BEST PIZZA EVER! This is our go to pizza place, the whole family loves it too! We have been coming here for about ten years and haven't been dissapointed. read more

We find ourselves at Dewey's fairly often but try to avoid during busy times like Friday and Saturday nights because it can get SO busy and the wait times are long. If you go early or for lunch you're usually good. We love the ambiance and service and think their their pizza is pretty good. We often do a half and half. Their Bronx bomber is my favorite and my little one loves their caprese. We also love their salads - and my favorite is their seasonal harvest salad (mmmm Boursin!) I've also gotten carry out for work events and they do a great job of packing everything up and making sure you have all the plates, napkins, etc that you need. In the summer, they have music on their patio which is a lot of fun! Downsides: it's it downtown Worthington and the parking lot only has like 5 spots so parking can be a bit of hassle, especially during community events. Also, occasionally the pizza comes out a little underdone in the crust and we have to ask them to put it back in for a bit....usually on the Bronx bomber so maybe all those toppings make it extra hard to cook through? read more

Decided not to eat here after they messed up the reservation. I made a reservation for two and they mistakenly put it down for four. They took us to a table and I told them we made a reservation for two. The hostess walked away with the menus and we went ahead and sat at the table. The hostess came back and told us we could sit there until another table more appropriate for two came available. This is absolutely poor customer service! I cannot believe it. read more

This was our 1st time here and we will definitely be back! The employees were all friendly and work as a team taking care of customers orders and bringing the food out to us. We got a 17" Pizza that was 1/2 Don Corleone & 1/2 Bronx Bomber minus mushrooms (yuk) and black olives because my fiancé doesn't like black olives. The pizza was very good. I like their sauce and the crust was perfect! Make sure to leave room for the chocolate chip cookies for dessert. They were 2 nice size warm chocolate chip cookies served with a cup of ice cold milk and were so good. We can't wait to go back and try something different. As we looked around at the tables and the different food they were serving, everything looked so good. Trust me you won't be disappointed when you eat here. Definitely worth the visit here. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - This pizza tasted so good! - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

This is one of the finest pizza spots I've enjoyed over the years. They boast an excellent drink selection, hefty salads, and of course delicious pizza. I'm an avid pizza lover and Dewy's hits the spot! Their dough and sauce is phenomenal. The cheese is just right! We even tried the taco pizza as odd as that sounds and it was exceptional! I can't really say much more about this place but how excellent the service was as well. This is just a perfect example of an All American Pizza place done right! If you Love pizza like I do in any form or fashion you're sure to Love Dewy's! read more

Both the food and the customer service here are unmatched. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and a caprice pizza, along with beers and side salads. All of the food, per usual, was delicious! Their salads are tasty and very good portions (usually not very noteworthy at pizza restaurants), and both of their pizzas were hot and delicious and also seasoned well. The restaurant was particularly busy, and one of our salads got lost in the mix. The serving staff were all very quick to fix the error despite the hectic atmosphere in the restaurant, and the manager even voided the salad off of our bill. Then when our pizza came out, it had a "hole" in it (just an unfortunate accident in the cooking process, nothing more). We were totally fine eating that pizza, but the manager personally gave us the pizza with the hole to eat (which was still delicious) AND offered us a fresh pizza to go in place of the original at no cost. Despite being a very busy night, all of the staff were very friendly and thoughtful, and their service was fantastic! As someone who worked in the restaurant industry for years, I can attest to the fact that when the restaurant gets very busy, it can be difficult to juggle efficiency and stellar service at the same time, and the whole staff at Dewey's really rallied around each other and helped each other out, filling each other's table drinks and expo'ing food, making the dining experience for everyone really great. I highly recommend giving Dewey's a try, and I believe it's one of the best pizza spots in the area. The service and the food are great. Thanks! Ps-when you receive great service, I feel like it's always a nice gesture to let a manager know. People are very quick to complain but never as quick to praise. Pps-TIP THE WAITSTAFF WELL! read more

Dewey's in Worthington never fails. Great service! Excellent pizza. Fun environment.

I recently got to try Dewey's Pizza for takeout for a work lunch meeting and I was quite impressed. So today my boyfriend and I decided to get carryout from this location. I recently read an article on how much commission fees third party delivery services charge restaurants so I've decided to make the commitment to drive out to the restaurants I want to support. We ordered the Edgar Allan Poe (my personal favorite), a 13" halved of Dr. Dre and Ryan's Inferno, and a peppercorn ranch salad. I especially love the fact that they will half any of their pizza sizes. They have a very effective curbside pickup system with one employee stationed outside under a canopy, who takes your name when you pull in and calls into the store on a walkie talkie for another employee to bring the order to your car. Both employees wore a mask and the transaction took no more than a couple minutes. Dewey's has earned a spot as my favorite pizza joint in Ohio! read more

See all

I've been multiple times and have had really great pizza every time. Beer selection is alright, but they probably offer at least something for everyone. Very good, will absolutely return. read more

This place was crazy busy when we had dinner on a Saturday night. We are at the bar because the wait was long. Too bad the bar is dinky. This will be a great place during the summer as they have a giant patio. Pizzas are delicious. And the salads were unique and tasty. Definitely would go again. Sorry, bit location in Downtown Worthington means parking is horrible. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

I cannot express how much we love this location. The staff is always extremely pleasant and helpful. You never have to wait long for anything, as everyone checks tables they pass to refill drinks or get boxes and your check. Tonight our pizza and calzone were taking slightly longer than average, but we didn't mind as the above comments are always the standard at Dewey's, and we were having a nice night out and in no rush. Not even 5 minutes after we mentioned only to each other (never to a staff member) that it was taking slightly longer, a staff member came over and apologized for our wait for our food. Already appreciative of the service we always receive, we felt this was even a step further. Dewey's will always be a go-to simply for the way they treat their customers and work as a staff! On top of the top-notch service, the food is always delicious! I love that you can get half and half on any size pizza. My fiancé loves the calzones! read more

Barely Melted Cheese + Super Thin Crust = Floppy Pizza. We ordered a Killer Veggie and the cheese was just melted, not brown at all. Firstly, that means that the pizza slice didn't come off the cardboard round they serve it on (cheap and wasteful, in my opinion!) easily--each slice stuck to the cardboard and was followed by long tentacles of cheese that refused to submit to my will! Since they don't give you a spatula, good luck with that. Secondly, the barely melted cheese thing means the pizza is just a little bit gaggy going down. I know you know what I mean!!! Probably the barely melted cheese problem has to do with the thinness of the dough. If it hadn't been rolled so thin, maybe it could have been in the oven longer, but as it was, the crust and underside were relatively brown. Cooking it longer would have resulted in a burnt crust probably. So the pizza is floppy and the toppings fall off. We still ate it all and it was okay. Decent coffee, excellent service, lots of parking nearby. Nice patio. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Killer Veggie sans black olives stuck to cardboard and losing toppings. - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

This used to be my favorite pizza place ......but never have I ever had to wait over an hour for a pizza. After 45 minutes, I was finally able to get the server's attention to ask where our food was . The manager finally came out and said they were having "computer problems" and that our pizza was never made. It would be ready in 10 minutes. 20 minutes later it finally arrived. It was warm but not "hot out of the oven". Not once did the server stop by to apologize or even acknowledge the fact that she never followed up on checking the status of our order until I inquired about it. Yes, they did give us the meal for free after the mishap, but I would have rather paid for it and had better service. I've been to this and other Dewey's locations in the past and have always had excellent service. Not tonight . Do better Dewey's, do better. read more

Every time we come here we go excellent customer service. Rodney is amazing. His knowledge of all the food and drinks are incredible. The Pizza is amazing and the Ranch dressing is to die...for. You will love Worthington Dewey's. I guarantee. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

Excellent family dinner from beginning to end! Had reservations for 12 and we were warmly greeted and promptly seated. This was quite surprising for a chilly and busy Friday night. Our server Brian was friendly and made good wine suggestions to go with our 6 speciality pizzas. We loved them all, but the Dr. Dre and Bronx Bomber tied for #1! The Harvest salad was tasty and large enough to share. The manager Lily was attentive and delightful. Can't wait to go back! read more

Deweys is my FAVORITE pizza place ever, so I was really happy to see a couple locations in Columbus when I moved here! The past year or so though I've been trying to eat at home more (I basically never go out to dinner anymore) BUT that's where this review gets good--I haven't actually eaten st this location but did you know they sell their pizza dough??? It tastes 100X better than when I try to make it and I think it's actually cheaper than buying yeast, flour etc. It costs 3.50 for a large dough ball (which I cut in half to make two pizzas) and they super kindly give you a second dough ball for free in case you mess up--God love 'em. Every time I've gone in to purchase dough balls they have been so so kind. I'd totally recommend this location for pizza OR dough read more

We got carry out from Dewey's last night. It had been awhile since we ate there, and I had forgotten how good it is! Totally worth the trip to Worthington. Great pizza, salads, and service. read more

Love their pizza and Cesar salad ! They have the best ranch! Don't forget to order some with your pizza because I don't even like ranch and I think theirs is delish!!!!! read more

Great place to eat for groups. Customer service is based on teams and this provides quality. Better than most pizza based restaurants. We would like more TVs but forces us to interact as a group. Pizza was spot on. Will come again. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Half Dr. Dre and Bronx Bomber - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

Wonderful service, well managed. Love the peppercorn ranch salad, and how the servers always repeat your order to you just to make sure they get it right. Also, they always check on your beverages and refill as needed. read more

It's more of a 3.5 stars for me. We tried the seasonal pizza and bronx bomber, both were good but the sausage on the bronx bomber was kind of meh. This place gets really packed around 6pm, by the time we left there was a line of people waiting for a table! read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Seasonal and bronx bomber - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

Great experience! Pizza has a flavorful sauce,great crust. Service was great, dessert delicious. I had a salad with yummy housemade dressing. Lovely patio atmosphere is on point. Located is historic downtown Worthington, a great relaxing vibe. We'll be back! read more

See all

Nice setting. Service is always good. Pizza's are great if not a little pricy. The big secret is the salads are great. They seasonally rotate the salads, but my favorite is the Harvest. read more

Had Dewey's for dinner tonight, sat at the bar and enjoyed a nice glass of Riesling and the seasonal pizza for dinner! It's always such a great experience here. From the food, to the service, to the management, they really do a great job, especially since the pandemic. While I was enjoying my dinner, I noticed the manager getting yelled at by a guest - who I'm assuming was having a bad day. I was surprised at how calm she was able to stay, and how well she was able to handle the situation. I have seen her many times since I frequent Deweys so I asked the bartender, Zach, for her name because after seeing her get yelled at by a guest AND still keep her cool, I just knew she was a great lady. Molly - you are awesome! Keep up the great work! read more

Went here last night. It's obviously popular because wait tines were ridiculous and carry out was quite brisk. We tried 3 different salads.. amazing. Then we tried a half and half pizza. One had sausage, the other side had goat cheese artichokes and garlic. But it was called green lantern with almost nothing green on it? So delicious. Talked to one family who said they come every week read more

This is the place for New York style pizza. Just ask for the number of slices and it's done. We come here often and if things aren't right. They make it right!!! I recommend Dewey's for pizza night. read more

I enjoy the heck out of Dewey's pizza. Hand-tossed, fresh dough, interesting flavor combinations, big slices of pepperoni/capicola on their Don Corleone pizza - it's a pizza that tastes awesome when it's hot, and meets the gold standard of pizza - tastes great cold! We are lucky to have this Dewey's between our house & the spouse's workplace. We stopped for dinner on a Friday evening, which are peak hours for most restaurants, and Dewey's was no exception. They are good at handling large groups and small kids, so if you have either of those, this is your kind of place. The staff are all nice and on the go for seating and service - which is an "all hands on deck," no assigned tables type of thing. As a jittery introvert, however, I HATE THIS MODEL WITH THE PASSION OF A THOUSAND FIERY SUNS. Ahem. It seems great, but I'm waaaaay too anxious for it. It kind of kept us away for a bit, and I thought it would be less of an issue once I'd experienced it again. But no. I enjoy getting another beer quickly, not so much being asked for a third time about it. Eek. The pizza itself is enough to bring me back for carryout, for sure, though. read more

Good pizza and always fast for pick up. My son loves being able to watch them throw the dough and make the pizzas from the glass watching area. A little greasier than I prefer but better than all the other chains like Pizza Hut, papa johns and the like. Update: Raising to 5 star for the customer service. Just picked up an order and dropped it when I got home. Called to have it remade and when I got there they told me it was on the house. Not many companies would look out for their customers like this so I will continue to give them my business. read more

Dewey's Pizza: What can I say to describe all the flavors? Delicious doesn't even begin to cover it.. Let me start with the calzones which come with your choice of 3 toppings.. I usually get the shiitake mushroom blend, banana peppers, and red onions..but what makes everything taste over the top is their homemade peppercorn ranch!! I also love the other dipping sauces which are a garlic oil blend and a marinara. I also adore all the pizzas and salads!! The Ryan's Inferno pizza is heavenly with just the right amount of chicken, gorgonzola, ranch, celery, and red onion...the best part is the Dewey's rewards card which gives you a punch every visit and after the 6th punch you get $10 off:) read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - The peppercorn ranch dressing is sooo good - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

When I used to live in Dayton, I loved the times that I went to the Dewey's there. Since moving to Columbus 4 years ago, I didn't remember that Columbus had locations too. This spot was chosen for our monthly after work meeting. I was shocked that there was hardly anyone there between the 4-5:30pm time frame that we were there, especially as it was a Thursday before the holidays. Our server was nice and very prompt about getting us anything we requested. My only complaint is that we probably shouldn't have been given a bigger table for our group of 5 as all the food and pizza stands were incredibly squished. I had the gluten free pepperoni and I thought it was great! I asked for a side of banana peppers and it definitely made it stand out even more. Our table had a mix of pizzas/salad and everything looked good. As I was the only person going straight home, they gave me the tons of leftovers and so I had a chance to sample all of the varieties. The Bronx Bomber was good. The fig base on the Porky Fig I did NOT like--at all. It was incredibly sweet and mixed with prosciutto and gorgonzola? I really disliked it and it was all thrown in the trash. Other than that, I'd recommend!! read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Bronx Bomber - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

I was super-disappointed at how bad my pizza was. I ordered a mushroom pizza with red sauce. The crust had no taste. Even a good frozen pizza or delivery chain crust (e.g. Papa John's) has a good yeasty flavor. Next, the cheese and sauce were used very sparingly. Overall, I'd say less than 3/4 of the surface of the crust was covered with anything and maybe less than half of the crust had both cheese & sauce. So if they crust is tasteless and they're stingy with the cheese and sauce, what have you got? A disappointing experience. The waitstaff was fine; the service was decent. read more

My daughter wanted us to try Deweys pizza for a while, she's gone there frequently. I order a medium Edgar Allen Po, a side salad with lemon dressing. My husband had the Don Corlione with a gluten free pizza crust. My pizza was good, i liked the house salad better, it was great. I tried my husbands gluten free pizza. For this, this was a premade gf crust (i think Udi's). I tried a bit when he finished. The gluten free crust gets tough and very dry, and i think all pizza shops offering gluten free use a premade crust, i would rather get frozen instead. Service was quick and our waitress really nice read more

We went here after having fun at Highball and found it to be very nice. We were greeted and seated very quickly (I and a young child found it interesting to stare through the window watching them make the pizzas). Our server was incredibly nice and even the manager that night came by and checked to see if our food was alright. The salad I ordered was very good and while the crust on the pizza wasn't as thin or crispy as I would've like the toppings were great. Seriously! Globs of good fresh mozzarella and nice chunks of sausage! Prices weren't bad - rather standard for places like this (meaning a large pie starts around $22) AND they have boxes for taking home leftovers ;) read more

I ordered the Candied Walnut and Grape side salad it was fresh and was very big for being a side salad. I also had a pepperoni and "mushroom mix" pie. The pizza was very good. The pepperoni was a little spicy but had a good flavor. The service may have been the best part of the meal! Our server was very attentive and knowledgable. I recommend this place and will be back soon! read more

See all

I saw this place being built 6 weeks ago while driving on High Street and read up on the reviews of the other store, which were really good, and knew I had to try it. So I convinced my girlfriend to bypass going once again to one of our typical pizza haunts and went down on a Saturday afternoon about 2pm on a Buckeye bye week to get some pizza. The place was nearly deserted with only one or two other tables in use. Not sure why it was so dead, perhaps it was because of when we came in or maybe it's because the Buckeyes weren't playing but it's a bit disconcernting to see a restaurant nearly empty, makes you wonder about their food. Anyways, we ordered two small pizzas, one Meatball and one Ryan's Inferno (buffalo chicken). The waiter suggested we save a bit of money and just get a large and do half-half which would also get us more pizza. I was really appreciative of him letting us know that rather than just placing the orders as it's always better to get more pizza for less money! After about 10-15 minutes a HUGE pizza came out that looked delicious. The meatballs on the pizza were large and tasty, very good quality meat and the cheese was great tasting. It may look like from the picture I posted that the cheese wasn't plentiful enough but it actually was great and plentiful. The other side of the pizza was Ryan's Inferno, a buffalo chicken whitesauce pizza. I was a bit skeptical seeing as it had celery on it but lo and behold they did a wonderful job with it. The celery was added after the pizza cooked so it was not hot and it was diced very small and didn't overwhelm the taste of the pizza. The sauce was just a hint of garlic and the chicken was of mild-slightly medium heat, not really all that spicy so most people will be ok with it. I went back and forth which side I liked best, leaning slightly towards the more traditional meatball but after eating the leftovers the next day I really think they were both fantastic. All in all this place was very good, a great gourmet pizza experience. It's not the traditional meat and sauce, huge pizza place but rather a more unique dining experience. I've not had a lot of gourmet type pizza and sometimes think it can be a bit pretentious and/or "weird" but this place suits me just fine, I think they could make you a traditional pizza or a more exotic creation either one and it'd be delicious. Highly recommended that everyone who is a pizza fan get down here and try this place out. The only thing that worries me is the utter lack of business on a bright and beautiful Saturday afternoon but then this place is new so maybe it just needs time to build a user base. Check it out, you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

First, I love Old Worthington so finding pizza on one of the main corners was extra amazing. I've been to this location twice now, once I sat inside and once I sat outside. Last night was perfect patio weather and we enjoyed drinks and pizza. My favorite thing is you can do a half and half pizza. My SO picks a half and I pick a half. Service is always good and House Pinot Grigio is pretty good. I recommend the Brewdog Hazy Jane brew for patio nights. read more

Dewey's is consistently good. It had been a long while since we've been to Dewey's although it's a favorite. We used the Yelp waitlist feature to save our spot in line. Our service was excellent and the pizza was delicious. We always order our pizzas well done everywhere and the quality and fineness is same every time. We got half pepperoni and half porky fig. Delicious! read more

Creative salads, unique pizzas, and outstanding customer service merit a firm 5 stars from me. When our large Killer Veggie pizza was delivered we were informed that they were in the process of making us ANOTHER pizza, free of charge, as the current one had a few holes. They wanted to provide us with the "holey" one to satiate our hunger but insisted on also delivering a perfect product. Honestly, the holes were not a problem at all and did not diminish my enjoyment of the pizza. However I am appreciative of the management and their commitment to good quality. We'll now be eating pizza for the next week and enjoying every second! read more

My daughter is a very picky eater, and getting her into Dewey's was like pulling teeth. I promised her that we'd order a plain cheese or pepperoni pizza and if she didn't like it, we'd order some cheese bread or breadsticks or something palatable for her. Bad news is-salad is the only starter offered. None of the other go-to's were an option. The good news is, she loved her pepperoni pizza. So much so that I was able to have a Green Lantern all to myself. It was delicious, and sparing you the details, the manager went above expectations when a snafu in service could have meant us getting up and walking out. My daughter said, "I like it here. They treat us like we're important." We'll be returning. No question. read more

Let's get one thing straight up front. These guys have great pizza. Hand tossed, perfect crust, and everything else as it should be. But. I wish the service would back off just a bit. Maybe it's the new cool thing to have every employee and manager stop at your table 3 times each over the course of a half hour. But sheesh. It's exausting saying "thanks we're good" over and over. I have 2 toddlers in tow and I'm trying to have a conversation with my wife. And how much beer do you want me to drink? It's like they're mad that I only ordered a medium pizza, and they're gonna bum rush me like those club guys on Saturday Night Live! And no, I didn't save room for your choco-sinful-decadence-flourless-richness cake! That is all. read more