I was in the area and decided to try this place. They have many different styles of crust, I decided to go thick. Service - While they do have seating, this place is primarily takeout/delivery. The service was good. They took my order and I headed over to Kroger. Atmosphere - I would not eat at the location just because it is busy (boxes and stuff which just does not make it comfortable. The lights were off so I just did my order. This has no effect on pizza or service. The seating is just overhead for the staff and they are busy taking orders / making pizza. Food - the crust is pillowy on the inside, crispy on the outside. I was not a fan of their pepperoni (now I am being picky). The pizza had a decent cook on the top but the pepperoni did not crisp up. I would eat this pie again but not sure if I would go out of my way to pick it up. It is a haul for me. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Pep and sausage pizza - thick crust - Italian Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Best pizza I have had in a long time . People where also very nice which is a hard thing to find nowadays .

The pizza here was pretty good! We were happy with ours. We got a Lrg. BBQ Chicken & Lrg. Pepp & Mushroom, both on hand tossed crusts w/butter on the crust. Not sweet, but definitely not spicy sauce either. Nice mix. Good volume & distribution of toppings. Service was acceptable. Not too friendly, but they weren't rude. Just young people trying to get through the night. No complaints there... As you can see in a couple of the pictures, the dining area was a wreck. Didn't affect the pizza quality or taste, but I don't think I'd eat IN there. The pics are older & it's STILL like that in there. Good pizza w/a respectable price & taste. I'd certainly try them again. Their menu is pretty decent, so there's a lot to choose from. We'll probably go there again. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - BBQ Chicken Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Overpriced subs with barely any meat on them. Do not waste your time or money. Go to next door to a sub place that gives you what you pay for read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Italian sub. - Italian Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I ordered a Deep Dish Favorite and was very pleased. Crust and sauce were spot on. The service was impressive - I called within 30 minutes of closing time and they still took care of my quickly. This is more of a carry out place instead of a sit down place. read more

Really good pizza, with generous toppings, tasty crust with garlic butter flavor, and priced very fair as well. Staff were nice and accommodating as well. We'll be back! read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Pricebuster Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

so nasty and dirty inside all the tables and floor was disgustingly filthy and lady making food coughing all over everything and didn't wash hands will never ever ever ever be back read more

Our food today was excellent!! Oh my goodness. The wings were soo fresh and crispy, the garlic cheese bread was amazing and the thin pepperoni was right on!!! Did I mention, the wings were awesome?!! Also, We had it delivered and they are always way earlier than the the time stated ( at least ten mins and we live about 5-6 miles away. I have been disappointed lately in wing prices and taste (from other restaurants) This is a definite read more

This place is disgusting! I have never been to such a dirty restaurant in my life. They had shoes everywhere every table was dirty. It's seriously nasty! Needs to be shut down! read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Trash, shoes, Looks like someone lives their! - Italian Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Horrible food. Staff is not friendly too. Stay away. Not sure anything here is fresh.

I've gone to this place quite a few times over the years and the pizza was just ok. I recently did a pick up on my lunch break and received a half baked pizza. I couldn't even pick up a slice because it kept falling apart. I called and asked if I could exchange it at a later point because I couldn't come back as it was my lunch break. They were rude and flat out said no. Apparently cooking the pizza thoroughly isn't their concern. I won't be returning here. read more

Disgusting slop. I'm not kidding when I say this is THE WORST pizza I have ever had in my life. I had a $30 order and took one bite of three different pizzas and then I threw it all away. I do not know how this place is in business. It should be called One Time Pizza. Cause you get it once and then never again. I should have known something was up when I asked what they were known for and the guy stared at me blankly and was like uhhhh we have pizza. Lol alright I get that part, but what's good? He said our specialty pizzas... Jesus Christ. Every pizza was so sloppy and dripping and gross it made me sad. By the way the desert pizza with the cream Cheese literally tasted like someone threw up on it. Do not go here. Let this place die. read more

Great pizza, cheesey bread and the best wings I've had from a pizza place... It also came early! We will be a repeat customer.. Thank you

Looking for different - Found awesome We're bored with most of the local pizza & subs selection and are always looking for something new and delicious. Visiting friends in Hilliard over the weekend, they suggested Cottage Inn Gourmet pizza. Just fantastic! The menu goes from classic to eclectic. The food is delicious. The service is friendly. We're going back this weekend! read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Ranch dressing! Yum! - Italian Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

WOW ! First time ordering! Ordered a large deep dish pizza and it was top shelf delicious ! I will be ordering again next time I travel to the area for business. The app was very quick and easy to use. read more

Going to keep this review simple. The pizza we had was great!! The salad had plenty of toppings and was good. I may order for delivery in the future but I won't eat in the restaurant again because it wasn't very clean and the guy taking our order was a little less than welcoming. Maybe he was having an off day....but it was enough to keep me away for a while. read more

Terrible pizza place that leaves food sitting outside in the rain then does nothing about it for customer satisfaction. What a waste of money! read more

The service at this location is awesome!! The food came out looking really nice and tasting great! It was also delivered super fast! I would 10/10 recommend! read more

A friend and coworker referred me to Cottage Inn over a year ago. They have a wide variety of pizza styles and other great dishes. I mainly get the pizzas and inn sticks (bread sticks). My favorite is their BBQ pizza in thin crust with no onions. The owners are incredibly kind and personable. I have purchased here a lot since first trying it. Though I'm not in every week or two, the owners treat you like family. High quality pizza. High quality people. I'll always go here. Highly recommended. read more

Can't review their pizza yet because we ordered lasagna, which was excellent. Ordered two dinners and only ate one serving between the two of us. Very good lasagna recipe. We were able to have lasagna again the next night for dinner. Yum! Friends tried their apple pie pizza dessert and loved it. We agree that we need to try their pizza. read more

Ordered a pizza and some wings for pickup on a Monday early evening. The online ordering process was a piece of cake and I appreciated the simplicity and efficiency of it all. The sauce on the pizza was great. It was tangy and flavorful. The crust was fine and the amount/variety of toppings worked well, too. The wings were a bit of a disappointment. Instead of saucing the wings when they came out of the fryer. they were boxed up with 2 cups of sauce. Wings need to be sauced when they are still smokin' hot to make sure the sauce adheres to all surfaces. Doing it at home once the wings have inevitably cooled down doesn't yield the same effect. read more

Had police called on me tonight after asking for a refund. I was called racist names and a cunt by various workers. After calling twice and getting hung up on, I went to the restaurant only to be treated worse over a $15 order. Easy to refund or replace. They said they would happily "burn it to a crisp" for me instead of making it correctly. Always rude. read more

Cottage Inn is a local family business that cares deeply about quality and customers. They have rapidly become my favorite pizza shop in town thanks to their great menu, fantastic food and wonderful people! read more

My go to place whenever I'm in town. The owners are beautiful people. Real American success story.

Flip this pizza over and you'll get a tasty little surprise: sesame seeds! The bottoms of these pies are loaded with the nutty flavored kernels. The parlor provides a sweet pizza sauce and is always loaded with cheese. The cheese gets a little greasy, but sometimes that's what I'm in the mood for. Plain old cheese pizza is my favorite when it comes to Cottage Inn. Accompanying the pizzas on the menu are subs, sides, Italian favorites, and salads. Cottage Inn also has a good website for a local business with clean graphics and fonts and fun little widgets. read more

The customer service was amazing, they were very friendly and ensured that we enjoyed everything!! The Apple piezza was incredible, I recommend anyone and everyone to go eat there!!! read more

I'm pretty fascinated by the mix of reviews about this place. The pizza is a pretty straightforward four-stars-for-chain-pizza for me. The deep dish is especially tasty (and way less greasy than Pizza Hut); the price is way better than nearby Granddad's, and tbh, I thought it tasted better than Granddad's, too. (Granddad's tiny pizzas + high prices . . . I dunno. I mean, they're not Bono or Harvest.) Maybe Cottage Inn has upped their game in the past couple of years, but I have ordered from them twice now and saw no reason to give it less than four stars. We've ordered delivery twice and twice it has come to us expediently, even earlier than expected. The pizza was hot, fresh, and good. Their cheese bread is also tasty (I'm a sucker for cheese bread, full stop.) Before moving out to the Hilliard-ish area, I was stuck with only Pizza Hut and Donatos if I wanted to get delivery. Cottage Inn is better than both, and they will have my delivery business from now on. read more

Friendly staff, delicious food, and quick service. An awesome place to grab lunch while waiting in line for DMV!

This place is seriously as cheap as it gets for the Hilliard area, but "cheap" isn't the word if you're looking cost wise. While dine in is available at this location.. I don't think it was much of an option for us. The place was really dated, slightly dirty, and it looked as if someone (guessing a worker there) had sprawled their junk all over one of the tables, for their relaxation time later on. The quality of pizza is on par with Little Caesars pizza. It's just unfortunate they're charging $3 more in price. Even the subs were dismal, tasteless, and forgettable. The pizza is edible, but lets face it.. there's other places to hit up in Hilliard instead. read more

Okay I know I have said that Rotolo's was my favorite and the best in Columbus, but does Hilliard count as 'Columbus'? I think Cottage Inn, while still rather obscure, is rapidly approaching the #1 mark in the HCA Book of Perfect Pizza. Seriously. Anyone who has said that 'a pizza is a pizza is a pizza' has never had Cottage Inn. I am a crust girl and this stuff is really off the charts with goodness. Rotolo's doesn't give me my crust fix but they do everything else right. So it's really a toss-up. You might have difficulty getting a delivery to you and it is located in Hilliard (Worthington location as well) but if you can stand it, go pick it up and try it. It is always worth the gas money to me! read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Good Pizza! Good people! The Cottage Inn Pizza is very very good and a must try. The owner hand delivered our company a pizza and we loved it. We will be ording company lunches from there on the Reg.. read more

I preface this review by saying that my better half is a NUT about cottage inn. We're originally from michigan so we're used to having a ton around and they're his absolute favorite. With that said, not a big fan of this location. We've made a special trip out from Dublin recently so he can have his fav. After this last visit, we've really opted to heading to the polaris location. The last order we placed just wasn't quite what we ordered. We asked for extra cheese, extra sauce, and well done, none of which was actually on my pizza. I'm usually pretty discerning when it comes to pizza places. I know some days can be better than others, people are not perfect, but this was also not the first time this has happened for this location. In general for the store, I did notice that they allowed one of their employees to work in flip flops. I noticed that he had come in from delivering a pizza and went right to work making someone's pizza. Pretty sure this is a health code violation. The customer service was decent, not good or great by any means. The pizza was edible, so I'm giving two stars for that. I wouldn't really recommend this location to a friend, and I doubt I'll be returning. That whole cooking in flip flops deal has me a little "ewwww"-ed out. read more

I wanted anchovies on my pizza , stupid Fuck face basterd gave me artichokes green peppers instead of banana peppers. Tried to tell them it was incorrect and he says, you said artichokes. I asked him, how is fish a artichoke? They lost me and my business read more

My girlfriend and I just finished the chicken cordon bleu pizza, and it was excellent. Very tasty, and, since it is on special this week, quite a good deal as well. We had it delivered, and it came (still pretty hot) in about 30 minutes. In the past, we've had the chicken alfredo pizza, which was just okay, and the wings, which are good, but you have to toss them in the sauce yourself (not a big fan of that). Overall, this seems like an affordable place to have quality pizza. read more

The pizza is cheap and it shows. Thin crust is very thin and cardboard like, very skimpy on sauce, cheese, and toppings. Not impressed and won't have it again. There are way too many great pizza places in Hilliard to bother with this one. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom - Italian Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

I've always had a great experience here. Their pizza and customer service is excellent. I can't get enough of the inn stix and garlic cream cheese! read more

I'm a little embarrassed that this is my first review, but not too cool to admit that Cottage Inn Pizza is quite tasty! What makes the pizza? Without a doubt the crust. The deep dish crust is slightly crispy on the outside but soft when you bite into it - plus if you're a glutton for sauces (and I am), you'll love the free crust options that Cottage Inn offers: garlic butter, Parmesan garlic, and even Cajun butter! The service was also impeccable. Our pizza order is usually complicated, specific toppings, no cheese, etc. Cottage Inn nailed it and delivered to us approximately 20 minutes faster than promised. The pizza was hot and the veggie toppings appeared and tasted fresh. If you're a sucker for a thick crusted pizza and like tons of menu options, Cottage Inn is a great fast and easy pizza experience. read more

My favorite pizza in Hilliard hands down. Truly better than the other chains around town. The owners are very friendly to us every time we walk in. I highly recommend the garlic bread sticks. read more

Worst place ever manager literally tried to cuss me out cause i called back and wanted to take the black olives off my pizza. Guarantee he would not try to say anything out of the way to my face. Dont go here!!! read more

Delicious pizza, quick service. You can actually sit and eat here if you want, unlike most carryout pizza places. Good price in general, but there are also coupons if you order online. read more