Paid 17 bucks for fish and chips, asked for extra tartar sauce and got none, fish was small so you're paying like a good 13 bucks for just some fries. read more

Haslam the reuben sandwich with kettle chips. Very good. Fresh brewed ice tea was delicious. Nice atmosphere and outstanding service.

Feels like a neighborhood bar. Lots of TV sets with closed captions. Loved the French onion soup because it has a rich, thick beef broth as the base. The onion rings were more plentiful this evening rather than the last time we were here. The Hugo Spritz depends a lot upon who makes it. The price certainly is better than LA prices. Good service. read more

See all

We waited to order. We waited longer for the food. How long for the food....? Well from the time we "ordered" over 45 minutes and never received food. we left hungry and cold. (It was freezing inside that restaurant) It was relatively empty The server was nice. Not sure what the delay was. kathy the server said there was a huge take out order that delayed our order and ours would be right out. (Which I feel may have been a fib.... Not sure but my gut say probably.... Why? No one had come in for a "big"take out order, I think she forgot to log in our order as she was distracted with the table next to us that had their former cook there. I could see that easily happening under this situation.) After waiting another three minutes and no food, we were "over" Over the Counter and nicely told her were leaving. To cancel our order. She nicely tried to entice us to stay saying the owner was going to give us a gift certificate... but that just further solidified that they "knew" our meals timing had gone sideways and we had been neglected. We chose to leave and we dont really plan on coming back. Why? The inside seemed old. We saw the kitchen from our table. It seemed disorganized. It gave off a bad vibe. Add our wait. Meh. Like I said Im over over the table. read more

See all

We came here for lunch on Sunday. The food was great; we tried the breakfast quesadilla and the huevos rancheros. They have a lot of televisions around, but it's not a sports bar. Our server was great about checking on us and getting the channel changed so we could watch the Reds. read more

Over the Counter - huevos rancheros - New American Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

What an odd little place this is wedged into the southern edge of Worthington. Outside it has this 60s diner vibe and inside it has more of a beerhaus vibe that was a little confusing. The menu is mostly Diner fare. I went here for lunch on a random Thursday just to check it out. The food was fine, but the service was pretty slow, the other patrons were considerably older, and the beer selection was awfully weak considering it seemed to be a focus. I didn't really feel like there was anything special about the experience as a whole unfortunately. Not for me. read more

Over the Counter - The Counter Burger and Onion Rings - New American Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

We have eaten here several times since we have decided to move to Worthington from Cincinnati. I think there is so much Competition in this are that it must be difficult to complete, but this little place must have a loyal following because the people working here are terrific and the food is excellent and very affordable. If you like BLT's, you are in for a treat! read more

We came here for lunch for the first time. I ordered a turkey club sandwich with waffle fries. My husband ordered the half spinach salad. The club was served on a tomato swirl bread and it had an unusual flavor. The flavor was either the bread or else it was from the griddle that it was cooked on. This was not something that I would order again. The waffle fries were hot and tasty. My husband enjoyed his salad. The service was friendly and quick. There was music playing in the background but it was at a level that we could still carry on a conversation. read more

See all

At brunch, my corned beef hash tasted only of salt. The over-easy egg whites were runny. The "bed of potatoes" looked like the frozen sliced kind. The "toast" wasn't toasted. I don't know how you make an over-easy egg with runny whites. When I make eggs at home, I flip the egg, and within a couple of seconds the whites are no longer runny. Some of Over the Counter's whites looked like snot. The other folks at my table had nice looking meals. I didn't stick around long enough to find out if they liked them. Between the undercooked food, the hard rock music at 10 a.m., and the too-cold air conditioning, I sent back my meal, said goodbye to the group and popped gum into my mouth to get rid of the taste of salt. I was with a large group, and the server said they were short a cook, so maybe the food is normally better. Portions are large. read more

We meet some friends here for dinner before going to a concert. It is located in a strip mall and has a little patio in front with some umbrellas. It does not have any heaters, so it would only be good in the warmer months. There was plenty of parking as the other businesses were closed by the time we arrived. On the inside it has some high tables with a bench on one side and high-top chairs on the other. The bar is located on the other side and has plenty of seats and televisions. Our server was nice and friendly. Big surprise, we started out with drinks. I got a whiskey sour with Makers Mark and a couple of cherries, to make it a wee bit sweeter. My man got a Yeungling draft, one of his regular beers. We shared the Beer Pretzel Bites, they were delicious. Oh, so crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, it even came with two ramekins of cheese. There was some cheese left over, which usually never happens. For my meal I got a cup of French Onion Soup and the Italian Chicken Sandwich. The croutons on the soup were large and crunchy, and there was a ton of melted cheese on top. I ordered the cup and it appeared to almost be bowl size. The chicken was grilled, with red peppers, lettuce, tomato, provolone cheese and some pesto aioli. The bread was something I had never seen before, grilled tomato swirl beard, like a marble rye. YUMMY! My man got the Counter Burger with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and red onion on a grilled bun, with a side of onion rings. It also came with a pickle spear on the side. Everything must have been good because he ate it all and did not even save me a bite, lol. We will definitely be back a couple of times. First for the brunch which is served on both Saturdays and Sundays. Second for the fish and chips and maybe a steak. read more

See all

The service was amazing, great suggestions and very on point. I had the grilled cheese with sweet potato fries and it was delicious. The cocktail menu was unique and thoughtful. Lastly, very affordable! read more

Went for lunch on a Tuesday afternoon. Got there at noon. Took 20 minutes to get a menu and a coke. It's now 12:45 and I'm still waiting for my food. My lunch hour is over at one. The restaurant isn't even busy. read more

Enjoyed a Thursday afternoon lunch here. They have happy hour 3-6pm M-Fri. I had the buffalo chicken wrap and substituted Mac and cheese for my side. Both were very good. The server was very friendly and our food came out quick. The restaurant was cute inside with a variety of tables, high tops, booths and bar seating. Will definitely be back. read more

I haven't been by OTC in a couple of years and decided to pop in to check it out. I went in around 815pm, knowing they were closed at 9. The staff was incredible with service and didn't make me feel rushed even though they were closing in less than an hour. I grabbed the Pretzel bites with beer cheese as an appetizer and the Route 23 salad with Salmon for my meal. These pretzel bites are ABSOLUTELY incredible!! I could stop in daily for these and never be disappointed!! They are so crisp on the outside and super soft in the center. It comes with 2 cups of beer cheese, which is enough, so you don't have to order extra ($0.99) The route 23 is full of flavor with goat cheese crumbles, candied nuts, and fresh strawberries!! The house made sweet balsamic dressing is the perfect pairing! I added the 8oz portion of Salmon ($7.99) vs the smaller 4oz ($4.99). The Salmon was cooked correctly and was a delicious choice! They had mutilple local and imported selections on Draft, a full bar to satisfy any drinks cravings, and wine. Thanks, OTC! Keep crushing it!! read more

Over the Counter - New American Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

Stopped in after church and had a GREAT Savory Cactus Chili. The taste was outstanding slightly sweet with an abundance of flavors, wish there was more. I had it with a nice glass of apple cider. My friend had the same with a Bloody Mary, he loved the horseradish (plenty). The service was fast, within minutes of ordering. There are plenty of tvs around the bar to watch any sports game you wish. Very clean, even the restrooms. Like a diner, with a high end bar feeling. Top shelf liquor. I never would have expected this much going on in such a small place. Outdoor seating available. This place is a must see. read more

See all

This little restaurant is really nice! The food was delicious. I love breakfast potatoes that are more than just shredded or cubed potatoes. They really hit the spot for me. The sweet & spicy bacon is AMAZING. The bartender who was our server was super nice and did a great job checking in on us even though they were super busy. Will be going here again. Highly recommend! read more

Over the Counter - OTC Breakfast with scrambled eggs and sweet & spicy bacon - New American Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

OTC continues to ramp back to their prepandemic self. They are now open Tuesday through Friday 11 - 9 pm, Saturday from 10:00 am, and Sundays from 10:00 am to 2:00 pm. There's no closing between lunch & dinner which is sweet! I've also heard that soon they're planning to be back open on Mondays as well. There are now daily specials, Tuesday through Friday, that rotate. A chef's choice Mac & cheese, a day with a wing special, and a grilled cheese with a different soup for some examples. Plus Happy hour has also returned!! There's a version of loaded fries, pretzel bites & cheese, and fried veggies for $5 each. I added a picture of the current discounts on happy hour alcohol. Bonus: happy hour is Monday - Saturday! OTC has upped the staffing considerably. Sometimes it still seems like they could use more folks but, with coming back to almost full tilt operation I'm sure that will all get sorted. read more

See all

A very adorable spot nestled between Clintonville and Worthington that I've been meaning to try. The atmosphere was great but the service and food were not up to my expectations. A friend and I stopped here for lunch and ordered sandwiches. I ordered the Italian Chicken sandwich but what I received was not correct. It was a chicken sandwich with mayonnaise---instead of pesto aioli and missing the roasted red pepper. It was still very tasty, but I felt like I was missing out on the "Italian" part of the sandwich. I also did not receive a pickle--which I know is picky AF--but I would have loved to have one with my sammy and chips. My friend was similarly disillusioned with the wrap she received. The ladies were plenty friendly and accommodating, but the service was slow. Both working full-time, we had an hour for lunch and we definitely went over that hour by a lot. For a sandwich place, I'd think they'd turn over their tables a little quicker. All in all, I'm glad I went to Over the Counter. And I'd maybe try it again at the bar for cocktails when I wasn't pressed for time. read more

I met a friend here for dinner and we sat on the patio. We later moved inside when the heavy rain started. Our young server was sweet and did a great job. I started with a glass of white wine - sad they didn't have Riesling. I chose the Route 23 salad minus the goat cheese and it was really good. My meal highlight was the Chicken & Rice soup, full of chicken, rice, and veggies. It was thick and creamy. I would get this over & over again. My friend had the black bean burger on wheat bread. They don't have wheat buns, so she subbed. When we moved inside, my friend wanted hot tea. Our server brought a variety of tea and a pot of hot water. There are tables, booths, and a large bar. We both enjoyed our meal very much and would return. read more

Over the Counter - Route 23 salad minus goat cheese, and Chicken & Rice Soup - New American Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

Good choices were excellent and the meninges something to eat for all. Service was very quick and the wait staff helpful with the menu. Family friendly menu and with a nice laid back feel! read more

Kathy S was wonderful! She made our day. Such a wonderful personality . Food was great too.

Consistently good food Good wait staff Friendly Super bar Lots of beer varieties too read more

A must try! Recently visited for brunch and had the best experience. Service was incredible and super friendly. Food was delicious, especially the pie, and plenty of drink options +a full bar. So happy we found this gem in Worthington! read more

See all

This little gem has been around for a few years and I've always been wanting to give it a try. So, for our weekly outing today, my wife and I headed to Worthington to try Over the Counter. This is an interesting place. I'd describe it as a typical diner except for the fact that they have a full bar with 10 beers on tap (8 microbrews plus a cider and Pabst Blue Ribbon). The menu is classic diner fare - many sandwiches, soups, and salads. The wife opted for the cream of chicken with rice soup and their 23 salad. She said the soup definitely tasted homemade and that it was loaded with chicken, rice, carrots, and celery. She said it was excellent and she'd definitely order it again. She said the 23 salad was very good but she wasn't sure she'd order it next time, I tried the Where's Waldo fried bologna sandwich with chips. The fried bologna was served on grilled sourdough with carmelized onions and a delicious spicey mustard. It was excellent and made me think of the famous fried bologna sandwiches in Waldo, OH. Service was excellent and the prices were reasonable. My only complaint was that the restaurant's thermostat was set too low and it was quite chilly in the restaurant. read more

What a great find! We were looking for Brunch and this place hit the spot! Great Corned Beef Hash with an egg over top. Casadea was big and filled with goodies. We will be going back for lunch and dinner soon. Menu looked varied and value priced. They were busy but staff was hustling and handled it well. read more

I went in for dinner, and specifically for the French onion soup which was one of the best I've ever had (definitely try it). However I followed that up with a grilled chicken Cesar wrap which was disappointing. The grilled chicken seemed marinated but had an odd flavor. And each half of my wrap only had a tiny dab of what seemed to be a house made non-classic Cesar dressing. I love trying different things, and I'm not a purist, so I appreciate different interpretations of meals, but this Cesar wrap didn't work. Fortunately I was able to wash it down with one of the many draft beers they offer. Service was really friendly and very attentive. While I did have an assigned server, the entire staff pitched in to help take orders and deliver the food and drinks. Ultimately, I would go back for the French onion soup and good beer selection, I'll just swap out the Cesar wrap for something else. read more

Great service with amazing food. Typical diner food but elevated. Quality ingredients and beautiful interior.

Been meaning to come for awhile, but it's not really on my way anywhere. When we ended up right next door while out and about on a Sunday, we stopped in. Mom had had their French onion soup before and said it was the best she's had outside of France. She got some of that again. Baby K had grilled cheese with fries, and loved it. I got huevos rancheros, which were very good. Egg, seasoned beans, crispy tortilla (I do mine with soft ones, but it worked.) Sour cream and salsa on the side. Cheesy sauteed veggies as well, also good. I tried a cup of chicken wild rice soup, one of my favorites. Very, very tasty. Lots of chicken, mushrooms, carrots, etc., in a creamy sauce. Not much rice, oddly. But still very good. Great service. We sat outside, a nice choice. A bit expensive, but for good, made from scratch stuff, it was worth it. read more

I am surprised a bit as I came here on the 4.5 star rating. Maybe it was an off day. Service was a little slow and our water jug needed returned due to floaters in it. Starting with the food it was good, other than the temperature. would have appreciated my breakfast being hot. The place was busy which may have contributed to the slow service. The place was clean and in order. I may give them another shot but it might be awhile. read more

Geez, I can't believe I never knew this restaurant was here! Met friends for lunch - loved it as soon as I walked in the door. It's a bit quirky with relic decor and has the original flooring (loved it). The waitress was very nice and attentive. The food! I only had French Onion soup (Delicious rich broth) and their fried pickle spears (really, really good with thin crusting and great homemade ranch dressing). One friend had chicken tenders which looked great - and he said they were very good pieces of chicken. I can't wait to go back! read more

David & his team(Ethan, Avery et. al are awesome & always friendly) food is great and restaurant/bar is always spotless. Thank you!

Great food and laid back atmosphere. Nice Clintonville vibe with great selection of drafts. Love sitting on patio under the classic metal umbrellas. read more

A really good place for a burger! The food is delicious and exactly like what you would expect from an American restaurant. From what I've experienced, the service is great. Everybody working there was very kind and helpful. The atmosphere is kid friendly as well as casual. I just wish this place was more original. You could get food very similar to what Over the Counter has to offer at virtually any other American restaurant nearby. read more

Is this a new place? It feels new. Or maybe I'm just now noticing it even though it's directly next to the church we go to. New or not, I'm pretty pleased that I stopped by here the other night. It was pretty busy when we came but was seat yourself. Bustling, but not loud enough to be overwhelming. It was really hard to limit the food I ordered for my daughter and myself. All the apps looked amazing, but I settled on splitting the basket of fries. They had a nice rosemary flavor to them. I tried the mac and cheese my daughter ordered, it was pretty good but a splash of Cholula really took it to the next level. I ordered the patty melt for myself and got the cole slaw as the side. The cole slaw was creamier than most I've had. The patty melt was delicious but I'll probably order it without onions next time. Overall a really nice experience and I'll most definitely be back in the future! read more

See all

Ok, we went for patio brunch today, and despite everyone's confusion about us wanting to sit outside, the food was EXCELLENT (like, such a great breakfast steak, and the potatoes were fabulous) and the service was lovely. Highly recommend (just leave me the table in the left back corner about once a month or so). read more

OTC was great. We took granddaughter there and she was treated well by wait staff who even yelled goodbye by name as we left. The food is great. I had an awesome Reuben and terrific Bloody Mary. read more

The food was delicious but there was only one server for the entire restaurant on a Friday night. I felt sorry for her. She was very nice but at the mercy of the kitchen and lots of customers. Will try again as the food was good. read more

Stopped in Monday for lunch. We both ordered some of their fantastic onion rings. Fried to perfection. Great batter. Large basketful. Treated my daughter for lunch Tuesday. Suggested several places. Where did she want to go? Over The Counter! Had BLT's [incidentally the best bacon i have ever tasted] and french fries, which come in a big portion. Dave and Kathy do a super job. Many other excellent choices on the menu. read more

Over the Counter - New American Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

See all

Sunday brunch at this fun spot in Worthington. Family all went for the customized scramble / omelet and we weren't disappointed. Only issue was that my son's omelet didn't have the bacon ordered but the staff responded immediately, offering to bring bacon or remake the omelet. He opted for the bacon and it was there in a flash. My scramble was great. Potatoes seasoned perfectly, eggs done right, bacon crisp and mushrooms and spinach perfect. Waitress was friendly and attentive. Only other complaint would be that it took longer than I would have expected, but nothing egregious. And the friendliness of the staff and service more than made up for it. Overall a great experience. read more

Over the Counter - Custom scramble - New American Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

Over the Counter is literally a hidden gem. It's easy to miss but once you find it you'll be blown away by the delicious food they have. I love everything about this place. The service and food is outstanding. Be sure to get some coffee, it's from One Line Coffee, yum! Order: Italian chicken sandwich - Grilled chicken breast,Roasted red pepper, L, T, provolone, and a pesto aïoli on tomato swirl bread from Lucky Cat Bakery. read more

See all