I can't get enough of their margherita pizza! Truly, a top 3 craving for me. The sauce has this irresistible tanginess and the crust has this great, satisfying texture. They man at the counter is always so nice. read more

Best Pizza and Fresh quality food served all the time. Benny is a great guy! Atmosphere is good.

The best classic pizzeria pie in Bloomfield. We order from here regularly. The cheese pie is fantastic, and the veggie pie is one of the best pies I've ever had. Owner seems very nice. read more

Best pizza and Italian food in the area! Restaurant quality, fresh ingredients, generous portions. You can tell he makes things from scratch with no shortcuts. Everything I've tried has hit the mark and then some! Plus, Benny is the best! True gem. read more

Absolutely EVERYTHING about Italia is just PERFECT!! My family moved to Bloomfield a month ago and we went to Italia, or what we now call "Benny's".. several weeks ago and immediately knew it was a staple for our family. The restaurant is simple and inviting.. everyone that walks in knows Benny and he makes you feel like you are in your own kitchen. He is extremely welcoming to the kids as well. My daughter asks daily to walk over to have Benny's pizza. Now .. the food!! The pizza is perfectly made and cooked .. the sauce is hands down the best.. it is tangy and delicious. The margarita is art!! The crust is perfect with a touch of crunch... Everyone must go try Italia. You will be amazed!! read more

Food had either too much seasoning or no seasoning at all, pizza was bland, garlic bread was overseasoned, the ambiance was calm but too monotone, and the guy was nice but it took a long time for our food to be cooked for the service read more

I was in the mood for a calzone, so there's run $8 ($1 extra for toppings) so I ordered one. It was ready in about $15. They are currently only doing pick up, and in summer it was really hot inside just waiting for the food, so power to the workers for carrying on. The calzone was HUGE. Like 2 means worth for about $10 is a hell yes. It was nice and hot, crispy crust filled with cheese and pepperoni. So the food was good at a good price. But if you are picking up, don't come too much earlier than they told you it will take as waiting inside in summer was tough. read more

Italia Pizza - Pepperoni calzone - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

I was vibing with the idea of having a buffy chicky wrap wrap so I ordered from Italia and got a pie to try as well. The wrap was good, but not what I was expecting. It's sort of a hybrid between a calzone and a traditional wrap. Still, very delicious -- likely would have benefited from more Buffalo sauce, but the side of bleu cheese of course saved the day. The pizza was good too, but nothing super groundbreaking UNTIL I had a slice of it cold the next morning. Dear Lord this is the best cold pizza I've ever had. The next time I order from here, I may immediately put the pie in the fridge. It's very cheese forward which makes the consistency a little chewier but in a good way. The guy who took my order (assuming the owner) was nice AF. Great little spot they have here. read more

See all

Great New York style thin pizza and fresh salads. My husband and I loved this place. The owner is very friendly too. We will be regulars here and very excited to indulge in the delicious food read more

I only had plain slices, fresh, crispy and delicious. My son goes here often and he says he hasn't had a bad meal. read more

Italia Pizza - Counter - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

Holy crap! We live a 10 minute walk away from this place for a year and a half and have been trying pizza places much further away trying to find great pizza and Italian food. All the food near us is good but for some reason, this place never came up on our internet searches. It finally did today, and we got insane qualities of delicious food and we are like "How the heck did we miss this place with amazing food?" Lots of places near us have great Neapolitan style pizza, Detroit style, etc. This is real NEW YORK style pizza. The foldable kind! Yeah baby! Awesome food... Highly recommended! . read more

Since moving to New Jersey about six months ago, I've been looking for a pizza parlor to compare to my favorite NY pizza parlor from my childhood (colloseo on long island). This is the closest yet. The first thing to stand out is how wonderful the gentleman behind the counter is. He has a true warmth and professional demeanor that made my family feel very welcome. I don't usually notice service but I had a great feel here. The pizza itself came out fast and had a great consistency. It was not too oily, firm crust without being too crispy, excellent craftsmanship. The cheese and sauce were solid. The meatball calzone we got was one of the best I've ever had, a true masterpiece. I'm not quite ready to put this above colloseo, but perhaps nostalgia plays a role. Either way, I will be back and I suggest you come try Italia too. read more

Italia Pizza - Menu (3/2022): wraps, cold heroes, hot heroes, chicken, side orders, coffee, desserts. - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

This place has the BEST pizza! That's the main reason to go. But the other reason I go there is because of the owner, Benny. We tried this place out, when my family moved here (1 1/2 years ago), and Benny became an instant friend to us all. He's like that with all his customers too. And, he's always there, because he literally has zero staff. Yep, this is a one man operation. He does everything on his own, and still has plenty of spare time to be super friendly. I don't know how he does it. read more

Food was excellent! Good sized servings. Had the Pasta w/ boar and Insalado. Unfortunately our waiter was a bit absentminded. But all good in the end. read more

One of the better pizza places in Bloomfield. Really friendly service. Quickly prepared and good food. Little to complain about with this place, I'd totally come back. read more

Italia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

Best customer service around.. I make sure I grab a few slices every time I'm in town.. love the margarita slice!

My husband and I were craving pizza and this place is super close to our house, so we decided to order a large cheese pie for take out. It got so many good reviews that maybe my expectations were high, but this was relatively underwhelming especially for the price. The pizza literally had nothing special about it; just cheese and dough, no special flavors or texture on the dough. Ever since this experience, we have gone to the close by Domino's pizza for our pizza cravings, and to be honest, we have enjoyed their pizza more, and for a lower price... read more

Italia pizza is hands down the best pizza in the area. Classic Jersey pie, perfect ratio of cheese to sauce, perfect crust. It's so delicious. Before coronavirus, we had numerous parties at our house where we ordered pizza from Italia. And so many of our friends and family (all Jersey born and bred) raved about how good the pizza is. They sometimes don't have a delivery person and will only have pick up. It's really worth the few minutes it takes to drive there to support a local business. Happy to keep supporting them and telling everyone I know about how good it is! read more

My family said it was good pizza. The service was good and seating was fine. I would return.

Best place in town for pizza. And not even close. Grew up in NYC and most pizza in jersey doesn't do it for me. This is the real deal pizza. Delicious. Haven't tried anything other than pizza, but just great pizza. Reminds me a bit of Joe's in the west village. read more

Excellent pizza. Best I've found since moving to Bloomfield. Haven't tried anything else yet, but damm their pizza is right on. read more

Happened across this place looking for a slice. It was so good that I went back and got a pie. This is my new favorite pizza place. read more

Italia Pizza - Medium cheese pizza with mushrooms and black olives. Soooooooooo good. - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

My favorite local place.... Like the plain pie without cheese. It's delicious. The owner could not be nicer. read more

Italia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

Tried to call them 5 times at 8 pm on a Wednesday night. No answer after trying 10 minutes later AGAIN after those 5 times. Will be taking my business to another location Had a good experience when I have gotten from here before so this was very upsetting ... read more

This is my favorite pizza spot. The crust is thin but hearty. The sauce to cheese ratio is perfect. I constantly crave this pizza and whenever I try pizza from somewhere else - no comparison. If we have left over slices they go in the oven at 400 for around 6-7 minutes and it still taste absolutely amazing. We moved out of Bloomfield but still get pizza from here. It's so good. I had fallen out of love with pizza a while ago due to so many bad slices. Italia Pizza opened my heart to pizza again. read more

The real deal. Great pizza, rich sauce, crisp crust. Large cheese pie for 15 bucks. Friendly pizza man is an added bonus when the pizza is this good! read more

Italia Pizza - Cheese pie - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

If you are looking for your classic NY-style pizza, then I highly recommend Italia Pizza. We got a cheese and a pepperoni pie, and they were both perfect. The whole family enjoyed. On top of that, the gentleman who took care of us was super friendly. This will be my go-to spot for pizza night. read more

I was just looking for pizza near me and I found this place. It's the best pizza I've tried so far in NJ! The owner is really nice and the food gets served super fast! 10/10 read more

I recently tried out this pizza place as it is close to my house. I ordered a cheese pie to go. I was intrigued by all of the good reviews. To my surprise, it did not live up to my expectations and was honestly one of the worst pies I've ever had. There is entirely too much sauce which makes the pie very soggy. It does not hold up and you can't even lift it without it breaking all apart. The sauce is also very tasteless. Hoping they improve as I love to see businesses thrive in the Bloomfield area. read more

I can't say enough good things about this place. I called and had no idea what I was ordering (I was trying to describe a picture I saw on yelp), the person helping me just so kindly laughed and was so patient with me. I went in and showed them the picture, they said it was a special order but they'll gladly make it if I'm willing to wait. So I waited! And man.. was it worth it! See for yourself :P. Finally found a favorite pizza spot in Bloomfield! read more

Italia Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

All five star ratings are NOT created equal. Meaning, after dozens of visits over the past three years, I've held off on reviewing this place to avoid misleading the Yelp faithful. But after much soul-searching and deliberation, here's my verdict: if you want great pizza, this is the best pie (or slice) in town, period. Sure, the ambience is super casual. Soccer (erp... "futbol" so as not to offend my fellow Euro-leaguers!) plays on a large screen in the back. Tables and chairs are nondescript... It doesn't scream "fancy" when you walk in, and that's okay; Benny and his staff aren't here to wow you with decor. But he is a pizza wizard, and it consistently shows. Crust is always crispy with a nice chew. Not too thick, not too thin. Sauce is simple and tasty, and for me, it always has just the right amount of toppings. Faves being the good ole' cheese pie, buffalo chicken, and extra bready Sicilian squares. Other dishes on the menu are filling and fine enough (his pastas and sammies in particular), but you'd be remiss to deprive yourself of his delicious pizza. Yes; their hours can be wonky. Yes; there are more "prestigious" pie parlors... but if you are looking for a hot, fresh, five-star pie, I don't think you'll regret a trip to Italia. If the cold is keeping you away, I recommend visiting in the early summer to grab a slice and Coke (sorry Pepsi-holics), and nabbing a table outside during Bloomfield's Car Show nights. Prices can't be beat, it's a good spot for the family, and who doesn't like a little bit of people-watching?? read more

Perfectly made pizza, the crust was crispy but still fluffy! Nice to have a great pizza place close by! read more

Italia Pizza - Look at this amazing piece of work!!! - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

I had my favorite Chicken Parmesan sandwich. I've had sandwiches were you look at the meat and you see processed meat with what looks like fillers rounding off the patty or strip. Real chicken breast is used at this place. The paddies were fried just right. The sauce was rich, and thick with ingredients as you see in the picture. I'm posting a picture showing the richness of the sauce. The bread was lightly toasted on the outside. If you're wondering where's the Parmesan cheese, I had the cook put it on the bread before he placed the patties and sauce on it. I'll be visiting them again whenever I get a thirst for a Chicken Parmesan sandwich. read more

Italia Pizza - Chicken Parmesan sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

Not bad, not bad at all. Not the "traditional" round some might be looking for, but for artisanal pizza - this place is solid imo read more

Great pizza and great service! They let me know they were taking longer with deliveries, and even the delivery guy apologized too Back to the pizza, so yummy, Classic NYC PIZZA, so good! Def check it out! read more

I was searching for a good pizza place before going to work, saw they have 4.5 stars. This pizza didn't have any type of taste on it! Very bitter. Never AGAIN!!!! read more

Great customer service. I had a taste for spaghetti so I Yelp for places in the area. This one had four and a half stars so I had to try it. The navigation had me a little confused but a local police officer assured me that I was in the right place...he said go in and there's Eddy. Eddy help me with my order...Penne grilled chicken with vegetables. My oh my it was delicious. Oh, and please try a slice of pizza...the best in NJ. read more

Italia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

Hosted a small birthday party here and the service was excellent. Pizza was amazing. Benny was super nice and accommodating. Highly recommend read more

This is our favorite place to order and pick up a large cheese pie! The crust is thin and crispy in the center yet soft and fluffy on the edge. Beats all the other pizza places we've tried in the area. We always go back to Italia Pizza! read more

I will stand by my opinion that this is by far the best pizza in Bloomfield. I keep coming back and it is consistently incredible! The owner also will ask how well done you want it to make sure it's baked to your liking! Seriously. Everything about this pizza is incredible. You won't regret going here. (This coming from a pizza chef and pizza aficionado) read more