Amazing brisket, great atmosphere and service at good prices!! I highly recommend this place and…read morewill definitely be back!!

First time here and all I can say is WOW! Everything was absolutely amazing. The brisket was…read moreperfectly cooked and pulled apart like butter, the seasoned fries were so good, and the mac and cheese skillet was a 100/10 fresh, super cheesy, and the breadcrumbs on top really made it. The service was just as impressive. The staff consistently checked on us, and I believe the owner even stopped by and showed us the huge slow cookers in the back, which was such a cool touch. They also had live music, and the restaurant itself felt welcoming and cozy. Such a great experience, I can't wait to come back and try more!

Came on a saturday, it was a slow night because it was so cold out and a snowstorm was threatening,…read morebut there were a couple of occupied tables and some bar patrons. Ample parking, the fireplace was blazing, very nice atmosphere. We were greeted and sat right away, and our orders came out in a very reasonable amount of time. We told our server to just bring them out as they were ready. A couple pints of Guinness and Loaded Nachos came first, then a Beet & Goat Cheese salad, and a Smash Burger w bacon followed shortly after. We ate everything. The food was great, the nachos were fairly loaded (beef), the beet and goat cheese salad was perfect, and the burger was done just right. Fries were ok. They also had live music that evening, and I didn't get the name of the performer but she was amazing. She played continuously for the whole time we were there, no breaks, and she just transitioned from one song to the next. We'll be back.

Nothing wrong with this place. Nothing really right either. Very clean. Service at the bar was…read morefine. Burger was good. Fries were OK. Not much more to say. Which may or may not be a problem.

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Do not sit on the dining room side. Food - 4/5 - solid food, solid portions. Service - 3/5 - friendly and solid. Ambiance - 2/5 - classic sports bar feel, little cold. Overall - 3/5 - solid food, solid portions, seafood is very fresh. Service was on par and friendly. Inside was a classic sports bar feel on the bar side but very cold and desolate feeling on the dining room side. Overall solid place tucked away in New Suffolk Best Dish - Friend Flounder Sandwich

I haven't been back to Legends since before their renovations. Back then when they were changing…read moreowners, the food and service really wasn't as good as it used to be. Now that they are under new management this restaurant is awesome! I was pleasantly surprised to see they have a sushi on their menu, as well as a great sushi bar and chef! The service is excellent, and the entire place has a whole different vibe, which is more inviting, energetic and overall so much better than what is used to be. I am so happy with the changes, and highly recommend checking this place out. If you are like me, and haven't been back since the changes, you need to go. We are so happy to have our New Suffolk restaurant back, better than ever!

Nice people own and manage the place. They have tasty food and different events throughout the week.read more

Not in anyway impressed. I used to come here often for a quick bite and drink for lunch. I'm…read moreanosmic but the food is basic enough, mostly bar food and bites. I have been told when you eat here you end up smelling a little like the kitchen due to lack of ventilation. What made me stop going? One of their bartenders berated me walking because of my Facebook political opinion, the second time it's happened, and the owners refused to remediate. I did not in anyway initiate and they confirmed they saw it on the camera. In essence, it feels unsafe to be here. Below is a bit of an example of their later night crowd and I'd encourage all to be careful.

Food is always fresh and delicious. The outdoor patio is…read moreespecially delightful . Watching the boating traffic is always fun.

Seafood was spectacular. Service was excellent. Ambience and waterfront view was perfect. Truly…read moreenjoyed.

Hidden Gem Alert! Yes inside a bowling alley but the food is really good! Service even better. Also…read morean amazing spot to watch your favorite game. Huge LED screens like CitiField. Pool tables should you choose to play and Poker on Wednesday nights. Wow!

This should be advertised as a spicy lettuce wrap, practically no chicken or anything else inside…read more Disappointing.

I stopped in with a friend for a cocktail and to shoot some pool. We were in town in the off season…read moreand did some shopping around town before coming here. The bar tender was very pleasant and we had some nice conversation. The place was quiet with just a few other customers at the bar. Nice music was playing. The kitchen was still open but we didn't order food. The place recently changed ownership and so there was fresh paint making it look nice. Basically a casual laid back kind of place.

We went there two times when we were in Greenport for my niece's wedding Fun vibe w/ good drinks…read moreat reasonable prices. And they have a cigarette machine! Very old school.. and I don't smoke

We were looking for a new place for something light and quick on the way to the Custer Institute in…read moreSouthold and ended up here. Street parking was a little challenging, but not bad. Found a spot a block over. The place is nice and spacious, dining area had a fireplace, bar area had some high tops. Service was pretty quick, our waitress was very nice and attentive, our cocktails came out shortly after ordering. We ordered the Chicken and Lemongrass dumplings, they were very good. Perfectly steamed, they were plump and not oily with a nice dipping sauce. I had the Asian Tuna Wrap, on which I drizzled the dipping sauce I saved from the dumplings earlier. It was magnificent. My better half had the Fried Chicken Boom Boom sammich and it was beautifully fried. I had a bit of it, and it too was fantastic. Added this to the short list of restaurants that we'll frequent on the way to Custer.

Great service and wonderful food at reasonable prices. We were seated in the dining room section…read morewhich had a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. There were four of us for dinner and we ordered both the dumplings and the beef tips as appetizers. Both were good but in my opinion the dumplings were the winner. Then as entrees we ordered the salmon which was excellently prepared as well as build your own burgers which were juicy, tasty and extremely filling. Throughout it all our waitress Val made sure that we were well supplied with drinks as well as anything else we needed. We will definitely be back.

Best little dive bar with a deliciously tasty menu of pretty much anything you'd hope to find on a…read more"bar menu" (burgers, fries, A LOT of other fried things etc). The fried pickles are super yummy!! Best thing about this place is the staff. Jackie & Todd are both very friendly and make you feel right at home! Also, the price is RIGHT. This is, by far, the most adorable place to stop for a drink and a bite in the Hamptons!!

Great wings. Good place for lunch .. then stop by the smoke shop in your way to Montaukread more

I have dined at this establishment many times. I have been here with family, and several others…read morewith friends visiting. I especially like that I can customize my meal to make it Gluten Free (GF). This Bar & Grill does not GF bread, and that's fine. I have been here in both the summer and winter months. The service and ambience are great. The many TVs throughout gives you an opportunity to watch a game or two. I am looking forward to my annual visit in May.

I Googled "Montauk Happy Hours" thinking I'd get no hits, but was pleasantly surprised to find that…read moreThe Point had a weekday happy hour from 4-6. My brother and I were out here doing a nostalgia tour of spots we used to come on family vacations here, and decided to stop in after walking by Puff & Putt. Ambiance is very much a dive bar. The bar crowd was us and a bunch of old men which was a nice change from the dressed to the nines influencers walking the streets here, honestly. Our bartender was super friendly and let us know their happy hour deal (half priced middle shelf mixed drinks which included Tito's and Tanqueray - amazing). This was a great stop for a quick, cheap, cold drink -- which are few and far between these days in Montauk. If you're here on a weekday, I highly recommend stopping in.