Tried it for the first time with 2 chicken bacon ranch slices. I will be back it was good. read more

BATHROOM IS ATROCIOUS!! If the Conditionally Satisfactory sign inside the restaurant is not enough to gross you out, check out the bathroom. Dirtier than the bathroom in the subway. Floors reeked of urine. The toilet seat is loaded with hair and urine. No paper towels. That was enough for me. I walked out. read more

I love their pizza! Great local pizzeria a with all the fixings. Salad (antipasto)done well.

Saw this place while stopped at a light in Montclair. Got a slice of pizza and another with mushrooms to just try out. The slices didn't make out of the parking spot. Ate them up!! So good! The thin crust was crunchy. Nothing was runny. Just enough of everything. So, before we left town to return to MD, we got 3 large boxes!! Grandma's, pepperoni, and supreme. Perfect dinner as we watch the Super Bowl tonight!! read more

See all

Pizza was good. I really enjoyed the crust. Price was okay. But we tried to call on a Friday... we were on hold for a loooong time. So we just walked in and ordered. Lots quicker! It's not a welcoming place, there are plastic partitions leftover from Covid. read more

This place sucks. The place is filthy and the food is way over priced and horrible. I would not give the food to a starving dog on the street . read more

Ordered a half plain, half mushroom pizza. I have never had such a bland pizza in my life and the mushrooms were scant, it was hard to tell which half had them and which didn't. Absolutely no seasoning to the sauce and the cheese wasn't good. We won't be ordering from there again. read more

I ordered a pizza, wings and mozzarella sticks. Delivery was fast and efficient and the food delicious. The pizza was a standout and the best I have had in Montclair. I highly recommend this restaurant. You will not be disappointed. read more

I was born and raised in Montclair 73 yrs. ago, lived on Forest St. I have been coming to this restaurant for years, even before Chris brought it from the original owner that had it (he and his brother worked there back then). To say the food is good is an understatement, it's fabulous. It's hard to find an Italian Pizzeria that knows sauce and how to make it, most places just dump tomatoe sauce in an pan without seasonings, not this place, all their products are fresh and are homemade. The raviolis, baked ziti and the other dishes are mountain sized and good, I should know as I worked in at least 5 pizza establishments in all my years. For the record I go there once a month and travel close to 75 miles to get there from there Pa. area. Best place around. Captain Jack read more

I try not to review places I've never actually walked into, but I feel compelled to let the world know just how good Panzano's is. This review pertains only to the delivery service, the meat lovers pizza, and the garlic knots. Again, I've never stepped foot in the door so I can't speak for the ambience, seating, parking situation, etc. etc. I called in my first order here last week (meat lovers and garlic knots), was told the wait would be 30 minutes, and truth be told, the delivery guy was at my doorstep exactly 30 minutes after they told me 30 minutes. Impressive. I learned from him that Panzano's had been open for about a year. I'm only sad I didn't know about them sooner. The meatlovers was loaded with meat (see my picture below) and the garlic knots were delicious. Nice marinara as well. $27 for everything, 20% tip included. When I called back here less than one week later for another delivery, I ordered the same thing. This time around, they told me they were out of garlic knots, but said they'd make some fresh for me. Again, I was impressed. Unlike other places, they could have just told me they were out and that I was shit out of luck. Not these guys. I'm just so happy that I FINALLY found a good pizza joint that delivers in my area. I moved to New Jersey 5 years ago and I'm happy to announce that my quest has finally come to an end. This is officially my new go-to delivery. Join the bandwagon. read more

See all

We stopped in to grab a couple of slices. The pizzeria did seem clean and service was good but the pizza and garlic knots were probably the worst in town. Very very dry pizza, little flavor, no sauce, and the type of pizza that destroys the roof of your mouth. The garlic knots were very stale - will not be ordering from here ever again. read more

This place is five stars all around. Great service, easy to go ordering, amazing white pizza, delicious plain pie pizza, best side salads too, and also fantastic garlic knots! CANNOT GO WRONG. Five stars read more

Panzano Pizzeria - White pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I'm not a fan of one-star reviews. I believe they should be reserved for businesses that are over the top awful. Panzano Pizzeria gets the one-star. I stopped in for a few slices to-go and the pizza was so bad that I feel disrespected. Seriously, it was stupid expensive to the point of feeling overcharged (prices aren't posted anywhere so who knows?) Plus the slices fell apart and seemed old, like days old. Just feel like I got screwed intentionally. That's not how someone should feel after buying a few slices. I spit on them and threw them out. read more

I really wanted to love this . But I have mixed feelings. I ordered at 5:30 and the food did not come until almost 7:30. They are less than a mile from my house. The veal parm dinner was good - Not tough at all and the sauce was really tasty..... but they delivered with the wrong pasta. I specifically asked for linguine and it arrived with penne... which I dislike. The personal size pizza was not what I was expecting. The crust was almost non existent and hard as a rock , with almost no color to it. Looked at the bottom and it also had absolutely no color on it. It was a bit unappetizing like supermarket frozen pizza and was also cold. I had to reheat everything. Like I said, the veal parm was really good, but I'm going to look for a different place for a pizza . read more

It's unfortunate that I'm writing this because I usually don't have a problem with this establishment. Yesterday, I placed an order for pickup. I ordered an entree and a sandwich. The chicken in the entree was burnt to a crisp and they seemed to try and cover it up with cheese and sauce, as if I wouldn't be able to taste it. As for the sandwich, it was supposed to be a chicken cutlet with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo but they sent me a chicken parmigiana sandwich instead. Again, I normally don't have a problem with this spot but yesterday's order was pretty disappointing. :( read more

Panzano Pizzeria - a slice of pizza on a piece of tin foil - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

This review is for their cheese pie. Truly good Jersey slice of pizza. Nothing fancy, just very good. And honestly it's hard to do a very good slice of pizza. New go to spot for casual Friday pizza needs. read more

A few years ago we used to love this place. Then one day the quality of pizza went downhill tremendously, and consistently. I didn't have time to update my review because...life. Fast forward to today, I ordered a plain and pepperoni pie because they had online orders and delivery and I needed something fast. And the quality was the same sub par quality I remember from a few years ago, which frankly saddens me as I have very fond memories of excellent pizza from here that our friends and family who visited us used to confirm as well. Two stars for having online ordering and super fast delivery. read more

Ordered for pick up when we were across the street at a Little League game. I've driven by Panzano and their perpetually broken window for two years and wondered if the pies were any good. With two hungry kids, my wife, my mother-in-law, and my father-in-law all hankering for lunch, a large half-plain half-onion pizza seemed like a perfect opportunity to halt the hangries and try this unknown potential gem in one stone. Pizza took too long (25 mins) and staff were pretty brusque when aforementioned mother-in-law and I went to fetch it (and several waters, Diet Cokes, and a Diet Dr. Pepper!). But a gem this place is. A perfect pie. Great New York style crust. Wonderful sauce with a perfect ratio of cheese and onion (tender but not mushy). Highly recommended. Too bad they don't deliver to my address! And did I mentioned Diet Dr. Pepper? read more

Best cauliflower crust pizza! It comes in a personal size (10 in) and is thin and crispy. Totally meets a craving if you are gluten free or on a low-carb diet. I got it plain but you can also get toppings. read more

Basic slice joint..., nothing more. Wish they were using better quality cheese. Slices are typically dry.

It's mediocre pizza. Ordered half veggie half chicken pesto. The veggie side was soggy and bland. The pesto side didn't look anything like the photos on yelp. Chicken was dry, could barely taste any pesto sauce. I can't tell you it's bad pizza, but definitely not good. This place falls in the category of good enough if you're hungry and need to quickly pick up a pizza. read more

Panzano Pizzeria - soggy bland veggie / burnt chicken pesto - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I drive out of my way to pick up pizza from here. It's crunchy, the sauce is amazing, and it's just delicious. I wish they made their pies a little bigger. read more

We got a deep dish plain pie and garlic bread. The deep dish pizza was pretty good, average on the flavor and definitely needed pepper flakes! The garlic bread was good, but would not recommend it seemed like a sandwich roll made into garlic bread. Delivery time was speedy though! read more

Panzano Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

First thing I did when I moved to this area 3 years ago, is check out the lay of the land --- and part of that surveying of the neighborhood, was making sure there was a good local pizza joint that's walking distance; I wanted that feeling of when I was a kid growing up in NYC, and had a great pizza place that was a hop n a skip away. Panzano's is that place and then some! They are keeping the neighborhood pizza joint aura and history, alive and well. Prices are fair, pizzas are always fresh, the other goodies like their heroes or hot sandwiches and salads are tah-die-for!!! Most important, is that the staff are great. The owner / head pizza maker I presume , is friendly and always seems happy and ready to chat it up with his customers. Need it to go? NO PROBLEM; need to sit down and eat? NO PROBLEM! This is a great local pizza joint, you just can't beat a classic slice --- sure all those new artisan pizzas that cost an arm and a leg are great too, once in a blue moon; but, if you want a great New York style slice, no frills no fuss, and want a place you can come back to with consistency --- then this is the place for you! read more

Friendly service, good food, the delivery took a bit longer then promised, but hey it was a Thursday night and they seemed busy. Personal pizza was pretty big, could easily feed 4 people. I saved it for later. Chicken Parmesan was excellent. I got it with a side of Penne which was also very good. It was so much food I saved the rest for lunch the next day. Lastly the baked ziti was very flavorfull and not too salty. I will definately order and stop by to eat here in person next time. read more

Panzano Pizzeria - Pasta Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I've only ordered from Panzano Pizzeria for delivery and I can say that the food/service is good! There are two factors that I take into account for a good pizza place: 1. good pizza 2. fast delivery Panzano's offers both. I've also ordered chicken parm and the grilled chicken fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, baby arugula sandwich. Although I can't attest for the chicken parm but my boyfriend said it was good. As for the grilled chicken fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, baby arugula sandwich - it's good. It literally has everything in the name on an Italian roll with some sort of vinaigrette dressing. Conclusion: I would lie if I said that this is the best pizza I've ever tasted, but it's still pretty good! read more

Panzano Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

I'm in disbelief at the pizza we received tonight. Not only was there no dough underneath the cheese, we couldn't even get it off the paper and completely ripped apart. When calling to speak with manager they were very defensive and told us that's why they sent a slice to go with it to make up for the side of the pie that didn't come out right. Why not just call us and explain the situation rather than sending us a pie that was inedible?! We will not be ordering from you again. Please just refund our money. read more

Panzano Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Place looks dirty and definitely not the place for an authentic chicken cutlet, got chicken strips with a mountain of lettuce and onion Sandwhich looked terrible and tasted worse read more

Disappointed first time came here had chicken pizza. Sauce was not tasty and pizza had no salt. Girl that work at the counter was not very welcoming I wanted a cup of coffee but was too lazy to make a fresh cup she said the coffee they had was sitting in the pot since the morning and said she could not serve me a cup of coffee. It's unheard of other pizzerias never had a problem to make a fresh cup of coffee. read more

Awesome pizza and calzone. Some of the best I've tasted in the New York New Jersey area. The owners are very appreciative of your business and they deserve success. I ordered here last weekend, and the linguine and white clam sauce, eggplant etc. pizza and calzone were incredible. Delivery was on time on Saturday and it was obviously very busy. Also not expensive at all with all the food they delivered. I'm going to order here again this weekend coming up. read more

Grandpa pie, arancini, meatballs, pineapple and prosciutto thin pie... it's all SO good.

Quintessential NJ neighborhood pizza place. Just solid all around, I don't think I've ever been disappointed. There's better pizza spots in town (especially if you're willing to pay $20 for a fancy brick oven pie), but they're not a three minute walk from my house so screw 'em! read more

Hands down, theeee best wings in the neighborhood. I won't buy wings anywhere else. The staff is on point. The pizza is also really good. Glad to see they made it through COVID. read more

I come here every couple of months, I grew up here and everytime I'm back here every couple of months the food is just the way I like it and the sauce for dinner is made the old. The pizza is the best and the guys do it right. I live over 70 miles away and make the trip cause up in PA they don't know how to do anything italian. read more

I had a really nice meal first time trying food was ok disappointed with chicken parm was like a shoe sole and overcooked not happy after all the money spend !! read more

The pizza and chicken were absolutely delicious. I highly recommend their food. I requested crushed garlic and basil on the pizza. They were very generous with both toppings. Do yourself a favor, patronize this business. read more

OK in a pinch but I think it's gone downhill over the years. The untopped portion of crust is getting bigger and bigger (approaching 3 inches). The pepperoni pie we ordered last night had about 1 1/2 slices of pepperoni on each slice. $34 (1 plain pie, 1 pepperoni pie, + tax and 15% tip) later...and I'm thinking there's many better choices in the area for pizza. For the LOL: One time the delivery driver didn't have a pen and asked me to sign the receipt while leaving me holding 3 pies in my building's doorway. He went back to the restaurant to get a pen! read more

Just ordered a cheesesteak and garlic knots on Uber eats with a dr.pepper! The cheesesteak is so big and good for the price! And the garlic knots were perfect and served with great Mariana sauce. Very pleased with the portions and will definitely try coming to this restaurant in person! read more

We ordered pizza here several times already. Provided specific instructions every time, requesting paper plates & napkins. They never send any plates & napkins. Despite asking since we are at a public pool. Pizza is not great enough to continue ordering from here. Specially this place can't even follow simple instructions. There's other pizzeria that can provide same or better quality pizza and decent customer service. read more

We waited two hours for the worst pizza in town. I mean it was garbage. All the sauce and toppings on one pie had slid off in transit and were just in a soggy pile in the corner of the box. The remaining pie made me wish it had been ruined too. A nearly cheeseless cheese pizza with a gummy crust that remained flavorless even though they conned me into paying fifty cents to salt it. Don't eat here. You're better off with the hot lamp pie at 7/11. read more