We had an outstanding dinner at Banshee in East Atlanta Village. This restaurant serves fine-dining-quality New American cuisine in a hip, casual atmosphere. The restaurant opened in September 2018. My wife wanted to come here for a while. We finally made it and found it to be worth the wait and hype. Banshee earned Michelin Bib Gourmand recognition in 2023 and retained the award in 2024. Well deserved.
This place is popular. Book reservations in advance (Resy).
Free parking is available behind the restaurant on Gresham Ave SE and in the surface lots on either side of Gresham. During our visit, the lots were full. I parked for free on the other side of the block, on Joseph Ave SE. This is East Atlanta, so the lots aren't in great condition. Watch out for pot holes, etc.
Banshee has two dining rooms and two bars, front and back. They also have a patio/deck, but it wasn't in use during our visit. The vibe and decor are very "EAV" in that it's eclectic and unpretentious. The spaces have exposed brick, ceilings, ductwork, etc., and are well worn, giving the place character. In terms of dress code, I don't think there is one. Come as you are. This place is great for special occasions. I took my wife for her birthday and we made a romantic date night out of it. All of the tables were candlelit and we enjoyed the fun and diverse playlist.
Food-wise, the menu was relatively small with only a handful of selections in both the appetizer and entree sections. Below is a list of what we had. It should give you a good idea of what Banshee has to offer and what the prices are like. We ordered four of the restaurant's five apps, half of the sides (1/2), and all of the desserts (2/2). We had leftovers.
Cocktails
* Stately Hag ($14) - tequila, Strega, Cocchi Americano, lemon, thyme
* Butterfly Knife ($14) - Alpe Genepy, sloe gin, apple brandy, lemon, angostura
* Killer of Caerbannog ($13) - Hoodoo Chicory, Chairman's Reserve Spiced rum, carrot + coconut, angostura
Begin
* Fry Bread ($10) - pepperoni butter, sesame, scallion
* Grilled Corn Ribs ($14) - corn stracciatella, cumin + cilantro butter, lime
* Mushroom Toast ($14) - glazed maitake, shishito jam, Parmesan cream, grilled focaccia
* Shallot Tart Tatin ($15) - whipped brebis cheese, salmon roe, chervil
Continue
* Duck Confit ($37) - charred eggplant caramelle, caponata, hakurei turnip, cherry jus
* New York Strip ($49) - Jimmy Nardello peperonata, crispy potatoes, black garlic + shoyu butter
Growing Now
* Charred Cabbage Salad ($12) - grilled tofu skin, shishito, crispy garlic, lime vinaigrette, toasted coconut
Finish
* Honeycrisp Apple Mochi ($10) - vanilla cremeux, apple chips, cider caramel
* Tres Leches Tiramisu ($11) - amaretto creme, thyme salt
Everything was phenomenal. It seems they perfected every cocktail and every dish. The execution was on point. Also, everything was presented beautifully. Just wow, all around. There's a fine attention to detail here and I'm sure that's played a large part in Banshee's success.
The cocktails were terrific. The Stately Hag was pretty. The Butterfly Knife was like a variation of the lemon drop; sweet and tangy. The Killer of Caerbannog, named after a rabbit in Monty Python and the Holy Grail, was sweet and thick. It was like a dessert drink, but actually went well with dinner. It was my favorite drink of the three.
Our favorite dish was the Mushroom Toast. We love mushrooms (especially me) and, simply put, the Mushroom Toast was an explosion of umami/flavors and appetizing textures. I'm not big fan of corn on the cob, but I loved the Grilled Corn Ribs. To me, it was a play on corn on the cob, but split into and eaten as multiple smaller pieces, like ribs. Again, the flavors were incredible.
The Shallot Tart Tatin was savory and distinctive. The whipped brebis cheese, made from sheep's milk, was shaped like the Michelin Guide logo. Coincidence? The Fry Bread came with Banshee's popular pepperoni butter. It's so popular, the restaurant sells it by the pint ($10/pint). The bread and butter went perfectly together.
The Duck Confit was amazing. The duck was tender and tasty. The caramelle (candy-shaped pasta) was al dente. I requested the New York Strip medium rare and it came out perfect. What was most memorable about this dish was the side of potato spheres, accompanied with some sort of cream sauce that had the velvety texture of ricotta. It was delectable.
The Charred Cabbage Salad was some of the best cabbage I've had, anywhere. I loved all the different textures (crispy and crunchy) and flavors.
Both desserts were superb. We preferred the Honeycrisp Apple Mochi because it was unique. My wife described it as a deconstructed apple hand pie, but if the crust was fried mochi. The Tres Leches Tiramisu was creamy and not too sweet. It was the best of both worlds.
Service was great. Our server was Tasmia and she took excellent care of us. All of the staff we interacted with greeted us with a smile.