Stopped by Sun 12/7 afternoon, first time there. I heard they had a great chicken caesar wrap & the guy working there recommended the special one with dill pickles & special sauce in it. Very happy I followed his recommendation. This was a really interesting, great sandwich. This is now my favorite chick caesar wrap. Also, it was huge, I only ate half & looking forward to the other half for tonights dinner. Got my son a chick parm with vodka sauce & he was very happy as well. They had many interesting, inventive choices, lots to try. Nice staff & great food. I will definitely be back & highly recommend. read more

My friend picked up this sandwich for me while I got my hair done and WOW did it hit the spot! From the sauce to the crispy hash brown and bacon to the soft bun - it really was delicious. Messy but worth it. read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Amazing little sandwich shop! Very artisanal and delish! Loved it and everything was so good read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Such a solid concept and spot. I ordered to go and was pretty impressed since there are sandwich shops nearby that are also amazing (ie. millburn deli) but I will say Dutch's was solid. They have a lot of awesome different sandwich options and although I found them a little pricey, they were a generous portion so if absolutely go back! The shop is cute but on the smaller side - it's a to-go kinda spot. Would recommend! (Also congrats on opening in Hoboken, I just moved from there and I have a feeling it will do so well!!) read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Tuna Crunch (Wrap) - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

I ordered the Pho Sure sandwich on a multi-grain bread but it came with carrots which I didn't want and substituted them with roasted peppers. I think this is how the sandwich should be made IMO. Carrots have no business being on this sandwich. The roast beef was cut thin and had so much flavor. The other ingredients were avocado, arugula and tomato which added the right amount of juiciness and the bachans and sriracha sauces pulled it altogether. It was supposed to come with pickles on the side but they ran out. That's what was missing for me but it was still an awesome sandwich. read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Pho sure - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

TLDR: food I ordered could definitely use improvement. Service- 5 stars. Food- 2 stars. Came here with a large group after seeing the sign that it is the "best" sandwiches in NJ. Seeing that sign, I had to come in a try it. The service was great and I had some great conversations with the workers. However, the food didn't meet my expectations. The bacon ranch cheese fries didn't have much cheese or ranch. After eating the few fries that were covered, everything else was just plain fries. Cheesesteak on ciabatta (recommended by a worker there) just didn't work. The ciabatta couldn't hold the sandwich together and everything fell apart. Additionally, the meat used had some sort of sweetness to it. Not sure if intentional or if that's just their seasoning but it threw me off a lot. Unfortunately I left this place craving more. I will definitely give this place another try as it is possible that I didn't order the right things. read more

See all

Sometimes a place is just so dang good the review can be short sweet and to the point and that's just what Dutch's earned ... BOMB SERVICE, BOMB FOOD & BOMB AMBIANCE! Jim and Ashley helped me select a custom made sandwich since I was torn between 3 sandwiches and it was MONEY!!!! Ashley whipped that bad boy up in the kitchen and I can tell it was made with love! I am coming back weekly to try a new sandwich because the menu is soooo fire and the service is second to none! OH and the music and decor ... A SLAM DUNK for the culture! I love this place! PS - I couldn't wait to get home to eat so I enjoyed 1/2 my sandwich in the car. read more

See all

This place may have the absolute best breakfast sandwiches. I stop in here whenever I can. My go to is the Hash Daddy and add bacon or sausage to it. It's ridiculous in the best way! read more

Another great sandwich joint. It's too bad these places don't stay open 24/7. Parking is around the corner.

Still the best! Always an amazing food experience and service is top tier. Amir the owner is so kind and friendly, always adding small details to his customers visits. The food has not disappointed yet! read more

See all

So many great sandwich options! Dutch daddy was my favorite on the soft brioche bun. I'll definitely have to get back to try some more sandwiches. read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Dutch Daddy - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I really love this tiny sandwich shop on Church Street in Montclair. The guy at the counter taking orders (the owner?) is very friendly. Every time that I have been here, it is busy. That is always a good sign. The menu has a long list of fun and creative sandwiches. They also have a great breakfast menu. I have ordered from both menus, and everything that I've tried has been delicious. They even make some excellent cookies for a little post sandwich treat. The prices are very reasonable, so it won't break the bank. Highly recommend. read more

Highly recommend Dutch's overall for banging sandwiches but most importantly their chicken caesar wraps!!! I randomly overheard of this new one that isn't on the menu yet that has pickles and it's so good. read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Chicken caesar wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

We were so wowed by Dutch's Sandwich Shop. Everything we ate was sheer perfection. Delicious to the last bite, and great vibes too! We LOVED the Dutch Daddy so much, my wife is dreaming about it. And the Tay Tay rivals all THEC sandwiches! ALSO, the place is named after the owner's beloved dog, Dutch, so if you are a dog lover, alllllll the more reason to go. read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch after looking at the great reviews we saw. To start off, all the staff was great and super nice. They also had a gluten free bread option which is always nice. I got the driver and my fiance got the Freddie mercury on gluten free bed. I asked for chipotle aoili on mine but it was kind of drowning in it and took away from everything else. The mozzarella was good but the chicken cutlet was just your average cutlet. The gluten free bread they use was fantastic but it does cost an extra $3. As someone who always has to order the gluten free option it gets annoying having to always pay an extra fee and $3 is alot. The freddie mercury sandwich itself was very good and the fig jam was a great touch. The fries were okay but could have used more bacon for being bacon cheese fries. Overall, after looking at the reviews my expectations were high and I was left a little disappointed. I look forward to coming here again and trying g their breakfast as I see that is what people really rave about. I still hope people go give it a try because the owner and people who work there are great. read more

See all

The food is delicious and the selection is abundant. The service was a bit disheveled but friendly and polite. As for ambiance, it's a hole-in-the-wall sandwich shop. On a beautiful day such as today, it's perfect to dine at one of their tables on the sidewalk. There is zero seating inside, so if it's not a beautiful day, it's a take out establishment. They 100% need improvements in their website. Check it out yourself. The Dutch Daddy is described as, "Best breakfast sandwich in NJ..." What's in it??? You'll have to go to find out! Some of the items are obvious, but some just need a more robust description, or any description at all... Plenty of drink options. I felt bad bringing a coffee over from Starbucks, as coffee is not amongst the drinks listed on their website. Only when I saw the sandwich board out front did I realize I could have grabbed a coffee there. I simply can't believe that they're able to offer so much as far as sandwich selection, desserts, sides, drinks you name it. They struggled mightily with their POS system. I ordered a BLT with avocado. A few issues here. The price in their system did not match the price on the menu that they have on display. They struggled to add avocado to my sandwich in their system, but did in fact deliver my requested avocado on my sandwich. What kind of bread did I get? White toast. What kind of bread was I offered? There was no offering either behind the register or on the menu. Do they have rye? Gluten free? Wheat? I still don't know other than that my sandwich arrived on white toast. I'd have loved it on rye, but I don't know if that's an offering and it simply wasn't a big deal as the actual sandwich was just fine by me. My son devoured his Dutch Daddy. I know that it had pastrami and cheese, and that it was served on a roll. Pretty sure it also had eggs and bacon, but it is not on the online menu for me to look it up. Shared a side of fries that came out hot, crisp and delicious. We waited outside at a table and they brought us our food. Really couldn't have been any nicer, and the food was on point. A little pricey, but not outrageous. I'm sure I'll be back sooner rather than later. Parking on Church St has always been tough. Street parking in general is straight-up luck, but there is a nearby garage that usually has space. read more

Yep, this place is legit! Stopped by with a huge order first thing in the morning. Took a bit of time because it was all prepared fresh, but the little wait was so worth it. I heard nothing but praise all around when I got to work and people dug in. We had a collection of about 8 different sandwiches ordered so there was a variety of praise that went around on a bunch of different menu items. I got the Dutch Daddy, which was a great call! The Pastrami was excellent, who doesn't love some bacon slid in there, the Muenster cheese was a unique (and excellent) addition and Dutch's Signature Sauce...sign me up for more! This was so good, how do I move on to something else next time? The brioche roll was outstanding!!! Even the person who self-admittedly got the "boring" egg & cheese sandwich said the bun was fantastic and made the sandwich excellent. Yeah, I'll be back! read more

See all

I wish I lived closer to Dutch's. Best sandwich shop I've ever been to. Owner is handsome AF. Not just the sandwiches are outrageous... Wraps, salads, treats... This place has it all. Best thing by far is The Stad for breakfast. A true masterpiece. Open a shop in NY plz. Thanks! read more

I have ordered from here twice now and I dont see myself slowing down. These breakfast sandwich's hit like a slow rnb song, you just want to take your time with it. I had the Dutch daddy and my gf had the hash daddy, let me tell you I ain't never chew that slow trying to savor something. I added their truff hot sauce to mine and that was a game changer. It's a must try spot and I appreciate the customer service and ambiance of their shop. read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Dutch Daddy - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

This is my new favorite sandwich shop. Everything I had was absolutely delicious. The sandwiches and wraps are 100 percent professional. Breakfast sandwiches are the best I've ever had and chicken cutlet was a 10 in my book. Here's what I tried : The Dutch Daddy** Hot pastrami, bacon, two eggs, muenster cheese, Dutch's signature sauce, on a brioche roll What's The Dill? Chicken cutlet, bacon, melted provolone, lettuce, pickles, dill aioli, on a hero (spicy dill kettle chips were also added) The Fairway Grilled chicken, jalapeños, red onions, lettuce, tomato, honey garlic sauce Honey Honey Honey roasted turkey, honey ham, white American, lettuce, tomato, red onion, honey mustard, drizzle of hot honey, on a hero The Chicken or The Egg What Came First? Chicken cutlet, egg salad, pickles, lettuce, tomato My absolute favorite was "What's the dill?" With fresh crispy chicken cutlet and dill aioli and second was the Dutch daddy breakfast sandwich piled high with juicy hot Pastrami. It was a tight place and only had 1 small high top table inside and 2 window seats. Seems most orders are to go. There's also seating outside (obviously weather permitting) it had a cool retro theme inside and he showcases art from local artists which is awesome. Plenty of chip and drink options. Super friendly fast service. I cant wait to go back and try other sandwiches. read more

See all

I grabbed call ahead takeout during a weekday. The place is small with just a few video games to play. Nice touch. A ton of different sandwich options. To choose from. I ordered the Popeye and Olive sandwich for $15 but over $17 after everything. The sandwich was delicious with fresh ingredients and a good combo of flavors compliments to the olive tapenade. It was quite filling too! My only negative was the price. Otherwise, a great spot! read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Popeye & Olive - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Went to the Hoboken site today and ended up with food poisoning. Hopefully they can get themselves situated

Got the Angry Bird with curly fries and honey mustard and the guava cronut. The chicken cutlet on the Angry Bird was perfectly cooked and spicy, and the caesar salad on the bread was amazing. The bread itself was delicious and a lil tough, which honestly worked with the salad and the chicken so well. The fries were amazing and the honey mustard was perfectly sweet and probably the best I've had in years. The cronut was amazing and absolutely filled w guava, and the cream cheese frosting worked well with the cronut. Would try again read more

Wow. The sandwiches here are !! Just tried their food for the first time and couldn't recommend it more!!! We got the caprese panini and the the driver!!! The owner threw in a Reese's brownie that was also to die for. Needless to say we will most certainly be back. read more

Actually found out this place through social media. The Pastrami was good. I had the chicken cutlet sandwich. That sandwich was dry needed more sauce. I would probably recommend putting extra sauce on the side for those who like extra sauce. Overall it was okay. I can't say I would go out of my way to go there. read more

Dutch Sandwich shop has entered the Montclair food ring and is definitely going to be king/queen/they of sandwiches in town. I started off with a Becky with turkey bacon and returned the next day for four more different varieties of sandwiches. The ingredients are fresh, soft and buttery brioche buns that made my mouth water. The sandwich meat is good Boar's Head brand quality with delicious flavor. The menu selection is curated to perfection and enough variation that there is something for everyone in the family. If you like a unique sandwich, not just your typical cold mom quoted "we have food at home" turkey and processed cheese slapped between white bread, this will be your jam. The staff and owner is super nice, reasonable prices, the establishment is clean with vibrant artwork to compliment the uniqueness of the menu. The only thing this place needs is a cool playlist to complete the vibe. Hope you enjoy! read more

See all

I'm officially hooked on the Dutch sandwich from this place. It's a must try and totally worth the price ($12). The only challenging thing about this place is parking. Street parking is very limited and it's located on a one way street so you might be driving around for a bit. The vibe in the place is super cool and the service is top notch. Seems like mostly a to-go type of place. It's pretty small and only has 1 high table and a sitting counter. read more

See all

This was my second time ordering from here. I got the Dutch Casa Crush which was a cronut with sausage egg and cheese and my fiancé and I shared the bacon ranch cheese fries. The sandwich was amazing. It was flavorful and delicious. Even when my fiancé opened it to see whose food was whose he was like this smells delicious. I couldn't even bring myself to let him try a bite. The fries were perfect as well. My fiancé always gets the chicken Caesar cheesesteak and loves it. I'm still upset with him for trying this place without me first. read more

See all

Best breakfast sandwich ever! I tried the Dutch Daddy and it did not disappoint! The service was quick and the ambiance was very cozy. It gave a "get in and out" vibe. No offense taken as I'm a native New Yorker! read more

We ordered the Barkley. It states on the menu grilled steak but what we got was chopped up meat. Could have maybe lived with that but the sandwich itself was just not that tasty and seemed low quality. It didn't help that they forgot to put the caramelized onions in the sandwich. Staff was very nice and did their best to help us as it was our first time. We will not be going there again. Also the inside of the restaurant is ok, small with two tables inside but was sweltering. read more

Downtown Montclair was in desperate need of a sandwich spot. The flavors are so so good, the service is A+ and on a nice day you can sit outside and enjoy a filling sandwich that doesn't disappoint. They have a sandwich for each meal of the day, so definitely give it a try! read more

See all

Cute sandwich shop. Very friendly cool staff. I ordered the driver with chicken cutlet as recommended. First off, I love the soft bread. Not a huge fan of hard subs. But I do think there was too much thick cutlets and not enough mozzarella. But I'm excited to try other sandwiches next time! read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - The Driver - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

I've actually just left Dutch's but I am so disappointed with my order that I had to right an immediate review. My partner and I ordered two young Turks. Basically a turkey and cheese sandwich. For $14 I expected to receive a good sandwich. The bread was hard and not fresh, barely any mayo and way too much vinegar. The meat also didn't taste like it was good quality turkey, I had such high hopes for this shop but unfortunately I will not be returning. Honestly, my local deli would've done a better job. read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - a roll of paper with a drawing on it - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Decided to deviate from my Sunday norm local sandwich spot and give this place a try. It's nested in a cute little spot on Montclairs famous Church street. I walked in and found the worker very unpleasant which is not what we are use to in Montclair. Especially after paying $31 dollars for two sandwiches. I ordered the fairway sandwich and the Pastrami Umami Sandwich. So let's start with the good; very cute location and decorations complete with arcade game. I requested the fairway on a roll rather then a wrap and the accommodated. The bad...The $15 sandwich was very light in regards to the amount of protein added. The Pastrami was also very light and not tasty at all. I doubt if I will patronize this business again due to the price and customer service. read more

See all

I really wanted to love these sandwiches but the few times I've been there, theres always something wrong. I had an egg, turkey bacon, cheese sandwhich on a brioche bread, it was VERY salty. Like the person cooking my eggs had no idea how much salt to add to an egg, which is a bummer because i could tell if the salt wasn't there, the sandwich would've been good. Chicken cheesesteak simply wasn't good. Need a whole new concept IMO. The Turkey sandwich (cant remember which exact one) was good but nothing special. Could get same thing at a regular NY deli. I cant see myself spending this much on a sandwich that isn't mind blowing. read more

Great sandwich selection and variety. The best roast beef sandwich I've ever had! Wonderful breakfast sandwiches too.

Sooooo good! The roll made it outstanding. Soft buttery flavorful!! Definitely will be going back again! read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Becky #7 - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I love the sandwiches here! Generous portions and packed with flavor. I usually order the dutch daddy or getting figgy with it.

Interesting, creative sandwiches. Even the ones that sound familiar will taste different due to the sauces and the microgreens. This is so not the regular sandwich place. We have had two casual parties (25-35 people each) handled by Amir and his staff and beyond being one of the nicest and most caring people you will encounter in this line of work, everything is well-plated, delivered as ordered (and 10 minutes before the agreed upon time). Beyond the great sandwiches, his green salad and dressing was also a hit! read more

Very impressed but the staff, the shop itself, the food and the overall experience. Plenty of options of snacks, drinks, menu items and they even had cold brew coffee on tap. Our sandwiches were very filling which is exactly what we needed. They have a public restroom for customers and outside of it had the cutest sign "Today is a Good Day". The bathroom felt like I walked into someone's very well kept and personalized home bathroom. I can't say I've ever seen a more clean and welcoming bathroom at a sandwich shop before. We will be back read more

Dutch's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all