A Little hidden gem in The Mattituck shopping center. Really good food. Comfy setting. The the staff are friendly And the food is great. What more do you want? They will not disappoint you. Lots of wine to choose from. read more

Amazing owners who are present. Great bar staff. Food good! Recent paint job look great. Worth a try.

9/20/24 CJ's is a local venue with wonderful food, service and atmosphere. It's a bit off the beaten path in a shopping center, but as a result, there is always plenty of parking. Tonight I chose to have the filet mignon with a green peppercorn sauce that could not have been prepared more perfectly. I ordered it medium rare and it was tender and very flavorful. They served it with a side of mashed potatoes and sautéed zucchini, green and yellow. I enjoyed every bite . Hubby chose to have a burger again. He enjoyed it as much as he enjoyed the Monday night special Burger night where you can order one burger and get another half price. Keep that in your repertoire for Monday nights as many of the local places are not open on a Monday night. Our Server Lynn made sure that we had everything we needed and she has a very delightful personality! Don't wait to come and try CJ's for yourself. read more

CJ's American Grill - Burger and fries, raw onion, lettuce, and tomato - American Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

We come here every year after we cut down our tree at the tree farms and we always have a wonderful experience. The wait staff is so nice and accommodating and the food never disappoints. It's tucked away in a shopping center but don't bypass this hidden gem. This trip, we just did some drinks and appetizers and it was fabulous. We had the nachos with chicken and the bang bang shrimp and my daughter had the kids chicken fingers. The nachos were piled high with so much chicken and toppings! Delicious as always. I had a bourbon Mule and a pumpkin beer and both were awesome. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Very homey, welcoming ambiance. Very friendly, great service and food is fresh and delicious excellent. Full bar read more

Great service and food. Ribs and chicken are my favorite. The staff is attentive and warm.

For the past decade CJs has been our "go to" establishment for many family gatherings, celebrations and date nights. We are grateful for their genuine staff, quality food and family friendly atmosphere. Always a great evening! read more

CJ's American Grill - Birthday dessert board filled with scrumptious after dinner treats! - American Near Me - Mattituck, New York

The food was so delicious and the strawberries been delicious chicken Parmesan and french fries was great the waiter was actually great. He's very nice. Very polite. I would definitely come back here again. Happy Valentine's Day to all staff that works here from your friend Dj Dee Love. read more

See all

Worst place ever, my mom is elegiac to red meat and cheese. After we got are food more then half a hour later wen we received the food,her plate full of cheese I mean every we're then my soup (seafood soup) it came cremated I mean I like creepy soups but not my crimps and crab the wen got something let's the fries we covered in this barbecue powder if I want it I'll ask read more

CJ's American Grill - Fried chicken sandwich - American Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

Great place to bring the family! The prices are reasonable with a variety of food the whole family would love in a down to earth environment. The ribs are amazing and the portion is very generous. The CJs vineyard salad is delicious with cranberries, Manderian oranges and Gorgonzola cheese. You can get it with or without a protein choice of chicken, steak and shrimp. They also have bottles of wine for $25! read more

Friendly atmosphere, local restaurant and bar. Service very good food is great. Need res on weekends. Wine of your choice $25 bottle.

Came here on a trip out East today. The restaurant has a very "homey" vibe. Diners were watching the football game and workers were very nice. I ordered simple chicken and fingers and fries (with seasoning) and my husband ordered the CJ burger. Both were very good! My entree came with pickles which NEVER happens - huge plus! The seasoning on my fries reminded me of a delicious wing place by me and it was very good, but there was a little too much seasoning for my liking. My husband enjoyed his burger. CJ's has a very extensive menu and I will make an effort to try a nice steak (they have great variety) the next time I am in the area. read more

CJ's American Grill - American Near Me - Mattituck, New York

My husband ordered French onion soup. The top was black which made the soup taste burnt. The table next to us got a bread basket that I had to ask for. My husband's baked stuffed clams were mostly tasteless breadcrumbs. I ordered lobster ravioli which I'm sure was from Costco but the sauce was good. The most frustrating part of the meal was the waiting. The table next to us got their food while we sat waiting and waiting. We had gotten there a good 15 minutes before them. read more

The service is always great! Love prime rib night on Thursdays. Busy place with a wonderful, happy vibe!

great food and very good service. Will come back again. We had steak sandwich, ribs and stuffed flounder all were very good.

This is such an amazing restaurant owned by two incredible human beings. I used to work here as a side job so I can vouch for the fact that they not only take great care of their customers, but of their staff as well. I recently saw on Facebook that they made and donated a ton of frozen meals to families in the community in need, and my heart just melted. They always were so very genuine and caring, not your typical business owners. This is absolutely a local business to support, and celebrate!! read more

CJ's American Grill - Going above and beyond for the community!! Such a blessing. - American Near Me - Mattituck, New York

The food is reasonable and good-and Barbara is professional and friendly. (Monday and Tuesday) We love this place. Variety, quality and not expensive. Thank you! read more

Took a ride out east... looked up a few restaurants in the area ...CJ's American Grill had some good reviews so decided to go there for lunch. It did not disappoint! The food was delicious. I had the Reuben sandwich with fries. Fries had a nice seasoning on them. Not one complaint! Service was great. Restaurant was clean. Can't wait to go back!! A+++ read more

Nice spot ... good drinks, food was good and great prices !! The servers/bartenders were all very nice and friendly !!

CJ's American Grill is located right on Main Road on the north side in a small strip center tucked back down a small paved walkway. On the east end this is one of the places you can go in he summer season or like today mid week, end of January and they are open to the local residents or those out off season. French onion soup is definite, would order again Didn't try the steaks or salads. My friend got an odd steak steak sandwich which was in fact a steak on half a hero type roll, covered with cheese and onion straws. Not typical. Good flavor but prefers sliced traditional. Tried a winning Pastrami Rueben with toasted rye, homemade sauerkraut & mustard. Nicely browned pastrami. Was done perfectly. Not that that matters when you put east. But it was a pleasant surprise on a cold evening. Worth a bookmark for Pastrami fans out here. This is a place to bookmark for generous and delicious Pastrami Rueben when on the east end read more

Great food. Great street. Good service. Perfect place if our doing the vineyards. Will go back for sure

Delicious! Everything was great! Definitely will go back! Must try the warm Nachos and guacamole! read more

We love CJs...we even had a rehearsal dinner there for my my son and his wife. I am glad that it is only 5 minutes away!! read more

Great place . Food is awesome. Drinks are good. Prices are good always busy. So you know it's a good place

Nice friendly neighborhood place. great happy hour deals, delicious food at good price point. The staff is always friendly and welcoming and always love when Sandra is behind the bar! she's fantastic! read more

Great service! Excellent menu with the best burger! Also love their wings. Will be bringing my friends next time they visit!

CJ is our #1 destination, the food is among our favorite, we travel round trip 100 mile to go there , the service is tops , & we get treated like family , & love the people there , read more

Delicious food at reasonable prices. Friendly service makes you feel like dining with family. Casual, cozy atmosphere. The steaks are always cooked perfectly and food is fresh. Steak Caesar salad is a favorite...be sure to get it marinated. read more

Food is always great! The bartenders and wait staff are exceptional! We are never disappointed!

Friendly waitresses, good food and fun environment. I recommend this restaurant for adults and children

Great food and service. A real home town place with a comforting atmosphere. If not for Yelp would have never found! Waitress was so nice and our food was very good. Highly recommend seafood bisque. read more

The food is outstanding.... I had the bang bang shrimp, which were amazing, and I also had the crab cake.... Maryann was our waitress and the service was above and beyond. The ambiance is very warm and cozy and we sat near my favorite picture of Jerry Garcia, so you can't go wrong with that read more

Consistently one of the best local spots in town! Food is always 10/10 and service is 11/10!! Family friendly yet still feels high end like a nice night out. Keep doing what you're doing over there, CJs! read more

CJ's is great. Solid food at a great price. Their catering company also catered our wedding and did a fantastic job! Highly recommend CJ's for a casual dinner. read more

This review is mostly about the service and not the food, we didn't make it that far. We spent the day at Harbes Family Farm and found CJ's American Grill on Yelp to stop at on the way back home. We went on Saturday the 12th of October at around 3PM. Keep in mind, the restaurant was nearly empty. Small menu so I ordered a French Onion Soup, two items from the kid's menu, and my wife and I were going to share four appetizers. It took about 20-minutes for our order to be taken. My French Onion Soup came out with the kid's food 20-minutes after that. We're now 40-minutes in. At this point, the restaurant had more guests. Had to send my French Onion Soup back because I like the cheese well-done, which they couldn't handle the first time around. No big deal. The French Onion Soup had potential, decent flavor, but it was loaded with TONS of Bay Leaves, which should be removed before serving. I get that one or two might remain in the soup, but there must have been thirty of them in there. No one likes eating stiff Bay Leaves. We're waiting, waiting, 45-minutes passes, we notice a group that came in 45-minutes later than us received their food, basically the same items we ordered, but we were still waiting. At that point I went to ask for a manager, requested the check, and just wanted to leave at that point. She said "are you sure, your food is up now", I said I'm positive, we just want to leave. We waited another 10-minutes for the check, manager came back over and asked if we wanted to take the food to go. What a joke, she should not be managing a restaurant, that's for sure. In any event, she said "sorry, I took something off the bill for you". She didn't, the only deduction on the bill was the 20% coupon from Yelp. Some good came out of this though. We found Jans Chinese Food in the same shopping center, which was amazing. Side note, they sat us at a table in the back-corner, which literally has a quad-outlet lined up with the TOP of the table, without any safety covers on the outlets. Luckily my 4-year-old knows better, but this isn't safe at all. It's only a matter of time before a child takes a utensil and sticks it in the outlet. read more

CJ's American Grill - Please go buy a few outlet plug covers. You can get a 32-pack on Amazon for $8.95 with free shipping. - American Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Great family friendly pub. The inside was spacious and the food was good. The staff couldn't have been nicer.

If you want to be berated into getting one of three things the server recommend, go here. Otherwise skip this place. There are plenty of better place within a few minutes of this one. We couldn't get out of here fast enough. The food is bland, absolutely nothing special. Who doesn't salt their burgers? They don't. They don't salt their fries either. Everything lacked basic seasonings. When asked of I could get mayo on the side, nope, didn't get that. Had to ask for refills on our water. Mind you, we were the only people there. The server was clearly having a bad day and we took the brunt of it. Needless to say, we won't be back. read more

Excellent food as well as customer service Celebrated birthday for a family member and we now have a precious memory Aren't we lucky to have this eatery in Mattituck!!! read more

Great place for lunch. Many choices and price fixed lunch for $13. Friendly service .

Went here for lunch. Chicken chipotle wrap was amazing and the waitress was nice and personal!