I love the fluffy Sicilian slice. It was soooo airy and really reminded me of what scarrs used to be. Personally I didn't love the elote sauce, it was a bit too salty for me. The regular slice was good, but could be a bit more crispy. It is quite thin and I think their tomatoe slice might be better with more marinara sauce. Overall I think this is a great pizzeria and very family friendly---saw like three strollers. I would come back to try the tomatoe slice and the Sicilian again! read more

Diamond Slice - Elote and regular slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best slice I've ever had. Got a plain and pepperoni slice here and both were excellent. Crust is perfectly crispy and tasty. The sauce is great, really nice flavor. And they have the right amount of cheese (not too much)! You don't realize how good a slice of pizza could be, will definitely be back. Small store but they do have seating and are very friendly. Easy to pop in for a slice. read more

Diamond Slice - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Service: 4.3/5 Food: 3.9/5 Price: $ (under $20) General consensus about the pizzas: large crispy + not greasy nor saucy pies, which means they are a little dry. Only a handful of tables available. Shop is more designed for takeout with a large waiting area. If you're lucky enough to get a table + it's a good hang. Tip: hot honey available + makes everything better, call ahead 30min for pies *What I Recommend What I Ordered: - Supreme: has jalapeños not bell peppers, so a little spicy - Mushroom*: ricotta adds some needs moisture - Caesar: refreshing, but messy to eat + doesn't add much to the pizza, needs more dressing read more

Hidden gem pizza that we accidentally stumbled upon while in the area Great variety of flavor and toppings Lots of seating Fast service We were initially sad because some flavors were sold out when we arrived but their service is very quick and by the time we were done with our first slice, the sold out slices were now available read more

Diamond Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Hopped on the bus and sped over here after a mid experience at Rita's. Needed pizza redemption!! Caesar salad slice was really good - and the prices are reasonable, considering the going rate for a speciality slice these days (I think the ones here are $5/slice?). Will be back for more! 4.5 stars. read more

Diamond Slice - Caesar salad slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I will go ahead and say it- best pizza in the neighborhood. -You can buy individual slices. -The line moves quickly. -Indoor and some outdoor seating. -Crispy but not charred crust. -Great selection of different types of pizza. -Prices comparable to other pizza places. -Suitable place to bring kids. read more

Diamond Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is a follow up review which I've never done before. I went back on June 3rd which became part of the new hours that Peter instituted for Diamond Slice. This time, in addition to the White Mushroom which is one of my favorite slices in the city, I finally tried their famous Caesar Salad slice. By god, this was one of the best slices I've ever had. The slice was well topped with Caesar salad that was very well balanced and the umami from the anchovies really gave it a kick which made it so delicious. Peter and his crew really hit that slice out of the ballpark and it's the top Caesar salad slice in the city by far. I highly recommend that this slice is something you must get at least once when you visit. And the service and vibe are amazing as always. Definitely my favorite pizza joint in Brooklyn as of writing. read more

See all

My boyfriend and I came to Diamond Slice specifically for the Buffalo Chicken and Caesar slices based on a recommendation from his friend and both totally delivered. The Buffalo Chicken slice is absolutely to die for. Hands down the best we've ever had, so good that we're still thinking about it. They had just ran out of it when we got there, so we waited for a fresh pie to come out while we ate our Caesar slice, and it was totally worth the wait. Perfect balance of heat, creaminess, cheese - topped with crispy chicken and loads of scallions :) I enjoyed this slice more than I actually like eating buffalo chicken wings. The Caesar slice was also a standout--packed with umami from the dressing, Parm, and anchovy. Even cooled down a bit, it was still delicious, but I'd love to try it fresh next time to see how it hits straight from the oven. The dough is fantastic- thin, chewy and crisp in all the right places - also foldable without falling apart. Classic New York style, elevated with real attention to detail. The interior is super inviting, with plenty of tables and booths for hanging out. It's the kind of place you want to linger. Between the delicious pizza and the chill atmosphere, we'll definitely be coming back! read more

Diamond Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Really impressed by their Caesar slice!! It seems like a gimmicky kind of slice but it's actually so good, very umami from the anchovy and a perfectly crisp crust. I like how finely chopped the lettuce is, it's not too messy to eat. I also got a slice of cheese, the tomato sauce is nice and tomatoey (if that makes sense) and the crust has a great crispy to chewy ratio. I thought it was funny that they put like 2.5 basil leaves on it lol. Definitely worth checking out this place! read more

Diamond Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I was in the neighborhood making deliveries and found this location based off a residents location. I can honestly say that I'm glad I ventured to this location the menu is a little different. I ordered the chicken bacon ranch slices and a glass bottle sprite. The service was amazing and the location decor is spectacular. I will definitely be coming back here whenever I'm in Greenpoint. read more

Diamond Slice - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is a new slice shop in Greenpoint, located just 400 ft away from Chrissy's Pizza, and probably throwing a shot at him with the "Slices are Forever" slogan on the windows. Anyway, as L'industrie and Mama's Too in the West Village have proven, there seems to be enough pizza to go around to plenty of people, as both of those have remained steadily packed. That should be the case here too, as both are incredible, and currently some of the best New York-ish style pizza you can get in Brooklyn. As the slogan references, all they have here are slices, with full pies available as well. There are 8 different kinds on offer right now, and all 5 I tried were great, especially the Pepperoni, Caesar Salad and Buffalo Chicken. Also unlike Chrissy's, this one has some nice seating, including a few large booths. I can't wait to return for more, and hopefully before the lines ruin it. read more

See all

Tried the mushroom slices (with roasted garlic cream, mozzarella and ricotta), spicy vodka and pepperoni slice. All slices were thin and crispy. No soggy bottoms! This pizzeria had (limited) outdoor seating which was nice as we brought a dog. Overall all the slices were good but the mushroom slices was the best. So so good. read more

Diamond Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Overdue review, went here a couple months ago and grabbed a quick lunch here. They have a great selection of slices and it's very nice inside with a couple booths and tables. I ordered the pepperoni and jalapeño slice and it was delicious. The cool thing is they give you hot honey to put on your pizza if you want. They have a Caesar slice that looked good and all the slices are topped with fresh parm. The guy helping me at the counter was very nice and I definitely recommend stopping by if you're in the Greenpoint area. read more

I am so glad I got to try Diamond Slice! I went around 7 PM on a weekday and there were plenty of slices left. I got the supreme and the chicken bacon ranch but they all looked amazing. The staff were really friendly and quick and got us an extra chair to sit down. It only took a few minutes for them to heat the slices. Both slices were cooked perfectly which is usually rare for reheated slices. NY slices can sometimes turn into dry crackers when reheated too much but this dough was crisp yet still doughy/chewy. I really liked the supreme which was pepperoni, jalapeño, sausage, and olives but I think the pepperoni jalapeño slice would've been better. The sausage and olives didn't add much. The chicken bacon ranch slice was like nothing I have ever had before. It was amazing! I think they also make their own ranch or something because it had a nice homemade taste. I highly recommend this place especially if you're into unique pizza toppings beyond pepperoni and cheese! read more

Diamond Slice - supreme and chicken bacon ranch - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Scared to give 5 stars because I don't want my spot blown up! So lucky to live down the street, I go here at least once a week. Favorite slice in the whole city is their buffalo chicken slice (another favorite is their elote square slice), but everything there is so good. Plus, the service is the absolute best - nicest food service you'll ever experience in NYC. Consistently great food, better than other great local spots like Chrissy's and L'industrie. I love Diamond Slice!!! read more

Extremely good. I also love the decor. Friendly staff fair prices. It just rocks. Top 5 pizza. Up there with L'indisutrie . lucia and cello read more

Diamond Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Blown away by the slices here! Came in not sure what to expect and all 3 slices we got were great! They also offer free hot honey to add which is really nice as it's often an up charge. I liked every slice but the Buffalo chicken was def a standout and I would highly recommend! read more

My new favorite pizza spot! So far I've tried the plain, spicy vodka and caesar slice. I really loved them all. I usually always get a caesar slice, but i need to try all of the other ones that they have read more

Diamond Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Amazing buffalo chicken slice! It has scallion. Olive s allion and have never had a buffalo slice with scallion. So hungry I ate it cold and it was amazing. Will return for a warm one! And cheap only $5 with tax. Eat here now. read more

Caesar slice was good very fresh and perfect amount of dressing. Also got a plain slice which was also very good and perfectly crispy. read more

Diamond Slice - Caesar slice and plain cheese - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Absolutely loved this place from the first time I went. Has quickly become my favorite slice in the city. The crust is crispy and delicious, the sauce and the cheese is perfect, everything they do is top notch. The staff are awesome, really friendly and care about the food. Highly recommend to anyone who comes to visit. read more

Truly amazing pizza! I'm impressed. I got the pepperoni jalapeño and the buffalo chicken and both were great. Thin crispy crust and great flavor. Two small complaints though. A pepperoni slice is like 3.75 and pepperoni with jalapeño is $5? That seems like a high markup for some peppers. My second complaint was that I wanted just regular pepperoni anyways but it was SO burnt. If they heated it up it would have been a charred crisp. They should have just tossed it and made another. I didn't see anyone order it and it looked like it had been sitting there awhile because....burnt. So I selected the other options which were great! I'll be back to get their regular pepperoni which I'm sure will be amazing if not burnt. read more

Diamond Slice - Pepperoni and buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best of the best. My literal only problem is that they don't currently do delivery but it's probably a good thing because I'd be getting it every night. The owner and all of the workers there are the nicest people. I love just hanging out there too. It's got the best vibe. My absolute favorite pizza place period. read more

Diamond Slice has the best classic slice in the area, but its other slices stand out even more. The shop is clean and finished in a retro-ish style with wooden booths to dine in if you so choose. Don't miss the tomato slice. read more

Wanted to grab a slice Friday night around 6 . I heard the pizza was great here . Waited in a line for a few minutes and noticed a LOT of people standing around waiting for their orders. Since I was in a hurry I asked for a slice on a paper plate ( not heated up) to go . I then was in the queue to wait for the slice and after a few minutes of waiting I noticed all the others from when I came in were still waiting . I then noticed a tiny oven behind the counter that heats up a fraction of the slices needed to clear the line and move things quick . So I realized I was in for a very long wait for just my 1 cold slice on a paper plate. I then just decided to leave . I don't understand why they just didn't give me the cold slice on the spot .. I also don't understand why they don't have a bigger over to heat up the slices... Nobody wants to wait a half hour for a slice no matter how good it is . read more

The only reason I gave 3 stars is because I really love their Pizza. But their service is slow. It's not good. You have a cashier guy who was there this afternoon. This Sunday, who literally handles cash, touches all surfaces, including rags to wipe trays. And then he has the audacity without washing his hands. The whole time that we were there to go handle the cheese constantly with his hands and grate it over the slices as they come out. And then also handle the Bay leaves, or whatever it is. He's ripping out of a bag and sprinkling on to the Pizza. Very unhygienic, very unprofessional, and totally unacceptable. That needs to be fixed because it's going to ruin this establishment. Many people who were there saw the same thing? And we were not happy with that. He's very slow and unresponsive and unhygienic. You need to be more attentive and how people are handling food or your establishment? Because it's gonna ruin your reputation. The pizza was great.But the service and the handling terrible read more

Just tried Diamond Slice and it's a great addition to the neighborhood! I had a Caesar slice and a Pepperoni slice. The Caesar had a great crackery crust topped with an anchovy umami filled Caesar salad topping. The Pepperoni was an excellent slice. The dough is reminiscent of a sourdough crust, as the dough has definitely been proofed for a few days... Nice selection of Mexican coke and Fanta to wash down the slices. read more

The buffalo and caesar slices are incredible. And the staff is kind and the line moved so fast. I think about the advice, "If you're in New York and you see a line for food, look a block away and find the better food." That's Diamond Slice for Greenpoint pizza. read more

Diamond Slice - Buffalo chicken slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

As a buffalo chicken addict, I was over the moon to hear this hype pop-up concept was setting up shop in our neighborhood. And come Feb, they're finally open. First off, service was super sweet and seemed to be rolling smoothly even though they were definitely likely still in the phase of getting their sea legs. 5 bucks for a slice seems to be standard now, and for specialty slices, I didn't sweat it too much. The interior is super inviting. Warm tones, tons of natural light, comfy banquets, and a solid amount of additional seating that you don't often see in NYC parlors. Got the two "specialty slices" -- Caesar and buff chix. I will say, the dough is fantastic. Pleasantly soft and pillowy with only that outermost shatter-crisp, it differentiates itself nicely from everyone doing the over-elastic chewy thing. I love them both, but it's nice to see people trying to differentiate themselves and plant a flag in a different texture. All in all, I wanted more punch. The buffalo sauce could've been hotter. And the Caesar dressing tasted a bit watered down. There is zero doubt in my mind I will be back, however, because these folks have something special going on. The above is undoubtably just due to finding their groove! read more

Top 5 Pizza Places in NYC. Unbelievably delicious pizza! The dough is perfection. No two pizzas are the same. So far I've been OBSESSED with the white slice. They have a great variety of pies. Don't sleep on this fantastic spot! read more

What a great no frills pizza joint. I ordered the vodka slice and mushroom slice. Both were thin and not floppy. The vodka slice was my favorite due to the robust fresh tomato they use. These slices aren't laden with cheese so you don't feel so stuffed after eating two. There were very few people when I went on a Friday afternoon so the slices came out quickly. They have a few other slices I had my eye on, so I guess I'll have to come back another day. There's a limited amount of tables and booth. If they're all occupied you can take your pizza on to either of the parks. There is also a one person bathroom for customers. read more

Best pizza in NYC hands down! Went to John's of Bleeker the day before coming here. Diamond is the new undisputed GOAT of NYC. Get here asap. Cancel all your plans. Order the Cheese slice well done. You're welcome. read more

Diamond Slice - 2x Cheese Slice and 1x Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza is DELICIOUS and the service is next level! Best by the slice in the area without a doubt. Will be back many times!

Favorite pizza slice in nyc. I live in Greenpoint and paulie gs used to be my favorite. Now Diamond slice is

Pizza is ok but for the time I had to wait ( extremely long due to mistakes that kept happening) not worth for me. Not going back.

Unreal buffalo chicken slice and amazing staff !!!!!!!! 10/10 will definitely be coming back to try the other slices.

Buffalo Slice, Caesar Slice and Hot Honey Jalapeño Pepperoni are amazing. This place gets really busy on Friday nights (as it should), but I'd much rather have that and wait a little bit for fresh slices than to to pay $35 bucks for a medium pizza pie up the block. Keep in mind they have only been open for 2 months and this is already a great addition to the area. Next time I'm going to try the spicy vodka and bbq chicken. My partner had the spicy vodka and she loved it last week, plus they have free hot honey for you to add. Its really great stuff. read more

This place gets EVERTHING right. Great slice, great sauce, nice people. Such a good addition the neighborhood.

The pizza is delicious and so fresh plus this is a great addition to Greenpoint!! The owners story of how he landed in this location also makes it very special! read more

So damn good. Try to get there early because I've seen them have to close for the day due to sell out.