Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cassie's Kitchen

    3.5 (4 reviews)
    InexpensiveNew American

    Cassie's Kitchen Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Cassie's Kitchen

    Recommended Reviews - Cassie's Kitchen

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Astrid S.
    104
    50
    9

    18 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jonathan F.
    213
    220
    274

    18 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    18 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Really good breakfast and lunch. Small town atmosphere, friendly people. Best burger in town and great turkey club.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 296 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Print House - The Vegan

    The Print House

    4.2(20 reviews)
    13.3 mi

    I love vinyl records, quirky fun places and eclectic menus, so had high hopes for celebrating my…read morebirthday at The Print House. Sadly my actual experience wasn't much fun at all. Made a reservation over a week prior to the date directly with the owner Joseph by FB Messenger. (I knew they were catering a party for a nearby art gallery that night, so I wanted to make sure they were available for a private rez. Owner reassured me it was fine and he would make a special rez for me). So imagine my surprise when we walked in and were told by Christina that we had no reservation and no tables were available either! I politely explained that I had made a rez with the owner and showed my phone as proof. She walked into the back and disappeared for a awhile, then emerged and said the owner confirmed my reservation so she would "find me a table". No apology, acted like she was doing us a favor. We were seated at a table in a small separate area by the window that's normally reserved for people with no reservations; it was warm and uncomfortable but I was still hoping for the best. Cocktails were good but diluted with too much ice. We started with the Nonna's meatball appetizer, which was fairly tasty but served barely lukewarm with some cool spots. It arrived at our table less than 1 minute after we ordered it. (Maybe reheated in the kitchen?) My quarter chicken with carrots was a paltry portion for the price and suffered from overly aggressive use of the pepper shaker. (Note the large black flecks of pepper adorning the carrots in my picture). Partner's pasta with peas and truffles was made with with undercooked peas and lots of pepper, he couldn't finish it. Given our offhanded treatment I was hoping for a birthday treat or at least a greeting by the mysterious owner, but none were forthcoming. After the meal our server just said "happy birthday" and handed me the check. Partner's "Paloma Lisa" cocktail was listed on the menu and chalkboard at $13 but we were billed $14. Not a big difference, just an additional petty annoyance to an already unpleasant evening. We paid, tipped and left. I rarely give two star reviews, but that's about right for the birthday "non-celebration" delivered by The Print House. Maybe they were having a bad night what with the art gallery party, but there's just no excuse for lackluster food coupled with truly bad customer service. One and done.

    We were excited to try this restaurant after reading so many positive reviews and happily drove…read morenearly 45 minutes to dine here. When we arrived early for our Sunday evening reservation, the restaurant was mostly empty. Cassidy told that the other two-top tables were unavailable because of a large reservation later that evening, so we were seated next to the bathrooms, which wasn't our favorite. About 10 minutes later, another couple arrived, and we overheard them being offered one of those same tables as long as they finished within 1 hour and 45 minutes. That inconsistency made us wonder whether we were treated differently because of our race. Unfortunately, the rest of the evening didn't improve. The live musician insisted that people applaud her although the music wasn't enjoyable, the food was average at best, and when the check arrived, our server Cassidy explained that she had charged us for another party's meal. Resolving the billing error took additional time and confusion. Overall, the experience was disappointing from start to finish, and we won't be returning.

    Photos
    The Print House
    The Print House - Gram's meatballs

    Gram's meatballs

    The Print House

    See all

    Phoenicia Diner - Buttermilk pancakes

    Phoenicia Diner

    4.1(842 reviews)
    25.8 mi
    •$$

    Had a nice late lunch here on our recent trip. (Note that they are often not open at dinner time.)…read morewe were told that the food and service were good and that they had a few unusual local ingredients incorporated into their menu. For this reason, I decided to go with an Arnold Bennet skillet that included smoked trout. If you at all like the thought of lox and eggs, then you definitely need to try this one. It also had Parmesan, chives, and crème fraiche mixed in. The taste of this combination on a piece of toast was delicious! And something I would happily enjoy again and at reasonable prices. Plus, it was enough food that I finished it for breakfast the next morning. The seating area looks and feels like a typical NY diner. Our waitress was quick and efficient and the coffee was good and fresh. Especially with the limited number of dining locations in the Catskills area, Phoenicia diner is definitely worth a stop.

    This diner definitely gets packed, but thankfully, the wait usually isn't too long!…read more The milkshakes were a little disappointing--they mostly tasted like melted ice cream rather than an actual milkshake. The cinnamon roll was the same one I had back in March, but unfortunately, the texture wasn't as soft this time. It was noticeably harder, although it was still generously covered in frosting like before. The scrambled eggs were soft and cooked well, but the biscuits and gravy were pretty heavy. The potatoes, however, were amazing! They were nice and crispy, which I really enjoyed. My daughter really enjoyed her meal. She ordered the French toast, sausage, bacon, pancakes, and eggs, and she was very happy with everything. Overall, the food was a mixed experience for me, but there were definitely some highlights--especially those crispy potatoes!

    Photos
    Phoenicia Diner - Turn The Holiday Spirit All The Way Up

    Turn The Holiday Spirit All The Way Up

    Phoenicia Diner - Chorizo Mac and Cheese

    Chorizo Mac and Cheese

    Phoenicia Diner - The Mitchell

    See all

    The Mitchell

    Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room - caramelized jumbo sea scallops

    Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room

    4.2(506 reviews)
    18.0 mi
    •$$$

    It's a beautiful restaurant with a dim, romantic atmosphere that makes it feel perfect for a date…read morenight. Just make sure to connect to the Wi-Fi when you arrive because there is absolutely no cell service! The bread and butter were divine! The butter could have been a little warmer, but the bread itself was fluffy, light, and packed with salty, garlicky flavor. I could have easily kept eating it! The gnocchi was just alright and probably wouldn't be something I'd order again. It wasn't very firm and tended to stick together with the other pieces. The steak, on the other hand, was incredible! It was tender, juicy, and cooked beautifully. The crispy vegetables paired really well with the steak and added a nice texture to the dish. We ended up ordering more bread, and I loved it so much that I took some home to enjoy for breakfast the next morning! Overall, a beautiful spot with a romantic ambiance and some standout dishes.

    Everything. Yes. Delicious food. Our server was amazing. The seating was superb. I wish I'd gotten…read morea photo of our table and chairs. We were tucked away in an indoor/outdoor area with gorgeous orange comfy chairs. We did not come in with a reservation. Again this place was a stumbled upon gem. We looked online for a nice place to go for my boyfriend's 30th birthday. He loves moose and we love farm to table food. The server helped us decide what to get for drinks, both delicious. The food.....holy cow. Heavenly. Our two meals tasted so vastly different so it was great that we were each able to sample the other's and they were both SO tasty. We asked our server for a special dessert for his birthday, she asked if we liked bananas and we enthusiastically said yes. Next thing we know, this decadent warm banana and caramel creation is coming towards us with a giant sparkler. This was probably hands down....one of the best desserts I have ever had in my life. I would make the trip back up here solely for that! Should we ever find ourselves back up in the Catskills, this will ABSOLUTELY be on our list of places to revisit.

    Photos
    Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room - Main dining room

    Main dining room

    Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room - Half a portion of the chicken

    Half a portion of the chicken

    Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room - Parking area entrance

    See all

    Parking area entrance

    The Old Mill - Braised short ribs with mashed potatoes and carrots. AMAZING

    The Old Mill

    3.7(22 reviews)
    12.9 mi

    Don't order the fish! I had the Baked Cod - it was really off-tasting (something you don't want in…read moreseafood!), overly fishy and unpleasant. My dining companions ordered the short rib, which was much tastier and tender. Perhaps this is one of the places that exceeds when it comes to "turf", but you should avoid the "surf." I also ordered an asparagus soup, which was too salty, but had the texture of a bean/split pea soup. They also served generous pours of wines and had friendly service, otherwise. Keep in mind this is a very pricey establishment. For a dining party of 3 people, our bill was nearly $200 for something very middle range -- it's not the glitzy-est of atmospheres for that high price. Instead, it was dark, dank and basement-like. I expected more affordable pub style food with that feel.

    The restaurant is cute & warm, an actual old mill. Our 1st time to Roxbury NY & a last minute trip…read moreto celebrate our 18th wedding anniversary. We walked in without a reservation. We were seated within 10 minutes which was very nice but the waitress/host seemed a bit annoyed. To be fair there were only 2 women serving the bar & restaurant and as someone in the service business, it's not easy BUT it's not an excuse just understandable. THE FOOD...it was good but I was disappointed in my Smoked Duck app which had three small thin slices of duck. The apricot vinaigrette was the star of the dish. The scalloped potatoes were good & were not soaked in cream & butter which I liked. Hubby had his go to drink, a Manhattan and it was ok. His entree was Pasta Carbonara, it was very good. All in all 3-stars maybe 4 because the ambiance was romantic or maybe that was us LOL.

    Photos
    The Old Mill
    The Old Mill - Smoked Duck app w/ apricot vinaigrette

    Smoked Duck app w/ apricot vinaigrette

    The Old Mill - The kind of clam chowder that saves marriages.

    See all

    The kind of clam chowder that saves marriages.

    Cassie's Kitchen - newamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...