If I wanted oily and limp pizza, I could have ate at pizza chain. Very disappointed with this place.

Have been a customer for over 25 years. Great pizza. Always order when in/around the area. Plain cheese pizza is favorite go to.

They say you can never find a pizza as good as in NY. Well they are wrong the pizza here is just as good. I love the staff real Italians who are loud and blunt. read more

Great little pizzeria in Belleville, New Jersey! The staff is friendly and funny! I'm not sure if you have ever had icebox cake, but it's yummy! Sicilian pie is yummy as well as the regular pies! read more

Our favorite local pizzeria. Pizza always delicious. Their family deals are a great bargain.

I have been coming here for years .Always liked food .Ordered potato and egg hero . Got greasy french fries all stuck together and a little bit of scrambled eggs. For an italian rest. they should know how to cook potatos and eggs . I normally would not call but it was really bothering me. Owner was too busy to talk to me so server apologized and offered a refund. Decided not to take her up on the offer. Went in the trash and $13.00 out the window. read more

Algieri's Pizza Restaurant - Potato and eggs ? What - Pizza Near Me - Belleville, New Jersey

Algieri's has great food we are never disappointed. They give great service and are super friendly. They are a staple to our town here in Belleville. Not to mention how generous they are to our student community they are always ready to help our kids fundraise and donate to our kid's events. Thank you Algieri's family for all that you do and stand for. read more

I got a Pineapple, Ham, and grilled chicken pie. I have a black cat named Chancellor Palpatine. I joined a fraternity at 27 years old. I am starting to question who I am in today's society... and what if I don't fit in... I just want to be in a society where people don't think I'm a psycho for ordering this pizza. anyway the pizza was perfect. read more

Algieri's Pizza Restaurant - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Belleville, New Jersey

I want to give the staff of Algieri's a 5 star review for the excellent job they did with my mother's repast. The food was delicious and the waitress was on point. I am looking forward to going back for some some yummy eats. read more

Theee besssst chicken marsala over penne!!! Get it as a meal, or a sandwich, and Thank me later!! read more

See all

Came here with my friend because he said he knew a good spot. Damn was he right! Pizza was absolutely unreal and the chicken Marsala was banging.. Owner and cook came out and greeted us. Truly felt welcomed and hope the best for them! Such a good vibe. read more

I live in Belleville with plenty of pizza places around but for some reason I never tried this place. I am so sorry I never tried it before because it is the best around by far. I got the double dough and so good. I can't wait to try again. It was fresh and hot and can tell they made from scratch If you need a pizza it sd the place to go. read more

Wonderful experience from service to food! The girls taking orders are friendly and get it right! The Saturday delivery guy found my apartment easily (which rarely happens) and came to the door and helped me put the very hot food down. The pizza box got a little crushed from the things on top and he made sure the pizza was still ok. Total class act! I like "different" pizza. And I saw someone on Yelp talked about their Taco Pizza. It's not on the menu but they make one; and it's fantastic! Tonight I tried their Italian Veggie Pizza, and they were very generous with toppings! It was delish, covered with cheese, broccoli Rabe, Eggplant, roasted peppers, artichoke hearts and olives on a thin crust that still stood up to the toppings. I had a taste of their pasta with white clam sauce and it was so smartly packaged in a second larger tin, to keep it from leaking. It was still hot and had lots of crushed clams, and the pasta was perfectly al dente. The fried calamari was tasty and not over chewy, the only thing lacking was a lemon wedge. The medium marinara dipping sauce was absolutely yummy on them. Oh and they are open late!!! Til Midnite Friday and Saturday. Their website for ordering doesn't work so just call them. They deliver locally directly and for out of area you can use doordash. read more

See all

I read the reviews, saw the news articles and had to dine here. What a treat. I went simple after asking several exhausting questions (thank you Samantha for being patient). The pizza...the pepperoni was outstanding!! But the crust!! I ordered a personal pepperoni pizza and it was large and very reasonably priced. I could not finish eating it. But the crust!! I managed to stuff myself as this truly was the best crust I have ever had!! I look forward to next trip to New Jersey to try the next item on the menu....until then, if your in the area stoop by and let me know what you think? read more

Algieri's Pizza Restaurant - To order!! - Pizza Near Me - Belleville, New Jersey

See all

Below average pizza and bigot vibes, I'm staying away. Taste homemade and service sucks. read more

Algieri's Pizza Restaurant - Looks like a home made personal pie - Pizza Near Me - Belleville, New Jersey

See all

Seemed a bit unorganized. Person who took my order was very confused. She told me an hour to pick up. I showed up an hour later and it was cold, like it had been sitting there for a while. Salad had no dressing on it either. Admitting it, this isn't my go to place, but I had been there before. Very disappointed, but I'll give them another chance. read more

Great food for a great bday party and fist time... no leftovers after Thanks Algieri's for making great food and on time delivery... read more

Love this spot I order from here every week the same thing lol Large pie with extra sauce sometimes I add on house wings and calamari but I ask for them to be well done or fried hard. Every single time, the calamari arrives soggy so I stopped ordering it...... but either than that every thing else taste amazing, which is why I continue to order each week. Delivery normally takes about 45-60mins (Loyal customer for 3 years ) read more

I have to give them 5 Stars "Great!" It is probably the best in the area as I've been all around trying pizzas in Belleville and the surrounding areas. Their prices are fair and food is delicious. They have a whole team working hard in the kitchen too so you know they're busy and its a pretty popular spot in the area. It's much much better than so many of the mediocre spots that are around. This spot really goes justice for NJ pizza. read more

First & LAST time. old oily pizza. not impressed. Looks inviting and has been in the town for a while but honestly surprised at my simple order being flopped. pizza needs to be made with love. read more

Algieri's Pizza Restaurant - what is this..... - Pizza Near Me - Belleville, New Jersey

I have experienced dine in and take out at this spot. I have never had an awful pizza from Algieri's, but I've never had awesome pizza from them either. There are other places in the area that I would go to before Algieri's. UPDATE: Here I am 1 year later, my family has recently ordered the Margherita pizza and my gosh! It is probably in my top 5 pizzas, and trust me when I say I have tried A TON of pizza places. The plain pie is even really great too. The price is right, and now I will continue to order pies from them. read more

Embarrassingly bad order~ Worst meal ever tonight from Algieri's. Pizza was always great at Algieri's but i decided to order other dishes after last time getting a crust that was half raw. 1) fried calamari has always been great, tonight it was under cooked big time, and off taste! just not edible! 2) garlic bread order was slices of bread tossed in aluminum pan with tons of tasteless oil (vegetable oil?), little garlic and oregano. Dripped oil all over when trying to eat it, just hold up slice and watch oil drip off!! WTF!!!! used a ladle to pour in??? 3) main dish ~alfredo primavera~ frozen mixed veggies (carrots, peas, stringbeans) asked for fetticcini~got noodles?????? and the alfredo sauce tasteless....Half cooked frozen mix tossed in boiling water with pasta and a corn starch sauce with no taste! There is just no pride or quality in Algieri's food. If chef doesnt really care, maybe find a new job? The origional owner had fabulous food all around with amazingly good pizza, sadly only the pizza is good and everything else is failing worse and worse, cutting corners on quality, taste and consistency. It seems that no one cares there anymore or has pride on being a chef. Maybe their not even a chef or know what great Italian food is. We hadn't order from Algieri's in a few months because of the quality of previous order with a half raw pizza crust, but fond memories we tried again...MISTAKE, we will just order from people who have pride in their food and not throw money at a lost cause resturant, who's food has become increasingly unedible. read more

Best pizza fries in our tri-guido area. However, tried the mozzarella sticks...not that good.

I ordered a half plain half pepperoni Sicilian pizza and honestly I have to say it was the most disgusting Sicilian pizza I EVER HAD . What boggles my mind is there regular pizza is delicious. Very disappointing . 24 dollars down the tube . read more

They have always made the best pizza. Small pizza well done with thin crust!, However today I walked in and told the chef that I was in the mood to have a great big meal! I told him that I Was in the mood for chicken Parm, When I got home, the chicken Parm was still sizzling from just being cooked, and this was the most amazing chicken Parm I have ever had. If you are looking for authentic food that is not generic frozen restaurant depot quality this is the place to go. Thank you for making my night! read more

I've been ordering pizza from Algieri's for a couple of years, and always pick it up. Typically it has been hot upon pick up but had a couple occasions where it was definitely sitting for a bit, even though I show up 10 minutes before they say to. Well, I decided to order for delivery....and will NEVER make that mistake again. I was told my order would be there in 45 mins to an hour. Exactly an hour and half later, I called to ask where my food was, and was told it was on the way. I said I hope its not cold, and they said oh it won't be. It was. Actually the pizza was burnt and cold. The eggplant parm sandwich was basically eggplant slapped on a roll, no cheese (maybe there was one lonely slice somewhere but not that I could see). Maybe their version of an eggplant parm is different than what I've had elsewhere, but typically the parm part of the name means it has cheese on it. They did offer to send another sandwich (hopefully they didn't spit in it!) as long as I returned the original sandwich, to which I said no problem. By the time I received the sandwich it was a little over 2 hours after I placed my original order. This one was a little better, but the entire experience turned me off from wanted to order from Algieri's again. If, in the future, I do go back to Algieri's, I will only order Pizza and only for pick up. read more

Slices were oily and limp. Really not the same place from years ago. Sandwiches have half of what they used to, mostly bread now. I'm done. read more

Welllllllllll they USED to be good but not anymore! Against my better judgment after ordering a thin crust pizza 2 weeks ago and it came regular not thin I vowed then I was done! However this evening I said what heck, maybe I'll try again?!i I said THIN ... VERY THIN!! Apparently whomever was there today making pizza clearly doesn't know how to make a thin crust or is it they just don't listen to the order? I guess if I want thin crust I gotta get in my car and drive to the Star Tavern in Orange!... It's really too bad because i really USED to enjoy Algeries pie...NO MORE!! Algeries I will never ever ever call your establishment again!! DONE!!! read more

My childhood favorite pizzeria and still my go to spot for my own family. From pizza to sandwiches to pasta dishes- never disappoints. Great food and great service! read more

Algeri's has the ambiance of a typical neighborhood pizza parlor with the addition of some tables outdoors. While they have a full menu, I've only had the Pizza so thats what I'll focus my review on. The pizza is probably the best I've ever had, if you're a thin crust lover you must try Algeri's! The crust is thin and crispy with just the right amount of their tangy sauce. Take advantage of Monday take out deals where a large pie is only $7. read more

My favorite in the Nutley, Belville, Bloomfield, Clifton area! Ralphs is ok but Algieri's is the right mix for my ideal Jersey Pie.

You know the pizza is bad when you can't hold it without all the cheese falling off. Ordered delivery and pizza was TERRIBLE. We got the tomato basil garlic pizza and it came out very soggy. The center of the pizza was undercooked so the "thin" type crust didn't workout.. We usually order from La Sicilia (best pizza in town hands down) but they were closed so we decided to try this out. First and last.. read more

Algieri's Pizza Restaurant - Soggy greasy pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Belleville, New Jersey

See all

Really solid pizza, definitely our new pizza of choice since moving to Nutley. We've had plain, pepperoni and even Hawaiian and loved them all. We are also big fans of their Penne Vodka! read more

Pretty good!! $8.99 for a pizza on a Tuesday (most places in Belleville have early week prices). The price goes up $1 for delivery. The shop is small, but new and clean. They have a self serve fridge and a small counter. I don't think they sell by the slice. I did not like that the guy took a minute or so to acknowledge me. His laptop and iPhone were more important. But my pizza was baking and wasn't ready yet, so no harm, no foul. He was friendly otherwise. read more

My aunt and uncle are huge fans of this place. After hearing so much about it and eating here a couple times, decided to do takeout. SO GOOD! Got a chicken and bacon pizza, mozzarella sticks and cavatelli with chicken and broccoli. Love everything! read more

Ironically, I don't flip over their regular pizza but Algieri's is a constant meal stop in my home. Their sandwiches are huge and delish (hot or cold), one of the best Sicilian pies around, and some of the best apps around. If you are just ordering for yourself, then only get the half sandwhich. I've put a few whole ones away but then regretted it. Actually did it with the Italian hot dog a few times. What can I say, I'm a glutton for punishment. When my wife and I order, we usually order a large sandwhich and a buffalo chicken salad. Everything is on point and more than enough. They may have the greatest mozzarella sticks around. Have bought from them to host friends over before and pretty much everybody agrees. The buffalo wings are legit as well. The very last time we got them, it seems they were made differently. I hope they go back to the way they were The Sicilian is on point. In a heavy Italian area, to say it's the best Sicilian pie around is the best compliment I can give. It's all in the bread and the bread is excellent in whatever you need bread for. Great bread place. Owner is a really nice guy too. Always greets me by my first name. Outside dining in summer is nice as well read more

I couldn't find a good pizza place around the area and I was pretty bummed about it because there is nothing worse than bad pizza. Through the graces of god, I found Algieri's after going to a family party and I was hooked! There pizza has the best cheese and a perfect crust--I cannot get enough of it. Other than pizza, I've had their sausage parm sandwich, a variety of pasta dishes and salads and all of them were delicious. I most always order for delivery and they're pretty fast for the most part. I haven't had to wait more than a half hour. The only thing that stinks is that when you pay with a credit card you cannot leave a tip over the phone or on the receipt for the driver so be prepared to tip with cash. I felt bad because I had no cash one day to tip and I was annoyed that they failed to mention that over the phone. My only complaint is that the staff are the nicest and are quick to rush you off the phone. They need to work on that but despite that they have quality Italian food! read more

I'll say you get pretty good portions for the price but the food is just mediocre. The go to for me is the eggplant parm and I highly recommend it! Everything else is just ok. There is really no WOW factor about this place for me but definitely check out the menu and see for yourself! read more

The only place that is open on a Saturday night! Love this and there pizza! Chicken parm sub is a must too!

Horrible place. Extremely rude staff. I called tonight to order food and when I was in the middle of ordering the girl in the phone laughed at me cause I asked a question and than I also heard another employee laughing as well. The girl than proceeds to keep laughing while trying to apologize. Rather than tell her that she's pathetic I hung up. Fuck this place. read more