Order Best Pizza Takeout or Delivery
Best Pizza Photos
Business Info
Best Pizza Popular Dishes
BEST PIZZA ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Best Pizza
Recommended Reviews - Best Pizza
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Best Pizza definitely lived up to the hype! Heard great things about this place and decided to check it out while I was in Williamsburg. The white slice was pretty fire with the sesame crust and the caramelized onions. Crust was thin and crunchy with just a bit of a chew. Almost felt like a bialy, but better. Definitely one of the best white slices in NYC!! The pepperoni was overheat by a tad but still solid. The pepperoni cuts were huge, sauce wasn't too sweet, and ratio of ingredients were appropriate. Several tables on the inside with some outdoor seating. Food came out quick despite the constant flow of customers.
Very good pie. It's got the fire flavor, if you prefer any coal or wood fire flavor then it's got the burn. Good cheese, just sticky and chewy enough. The bottom crust is crispy, thin, enough dough flavor. Definitely not bread dough. It's definitely an OG NY pizza.
Omg!!! Came in here while at the italian festival. We sat outside and this was the best pizza I ever had. Crunchy sides perfect amount of sauce and cheese the seasoning were perfection.
Best Pizza is the original NYC elevated slice shop. It doesn't get as much hype anymore since it's been around for so many years, but it's still just as good. I stopped by on a weekend afternoon and there were a few other people inside. I ordered a grandma slice and the seasonal veggie slice. They were both warmed and ready about five minutes later. The seasonal veggie was a white pie topped with kale and sunchokes. It was a great combination and I could eat multiple slices of it. The grandma slice is a classic square, covered in sweet tomato sauce. Always a solid choice. The sandwiches here are also delicious and worth getting. Can't go wrong with anything at Best Pizza.
I'll die on this hill: Frank Pinello (owner of Best Pizza, former Roberta's alum) is the king of pizza. His pizza is just so effing amazing. He never gets the flowers he deserves in the press and on social media. Big slices, bursting with flavor. His grandma slice, which is HUGE, is my favorite, with its tart anchovy marinara sauce. Caramelized tomato and garlic. And his regular cheese slice is also pretty damn good, with a cheesy flavor that will punch you in the face. Nothing halfway done here at Best Pizza. Service is always with a smile and the price is just right. It can get busy, but overall, there is plenty of room for everyone to have a seat. Three huge slices and two drinks were 18 bucks, but one slice could feed one person, seriously.
My Brother and I were going to try out as many pizza places as we could on our drive through the city. Best Pizza was our 4th stop. We went with a slice of cheese and a slice of grandma. I honestly was looking forward to Best Pizza and Sallys up in New Haven the most on our trip, and unfortunately, both of them kind of let me down a bit. The cheese slice was fine, typical NY slice and pretty tasty. The grandma slice was skimp. The dough was super light, indents in the bottom of the dough, super thin, and not enough cheese on it. It was like a bread slice. Meh. Still love you Frank, even if I thought your pizza was just average. Love watching you on Youtube and learning about pizza from you!
Frankie P knocks it out of the park! On my pizza tour this was the number one in my book, the white slice is a must have and the others were perfect as well. If they moved this to Ohio I'd die happy
My friend and I are on a mission to find the best pizza in NYC. First on our list was Best Pizza. I loved the straight forwardness of the place. Staff were friendly and direct, order in, paid for quickly and they even brought it to the table for us. The place is small but set up in a way then even if it was full, you wouldn't feel crowded. Decorated paper plates line the wall, and you realize people are coming from all over the world to eat this pizza. Hell, I came from Rhode Island so I get it! When I bit into the pepperoni, I said to myself "yes, this is a NY pie". When I think about what qualifies it to be NY style, this slice embodies all of it. Good crust, good sauce, good cheese. Care and attention was paid when making it, even though the big boss was nowhere in that kitchen. The pepperoni edged out the cheese as the better slice for me. It was cooked more and the crispiness of the crust was pleasant while accentuating the flavor. The sauce wasn't anything over the top but made its presence known with a bold tomato taste. The cheese to sauce ratio was on point, a bit of pull without it being overwhelmingly cheesy. Best slice in the city? Probably not. But it was 100% delicious and a great way to start our quest!
Best Pizza doesn't scream for your attention. In fact, it looks like the stereotypical NYC pizza place you'd see in a Scorcese film: white walls, hand-drawn art on paper plates, two ceiling fans overhead and a slice case. Wu-Tang cuts through the room like garlic. The staff moves easily, friendly and natural. Lauren Hill drops in next. Then Chubb Rock. Nobody here is performing, yet it's all part of the neighborhood experience. Now for the slices. The pepperoni curls just enough, its edges dark from the heat. It's a little crisp, not too oily. The cheese lays smooth, layered over a sauce that speaks softly, despite a little bite. There's some chew to the crust, some char on the edges. You get crunch in the right places. Nothing soggy, nothing sloppy. Garlic knots sit on the side, blistered and warm with a that spicy marinara. It's a slice you'd eat on your lunch break, or after a show, or walking home. You could call it everyday pizza. You could call it neighborhood pizza. You could call it a terrific version of both, and you wouldn't be wrong. Maybe that's what makes it stand out. It's not trying to blow your mind; it's just really good stuff. Frank Pinello wasn't behind the counter today, but you feel his fingerprints in the restraint and balance. This place feels like someone who knows how to cook anything but he chose to make pizza out of love. And while it's still a neighborhood spot, his national recognition has made it a true destination. You've had this slice before in other places. You'll have it again. That's the point. It stays with you not because it's excellent in any way, but because it's familiar. This is a classic New York slice, wood-fired, chewy and crispy, served in a room that doesn't care if you're impressed. They know that you know they're good. Not a pilgrimage, but a pretty good stop.
I have wanted to come here for a long time and finally made it. Ordered the white and the grandma. Both were great. Even my oldest child that has lived in Brooklyn for over 10 years was impressed. Thanks for the great pizza !
Decent slice but nothing special (sorry) the 3.8 rating on here is probably accurate. I would def get a different one if I ever come back here
" Kramer has been swimming laps between the Queensborough bridge and the Brooklyn bridge." -Jerry Seinfeld da Scene: Hanging out in Brooklyn for a few days and decided on doing a lil' pizza jaunt. Old and New school style since Di Fara's said goodbye to Dom (rip) for old school we decided on trying Franks' place - Best Pizza to represent and wasn't disappointed. da Grub: Did Cheese, Pep, White, and Grandma. Quintessential NY slices, ate them right on the hood of the rental car. Crust had a lil' crunch w/ a chew, GREAT sauce. White pie was nice and garlicy, Grandma was a lil' dry for me. Overall solid Brooklyn spot. Service: No nonsense, ya place your order at the counter and wait for the goodness to arrive minute later. Grab napkins and shake on some peppers if you like before heading outside to grub. Frank's recipes and methods represent Brooklyn pizza well, check him out!
Reviews are mixed. Many praise the crispy flavorful pizza, friendly staff, and casual neighborhood atmosphere. Service is generally quick.
Read the full review summary in the app
6 months ago
really good slice. one of the better pepperoni slices in the city. quick service and friendly staff read more
I did a pizza crawl through Long Island and Brooklyn. This place was my favorite. At first glance, it looked like they went skimpy on the cheese, but once I bit into it I quickly realized it was perfectly balanced. I absolutely loved it. Yum. Visually appealing. No flop. Crispy and chewy crust. Delicious cheese and sauce. Great price. No complaints. I got a regular slice and didn't add any garlic, pepper or parm. It was excellent the way it was straight out of the oven. read more
In the pursuit of finding one of the best slices in NYC, I stumbled upon Best pizza. This place is hot, literally and figuratively! Best pizza was packed when I stumbled in, but the wait time was decent and the pizza was worth it. I believe I paid like $6-10 for 2 slices? Loved the thinness of the pizza and the way the cheese literally melted off. So fresh and it definitely warmed my soul on such a cold day. Still have tons of more places to try, but this definitely hit the spot and worth the try! read more
Small, vibrant and extremely bustling spot in Williamsburg, Brooklyn serving elevated wood fired pizza. Best Pizza is just a handful of 9+ ever given out by @onebite review and IMHO; definitely lived up to the score. read more
2 years ago
The standard slice is a solid anchor but the square and the white pie are really where it's at. It seems like there is quite the variety here where on the cheese the crust is more the pillowy style, but on the white pie it's stretched thinner and got a crispy cracker crust. The fresh tomatoes on the square was really a treat. We've been crushing pizza after pizza after pizza and the freshness brought us back to life. A real neighborhood spot with construction guys hitting it up on their lunch break. Overall, I would recommend and the sesame seeds on the crust is really nice. I've done this on Detroit pizzas at home, but think it works better in this thinner white pie. read more
2 years ago
Went to New York for a long weekend and had pizza on our mind. We went everywhere and I mean everywhere. This place was hands down the winner. We're from Chicago and have great food at our fingertips but this pizza has ruined what I thought was pizza. I dream about the grandma slice weekly since we've been home and frankly, I'm jealous that New Yorkers have this joint in their backyard. Best damn pie I've ever had. read more
7 months ago
2 years ago
Vibe: 6/10 - has a bit of seating but nothing special Service: 6/10 Value: 6/10 Pepperoni: 8.5 White pie: 7.25 - I just prefer a more buttery crust, found it to be a bit dry Overall: 6.75/10 (3.375/5) [To clarify our review system: 10 = we'll never have anything else as good as this in our lives (we use 10 very sparingly!) 9 = extraordinary 8 = great 7 = above average 6 = average Anything below 6 is being critical] read more
I've always wanted to eat here after watching Frank on YouTube. A lot of people raved about his pizza being the best, so we came on a Saturday a few mins after they opened. Inside felt very rustic and cozy. You can see they have a wood fire oven behind the counter. We ordered a regular slice (4), pepperoni slice ($4.75), and grandma slice ($5.25). They also had complimentary water near their condiments area. I'm not sure if it was because they just opened for the day, but we were disappointed by the pizzas. The slices had a nice crust (springy interior with crunchy exterior), but weren't hot despite being taken out of the oven... The cheese and grandma slice were just okay. My favorite of the 3 was their pepperoni slice. The pepperoni was crisp and flavorful. read more
SORRY Not The Best Pizza for Shaw, In my opinion you must be very careful what you name your food establishment period especially if you name it The Best !!! We wanted to so like this pizzeria especially that we follow Bar Stool Pizza ... As soon as we walked in I told my family we are not gonna like their pizza totally just by the over whelming smell of their oregano !!! We didn't even get to their pizza counter display before I past that comment; however when you hit their display counter and see their pies they look amazing ya gonna want to try em all.... As we did ... We were 5 people and we agreed on one thing; their best slice was their White Slice with caramelized onions definitely a 4 star slice. However their plain slice & their pepperoni slice 2 stars based on the following; over whelming oregano and lack of sauce we found the slices to be very dry. Their dough their crust is definitely a winner but it'a all about how you top it !! More sauce please & loose some of that oregano... as far as the service, the old world nostalgia it's a 5 star but the pizza for us fell short of its high rating from Bar Stool ... definitely needs to be reevaluated we follow Bar Stool Pizza almost everywhere we possibly can and this high rating that he gave this pizzeria is way off we don't and can't agree with it we challenge him to come back and reevaluate his high score that he gave this pizzeria .... In fact he may have lost his Pizza credibility with us !!! Sorry " The Best Pizza " but your definitely not the best !!! Thanks, Greg D & family read more
This place is way better than the 3.8 Stars it has on Yelp. It's in my humble opinion one of the best pizzarias not only in Brooklyn, but all of NY. I think what really sets it apart from the others is just how well it does every single slice. If you've ever seen Frank Pinello's (the owner) videos on YouTube or his series on Vice, you'd know he's the real deal and is very passionate about pizza. Frank captured the 80's-90's pizza joint vibe perfectly, from the sign outside, to the menu inside. It's one of the cooler things about the place. There's so many places that attempt to do this and it comes off as cheesy. Not here. And the pizza is even better than the aesthetic. You cannot go wrong with any slice on the menu. Thin, crispy, full of flavor. You can tell quality ingredients are used with each bite. There's been a lot of thought put into what makes a perfect slice of pizza and the crew here is able to check all of those boxes. One thing is for certain "Best Pizza" is appropriately named and is indeed one of the best the city has to offer. read more
I first saw Frank on the Pizza Show as most folks have. Loved his vibe and what he was doing so I decided to check out his spot. This is a typical NYC slice joint - in and out in a matter of minutes with a hot slice. There were a few tables outside with a couple of locals chatting after finishing their food. The inside is small but just enough space to scarf down your slice. I got a plain which came out super crispy and steaming hot. What at treat! In a city full of pizza joints, I'm glad Frank is doing his thing in Brooklyn! Can't wait to go back! read more
Stopped in as part of my quest to go to all the best pizza places in NY - no pun intended - and with a 9.1 from Dave this was clearly on the list. The slice was a nice light slice - solid and up there with what you expect from good NYC pizzeria pizza. Doesn't compete with the coal and brick oven places you typically think of when you think of spectacular pizza, but for a typical pizzeria slice, it's definitely in the upper echelon. Delicious sauce and cheese blend, with fresh basil being a nice touch to complete the bite. Absolutely no flop, a great char, and a chewy crust. Not sure I'd travel back to Williamsburg for it, but if I were in the area, I wouldn't hesitate to grab another slice here. read more
3 years ago
This was one of the best slices I've had in the city and beats out a lot of the others I've had (including L'industrie). The pizza is cooked in a wood fired oven and the undercarriage was perfectly crispy. My favorite part about the pizza and what made it stand out from other pizzerias was the sauce. It was very garlic forward but well balanced. It also had a slight kick to it. I like the seasoned sauce more than other spots that use pure tomato puree. The grandma slice was nice and airy. The service was really friendly and the prices were fair. I'll definitely be back! read more
2 years ago
Absolutely love this slice. It has everything you need: perfect crunch, perfect ratio and perfect seasoning to the sauce. I found this spot from the pizza show and I remember they emphasized how much they care about using quality ingredients in their pizza and their pizza is just that, quality. They're always super nice here and they get your order out quickly. It a nice spot out here in Brooklyn, it's small but it's still in a beautiful area with outdoor seating so you can enjoy a slice while you take in Brooklyn. read more
3 years ago
I think Best Pizza is underrated and deserves a bit more recognition! But I still prefer L'Industrie (personal preference). We tried a few of their slices to try it all- a cheese, white, pepperoni & grandma. Our favorite was the grandma pizza; the crust was perfectly seasoned, doughy yet crispy and not too thick nor thin. Their round thin slices had a good carriage/hold but were just whatever to me because it wasn't saucy or cheesy enough for me.. they kind of skimped. Their dough and crust stood out the most and is what makes the pizza still good! I would only come back for the grandma, would get a pie of that any day. read more
9 months ago
I had the veggie slice. The crust is great - just the right blend of crispy and chewy. I also liked the uncommon toppings - beets, tomatoes, and greens gave the whole thing an earthy taste. I just would've liked a bit more sauce on there. Not my favorite choice for pizza, but a solid slice. read more
1 year ago
Great and friendly service! They were super helpful with my daughter with multiple food allergies. This was probably the best gluten free pizza she's ever had! Gluten pizzas were delicious too. Will likely be back during our stay. (Disclaimer... I'm a tourist.) read more
2 years ago
One of our favorite pizza spots in Brooklyn, I believe it was a 9.2 on the one bite pizza app.. and a 9.3 in my personal opinion... great place ,, no seating but just a few chairs outside n some bar stools but who cares when the pizza is amazing read more
10 months ago
First off - the music playing was not only load but very inappropriate. You are a stop & visit restaurant where folks from all over come to try a slice. Playing Thug, Gangster, Hip-hop music with sexual lyrics blasting is not what i would expect, especially watching how you act and conduct yourself on The Pizza Show. Second - The slice(s) was not all that, improving the taste by adding spices, oregano I believe. Sorry but the food did not deliver. Bummer as I really enjoyed you on the PS. read more
1 year ago
I don't know about 'best pizza' but that's only because I didn't try the pizza. Maybe best 'meatball hero' or at least best 'hero' because the bread was really good but my grandma's meatballs are still better. The staff and space were fitting too. read more
2 years ago
Amazing! Better than all the 5 star reviews would suggest! Crazy delicious pizza. Crust thin & crispy, top-quality ingredients. Went with a large group, had the white, plain, pepperoni and and bacon/sausage pie. We were rendered speechless by the overall flavor. The white pizza was brave with sesame seeds and that just blew us away! The sausage was delicious with some tasty spice. Probably homemade. Service was very good. It is not a fancy place, to say the least! Ambiance is casual and plenty of people smiling as they discover the food here. read more
2 years ago
Cheese Slice. SUBPAR. A nice looking Slice with a thin crust but you don't pay for looks. Odd tasting Cheese on the Slice which didn't appeal to me. I made the mistake of ordering an Unsweetened Tea which was HORRIBLE tasting and served at room temperature. AVOID. read more
Back again after 6 years. And my 4 star review holds true. It's a very average New York Slice. If you're not familiar with NYC pizza, maybe it's a 5. But if you've had some of the best the city has to offer, this is in a tier below. read more
"when the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie that's amore" (Dean Martin) So there we were, 50 or so party goers enjoying a pre-wedding celebration in a cool Williamsburg bar. After a while, the laughter and visiting and drinking gave way to another activity - the sensation of hunger. So, imagine our elation when Best Pizza arrived carrying in 20 pizzas to our group, and set them up with plates and napkins for everyone. There were traditional red pizzas with cheese, meat pizzas, white pizzas, veggie pizzas and some amazing thick crust square Sicilian pizzas. Oh, and BTW, the slices were as gigantic as they were delicious. Great job, Best Pizza!! read more
2 years ago
Was it worth the price? Not in my opinion. The flour used was perfect, but there wasn't enough cheese or sauce for my liking. I might give it another shot with a sandwich or maybe their grandma pie. If you prefer a thinner pizza with less sauce and cheese, this could be perfect for you. However, I'm a fan of saucy and cheesy pizzas. I plan to try their sandwiches next time; this meal was a disappointment for me. Even though I really wanted to enjoy this pizza, I didn't like it at all. I spent $45.94 on this, and unfortunately, it felt like a waste. At least I got to try it, but it felt more like flatbread with pepperoni. read more
3 years ago
This is one of my favorite slice shops in BK. Any time I visit NY, this is always on the bucket list. This was my second time here. The workers were very kind and friendly, which I usually don't get in NY. It amazes me how the people in LA (where I'm from) are a lot more courteous, which still befuddles me. That's a story for another day. I went in and got a white slice (S-tier slice) and a pepperoni. I then proceeded to go use their restroom as I literally have to go hourly anytime I visit NYC. My only gripe was there was NO toilet paper! Luckily, it was a #1, not 2. Once I got out, I went to my seat and plopped on my table was an original slice and a white slice. I went to the counter with the plain slice and told them that I ordered a pepperoni slice (kindly). They confirmed it, cooked up my pepp slice and let me keep the plain slice. Kudos for making things right and having such amazing pizza on top of it all! PS -- tell Frankie I said hello! One of these days, I have to take a photo with the GOAT. read more
2 years ago
I want to still love Best Pizza, when you get a slice that's part of a fresh pie that's right out of the oven, it can be magnificent. But there are just too many qualifiers in that last sentence I wrote - these days when I go I rarely get a slice that tastes anything like it does when you get a fresh pizza slice. They usually taste like they've been sitting there too long and the reheat just doesn't cover it. Even when it's fresh, it's not always amazing, there's a consistency problem that makes the slices vary between "holy shit they know what they're doing" and "eh, this is a pretty average NYC slice". When I first went pretty regularly ~4 years ago, it was much more consistent than it is today, it just doesn't deserve the acclaim it once did. read more
tl;dr the well-executed Grandma square is the highlight of this traditional, NY-style slice shop, even if the pizza falls just short of being the "best" Best Pizza opened its doors in 2010, founded by Brooklynite and Roberta's alumnus Frank Pinello, now better known as the host for The Pizza Show on Vice. With a name like "Best Pizza", a business immediately opens the door for scrutiny. Yet, this hole-in-the-wall joint rose to the occasion and garnered rave reviews across New York media outlets and Barstool Sports alike. At first glance, Best Pizza looks like any of the other NYC shops claiming to serve the "best" slices. The worn-metal, cherry-red sign pops against the hunter-green exterior. Inside, the off-white Victorian-style walls are lined with artwork sketched on paper plates. A single shelf on the left holds assorted knick-knacks including a Jesus statuette, a laminated Best Pizza news feature, and a custom Best Pizza wooden traffic sign. Black wooden tables are paired with thrifted seats indoors, while fabric lawn chairs are pressed against mismatched patio tables just outside. A small pie display is placed on the ordering counter in the back, and the walls echo with old-school R&B. In the summer, the pizza ovens leave the shop swelteringly toasty. I stopped by for weekday lunch, and a handful of locals were slowly trickling through. I was able to order immediately, and the helpful staff were happy to engage in conversation and indulge my request for 2 super hot slices: a Pepperoni slice and a Grandma square. For the former, I enjoyed the super-thin crust, charred on the bottom without erring on burnt, although I wish it had a bit more flavor when sans toppings. The slice sported a slightly-too-thin layer of cheese and large, not-overwhelmingly-greasy pepperoni rings. The star of the meal, though, was the grandma square. Its thicker, more flavorful crust was crisp on the bottom and pillowy in the middle, as (or more) impressive than any other square I've had in the city. Bubbles of crisp cheese were dolloped with notably sweet, basil-y tomato sauce and cooked basil. Best Pizza has plenty of competition around Williamsburg, and I'd be lying if I called Best Pizza my favorite pizza even within a 10-block radius. But at $10 for quick service and 2 darn good slices, Best Pizza remains a solid addition to the neighborhood and a worthwhile visit for any pizza fan. read more
1 year ago
More info about Best Pizza
33 Havemeyer St
Brooklyn, NY 11211
Williamsburg - North Side
Directions
(718) 599-2210
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.best.piz.za.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
More Info
Health Score
Best Pizza Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Best Pizza
Is this Frank Pinello's Best Place Pizzeria?. I viewed his UTube video with his grandmother Nonna making Chicken Cutlets. Would like to stop by for lunch, possibly meet Frank, maybe his grandmother too.
Yes, this the the same place owned by Frank Pinello, also known by pizza fans as the host of "The Pizza Show" airing on Vice Network. I have visited from out of town twice and both times neither Frank (nor his Grandma) were in the store. If one of…
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
48 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 years ago
12 years ago
12 years ago
14 years ago
10 years ago
8 years ago
6 years ago
11 years ago
13 years ago
10 years ago
8 years ago
7 years ago
7 years ago
11 years ago
16 years ago
11 years ago
13 years ago
11 years ago
