Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Diamond Slice

    4.6 (48 reviews)
    Open 12:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated 3 months ago

    Diamond Slice Photos

    DIAMOND SLICE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Dogs allowed

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Diamond Slice

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Chicken bacon ranch
    Aikeem V.

    The service was great, food was great, the ambiance was cool. I ordered the elote and chicken bacon ranch. The chicken bacon ranch was good, but the elote slice was great! It was my first time having an elote slice and it did not disappoint.

    Timothy L.

    Good tasty thin crust pizza in the Green Point area. Brick oven baked for that charred taste. Great selection of variety to choose from. I found that $3.75 /slice of cheese pizza was priced lower compared to other places but not much of a price break for the whole pie. The restaurant was busy when I went there for lunch. All tables were occupied; no standing counter to eat from. Decided to take out rather than wait for a seat. Overall an enjoyable experience; definitely coming back again.

    Christopher W.

    One of the best pizza places in the Brooklyn area we have ever had! The crust was amazing and the sauce/cheese flavor was out of this world. They have a wide variety of toppings and pizza flavors! The staff were amazing and super friendly. They have a small are for dining in if you want the pie hot and fresh. We will definitely be back!

    Pepperoni slice
    Peter L.

    Best slice I've ever had. Got a plain and pepperoni slice here and both were excellent. Crust is perfectly crispy and tasty. The sauce is great, really nice flavor. And they have the right amount of cheese (not too much)! You don't realize how good a slice of pizza could be, will definitely be back. Small store but they do have seating and are very friendly. Easy to pop in for a slice.

    Caroline W.

    Hidden gem pizza that we accidentally stumbled upon while in the area Great variety of flavor and toppings Lots of seating Fast service We were initially sad because some flavors were sold out when we arrived but their service is very quick and by the time we were done with our first slice, the sold out slices were now available

    Midori G.

    I will go ahead and say it- best pizza in the neighborhood. -You can buy individual slices. -The line moves quickly. -Indoor and some outdoor seating. -Crispy but not charred crust. -Great selection of different types of pizza. -Prices comparable to other pizza places. -Suitable place to bring kids.

    Caesar salad slice
    Gab G.

    Hopped on the bus and sped over here after a mid experience at Rita's. Needed pizza redemption!! Caesar salad slice was really good - and the prices are reasonable, considering the going rate for a speciality slice these days (I think the ones here are $5/slice?). Will be back for more! 4.5 stars.

    White Mushroom
    Oliver G.

    This is a follow up review which I've never done before. I went back on June 3rd which became part of the new hours that Peter instituted for Diamond Slice. This time, in addition to the White Mushroom which is one of my favorite slices in the city, I finally tried their famous Caesar Salad slice. By god, this was one of the best slices I've ever had. The slice was well topped with Caesar salad that was very well balanced and the umami from the anchovies really gave it a kick which made it so delicious. Peter and his crew really hit that slice out of the ballpark and it's the top Caesar salad slice in the city by far. I highly recommend that this slice is something you must get at least once when you visit. And the service and vibe are amazing as always. Definitely my favorite pizza joint in Brooklyn as of writing.

    Steph Y.

    My boyfriend and I came to Diamond Slice specifically for the Buffalo Chicken and Caesar slices based on a recommendation from his friend and both totally delivered. The Buffalo Chicken slice is absolutely to die for. Hands down the best we've ever had, so good that we're still thinking about it. They had just ran out of it when we got there, so we waited for a fresh pie to come out while we ate our Caesar slice, and it was totally worth the wait. Perfect balance of heat, creaminess, cheese - topped with crispy chicken and loads of scallions :) I enjoyed this slice more than I actually like eating buffalo chicken wings. The Caesar slice was also a standout--packed with umami from the dressing, Parm, and anchovy. Even cooled down a bit, it was still delicious, but I'd love to try it fresh next time to see how it hits straight from the oven. The dough is fantastic- thin, chewy and crisp in all the right places - also foldable without falling apart. Classic New York style, elevated with real attention to detail. The interior is super inviting, with plenty of tables and booths for hanging out. It's the kind of place you want to linger. Between the delicious pizza and the chill atmosphere, we'll definitely be coming back!

    Autumn L.

    Really impressed by their Caesar slice!! It seems like a gimmicky kind of slice but it's actually so good, very umami from the anchovy and a perfectly crisp crust. I like how finely chopped the lettuce is, it's not too messy to eat. I also got a slice of cheese, the tomato sauce is nice and tomatoey (if that makes sense) and the crust has a great crispy to chewy ratio. I thought it was funny that they put like 2.5 basil leaves on it lol. Definitely worth checking out this place!

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
    Romel B.

    I was in the neighborhood making deliveries and found this location based off a residents location. I can honestly say that I'm glad I ventured to this location the menu is a little different. I ordered the chicken bacon ranch slices and a glass bottle sprite. The service was amazing and the location decor is spectacular. I will definitely be coming back here whenever I'm in Greenpoint.

    Mike C.

    This is a new slice shop in Greenpoint, located just 400 ft away from Chrissy's Pizza, and probably throwing a shot at him with the "Slices are Forever" slogan on the windows. Anyway, as L'industrie and Mama's Too in the West Village have proven, there seems to be enough pizza to go around to plenty of people, as both of those have remained steadily packed. That should be the case here too, as both are incredible, and currently some of the best New York-ish style pizza you can get in Brooklyn. As the slogan references, all they have here are slices, with full pies available as well. There are 8 different kinds on offer right now, and all 5 I tried were great, especially the Pepperoni, Caesar Salad and Buffalo Chicken. Also unlike Chrissy's, this one has some nice seating, including a few large booths. I can't wait to return for more, and hopefully before the lines ruin it.

    Christine R.

    Tried the mushroom slices (with roasted garlic cream, mozzarella and ricotta), spicy vodka and pepperoni slice. All slices were thin and crispy. No soggy bottoms! This pizzeria had (limited) outdoor seating which was nice as we brought a dog. Overall all the slices were good but the mushroom slices was the best. So so good.

    supreme and chicken bacon ranch

    See all

    1 year ago

    Pizza is ok but for the time I had to wait ( extremely long due to mistakes that kept happening) not worth for me. Not going back.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Unreal buffalo chicken slice and amazing staff !!!!!!!! 10/10 will definitely be coming back to try the other slices.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of R B.
    0
    3
    0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    This place gets EVERTHING right. Great slice, great sauce, nice people. Such a good addition the neighborhood.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    So damn good. Try to get there early because I've seen them have to close for the day due to sell out.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Diamond Slice

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 154,376 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Lucali - Mushroom, garlic, and artichoke

    Lucali

    4.2(2.3k reviews)
    4.1 miCarroll Gardens
    $$

    Worth the hype! Absolutely insane calzone... That was our must order!!!…read more The pizza is also incredible - you have to try. We had a pizza + a calzone and for 2-3 people this is enough. Reservations were tough (stand in line and then they'll tell you what time to come back) and we got an 830 res. Still one of my favorite pizzas!

    The pizza is great, really hands down delicious no question about that. The menu is simple and…read morestraightforward. Cash only, BYOB (with rules depending on how many people), and a time limit on the table. Know what you want when you sit down. Menu is easy, pizza, calzones, sometimes pasta. Simple. Is it worth waiting in line for - maybe - if you have 2-3 hours free and nothing else to do and it's a nice day, sure. But honestly can't say I am running back to do it again. Waiting in line to get added to a waitlist that still doesn't always guarantee you will sit down to eat at the requested time - we were seated 40 mins after checking in (unusually long, never had more then 20 mins or so in past visits) but still a strange system, keeps the spot exclusive I'd guess. Have visited several times and always have had a good meal and the prices are very fair. Seating is not super comfortable and they pack you in for real, the restaurant is also unnecessarily dark and loud - But not in a bad way? I can't explain it but the very delicious pizza makes up for the weird ambiance and all the rules... definitely something to experience atleast once.

    Photos
    Lucali
    Lucali - Large Pepperoni with Onions

    Large Pepperoni with Onions

    Lucali

    See all

    L&B Spumoni Gardens - Sicilian Square Pizza Pie

    L&B Spumoni Gardens

    4.2(5.1k reviews)
    9.2 miGravesend
    $$

    Spumoni Gardens is one of those places where I already know I'm not leaving with just one thing…read more The Sicilian slice is DIVINE. Thick, cheesy, saucy, crispy around the edges, and just completely different from a regular slice of pizza. This is the thing I'm coming here for first. Then there are the homemade frozen treats. I've had both the Italian ices and the ice cream, in more flavors than I can even remember at this point, and I genuinely can't tell you which one I like better. Every time I think I've picked a favorite, I try another flavor and change my mind. LOL. There's something very old-school Brooklyn about the whole experience too. It's not trying to be trendy or reinvent itself. It knows exactly what it is, and that's part of why people keep coming back. Give me a Sicilian slice and something frozen afterward and I'm happy.

    We chose L&B Spumoni Gardens because of the strong reviews and because it seemed to be one of the…read moremore popular places in the area. Unfortunately, our experience was extremely disappointing. We ordered a glass of wine, a beer, an arugula salad, and our main food order. Everything started out fine, and the salad came without a problem. But then we waited. And waited. About 30 minutes after we had ordered, I asked our waiter where our food was. He apologized and admitted that he had forgotten to put the order in. By that point, we had already watched other tables receive their food, including people who had arrived well after us. We continued waiting, and after roughly 40 minutes or more, our food still had not arrived. At that point, the dining experience was already ruined and we decided to leave. Ironically, just as we were getting ready to go, the food finally started coming out. I told them we no longer wanted it. The waiter did apologize again and offered us a pizza to take with us, which I assume was complimentary, but by then we were simply ready to leave. Even paying the bill became unnecessarily drawn out. We were charged the full amount for the salad, beer, and wine. I sat with a $50 bill ready to pay, was handed the check, and then ended up standing around for another five minutes waiting for someone to actually take the money. There was no apology from the person handling the payment. I understand that mistakes happen, and I appreciated that our waiter admitted he had forgotten to place the order. But when a restaurant makes that kind of mistake, the recovery matters. After waiting that long, watching later-arriving customers get served, and then having difficulty simply paying and leaving, an apology and a pizza at the very end didn't really fix the experience. Unfortunately, based on this visit, I can't say the service lived up to the restaurant's reputation.

    Photos
    L&B Spumoni Gardens - Stack em up

    Stack em up

    L&B Spumoni Gardens - "Rainbow Spumoni" (Vanilla, Chocolate, Pistachio)

    "Rainbow Spumoni" (Vanilla, Chocolate, Pistachio)

    L&B Spumoni Gardens - Classic Sicilian Square

    See all

    Classic Sicilian Square

    Roberta's - Lunch in Williamsburg, Brooklyn w Anki and John. Post 'Blackout' premier. 3/24

    Roberta's

    4.0(3.5k reviews)
    1.5 miEast Williamsburg, Bushwick
    $$

    Roberta's is an iconic Bushwick institution, but what makes it special is the entire cultural…read moreecosystem that grew around it. I've eaten here, come to the Bushwick Block Party to see Action Bronson perform, and spent enough time around Tiki Disco to associate the place with a particularly inventive, free-spirited period in the neighborhood. The dining area still has that wonderfully idiosyncratic character: exposed beams, communal tables, mismatched details, and an open kitchen turning out genuinely excellent pizza. What impresses me most is how naturally Roberta's became more than a restaurant. Food, music, parties, outdoor spaces, and an extraordinary mix of people all seemed to converge here, giving the place a cultural gravity that could never have been designed by committee. It remains one of those places that instantly takes me back to my bachelor years and an especially fun chapter of my time in the city, when Bushwick felt endlessly creative, and Roberta's seemed to sit comfortably at its center. Sending my highest recommendation!

    Great Neapolitan, soft and chewy pizza with unique toppings - there's something for everyone! For 4…read morepeople, we shared the Little Gem Salad (perfect starter: refreshing and crunchy) and each got our own pie - and left with 2 slices to go. My favorite was between the Fyre and Ice and Ursula's Parade - but all were delicious. There's plenty of seating - inside, atrium, and bar. The atrium was nice and cool - dog-friendly as well!

    Photos
    Roberta's - Inside

    Inside

    Roberta's - 4 Emperors (BRING IT BACK)

    4 Emperors (BRING IT BACK)

    Roberta's - Run Rabbit Run

    See all

    Run Rabbit Run

    Brooklyn DOP - Pizza slices (La Regina, Giseupp (NY style), Nona Mena (grandma) and DOP Sicicilian)

    Brooklyn DOP

    4.3(113 reviews)
    3.9 miPark Slope

    Got a TGTG order here. 11/10 I'd do it again…read more Brooklyn DOP actually originated as a pandemic business where my friend's personal trainer started baking pizzas outside of his Greenwood Heights apartment. When the hype got large enough, the owner decided to start a pizzeria and the rest is not history. This is one of the more worthwhile TGTG orders to me. Their pizza is SOOO perfectly crisp and charred, and actually is one of the closest pizzas that reminds me of the famous originals in Napoli.

    Brooklyn DOP is a prime example of what happens when a pandemic lockdown, a dough obsession, and an…read moreinability to sit still all collide. We visited as a stop on Scott's Pizza Bus Tour, which meant we were actively evaluating it against some of the best pizza in the city. Evaluating pizza on a tour is tricky because excellence becomes relative when you are eating multiple high-end pies in a single afternoon. According to Scott, Brooklyn DOP began in founder Thomas Ardito's apartment during the 2020 lockdowns. With his primary work on pause, he started baking pizza and selling pies through Instagram to pay his rent. People kept ordering. His friend Jason D'Amelio joined the effort, and what started as an apartment project turned into pop-ups and eventually a brick-and-mortar shop on 5th Avenue in Park Slope. That is a considerably more compelling origin story than a corporate franchise business plan. The setup in Park Slope includes a quiet back courtyard, which offered a comfortable spot for our group to sit, eat, and recover between stops. It feels relaxed and distinctly Brooklyn without trying too hard to remind you where you are. The pizza itself is very good. The crust strikes a proper balance between a crisp bottom and a chewy interior. The toppings are handled with care, from the crushed tomatoes to the fresh mozzarella. This is dough crafted by people who take fermentation seriously rather than relying on pre-packaged shortcuts. On its own merits, the pizza is a solid 4.5 stars. Unfortunately for Brooklyn DOP, it was competing on a tour against places operating on another plane. It is an excellent pie, but it was not the single slice that caused the entire tour to fall silent in collective awe. Still, that is an aggressive standard to hold against any local shop. Brooklyn DOP offers a great courtyard, a serious approach to dough, and a standout product. Landing just shy of five stars says far more about the sheer volume of elite pizza we ate that day than it does about the shop itself. Four stars. And if you are not spending the afternoon riding around New York with Scott Wiener eating pizza at some of the finest pizza joints the 5 boroughs have to offer, you can probably bump that half-star back up.

    Photos
    Brooklyn DOP - Interior

    Interior

    Brooklyn DOP - Nona Mena (grandma) and DOP Sicicilian

    Nona Mena (grandma) and DOP Sicicilian

    Brooklyn DOP - Interior

    See all

    Interior

    Diamond Slice - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...