Food is on point, service is great. Wood fire Pizza tastes great. One of the few diamond in the rough for upstate NY. If you are hungry or have kids with you, this place is the spot. read more

AMAAZING PIZZA!!!!!!!!!!Actually fire roasted!! Fresh ingredients! Just like home pizza! [long island] read more

Oakley's Place - Chicken Wings Near Me - Arkville, New York

See all

Oakley's is a great spot to have in this area, for locals and visitors alike. My family has been many times and service and food always top notch. Joy is fantastic! For those complaining about wait times - this restaurant (like many others) continues to deal with staffing issues. The staff do the best they can!! The outdoor area is great in summer, and we just learned it'll be insulated for the cooler months. We went last week over Columbus Day and everything was great. The specialty salad is massive and delicious. Pizza, chicken sandwich and the spaghetti & meatballs were great entrees. The spaghetti was a massive portion. New owner is great, too. read more

Oakley's Place - Chicken Wings Near Me - Arkville, New York

Great pizza. Easy going atmosphere. Wonderful service. Found this spot accidentally.. but it was a great surprise

Was 2 stars now 1 star for owner's junk response - showing zero care or commitment to providing quality (while charging high prices). "We are busy" is no excuse for bad food. *Note... going back in to change your original awful comment after being called out doesn't change anything, just shows you're dishonest and all about appearances versus quality food or customer service. Ambiance is nice but you can't eat ambiance. Waited 73 minutes for our pizza - not even a special wood fired just regular. No explanation. No upfront warning "pizza will be a long wait." Had to flag down and ask what was going on after nearly an hour. Received An apology as pizza served "thanks for your patience." Ok... how about you comp us our soda? Send us home with a slice of cheesecake? If you can't handle the volume, add an oven or tell customers upfront it's a long wait. Pizza was NOT ok - Definitely not 73 minute wait worthwhile. One side badly burnt crust, middle was soggy. We asked for half the pie with onions and peppers ... they put on entire pizza. Almost no spinach, three tiny pieces of broccoli and looked like a giant can of olives all over one side. Some pieces had almost no cheese. It was prepared with zero care, sloppy and improper order. Caesar salad was so soaked in dressing, had to order a bowl of plain chopped lettuce to mix it up. Owners seated in the bar holding court, oblivious to the kitchen back up, not helping staff nor checking on customers. Brio in Phoenicia is a longer drive but totally worth it. Will not be coming back unless desperate. read more

Just because their sign says "wood fired", doesn't mean it's going to be good. Service was good, ambience was good. Food was awful. Our "wood fired" pizza was still doughy, and extremely soggy...like a wet tortilla....and overpriced for a pizza that size. Ordered a fried chicken sandwich that was still cold, and fried in what I would assume is 10 year old oil. Fries were dripping with oil, and not seasoned at all...also overpriced for what it was. Is it worth it if you're in the area? No...there are far better places within 10 minutes in either direction. Maybe the cooks were having a bad night? read more

Disappointing Experience Despite a Few Highlights I came in to try the wood-fired pizzas and ended up ordering more than planned. I started with the Margherita pizza, expecting a classic combo of tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil. Being from Long Island, I found it strange that they used raw tomato slices on top as if I ordered a pizza with tomato as a topping. While the crust was nicely done, the rest of the pizza was bland and didn't suit my taste. On the bright side, the boneless buffalo wings were a hit--perfectly spicy and paired really well with the bleu cheese sauce. The shrimp tempura was also great: light, crispy, and flavorful. I had a beer that tasted like a mix of apple cider and beer (can't recall the name), but it complemented the wings nicely. One major issue was the service around my cheeseburger order. I asked for cheddar cheese, expecting the usual yellow cheddar, but received white cheddar instead. When I asked about it, another server stepped in with a really unprofessional attitude, insisting over and over that it "tastes the same" rather than just answering a simple yes or no to whether they had yellow cheddar. My original server eventually came back and echoed the same dismissive tone after hearing the story from the other girl. I felt like just sending the burger back and paying for it out of frustration. I ended up keeping it, gave half to my spouse, took one bite, and regretted not giving her the whole thing. The burger was underseasoned and just not enjoyable. I ended up tossing what was left. The view of the mountains from the window was a nice touch, and the atmosphere overall was pleasant--but food consistency and staff attitude (from certain people) really need work. I won't be returning, but I still left a tip. read more

See all

I was warned by multiple people to not come here, YET, because there was new ownership and they were working out kinks... well I chose to find out for myself and boy did I find out. It was a Saturday night at 7pm on Columbus Day weekend. The restaurant, inside and outside were both packed. The restaurant itself is very cute, and fitting for the mountain town that it is in. My friends and I were craving pizza and bar food and just wanted a quick place to eat before heading to the distillery down the road. We ordered our food at 7:20pm.... My soup came out quick and was delicious.... 8:20pm comes around and we still haven't gotten anything else we ordered. Finally I get up and approach the owner, who seemed to not care much at all that we'd been sitting there for an hour. After I explained what we ordered he did go to try to figure out where our food ticket was because at that point I assumed our food wasn't even put in. As we watched the staff nervously try to figure out what was going on, no one was coming to our table to explain anything. I am a very patient, understanding person when I go out to eat, especially because I have worked in busy bars and restaurants, I know first hand how things can go on a busy Saturday night. I was specifically in town and chose to eat at Oakley's because I am creating content for the local tourism board to promote businesses!! It's extremely frustrating to go somewhere where I am supposed to be capturing content, and not be able to do that. I don't want to leave a place and be miserable, I want to leave a business and be happy with my experience so that I can share it in a positive manner with people on the internet. I'll give this place benefit of the doubt because they are under new ownership, but what I hated was that we barely got an apology. The owner told our server we could get a round of drinks for free to make up for the chaos. I guess something is better than nothing, but the fact that the owner himself couldn't even stop at our table to apologize is pretty pathetic. We saw very little remorse from the owner and staff, it was more so them wanting us to feel bad for them because it was "so busy" and a "holiday weekend". Maybe don't fill every table in your restaurant then ? That's what a wait list is for... If you own a restaurant and know that it's busy and things are backed up, take it upon yourself to go up to each table and explain that to people then. It's really not that hard to be honest and apologetic. Why are you packing your restaurant, stressing out your kitchen and servers and then making people sit there for 1.5 hours miserable, only to serve them undercooked, flavorless food. On top of it, the men's bathroom was DISGUSTING. And then as we were leaving the owner is sitting outside having a pow wow with his staff literally outside of the entrance door. Very unprofessional and just an overall absolutely horrible experience. Literally in my top 3 most horrible restaurant experiences and I eat out A LOT. I truly hope that the ownership gets it together and this place turns itself around, because the potential is there! Had the owner just shown that he cared at all about how upset we were, I might not be leaving this review. Also, since it took us 2 hours to finally eat, the distillery closed and we never ended up getting to go there, which I had really been looking forward to. read more

See all

Glad to see this place doing well. Been coming here for years. Varied menu, great staff and beautiful deck. The pizzas are the stars, great wood fired char with quality ingredients. The kinda place that makes you happy to be there! Bravo! read more

Pizza and beer selection was great! You can sit inside or out... but definitely pick outside if it's a nice night. It gets very busy on the weekends, so plan ahead. We had 2 of their vegetarian pizzas and they were delicious. The pitcher of beer seemed expensive but since we couldn't even finish it, so it was a lot for the money. read more

Ambiance (4/5): The inside is super cozy with low seating, dimly lit, and tight spaces. It feels like a rustic log cabin with a fireplace and a bar. The dining area overlooks the kitchen where the firewood oven is. There's also outdoor dining as well as an enclosed outdoor dining area. The guests appeared to be mostly post-mountain skiers and families. Service (4/5): The establishment was very busy but there was plenty of staff members on the floor assisting. The workers were all very polite and quick to get us anything we needed. The pizza took 50 minutes so I'd recommend getting some appetizers to hold you over. Food (3/5): The bottom crust of the pizza was soggy so the bites were unsatisfying. The buffalo chicken pizza was delicious but ultimately, I've had much better pizza elsewhere. When reheating the pizza at home, we pan-fried them to allow for the bottom to get crispy and it was a drastically better slice. read more

See all

I never had a Margherita pizza that had shredded cheese, burnt basil and cold unripe tomatoes placed on after the pizza was cooked- I am assuming, as the tomatoes were cold. It's unfortunate, I enjoyed the pizza in the past, not sure what happened! read more

New owner so we went to support. Always had great pizza. Not now. I would say terrible compared to former owners. Also Cesar salad was swimming in dressing. Almost uneatable. Under new pizza chef coming in two weeks. Will try again in November and truly hope it meets or exceeds the experience we have had for years. read more

Oakley's Place Proprietor(s), YOU took my factual review to forewarn others "PERSONALLY"? Bwahah! You pissed & moaned on Yelp because I clarified significant dangers I experienced first-hand. Fact: You carelessly sold me very toxic ill-prepared food. You spend so-much time here, yet you obviously need help. You still don't understand the principle purpose of Yelp! Get a clue. Here come more truths, especially for you. Organics would be justified at your price-points. At-least go non-GMO. I take it personally that you did not emulate concerns regarding your food safety responsibilities on behalf of your public. You are a New York State Licensed restaurateur. You showed no remorse, nor intent to address faulty food preparation practices involving food-related toxins, despite liability for knowingly continuing to produce, & serve them. You publicly disregarded dangers without any indication of addressing your unsafe practices at this establishment. Meanwhile, you have nearly $200 of my hard-earned cash! I take that very personally! I also take it personally that I would have been poisoned, if I trusted that your food was safe to consume sans vigilant inspection. I may have suffered indeterminate, potentially life-long detrimental health consequences. That qualifies as extremely personal. As anticipated, and based upon your past irresponsible retorts to legitimate Yelps, your reply is fraught with excuses which make no sense. Interesting that you blatantly ignored my revelation regarding your toxic wings. They are carelessly tossed into your wood-fired pizza oven within aluminum take-out tins, presumably to save more time and money. You cannot possibly be mindful of customer health & safety, or you would have immediately halted this dangerous shortcut, post-haste. Unbelievable! The correct and safe wing preparation method is quite simple. Yet you choose to cheat, knowing of potential health consequences for paying customers. Permitting employees to shortcut approved food cooking and preparation practices on your behalf is horrific! Wings should obviously be fully prepared in oven-certified bake-ware before placement in thin tin to-go containers. Large holes were burned through the tin containing the wings you sold to me. Inevitably, thin oil (not wing sauce) coated every additional container. Creeps! Unimaginable! I clearly explained this serious culinary faux-pa in my initial Yelp!, and true-to-nature, you failed to express dismay, & showed no intention of addressing this easily-remedied issue. Your very expensive 'to-go wings' are definitely toxic due to melted tin fusion, and yet you carelessly think of review implications for your business. You incessantly ignore legit health & safety dangers for patrons. By the way, the cheap & thin hot-sauce infused oil applied to your wings is pathetic. It does not resemble, nor qualify as wing sauce. And as previously stated, your blue cheese dressing is more-salty than Ontario's Goderich mine. Despite your denial regarding massive sodium dosing in nearly everything you serve, it remains a fact with undeniable potential of severe health consequences. Perhaps extreme salt levels is your slick trick to increase beverage revenue from unsuspecting folks. My detailed Yelp! of factoids experienced at your restaurant to the tune of nearly two C-notes clarifies extreme personal significance. You allow your staff to burn very expensive pizza, rendering much of it inedible. Train them to monitor your wood-fired oven, & instruct them to rotate the pies out of respect for your patrons! Fire incapable individuals, and hire people with common sense. Regardless of your claims, your $20 Greek salad lacks volume, has too few tomatoes, negligible Kalamata olives, sparse feta and way too much inexpensive onion. We wonder how y'all can sleep knowing these things about yourselves. Perhaps you find comfort by laying your head upon a pillow stuffed with customer cash. Many believe that evildoers cannot truly escape accountability, whether in this life, or the next. Perhaps it comes upon learning the answer to 'The Big Secret'. You know. The here-after. That which comes next. There has to be some brand of Almighty accountability to follow. Too many would escape a genuine accounting. So, it wouldn't impact your cash-flow to have addressed these issues for the sake of your remaining customers. Pretty revealing as-to your priorities. Bottom Line: Young, mature & elderly, everything we consume has good or bad consequences for our bodies over our lifetime. Anyone who values their health needs to acknowledge taste-bud signalling at first bite, which is when heavy salt, toxins and metals are detectable. Senses of taste and smell become overwhelmed rapidly. Also, we must pay close attention to every detail of the foods we are served, no-matter how hungry. Carefully examine all food before deciding whether it is safe to put inside our one-and-only bodies. BEWARE out there! read more

Oakley's is exactly what it is and not more - a Catskills roadhouse. Expect decently good service, a nice choice of draft beer, and marginally acceptable food. I write this review only for one reason: WTF is up with your wings? Since changing ownership (yet again), the once routine and predictably buffalo-y buffalo wings now come coated in ketchup. I wish I was kidding. Wife and I ordered wings the other night, and they come out dripping in red goo. Never one to turn away food, I tried them anyway. Something's not right, I thought to myself. They were sticky sweet and tangy. I asked the waitress if maybe she ordered the wrong kind of wings. Nope, she says, I keep telling them not to use ketchup, but they won't listen to me. She offers to take them back and have them redone without ketchup (what a novel idea). I concur, and ten minutes later she returns with a new basket of wings - covered in ketchup. The poor thing looked at me with a mix of shame and fear in her eyes. "I'm so sorry, she said. He insists on making them this way. Maybe you can take them home and rinse them off?" To the management: WTF, actually. read more

Fabulous wood-fired pizza! Stopped by for a late lunch and shared a large (16") margarita pizza and garden salad. Quick pleasant service, including free soft drink refills and several check-ins to see if everything was OK (it was!). Decor is rustic and inviting with a long bar and plenty of tables. We're NY City natives with plenty of pizza gorging experience under our ever-expanding belts, and thought Oakley's pizza was among the very best we've ever had. Nicely charred bubbly crust, fresh cheese and a scattering of basil leaves on top. Simple perfection, at a reasonable price. As we left we spoke to proprietor George who was sitting outside on the spacious deck. George told us that he had reduced opening days to four days per week (Thursday through Sunday) for the time being, in order to give the staff a chance to rest up during these trying times. Judging from our friendly service and great food this strategy is working well. Recommend! read more

See all

I should have ordered a pizza. My wife did and it was fantastic. Marguerita pizza. Love the wood fired flavor. We had fried pickles as an appetizer. These were good. My daughter and I both had pork schnitzel. The pork was good. The broccoli was great. The rice.... Well, it was both over cooked and cool... not even room temperature. So it was a holiday weekend and this place was busy and they feel very under staffed. If this is normal plan to wait for your food. That said the servers work their butts off and were great. It felt like the kitchen may have been the issue. That said, if I wasn't in a rush, I would come back just for the pizza. My guess is the rice is a fluke due to an understaffed kitchen. Considering it is not a German place, the schnitzel was pretty darn good. read more

Oakley's Place - Marguerita Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Arkville, New York

See all

Ordered a veggie pizza didn't have egg plant like it said it would. And they did not cook the egg plant well. I ordered the bacon jam burger and it did not include bacon jam it had slices of bacon and it did not have Gouda. We also ordered her pumpkin beer and it tasked like they put grass in the beer. Service was blah. The music was the only good thing. It smelled like garbage due to the garbage being right next to us the entire meal. Not a good restaurant in this town. read more

Food was horrible. They need to get a chef that knows how to cook good meals. Hamburgers were good. The service is lousy. We waited 30 minutes before we saw a waitress. After ordered it took an hour and forty five minutes to get our meals and they were horrible. Dry chicken undercooked french fries. Chicken sorrentio tasted like chicken parm. The pull pork sandwich was as thin as a 2 piece ham sandwich and didn't taste like pork. It was more like dry brisket. They said they are the only place in town so you'll be back. The old owner was much better at it than the new owner is. New owner didn't even care enough to walk around and visit with the customers to see if everything was alright. He just sat outside and drank wine. Long time before I ever go back. Bring back the previous owner. read more

If I could give a 0 I would. We had booked our rehearsal dinner here almost 2 months in advance for 25 people. 2 days before the event we saw on Facebook they were going to be closed for 2 weeks, we reached out to make sure we were still on and they told us there was a mistake and were on vacation, if we had never reached out we would have shown up with 25 people to a closed restaurant . This has put so much stress on us days before our wedding trying to now find a place that can accommodate us all for a rehearsal dinner. What a terrible thing to do to people. read more

Been going to Oakley's for 20+ years. We love their chicken wings, wood fired personal pizzas and salads. What makes them really good is their customer service. Vinny, one of the owners comes around to each table. If he doesn't deliver your order, he's checking if you need anything else to complement your meal. Now, he is serving Jane's ice cream in a little kiosk outside the restaurant. A perfect ending to a perfect meal and experience!!! read more

We eat at Oakley's Place every time we visit Margaretville. I hesitate to share my true opinion because I don't want to create long, long lines to wait for a table but... it needs to be said: Oakley's has pizza better than the local pizzerias in my Brooklyn neighborhood. The word "better" does not capture the superior experience of eating this pizza. But for Brooklyn reference, it would be as if Grimaldis Pizza (the one by the Brooklyn Bridge) and Patsy's Pizza had a pizza baby. They have a fire wood oven and apparently, absolutely KNOW how to use that thing to achieve perfection in a crispy crust pizza. The sauce is delicious, neither too sweet or too tangy. The cheese stays on the pizza, not sliding away as you bite into it, and they are generous with the pepperonis which cover the entire pie. Honestly, if you are within 50 miles of this place, you should stop by. read more

This once delicious pizza restaurant just changed hands to become more of a "grill" with new menu items, but the new owners' decision to remake the pizza is, in a word, a disaster. First, they have re-defined what a "large" pizza is. We ordered one for $24. 95 expecting the usual size. What we got was about a foot in diameter. The dough was thick, soggy, undercooked and very salty. It was just a flat bread. Do they really think people don't know the difference between real pizza dough and a flat bread? The Margarita that we ordered had hardly any cheese, just underripe tomatoes and basil "flavor" (I did not see any physical basil). It was inedible. They gave us a $7 dollar credit on the pizza but we were still paying $17 for very poor quality and quantity. The salad was big and good but with commercial dressing you could get at the supermarket. The waitresses were excellent however, friendly and obviously a bit confused by the changes made by the new owners. I guess they overpaid for the place and want to make a lot of money fast. read more

Stopped at this restaurant clinging to the road in the middle of the Catskills woods. I had to go in because it was crowded on a Wednesday night. They have a wood fired oven. They serve wood fired pizza but on that night had a steak special for me. Perfectly cooked steak, bistro quality salad, and mashed potatoes that were as a good as -- well -- mine., Friendly and efficient staff, like I was visiting a friends mom. read more

Oakley's Place - Steak, mashed potatoes, good collard greens - Chicken Wings Near Me - Arkville, New York

wish I could give negative stars. not a local and came here after 2 other places in the area were closed/understaffEd. came in and ordered 3 pizzas, fries, and a burger. was told 45 minutes and no clarification on eat in or take out but told 2 people my party if 6 were waiting at a table; ordered deinks from bar, fine and speedy. waited 1.5 hours for food and only got it when we inquired TWICE. When we asked we're told "just waiting on fres" (fries were on the counter for 45 minutes already). when we asked we're told we're met with insane defensiveness and hostility- no "sorry". would've been fine if they admitted mistake. all food was cold and wrong. pizza was burnt and still raw. paid $98 for this. disappointed and will never be coming back. read more

This place is AMAZING !!! I had their signature pie and it's absolutely delicious!!' I also had their sweet potato fries !!!! AMAZING!!! They have a maple sauce that goes with them !!! YUMMMM!!! The service was wonderful!!!! It was a nice place and was not too busy at all!!! The ambiance was amazing !!! read more

Oakley's Place - Chicken Wings Near Me - Arkville, New York

See all

Best pizza I've had in decades. If you're hungry and within an hour of this place, it's worth getting their pizza. read more

I visited most recently in August of 2020 (during COVID) and was truely impressed with the new outdoor seating areas, distancing between tables, thorough cleaning between customers and the sanitation they practiced. Oakley's is still going strong and pumping out great food at reasonable prices. You might not expect pizza in the Catskills to be anything special -- but at Oakley's you'd be dead wrong. Their pizza (like alot of their menu) is cooked on their wood fire, fueled by locally harvested wood for an authentic mountain flavor. Wash it down with one of their numerous tap beers or a drink from the bar - and its just awesome! I also really recommend their wood-fired chicken sandwiches and wood- fired burgers. This place has been consistently pumping out perfect pizza pies to please passers-by and locals alike! read more

See all

Oakley's is gem of a Restaurant! Great service, awesome staff and the Proprietor George was a great host! Gerald & Diana read more

Our food was good, the waitress was great BUT $9.50 for a draft Yuengling !! Ridiculous!! We won't be back!

Very good! Seated quickly and service was great! I can't remember our waitresses name but she had a black and white spiderweb shirt. We ordered wings, sweet potato fries, garlic knots and a bacon Mac and cheese pizza. My boyfriend said the wings were a little dry but over all very good! The pizza was amazing and worth the wait (which wasn't that long to begin with) the staff kept apologizing for the (not long) wait. The garlic knots/ sauce were great as were the fries! Next time we're in the Catskills we will be back! read more

Oakley's Place - Chicken Wings Near Me - Arkville, New York

I have had a lot of burgers and Za and this is a standout. Burger had excellent flavor. Pizza was fantastic (CBR on recommendation of waitress). And good beer list and fantastic service. read more

Really nice spot to casually eat. Stopped in two nights in a row while in the area for a weekend getaway and I will say I found their comfort food (i.e. pizza, burgers) better than the speciality food like pasta. First night I stopped in I had spaghetti and meatball and it was just ok. It wasn't terrible but it wasn't amazing like you get an an authentic Italian restaurant. The pizza I had was better and the comfort food my girl ordered was good as well. It can get crowded because this seems to be a local favorite hangout spot. Staff is amazing though. read more

Unfortunately, all of my experiences with Oakley's have been infuriating. I've been there several times, and each time I have left before ordering because of the insane wait time. Don't come here if it's past 6pm- don't even bother. Wait for tables is pretty long, and only once you're seated do they tell you how long you'll need to wait for your food. Tonight, it was 1hr + 45 minutes for every item on the menu except two salads. The one time I actually got the food, it was fine, but not worth two hours of waiting for. I hate leaving bad reviews, but each time I've been here there was long wait times and unpleasant atmosphere, and I was left hungry and frustrated. read more

+ excellent service, friendly, helpful +real wood fires oven +not gourmet wood fires rustic wood fired and it works well +the food pulled pork, burgers and Stromboli all excellent - none Stop in this place today where locals and tourists blend well. read more

Good was cold Food was cold and service was mediocre, took long time for burgers and got served after people that got there after us read more

Great Food, great staff. My friends and I love this place. The wood fired pizza is perfect. The best chicken wings in New York.

First time here, staff was friendly and order was fast. We did a pickup so can't comment on dine in. Burger was 100%. Will be checking them out again once back in area. read more

Great spot! Many menu options with great flavor. Indoor and outdoor seating. Great little bar inside also. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I don't know what happened to this place. Came here at 5:30 dying for pizza. 2 plus hours wait for a pizza. George...it's a pizza place. You can't make the sitting patrons wait 2 hours for pizza! Also my martini glass was 1/2 to 3/4 full. My wife's was filled to a decent level. Everything else we ordered was good. But this is Oakley's wood fired PIZZA. I got no pizza. Will probably never come back again. Maybe during the week. They have great pizza but seriously? I don't come up here too often usually just to ski. But I'm so annoyed I'm probably skipping this place in the future. Nor would I recommend it again. I'm sure they won't miss me. Good luck to you. Update: Found a nice hair in the gyro order. Add insult to injury. Come on. The waitress did take it off the bill. Much appreciated. And classy. read more

See all