This place appears to have undergone some changes between the first and subsequent visit. I recall it being more casual (different entry too?) and it was handy for grabbing a pizza and heading across the street to the brewery. The dining-in restaurant is stylish if a little sterile, and the menu is limited compared to Arturo's in Maplewood, and for that I would give it 4 stars. BUT the sesame and stracciatella cheese pizza is so utterly amazing (and inspired) that I have no issue giving this place 5 stars for that alone. read more

A clear 5 out of 5. Never disappoints. I can never decide what I like best... the atmosphere, the service or the pizza(or anything on the menu) On the service front, Mike is the best! read more

Was here with a nice group, we only had a 2 meatballs, two salads and three pizzas and the bill was $150!!! Just be prepared very very overpriced pizza I thought it was OK nothing over the top. I don't think I would be back to be honest with you. I didn't like how cold it is inside. Also, it feels like you're eating in a cafeteria it's also very loud be prepared to scream to talk if it's crowded. The saving grace was the server. He was sweet, seemed a little wet behind the ears, but still sweet and was trying very hard. read more

Not your typical Neapolitan pizza joint but possibly my favorite pizza in town. I've tried a bunch of their pies and none of them disappoint, though personally I'd recommend their less traditional ones. I'm a sucker for Buffalo chicken pizza and they knock it out if the park. I've also tried their gluten free detroit style and it's shockingly good. The prices are a little on the higher side but nothing abnormal or unfair for the location or the cuisine, and I always go home with a couple slices leftover (your mileage may vary - I personally have to fight myself to not just crush the pie). read more

We love Brick + Dough. The meatballs and knots are always spot on and the pizza choices are fun. It is definitely and indulgent night but last night was a miss. We have only ever sat outside and usually bring a few drinks and a Pellegrino water. Last night we sat inside and the waiter came up to our table and very brusquely said " We have sparkling water here. You don't need that". We apologized and told him we always bring one and were never told but from now on we understand. Not really an issue. The waiter just seemed put off and was really grumpy with us all night. We never got his name. He never asked how were were. Never got any extra napkins. He forgot the garlic knots which is understandable on a busy night but he overcharged us after we only ordered a few, we paid for double we ordered. I have to say, when you're paying a premium and tipping on top, it would be nice to have friendly service. read more

I'm sorry to write a negative review but this is the third time that the pizzas are burnt on the bottom, you have to teach your "pizzaiolo" how not to make this mistake! especially because you offer Neapolitan pizza. read more

Enjoyed the meatball ricotta pizza for a quick lunch in between meetings. Delicious and it wasn't super heavy. The service is solid as well. Overall a great place for pizza in Montclair! read more

Very fresh food, whether it's their signature pizzas or sides. Their dough is the best! I will say that sometimes, their pizzas are skimpy. Meaning that they could add more sauce, cheese, or toppings. While other times (like the photos pictured), the food is perfect. Service is similar, ranging from good to exceptional depending on the day. Our server Michael was the best we've had in a while! So attentive and helpful. read more

Brick + Dough - Sesame pizza and four cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Great service. Amazing pizza and they were playing a 90's playlist. Checked all of our boxes for an awesome lunch. read more

Brick + Dough - Fig, spicy salami & goat cheese pizza and chicken vodka pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Stop reading this review and get yourself to Brick + Dough! As a gluten-free vegetarian, I'm always on the lookout for different pizza places. Brick + Dough came up as an option for gluten-free pizza and I couldn't believe it when I saw they offer gf pizza by the slice. I couldn't even tell you if I've ever been anywhere where I wasn't forced to get a pie because they didn't offer gf slices. The shop is currently offering outdoor seating, which was nicely set up on the sidewalk. Upon entering, everything appeared extremely organized and clean. They have a large display case with a top shelf featuring gluten-free items like thick Sicilian-style pizza slices and garlic knots, while the shelf below contains regular slices. I was in total disbelief that I could order a garlic knot, which was heated up for me. I quickly devoured the seasoned, buttery, chewy goodness of that garlic knot. I opted for a tomato pesto slice and found it to be just slightly bland, but the crust was absolutely incredible. Airy, thick, and with the perfect amount of crunch, I couldn't believe it was gluten-free. My partner's regular buffalo slice was reportedly delicious, as it quickly disappeared. We also tried their gluten-free brownie bites and my partner described it as, "A chocolate cotton ball." This was meant in a positive way since the bites were so airy and light,-- the bites didn't stand a chance against us. Get ready to spend some dough, this is definitely a spot to visit while in the Montclair area. read more

See all

Best pizza we've had since moving from Brooklyn! The dough is crispy and chewy, toppings are plenty. Service is friendly and fast! read more

See all

There were alot of people here the night we went, but it didn't affect the service. Got seated after about 10 minutes and the food came out hot, fresh and quick. Ordered two pizzas, cheesy breadstick, and a caesar salad. All of which tasted great. No complaints, would definitely be back to try other things. I wish they offered their sandwiches regularly. read more

See all

It's in the name--if you don't like dough-y pizza, this isn't the pizza for you! I loved it, however, and the dough was artisan, soft, delicious and bubbly. I tried the Margarita (which I typically do not like, but it was great) and the meatball. They also have gluten free options for most pies! Delicious, can't wait to try others. I have been looking for this style of pizza ever since I tried Emily's Hearth and finally found something close to work. read more

Finally an amazing brick oven pizza place. I debated on keeping this place a secret because I love it so much but it would do a disservice to how good this place is. It is just what I wanted for brick over pizza. I usually go with the margherita and Buffalo chicken pizza and both are amazing. I definitely recommend checking this place out. But if you order online, you have to make sure to order early enough cause once I tried to order online at 6 and the next available time for order was 9. But it was worth it! read more

This is a great little spot for a quick date night or a dinner our with friends. My absolute favorite were the Rodolfo's Knots and cheesy bread sticks. The portion sizes are huge and i could have easily made this my dinner. The crispy brussels sprouts are absolutely delicious!! The miso aioli is just perfect. Our group shared the sesame + stracciatella, new york style and margherita. They all were delicious, though it was hard to tell the difference in taste between NY and margherita. Overall, I really enjoyed our dinner here. I would come back just for the breads and sprouts! read more

Love the food!! Yummy pizzas and salad. Ambiance was nice too, chill kinda vibe.. they actually sat us alone which was kinda nice (they gave us a choice) Service wasn't bad either. I would recommend this place if you're looking for a fancy pizza place. read more

Just had Brick and Dough today for the first time at a catered event and omgsh it was so goooood! The pizza was perfectly chewy (I think the Buffalo chicken pizza was the best) and their fried chicken sandwiches were absolutely mouthwatering. I try to have one cheat meal a week and this one was so worth it ;) read more

See all

I am real funny about my pizza, B&D is definitely a must. I think they are just a tad pricey, but none the less they are good. Price won't keep me away read more

Food is amazing, great quality and fresh. The service and ambiance are also great and it's a fun place to hang out and have a drink. Pies are Neapolitan-style, so don't expect them to be large (no Neapolitan pizza is). If you want a "bigger" pizza, order the NY style. We tried everything and each pizza was better than the previous. Other menu highlights are the lamb tacos and the burger bowl. The owner Jason was super accommodating and very friendly and you can tell he is extremely passionate about this place! Don't leave without grabbing some of the GF brownie bites on your way out. read more

Brick + Dough - foragers and margarita - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I am truly mad at myself for waiting so long to go here. With every bite I kept saying out loud "the dough.. the dough is so good" the dough itself was truly a 10/10 - soft and buttery? and perfectly crispy. The Buffalo chicken also had the perfect flavor. I'm excited to try the other pies. The owner was also super friendly and helpful. There are nice tables inside and out to eat or you can take it across the street to Montclair Brewery! read more

Brick + Dough - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

First time here and it was great! The hostess accommodated my husband and I to the outside area where we requested to sit. They had some music playing outside as well. To start my husband got the garlic knots and I got the focaccia, 10/10! Going back for the focaccia!! Ask for Mike when you go, he will not disappoint! Recommended some dishes to us and was super attentive and nice! read more

Visited this restaurant on July 6, 2024. The food was excellent. The garlic knots are the best, the salad was great, and the bbq chicken pizza was amazing. read more

Service was excellent! Our server was there when we needed, knew the menu and provided good advice, and had a nice attitude. The space is kind of bland and had a weird vibe like it's temporary. And the music is ridiculously loud. Our Ceasar salad was almost 50/50 lettuce/croutons (really) and had a really bland dressing. Pizzas looked perfect, spotted with lovely black spots, but were strangely raw in the middle and too wet and chewy inside. Toppings were tasty - but there was clearly a problem with the dough or oven or cook. Dessert was a panna cotta that was small and tasteless, overwhelmed by the topping of what tasted like crumbled Chips Ahoy cookies. read more

Ear to ear SMILE. Pizza is my love language and this spot did not disappoint. Service was solid and owner made his rounds. The dough tho' .... BOMB. Not one piece of crust was spared. Couldn't pick a favorite ( Taco dirty to me or Foraged Feast) the flavors were sooo different but soooo good. Layers upon layers of FLAVA. Hands down a must try whether your in the area or not, add it to your must try's. read more

See all

This place is great. I always recommend it to anyone willing to listen. The pizza is Neapolitan style so be prepared for a little char on the crust which is always nice. The ingredients are top notch. Owner is a super nice guy as well. Looking forward to dining in! read more

Brick + Dough - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Suddenly among my favorite new pizza places in New Jersey. The dough is tremendous. Definitely the best part about the entire pie. It almost overwhelms the eating experience because it's just so good and you want more and more. Don't be one of those people that doesn't eat the crust here because you'd be missing out. But everything else is good too and the flavors are lively. The RAMP time was tremendous. The margherita is strong. Can't wait to try the other pies and all the other things they sell here. read more

Brick + Dough - RAMP time - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Wowwwwww is all I have to say. And I know that I will be visiting a lot during Lent. Well worth the calories. Pizza is amazing but the sides , oh yes I'm going back hard. Service was great and attentive. I got to find out if this is BYOB or not I can't remember. Nice place for a date or family time. Really cool to see an open kitchen watching the magic happen or just scoot to the back with that really cool big ball of light! read more

Came here with a group and we tried a number of different things. All of the pizzas we had were excellent and the ingredients were high quality. You can tell they put a lot of thought into their menu and how the construct the pizzas. The ny style pie was incredible, actually among my favorite pizzas I've had anywhere. We also tried a number of their non pizza options. Again just like the pizza everything was very delicious and high quality. The lamb tacos were incredible. Staff super friendly and the restaurant was clean and has a nice seating area where you can watch pizza being made. Will definitely be back. read more

Brick + Dough - NY style pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Had a great dinner last night! I highly recommend the meatball and ricotta pie. We also enjoyed the sesame. Really unique with a great flavor. Nice service and atmosphere. read more

Really, really good pizza. Crust is perfect. I would definitely buy this sauce if jarred. Really like the vodka pie, an interesting take on vodka sauce. read more

Chill vibe, awesome food and service. Affordable prices. Nothing to complain about. The cheese bread is a must have.

Great Pizza! Very cool spot! Not normally a fan of Neapolitan but this place is off the charts.

Not one thing I have ever experienced from here has not blown me away. The pizza to start is outstanding but the sleeper is the gluten free pizza. They also have an awesome burger that's just so simple and delicious. Recently I made it my staple for breakfast with their insane Taylor Ham Egg & Cheese on a croissant or even the soft scramble eggs on ciabatta. They also just added amazing wood fired bagels! I top it all off with a Cold Brew and it's a great breakfast. read more

See all

Great experience. Ordered 3 pies: forager feast and the spinach pizza. The dough is actually the best I've ever had in my life. Sesame is a little heavy due to the cheese used, but if you stop when your body tells you to (I didn't) you will enjoy. Great staff that checks in regularly. I do wish the space was smaller or more furnished, but that won't stop me from coming here every time I'm in Montclair. Tell them to go light on creamy cheeses and you won't be able to put your pie down. Can't wait to go here again. read more

Great pizza, also good brussel sprouts appetizer. The BYOB is a plus. great vibe, very lively.

Love this place. Very creative, unique crust with the flavor of brick oven but a deliciously doughy chew you'd find in a bakery.

Ignore the negative reviews. Those people don't appear to have any appreciation / understanding of what Neapolitan pizza is, how it is prepared and the end result of that process. It's not quite on the level of places like Motorino, et al in the city, but it's damn close. It's some of the best Neapolitan pie I've had in the states. The meatballs were also fantastic; melt in your mouth level of tenderness. read more

Came last night with my family for my birthday dinner. Luckily we are just a short walk away--we have done takeout from here many times but never ate in. Very nice dining room, fantastic waiter who gave us impeccable, friendly service, and everything we ate was extremely delicious. Plus the food came out quickly and was cooked to perfection. The highlight for me was the Mary Had a Little Lamb pizza, which was very unusual and so good--homemade merguez sausage ragu, tomatillo salsa and grated ricotta salata. The dough on all the pizzas is so good--with that nice blister you get from a very hot wood burning oven. Honestly, any pizza here is outstanding--you can't go wrong. Highly recommended! read more

Went here last week and was blown away with the food service and overall vibes. I'd say it's priced reasonably and the food comes out quick! We got the plain and chicken parm pizza and they were visually appealing to the eye and to the stomach! After dinner we tried the cookie crumble cheesecake and it was the perfect desert. Nice and light and was sweet but not too sweet... just right. Perfect date spot and will definitely be going back! read more

Went to dinner here recently with some friends. It's really a 3 1/2 star place. Nice decor, friendly staff although our waiter was a typical clueless millennial. Didn't know half of what they served there, but by the end of the meal we were joking around with him. We all loved the apps: cheesy breadsticks with marinara and stracciatella, crispy brussel sprouts and poutine. The pizzas were burnt and mediocre tasting. Hence my rating, if your prime business is pizza it better be awesome, it was not and it was also overpriced. We all said not going back. Plenty of other better options in Montclair. read more