with lettuce, cucumber slices, tomatoes, red onions, olives and pepperonchini. Very nice value. read more

4&1/2 stars as posted by Yelp. Hmmm...well...NO. It is NY style but as far as the flavor...it's lacking. I'm not saying it's a lousy pie but there is NO WAY it ranks so highly. 3&1/2 tops. Don's is priced reasonably and service was quite good so props for that. Large sausage & mushroom w/2 cans of soda only cost a fraction over twenty bucks. Good value but dreams are not made of pizzas like these. I'll try Grimaldi's next pizza stop to check out their claim as Best Pizza in Phoenix. Didn't find it here. read more

I have been getting Don's NY pizza for a few years now and they don't disappoint. Today I ordered the x large eggplant and a X large NY special. All I can say is they got it right again! They both were to die for. Thanks Don's read more

Searched high & low for our new pizza place once we knew we were relocating, to say the least to a native NYer is no easy task!! Well we don't need to look any further thank God!! Love the pizza it's as good as it gets being as far from NY as we are & anyone who says different isn't a born & raised NYer like this Long Island girl & they should stick with their coal fired pizza, case closed! They'll definitely be seeing a lot of us & I look forward to it even though my hips don't, LOL!! read more

See all

I always get the lg cheese pizza and the 20 wing special and it's always good. Pizza is always consistent. If you like your thin crust kinda crispy like me, I'd tell 'em to go well done and they make it perfect. Wings are always a hit, good size wings and their sauce is quality sauce!! I've also tried the pastas, calzone, and some of the side dishes and it's all been good. Definitely got a repeat customer! Service is great too! read more

Price is on point at this place! If you want a filling meal for a little damage to the wallet definitely try this place out. That said, food is mediocre for an Italian spot, the pasta meats are not made from scratch (they never claimed such). I'd say this place has way better pasta then Olive Garden if that helps. All in all I will probably be back at some point. read more

Don's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

I usually go here for family dinner every Friday or Saturday. Im a very loyal Customer and tonight i was over charged which in my open says alot about this pizza place! I respect the owner so much but to be over charged like that was very messed up. My family and I are on the verge of not going back ever again. Pizza is delicious and wings are great but poor customer service like that is very disgraceful. read more

Very nice place clean and a very very large awesome table for about 15 people! So we got there around 6:30 pm ordered and our food came out pretty quick! We ordered a xl pep pizza a bacon medium pizza, wings, lasagna and they were pretty good! The pizza was a little greasy but that's actually the awesome flavor that I loved and the crust was crispy but not burnt! Definitely on my list to order from in the future! On the east side of Home Depot you kind of have to look for it and Pepsi products not a big deal unless you are coke fan like us!!!!! Def a try it place! read more

Don's NY Pizza - Oh yesssss!!! - Pizza Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

I've been coming to Don's NY pizza since they open up , it brings me back Jersey ... their garlic knots are on point ... y'all should try them ... great service . It is always #forgetaboutit read more

PLEASE know that the Peoria location is completely different from the Camelback location. The Peoria pizza tastes different, just not the same. The Camelback location is on point! The guys may not look friendly but they know what they're doing in that kitchen so enjoy or leave. (Im such a groupie of this place lol) read more

NJ native here, always looking for a good fold-able slice of pie and I saw Yelp loves this new place so I though I would give it a try....but when specifically looking for it it was very difficult to find. It's on the east side (closer to loop 101) of the parking lot with Home Depot. Upon entering I was greeted promptly and noticed a very fine selection of slices even though I came in at 3pm. Got the 2 slices plus a drink special for around $6. Mushroom pepperoni was my first pic. A lot of cheese, fantastic fold-ability and the crust. Molto Bene! ***FUN FACT*** the reason we fold slices back East is because you won't burn your tongue or roof of your mouth with bread on both sides. (picture the 'more you know' cartoon from NBC) read more

Don's NY Pizza - Legit! - Pizza Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

This is the best pizza place ever. Too bad they don't deliver but it's worth it! They are very cleans & very nice there!

4 stars instead of 5 because they cut corners a bit on the cheese. No pizzerias out here use Grande....and I wish they would. HOWEVER for pizza in AZ.....and in the west valley...this place is fantastic. I really enjoyed it and they deliver. I attached a pic of the pizza as soon as it was delivered. They even cooked it perfectly which seems to be an issue here in AZ. read more

Don's NY Pizza - It's not digiorno it's delivery. - Pizza Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

My first visit hands down 5/5. I did have to wait 20 mins in store for 2 slices of pizza, cheese sticks, and a salad. However quality 10/10. Today I placed an order for delivery since I'm working from home and I live literally down the street (5mins) and my order took 2 hours to deliver..... again I had 2 slices of pizza, a salad, some cheese sticks. 2 hours... I called to see what's up, the guy on the phone said "it should be there any minute" then hung up. Wasn't really impressed. From now on I'm only going to utilize ordering there in person since over the phone and delivery was complex it seems. Still a fan of their fresh food. But disappointed this time around. read more

Not bad in a pinch. If you're looking for some thin, foldable NY style pizza this will no frills place will do the job.

Ordered through door dash. I had the margarita pizza, pepperoni pizza and wings. All were pretty bland. The sauce on the wings was odd. It wasn't the worst but not worth the money at all. The Margherita pizza didn't taste right at all. The pepperoni pizza needed more sauce and the sauce needs more flavor. It fed us but that was about the only positive I really have. read more

As a Brooklyn native, one of the biggest let-downs of leaving NY was knowing that I would no longer have access to the greatest pizza in the world. Dons is the ONLY pizza place that I have EVER tried in a state other than NY that actually, truly does serve NY-style pizza. Despite being 35 mins from my house, I will ALWAYS make the drive to get Dons over anything else. I could tear up just thinking about how happy I am to have pizza close by that tastes so much like home. To anyone who hasn't experienced the miracle that is NY pizza- YOU HAVE TO TRY DONS!!! read more

Delicious pizza for a great price. I recommend the special that comes with the wings!!

This is very good New York style pizza. Generous and flavorful cheese, chewy thin crust with just the right amount of greasy goodness. Overall, satisfying large foldable slices of pie! I picked up a cheese pizza without sauce for carry out. I could tell the guy with a New York accent who served it to me (Don maybe?) was perplexed & slightly disgusted that I wanted a pizza without sauce, but nevertheless, he made a great tasting pizza! read more

Why go to DON's NY PIZZA? Because they'll make you an offer you can't refuse!!! Great slices, excellent appetizers and sides. These guys are the real deal! Step out of AZ and into Brooklyn via food. read more

Don's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

It's not quite the same as NY pizza but it's pretty good. They have many items on the menu to keep the whole family happy.

This is one of our favorite pizza joints and easily our favorite on the west side of Phoenix. They have a great selection of menu items, good service, and great taste. Please keep in mind that this review is about this west side (Avondale) pizza joint. The pizza is great but this is not a hipster / trendy place like pizzeria bianco or other downtown locations. We order our birthday party dinners from here and get late night pizza when we want something more than just a quick chain pizza. This place has a freaky great menu full of pizzas different pizzas. We have not had one we do not like. And on top of that they have a good pasta, salad, wing, and calzone selection. All of these items are great. When a pizza joint sells a pasta that is so good you might get it instead, you have some great decisions to make. Service is in the name. It is Don's NY pizza. We visited New York and would say the service feels just like that. They are friendly and no nonsense. It feels family owned and managed. If they are not busy, they will gladly talk about anything, but if they are busy, probably get your pizza and move on. They are not going to fall all over you, but they will treat you with respect and you will know the hands that went into every part of your pizza. Finally the food tastes great. We really have not found anything we did not like. The pizza is a step up from any other we have found in our area. The pastas are great, the wings have a great heat, and overall they do a great job. So, if you live in this area, happen to be on the west side, or are driving through on the I-10, this is a great restaurant. read more

Delicious pizza and so much more Don's NY Pizza is reminiscent of the neighborhood pizzeria you remember visiting after school to grab a slice of pie with a coke, and relax with your friends. Don's offers no-frills delicious pizza, served either by the slice, or as a whole pie. Don's makes their dough fresh daily and splash on a generous portion of homemade sauce then slather your pie with freshest toppings of your choice. This pie is the perfect combination of crispy crust, delicious sauce, and the perfect amount of toppings. If you go to Don's New York Pizza you have to try the Margarita Pizza it's the best I've ever had, perfectly delicious as is the pepperoni and cheese pizza. In addition, too delicious Don's offers salads, calzones, sandwiches, desserts, wings, pasta, and an assortment of appetizers. I can't wait to visit again and try other options off their menu. So, If you are a pizza fan (and who is not?) You have to visit Don's you won't be disappointed. read more

If I could give it 0 stars I would. This was horrible I ordered Uber eats and I got a margarita pizza and cheese sticks, not paying attention to the couple bad reviews and seeing all the good ones. It was HORRIBLE. The pizza was so watery I needed 6 napkins to eat one piece the sauce was bland and very little cheese on it. The cheese sticks were so CRUNCHY and hard they tasted freezer burned. BE WARE OF THIS NASTY PLACE. read more

Stuffed to the Max. The pizza was delicious. Got the lunch special with salad a great deal. Happy we came in here. Great service :)

They weren't nice to us, but the food was tasty. No paper towels in either bathroom. So, you decide. Me...not returning. I prefer nice service. read more

Okay it was good, but not great... If you like a lot of food for a good price this is the place, BUT the food is plain.. the garlic knots are just dough, fries aren't salted, chicken strips are plain. The calzones are good tho and are the only thing that I ordered with flavor.. Also, if you want your man to get flirted with this is the place to be, the two girls working nights were hitting on him lol! read more

This Dons Pizza has my vote . I usually order from the Camelback loc. , but the are both very good . If you like a thin crust NY style pizza that ends up with oil on the top , this is your pie . You'll hear some people complain about the guys at the Camelback location , not being chatty . They are good to me . And they will give you crushed peppers and and graded chesse , no problem . read more

Really battled over four or five stars but given I can't really fault any part of our grub I am going to roll with the five star rating, but think 4.5 is most accurate. The prices were good and staff was very outgoing. You could tell they had been working all day but still provided good conversation. As for the pie, we went with a cheese and a pepperoni. Both were very large and hot when picked up. My daughter and her friends devoured them and my wife and I were fortunate enough to get a couple slices. The pie was tasty and had just the right amount of all ingredients. We also ordered an antipasta salad that was good, but did lack a little heat. Overall, price was right and the pies were on point. Would hit this place up again if in the area. read more

See all

This is your average AZ New York style pizza joint. The cashier on the phone was pretty brutal to deal with. She was having a hard time remembering our large pepperoni half pineapple pizza. Had to read my card number twice to her over the phone. Took 50 minutes to receive large pizza and wings. Pizza was very greasy and extremely salty. Not terrible, just ok and probably won't order from here unless we are in a bind. Wings were not great. Again, just what you would expect from your strip mall pizza joint. If people give this place 5 stars, I would say they have never lived anywhere but Az and don't know good authentic pizza! read more

Super sad!!! We have ordered multiple times from the 75th and peoria location for delivery and have never encountered an issue until tonight. Just wanted some delicious wings but apparently we are now out of the delivery zone... asked to speak w the manager and she told me that they were super busy and only had 2 delivery drivers... when I told her, " fine... I guess we will take our business elsewhere" she responded ok ...bye... completely rude and unprofessional. I will miss their wings but not their lack of customer service. read more

This place absolutely rules! Their pizza is great and taste fresh and delicious every time. Their wings is the best I've had in the west side. These are second to Red Devil's wings. 10/10 spot without a doubt. read more

I moved to AZ back in November, and I've tried so many different places since, I've been here trying to find where I like best. And Don's really is it. Great staff there and they give you incredible quality pizza for a reasonable price. read more

Such a great place. They know my wife and I there now. It's our go-to for pizza and wings. I love their pizza with the white sauce. Their calzones are great too. Everyone there is great. Can't say enough good things. Go there. Eat. Enjoy. You're welcome. read more

Been coming here for the past 2years. The best pizza hands down. The wings are always perfect.

Awesome pizza and salad! I cannot wait to order from here again. Extra ricotta is a must! I can't say anything about their calzones yet, but I will definitely get one next time. Thanks for the awesome food. read more

My current favorite pizza!!! Cheesy, not greasy and true NY slices. 4 stars because the seating inside leaves a lot to be desired but hey, we just pick up our pie now! read more

Amazing food, huge portions you just got to try it. Had the two slices deal with the free soda and it was f****** huge. And you gotta understand something, I'm a big guy I'm like 280. If I'm telling you this was almost too much food it's almost too much food it's f****** phenomenal. The sausage and pepperoni to cheese the dough it all works man it all works beautifully together nothing's too much or too little is just f****** delicious. I've worked at several different kinds of pizza places Chicago New York the chains this is as good if not better than all of them. I put Rosati's up there with them. read more

Don's NY Pizza - 2 slices and free drink lunch special. Garlic powder Italian seasoning parmesan and red pepper readily available. - Pizza Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

I'm from Jersey but live in CA. I was visiting family in AZ and was looking for a good NY style pizza pie. Found Don's and was very happy. I ordered the xtra large pie with sausage, pepperoni, and onion. It was reasonably priced and delicious. When I visit again, I'll be ordering another pie. All you folks that live there better take advantage of good pizza while you can, cuz I can't find anything that tastes like Don's that is close to me in CA. read more