Went there in a Tuesday evening Great service, nice atmosphere. They had a seasonal peach pizza which sounds weird but it was pretty good. They let us get different flavors so we mixed and match a few flavors. Definitely recommend read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - There's the peach pizza which sounds - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

Dewey's is probably my favorite pizza restaurant in Columbus. The salads are truly excellent with big portions: a side size is probably enough for two people to split. The pizzas are delicious with some inventive specials (like the Porky Fig, which is sweet and savory with blue cheese, honey, prosciutto, etc). You can also do half and half of specialty pizzas, even mixing white and red sauces on the same pie. Get a side of their ranch dressing too; it's perfect for dipping. The place is usually packed for dinner, so be ready for a little wait. (They've also got a nice patio in warm weather!). read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Porky fig & Green Lantern pizza (we already ate half!) - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

A favorite pizza place in Columbus. And the service is always excellent. Highly recommend!

I came here with my mother for lunch around 1pm. The parking lot was small but there is tons of on street parking and a public lot across the street. At 1pm the place wasnt busy at all. There was one other customer at a table against the wall. The hostess was very welcoming and let us pick where we wanted to sit. For some reason my 84 yr old mother always wants to sit by a window. That is more scenic but in the late fall, on a damp, cold, dreary day.... Sitting by the window was also cold. She couldnt figure out why she was so cold. Lol. Also adding to the temperature conundrum was the hvac had a outport directly over the booth she choose. Still she didnt want to move. So I sat there freezing but smiling. The menu has a lot of things to choose from. Being fall, I knew they had the harvest salad. So I knew that was what i was ordering. She wanted pizza. At Deweys, you can order any of the specialty pizza half and half. So we ordered half Van Damme (brussell sprouts, onions, bacon, garlic n cheese ) and half a Hawaiian. Pizza was big enough to share and have three pieces to take home. Salad was huge and I ate every last leaf. Its one of my favorite salads. It has peptitas, figs and boursin cheese topped with homemade cider vinaigrette. Soo good. We left full and happy. Thanks Deweys. read more

See all

I've been wanting to try Dewey's for a while, but it's a bit of a trek from home. We finally made it out to the Worthington location for a late lunch to celebrate my daughters' last day of school. We started with the peppercorn ranch salad and loved it so much we ordered a second. It was super refreshing, and according to my daughter who's a self-proclaimed ranch connoisseur; the dressing was superior. For pizzas, we tried Ryan's Inferno and a classic pepperoni. Ryan's Inferno is their take on buffalo chicken pizza, topped with buffalo chicken, blue cheese, celery, and ranch on an olive oil base. It had great flavor, though the blue cheese was a bit overpowering. Next time, we'd probably skip that topping. The real standout of both pizzas? The crust. Light, airy, fluffy and seriously delicious. However, the pepperoni pizza fell flat. It tasted low quality, almost like something from Little Caesars. We couldn't quite tell if it was the sauce or the pepperoni, but it lacked flavor and felt underwhelming. Ryan's Inferno was the clear favorite at our table. I can see why Dewey's is a neighborhood go-to, but for serious pizza lovers, it's just okay. Major kudos for the crust, though, it deserves its own spotlight. read more

See all

If you need gluten free- good place to be! The types of pies were delish and easy to grab to bring home

I have had Dewey's Pizza in Grandview and this Worthington location a few times. My friend and I shared the seasonal Harvest salad with fig, bacon, and pumpkin seeds that was delicious before the Bronx Bomber pizza with Pepperoni, Sliced Sausage, Black Olives, Green Peppers, and Onions. I loved the Bronx Bomber because of gooey cheese and sliced sausage. Other pizza places do sausage crumbles while Dewey's is one of the few that does sliced sausage on their pizzas. I love the New York style thin crust that crispy on the edge and soft that you can fold the pizza slice.It was lunchtime and not that busy, there was one server who did a wonderful job in taking great care of my friend and I. I like you can see where they make your pizza. I will be going back to Dewey's Pizza in Worthington, Grandview, will check the Dublin location too. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Bronx Bomber pizza with Pepperoni, sliced sausage, black olives, onions, and green peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

First time trying Dewey's pizza and it was incredible! We ordered the elote pizza and a cheese with jalapenos. The elote pizza is seasonal so definitely try it before it goes away! The sweet smoky notes of the roasted corn are complemented by the tajin crema drizzled on top, adding a zesty brightness that cuts through the richness. What sets this pizza apart is the crust of the pizza. It is baked to perfection, it's fluffy and light. I would 100% recommend this spot! read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

Dewey's Pizza has a good variety of specialty pizzas. I promise myself I will try something new each time I go. However, I always end up ordering the Porky Fig pizza. It is just too good. The Porky Fig pizza has a fig jam base, mozzarella, fontina, prosciutto, caramelized red onions, gorgonzola. It may sound a little odd, but it is a delicious combination of sweet and savory. Dewey's restaurant is not that large of a space, but it does offer seating space outside as well. They also sometimes bring in live music. The bar area is pretty small. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Porky Fig - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

Stopped in for Lunch with the Hubby. Our first time here. Inside was nice and open. They have a window to the kitchen. You can see the magic happening. Staff was very friendly and the space was nice and clean. We decided to try 2 different pies. One was the Hawaiian and the Other was a Veggie. They came out nice and hot and both had nice flavor to them. Nice amount of toppings. We enjoyed everything about our experience. Not normally in this area but if we are we will come back to try more. read more

See all

I've came here off and on over the years - and it's consistently been a good experience all around. The pizzas are always tasty, the service is always fast and friendly. I'll be back, and I do recommend them if you see them and end up curious. They may not blow you away - but they will leave you satisfied. But the specifics: I've had a variety of pizzas, I don't know if I have ever done a "basic" pizza here, I really should to verify that's as good as their specialties. It hasn't been mind blowing - they're never my first choice, but when someone says "want to do Dewey's?" I'm reminded it's been some time and they still hit the mark, well enough. I'm not a pizza snob, but I know what I like, and Dewey's is pretty good (although, no Flying Pizza/A Slive of New York). I ate a salad once - it was a great deal for the price! Big enough to share, for sure. I would definitely go back for the salads. read more

Sherley Temple had the perfect amount of grenadine syrup. I never knew how delicious garlic sauce was on pizza until I went here.

Best gourmet style pizza. Period. I started going to the first location over 20 years ago Oakley (Cincinnati). The food quality has remained high, and their management, service and training keep getting better and better! We love the big salads- they are always well done. The pizzas are darn good- a fluffy crust, slightly spicy sauce and high quality toppings. The calzones are the sleeper here- its not easy to find calzones this well done. Sauce for dipping on the side. Sit at the bar for a simple weeknight date night. read more

Great food. I also would like to give a shout out to Andy, the general manager, for handling a minor delay with the utmost professionalism and good service. We will absolutely be back. read more

I've loved Dewey's since back when I lived in Dayton and that love is still true. Exceptional salads, fantastic 'za and a truly great service model make for an amazing experience. Today I had the seasonal Harvest salad which rocked my world with abundant greens, dried figs, garlicky Boursin cheese, pumpkin seeds, bacon and a cider vinaigrette. I followed that up with a pizza that was half porky fig, half meatball. A finer gourmet pizza I've yet to find - it checked all the boxes. My mouth and tummy are happy. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Porky fig / meatball pizza - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

So after having Dewey's pizza, I'd say its definitely towards the top of my Columbus pizza list now. Staff was nice and patient, restaurant was nice and clean, food was great. My only complaint would probably be that parking appears sort of sparse but it didn't seem to be an issue when I went. We got 2 small half and half pizzas. You can literally make any pizza half and half, which is amazing cause I like to try everything. They also have create your own options so really you can sort of do whatever you want flavorwise. As the preset topping combos were already enticing, we tried 4 different ones. We got the seasonal arugula prosciutto, meatball, green lantern with white sauce, and edgar allan poe. Also got everything well done cause im a crispy bitch. All the flavors were great but the arugula prosciutto was def my favorite of the bunch and made me sad it was seasonal. The choice of getting white sauce for the green lantern turned out great. Don't know what it'd be like as is so can't compare. Overall, it was great pizza and having the welldone option made the pizza so crispy. It also felt super light for what it is and I was able to finish a whole pizza alone. No shame, fatty life forever. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - MEATBALL and arugula Prosciutto - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

Stopped in the other night and was impressed with the dining room and facilities, very clean, Employees seemed happy to be there, nice seeing them hand toss the pizzas. We got a new trainee waitress who did a great job. Now we just tried a basic pizza (cheese and pepperoni) Delivered hot and delicious. Thin hand tossed crust with tangy sauce. Very good! read more

Dewey's Pizza is definitely good pizza. We ordered a cheese, veggie, and a caprice. The caprice is a white pizza with garlic, cherry tomatoes, and basil. It was by far my favorite. The veggie was also delicious. I found the cheese pizza to be fairly unremarkable but decent. The salads were good as well. The brownies were amazing which I was not expecting. No idea where they get them from but they are so good. Like best I have ever had good. The only issues we had was it was a bit difficult to order and we ended up getting an extra pizza, not for free or anything. The person I was speaking with had a really hard time hearing and said that their phone didn't work well. There also was an event uptown so we couldn't get to the location to pickup the order which is no fault of Dewey's but it would have been nice of them to give us a heads up that we would have to park somewhere else and walk there to pick up the food. Regardless I'm still thinking about those brownies so they are doing something right. read more

See all

My favorite take out pizza for a reason, especially if you are looking for something a little more upscale. I love the fun and eccentric pizza toppings. My all time favorite is the Porky Fig with fig and prosciutto, but the Dr Dre was also very tasty with a spicy kick!We also tried the salads, which were very good. Overall highly recommend - I always get a large because the leftovers are more than worth it! read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - PORKY FIG - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

Dewey's is always amazing. Their Caesar salad is a MUST. So good. We got a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and their seasonal pizza. it was good! Roasted potatoes, bacon, cheese, onions, basically a loaded potato pizza. We loved it. Always such good service here too! read more

See all

My daughter and I had the opportunity to eat here in advance of a Blue Jackets game. The location is parking challenged, however the restaurant was clean. Their kitchen was open for everyone to see which was nice. No hiding a bad kitchen here. Was told there was a wait for a table with visibly open tables. While we were told they were reserved, many open tables remained the entire time we were there. We sat at the bar and the staff was awesome. Very interactive, attentive and friendly. We enjoyed a half and half pizza end enjoyed the food. For my taste, there are other pizza that I enjoy more, but not bad. read more

Dewey's is one of our favorite pizza places we've found since moving to Columbus. The pizza crust is thin and floppy like NY pizza. They use high quality toppings and have great pizza of the month specials. But for whatever reason, this location is very stingy with the toppings. That is my only criticism. Of the pizzas we've tried, I'd say the meatball pizza was our least favorite. It was really lacking meatballs and toppings, which made it bland and not filling at all. To quote my hubby, "it was weak". LOL! Our favorites have all been monthly specials; the arugula prosciutto, Tito Santana, and the elote. They were all amazing! A while back we tried to replicate a pizza that Pagliacci's in Seattle makes (Dewey's crust is very similar to Pagliacci's). It had an olive oil base with Gorgonzola, fontina, tomatoes (added after bake), fresh basil, and oregano. It turned out pretty good but it was very light on toppings. We paid a premium for each topping, so I don't feel we should have to pay for extra toppings next time just to get a normal amount of toppings. We often find ourselves taking the toppings and trying to distribute them onto pieces that have little or no toppings at all. They don't offer any sides/appetizers like breadsticks, garlic knots, or garlic cheese bread. They do have a variety of salads to choose from though. If you are wanting pick up or delivery on the weekends, make sure to order ahead, because it usually takes around 90 minutes. read more

See all

Rotten lettuce in my salad. Pizza was good. Get lightly done. Yadayadayadayadayadayada read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Rotten lettuce in my salad tonight. Yuck! Pizza was good. - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

The pizza selection is really good! They have some great specialty pizzas and the quality of ingredients seems to be better than most. I never really feel "bad" after eating here whereas at other pizza places, it tastes good but then sits in your stomach like a brick. read more

We came to Dewey's on a weekend afternoon. To start, I got the Downeast original cider, which was great. My fiancé and I split an 11 inch pizza, which was plenty of food for us. Each of us had 4 slices. We got pepperoni and half banana peppers, half onion. The pizza was crispy, yet fluffy. The sauce was pretty bland. I wished there was more flavor overall. The service was great and attentive. However, Based on this two topping pizza, I would say it was just ok and not anything I would crave. If I come again, I might try one of their signature pizzas! read more

See all

porky fig extray crispy. porky fig extray porky fig extray crispy. crispy. porky fig extray crispy porky fig extray crispy. porky fig extray crispy. porky fig extray crispy. porky fig extray crispy. porky fig extray crispy. . porky fig extray crispy. read more

Tried Dewey's tonight. It's been on our list of must try pizza spots in Cbus for awhile. I'm from Cleveland originally and not a fan of the traditional square, cracker thin pizza here. I'm constantly on the hunt for a NY or hand tossed oozing with garlic butter and the perfect sauce. Dewey's is one of the rare spots to include ricotta in their calzone which sold me right away. The dough is perfectly soft and chewy! Bacon is a bit lackluster but the topping to crust ratio was a perfect balance and you could tell everything was incredibly fresh. The service was fantastic and you could see right into the kitchen. We enjoyed seeing the kids lined up on the benches amazed at the dough being tossed back in there. Interested in their endless options of toppings, long list of specialty and the option to do a 1/2 and 1/2 on any of them. We'll definitely be back. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - CALZONE - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

Best pizza ever! Very creative flavors and creations. Stafford was friendly and atmosphere was great. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Cuban pizza...so yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

The staff was so amazing here and the food- outstanding! I love the variety of pizzas you can get and the quality of the ingredients is very good. read more

Yummy food, quick and friendly service, and nice ambience. We went here for the first time on National pizza day and it did not disappoint at all! We got a drink each and then a large pizza with white sauce, fresh basil & toasted pine nuts toppings (I don't think I've seen these options anywhere else, loved it!).. oooh and the pistachio cheesecake was too tempting to pass- decadently delicious! Also, it was fun to watch them make the dough from the glass windows as you walk in and if need to wait to be seated :D read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - White sauce Fresh Basil Toasted Pine Nuts - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

They have great calzones!! Haven't tried the pizza yet. But their calzones are so good, i'm sure the pizzas are excellent as well. Everytime I go, i'm treated well and greeted when I walk in a timely manner. Highly recommended!! read more

I have been coming to Dewey's for years and they never fail to deliver a great experience. From a traditional slice of pepperoni to their fancier pies, each pizza is packed with flavor. I recommend their salads as well! Also, the managers at the Worthington store are excellent, especially Lily. She was so kind and went above and beyond to ensure we had a wonderful family dinner! __________________________________________________________ YELP SCORE: 5/5 *Value *Food *Atmosphere *Drinks *Service __________________________________________________________ XANDER SCORE: (4) CRITERIA: (1)-Nobody should enjoy their experience here. (2)-I disliked my experience here, but I could see why others might enjoy it. (3)-I enjoyed my experience here, but I could see why others might dislike it. (4)-Everybody should enjoy their experience here. read more

Loved this place! The salads were to die for with really great homemade dressings- the red pepper Greek dressing was amazing. You can get a half and half pizza which was a crowd pleaser. We just split a huge half and half and loved it. Plus, downtown Worthington is so cute and this has a great outdoor patio read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

Dewey's is amazing! Pizza is a bit in the pricy side, but they specialty of options they offer is fantastic! Their salads are exquisite as well! One of my favorite pizza places in Columbus. read more

I really enjoy the pizza here. The thin crusty doe is amazing and the toppings are always fresh. Great customer service as well! One time they "messed up" and put the wrong color peppers on my pizza and it wasn't until they brought out a whole new pizza to go did I realize their small mistake. I prefer the Ryan's Inferno speciality pizza but I've never had a bad pie here. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - 17" half DR. DRE, half RYAN'S INFERNO - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

We have frequented this location on numerous occasions over many years. We have always enjoyed our food and dining experience. Tonight I jumped online to see what the wait was for our family of 4 and it said 0-5 minutes so we headed from our home to Dewey's. Upon arrival we were told a 45 minute wait. I told the server and a woman I believed to be the manager that online had said 0-5 minutes thus we did not put our name in. I went ahead and put our name in. I used the restroom and upon returning to the waiting area I pulled up the website so I could show the manager that it was showing a minimal wait. When I did it showed no wait! I thought if I was a manager I would want to know this. I proceeded to show her and she was downright rude! Very nasty tone saying she cannot control what it says online. Not the response I was expecting. Needless to say her nastiness made us leave. Upon getting to our car (a 3 minute walk) I received a text that our table was ready (all of this occurred in less than 10 minutes, not 45). We did not go back and to be honest I don't know if we ever will. I did not deserve to be spoken to the way I was and I will choose to take my money elsewhere. read more

I love this place! They have a huge selection of Ohio beers to choose from, delicious food, and the service is outstanding. I always come here for their calzones, which are out of this world! And, considering how big they are, they're a bargain! read more

Great pizza and salads, but the salads are on the smaller side considering the price ($7+). We typically eat here monthly.

Fast friendly service leading up to outstanding pizza pies! Some of the best pizzas in the Columbus-Worthington area for sure! You won't go wrong with a trip to Dewey's!! read more

The service was great, lots of young high school kids it seemed like. The ambiance was nice, except for sitting at the bar was not the best view. The pizza was good, crust was great, ingredients were a bit sparse for the price. But overall great. Nice selection of brews. read more