We checked this spot out for an early dinner on a weekend night. They do seem to do takeout more than eat in but have plenty of tables indoor and out. This place has options from different crusts to vegan to toppings galore. As someone who has gone through dairy free and vegan phases, I appreciate the options! We tried the mozz tots ($10) which were basically mini mozzarella sticks and just as delicious as they sound. We tried the American pie which was a thin crust and was light and crisp - pretty good pie. I really like puglia which we got on focaccia bread which made it a hearty pie. Plain but done well. I was impressed with the quality and the options overall so definitely will try this spot again. read more

See all

we popped over for a quick meal a few days ago to grab some pizza. overall this place was a huge disappointment. the meatballs were rock hard and tough to chew. the pizza was okay but not worth the price. maybe we will come back to try the foccacia style crust, but with so many better options in this area it wouldnt be my first or second choice. the outdoor seating is nice for small ( 4 ppl or less) groups and i would consider this place kid friendly. read more

Pizza is DECENT but $27 for a single pie with just pepperoni, that is insane!!! This is not Lucali or something extraordinary.

I came here to get takeout with my friend who is gluten free and lactose intolerant. We ordered the gluten free 4 cheese vegan pizza and added pepperoni on top. The host was very friendly and gave us extra utensils . The place is very laid back and cute there are some tables to eat outside as well . The pizza is delicious and I really couldn't believe it is vegan . It is very fresh and filling ! We are definitely coming back read more

See all

Unfortunately, we were very disappointed by the food at Tino's. The pizza lacked real flavor and frankly, cheese. Our gnocchi and chicken bites tasted as if they were previously frozen and reheated in an air-fryer. The only reason for the second star is because our waiter was very attentive. Sadly would not recommend. read more

My go to for a freshly prepared salad! Customer service is awesome! Clean&Friendly environment!

I love the cacio y pepe pizza with cauliflower crust and the salad with the tender breaded chicken cutlet. So delicious, fresh ingredients, and quick and friendly service. I have never had to wait! Try it, you won't regret it. read more

Pizza absolutely tasteless. Ordered a cheese pizza with sausage. Cheese was fresh mozz and I'm not quite sure about the upscale appeal. It's like galvanized plastic when cooked. No sauce to speak of beneath. Sausage crumble was tasteless and dry. read more

Decided to finally stop in with my husband to give this restaurant a try. Ordered the truffle gnocchi bites, salad, and pepperoni pizza. Staff was friendly and immediately greeted us when we walked it. The truffle gnocchi bites were pretty good. I ordered the beet salad and asked for dressing on the side. It definitely came on it. When I told the food runner he insisted it was on the side and gave me more. I then took a few more bites and told our server and she said " oh I heard". So I basically just picked the chicken out. The pizza was ok, tasted similar to like a personal Blaze or Urban Bricks. Nothing I would crave in the future. read more

See all

Wanted to try. Ordered food for delivery via Grubhub (this was after calling directly and told to order via GH or DoorDash). Unfortunately even though order was placed and I was informed that food was out for delivery by GH (after the delivery window was missed - I also could not call direct as restaurant was now closed) the food never materialized. Super disappointing. read more

I have ordered from Tino's many times and I really love that they use quality ingredients. I have a Dysautonomia condition so if I go out to eat and someone is using less than quality ingredients it will send my heart rate speeding- unfortunately this means I usually can't have pizza and most Italian food (unless I am in Italy). Every item I have ever ordered from Tino's it has not only been delicious, it has been made with zero junk! I always opt for the sourdough crust since that is best for me, but I have had their regular crust with no issue. Here is a list of my recommendations: Tartufo Pie Dora Pie Parm Pie Truffle Gnocchi Bites Tino's Margherita Pie The real antipasto Side of Tino's hot agave Puglia Pie The dolce vita dessert Anyway - thanks Tino and the rest of the staff for opening a spot in Montclair so I can enjoy pizza again! read more

Resorted to walking out due to rude service. We're trying to figure out what to order with our family of 8 and we're rushed to pick a drink. When we asked what drinks they have we're rudely told to look at the menu. read more

My son and I walked in after enjoying such a beautiful fresh pizza aroma as we walked past . We were greeted by Rafael who was extremely helpful as he walked us through the menu. We enjoyed a nice conversation and an amazing meal. Dinner time came and we decided to go back for more and brought the rest of the family. Again, a great experience! Rafael and his staff are amazing and the pizza's mouth watering. To all pizza lovers, you must check out this place! Highly recommended read more

The place is quiet and chill and byo. The pizza is delicious but I highly recommend the honey and truffle buratta and the antipasto with bread is a meal in itself. Everything is fresh and delicious! Staff is very friendly and accomodating! read more

This is 4 stars just for the takeout pizza. It wasnt too salty, it was the perfect size. Light and dont feel heavy or gross afterwards. Looking forward to going there in person and also see what other menu options there are. read more

Great Service, Better Pizza! Beautiful interior and quaint outdoor seating. Don't know where to eat? Now you do! read more

Tino's was such a pleasant surprise. They have great personal pizzas but their other food was also a treat. Even their salad was great! They clearly use fresh ingredients of a better quality than most pizza places. The place feels warm and cozy and the staff are all very kind and made us feel at home. This place is a hidden gem but it is now my favorite pizza place in Montclair by a long shot. read more

Overpriced mediocre pizza. Just completely average and disappointing when you spend $16 for a super small pie & read the marketing you'd expect a little more, but the product does not back it up. The amount of basil was shameful, look at the pic it's tiny shreds couldn't even get a leaf on that pie haha. Lacking flavor didn't hit the spot only hit the wallet. Seemed like a good idea to have an artisan pizzeria but this is clearly a chain restaurant & will fail in Upper Montclair bc people actually care about quality of food here. read more

Tino's Artisan Pizza - Sad za - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

DORA- It's the sausage & pepperoni pizzette great sauce to mozzarella balance, perfect sausage to pepperoni ratio, crisp and delicious. Highly recommend it! read more

Tino's Artisan Pizza - DORA - Sausage & Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

love the pizza. only have ordered to go. It's fresh, quick, and they do a good job making the pie. read more

Tino's Artisan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

The pizza was amazing, the service was great. We had the cauliflower and sourdough pizza.

We tried really hard to like Tino's. Kept checking the site to see if they were finally open. But after trying it a few times, moving on to less expensive options with better pies. Maybe the slices are good? But ordering for a family of five is just a wallet killer without any justification. There's little value here. Which is unfortunately kind of standard in Upper Montclair these days (see SLA Thai as another example of overpriced mediocre food). read more

i had the ruchetta and its so freakin good! everything was cooked perfectly. i love arugula on pizza. this is my new fav pizza place in Montclair. everything taste great and authentic! i always had it down the shore. now i'm glad its closer to me :) read more

Tino's Artisan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Amazing place with incredible pizza and food - this is just like being in Italy - you've got to try the Nona's macaroni and meatballs

This place is small, casual and BYOB, what else can you ask for. I had The Antonia pizzette and it was simply fabulous. We actually met Tino the night we' were there and he was working it, he is very friendly. We wish him continued success with this venture. Waitstaff were very attentive and kind. This is located in Upper Montclair and highly recommend. read more

To say that Tino's Artisan Pizza really delivers is a bad pun, but it sure makes sense for the pizza they serve. I ordered the margherita to check out the basics, then added artichoke hearts--and also anchovies since I'm the only one left on the planet who likes them. What came in the box was a gorgeous pie, layered with plenty of toppings, as opposed to the skimpy add-ons in so many other places. Tomato and cheese really flavorful. Great crust, too, rather thin and halfway between chewy and crunchy. A bit pricey and worth it. Would I go back. Yup. Yep. Yes. read more

This is fantastic! We loved everything we ordered!!! Worth a trip to try it out. We will be coming back!

We had two individual pizzas, garlic bread and arancini + two salads + chicken parm sandwich. Across the board, food was average at best but priced at a premium. Really wanted to like the place. read more

Excellent pizza. I especially like the use of fresh mozzarella and other fresh ingredients. Pizzas are smaller than usual but well worth the price. read more

Delicious! I'm a vegan and all of their vegetarian pies can be made vegan! Highly recommend Tino's!

Really good artisal pizza. Perfectly cooked, ingredients are fresh and delicious. Thin crust nicely browned. Highly recommend!

Since becoming Elite I've tried to keep my reviews positive, so let me begin by saying, what I attempted to eat last night was positively dreadful. I also feel that I have an above average vocabulary. That said, I was unaware that artisanal also meant void of taste. I moved to Montclair a little over a year ago and have unfortunately had some pretty lousy pizza, but last night took the cake, or shall I say the pie. I had the misfortune of ordering not one, but two tasteless, meaningless excuses for pizza. I had to refer to my bill to even remember what I ordered since they were both forgettable in their own ways. A mushroom sausage pizza was covered in mushrooms and crumbled bits of what I can only assume was sausage. The cheese was spotty, the sauce almost non-existent and the thin crust made me long for matzo. The second pizza was a poor excuse for Cacio e Pepe, and the only taste it delivered was off-putting and not peppery whatsoever. Nothing in these two pizzas was even salvageable, so I opted to eat a delicious ice cream sandwich I had procured at Van Hook earlier in the week. I will be heading back there today for one of their spectacular grilled cheese sandwiches, since the cheese that I thought I was going to consume on the pizza was clearly M.I.A. Lest I forget, my non-meal began with a meaningless Caesar Salad that was Et Tu Brutal. Stale croutons and bitter dressing over shards of limp Romaine lettuce. The upside was that I saved numerous calories. The downside was that I spent just south of $50 for this not so hot mess. Thank the pizza Gods, I managed to secure a reservation at Bivio next Friday, for what is far and away the best pizza this side of Florence, and one of the only pizzas well worth eating in a town starving for good pies. Sorry Tino's and all those who gave this artisan pizza 5 stars, but this tasteless blob of I'm not sure what left me speechless. read more

Been coming here with my family since they opened. Friendly great staff. Food is amazing fresh produce and delicious. The Hernanadez family recommend you come if you haven't yet you don't know what your missing !! read more

Everything we ordered was fresh and tasty: chicken bites, Greco salad, and Antonia pie. Prices seem to be on par with what other restaurants with similar offerings charge. Looking forward to trying other things on the menu. read more