This is a staple of my childhood. I grew up next to the one on 4th Ave in Bay Ridge before they moved and went to this location years ago. There's no other place that does a bagel the way they do. They have these marks/print at the bottom of the bagels they give it an extra texture crunch to them. My standard order as a kid was always a bagel with cream cheese toasted and it's always warm, gooey, and sometimes messy but guaranteed delicious! They're a local spot in in Bay Ridge and everyone will double park at the bus stop, across the street, or by the hydrant to grab their order. Cops won't even give you a ticket because they're also going in for some breakfast. They offer a wide variety of options: blueberry, croissants, muffins, rainbow, pumpkin, everything bagel, etc. They have different spreads of flavors. Occasionally I'll treat myself to a salmon lox bagel and it's worth every penny. Egg sandwiches are great and they can do any combo you're looking for. Now my standard order is an amazing crunchy toasted sesame bagel with cream cheese (sometimes i'll also throw in some scallions). Best bagel in New York City. read more

Bagel Boy - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Nothing better than a hot fresh bagel, with you favorite spread on top. Especially when you wake up to a few inches of snow. Today I had a multi grain bagel with scallion cream cheese and large Hazelnut hot coffee! Bagels for breakfast on a cold winter day! Gives me the warm feelings on the inside, when then the cold snow is coming down outside. Happy Shoveling! read more

See all

This is our favorite breakfast bagel place in bay ridge. This time I came in at 7:30am on a Saturday and ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel toasted and a sausage and egg in a whole wheat everything bagel for my partner. The sandwich also allowed you to get a free drip coffee which I took them up on. I ordered and paid, and waited around the register to get my food. It was quick and seamless. The bagels are are so fluffy and I love it! It usually gets busier around 9-10am so come early! read more

It's been a minute since I've had a bagel from Bagel Boy. Bagel Boy, hands down, has the best bagels in New York City. Come at me. I grew up eating their bagels from the Sheepshead Bay location and even in Bay Ridge, they are still A+. This morning I had delivered an egg everything bagel with flavored cream cheese and fresh lox [$10.75]. It just doesn't get any better than this. The bagels from Bagel Boy are on another level. They're big, they're crunchy on the outside, and pillowy and fluffy on the inside. They're great even just by themselves. The lox was super fresh. There was a generous amount piled on. The cream cheese, I suspect, was vegetable cream cheese which added a nice bit of texture. Delivery was fast and they left the bag outside my door. Huzzah for COVID safety. read more

Bagel Boy - Egg Everything Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese and Fresh Lox [$10.75] - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

With the exception of a few workers, this place is awful. When they're busy, they constantly mess up orders, take forever, very sloppy. One of the workers is rude, ALWAYS messes up the order, even after repeating it, and rolls his eyes when I repeat the order because I know he'll mess it up. Place is small, and gets crowded too fast especially since the staff isn't competent or able to keep up. I rather get frozen bagels than deal with the staff here. You stink bagelboy. read more

If you are in Bay Ridge there is no other bagel store to come to! Hands down best bagels in Brooklyn!!

It took over 30mins to get our food after we ordered, I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a roll and there was one piece of bacon throughout the whole sandwich and it was cold. The cheese had already turned solid and greasy. It obvious the sandwich was ready well before they gave it to me read more

Out-of-towner here. My son-in-law told me, "We are a Bagel Boy house" and I can see why. He brought home an assortment of savory and sweet bagels. I had both the poppy seed and the everything bagel during my stay. Great chewy outside and tender outside - an excellent bagel that is ready for whatever topping you'd like. Try it today; you won't be sorry. read more

Best bagels in bay ridge. Chewy and big! My daughters love their rainbow bagels with cream cheese! read more

Bagel Boy - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great place to visit when I stay with my son , service is fast and reliable. I love all the variety.

While our clothes were being washed in the laundry room. My husband and I went to Bagel Boy for a meal. This time we got a bagel with whipped cheese. Delicious and hearty read more

Bagel Boy - Inside - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

My favorite bagels in Brooklyn! Their selection is wide and have great specialty sandwiches like the Peter Luger or Surf & Turf if you're looking for some recommendations. They always have a line but their service of quick and organized. read more

See all

Lovely bagel spot in brooklyn, easy sidewalk parking and you can order over the phone (during COVID). Lots of snack options. The bagels and sandwiches were actually super delicious, better than most places. read more

Quick. Delicious. Easy to get to for pickup and just as quick when you have it delivered...AND there isn't a single thing they won't make for you here, THEY HAVE EVERYTHING!!!! Even if there seems to be a line don't get flustered...the amazing staff will take your order and get you out of there in No Time...A MUST TRY IF YOU HAVEN'T BEEN. IF YOU HAVE BEEN WELL YOU ALREADY KNOW read more

Bagels are really fresh from here. They sat in the bag for about an hour after I picked them up and still tasted warm and good as new. Good quality and store is fine. read more

To toast of not to toast? According to a NY Times article, the Mayor, Bill De Blasio crossed into treacherous territory when he said his go-to bagel was whole wheat with extra cream cheese. Toasted! Whatever side of this bagel argument you might be on. One thing is for certain. Bagel Boy is the best kept secret in New York City. My favorite location is Bay Ridge. Hands down, Bagel boy has the best Fresh Lox and cream cheese bagel for the price ($8.00). Of course you can add tomatoes, capers, and onions but that will cost you a bit extra. You can even get a different flavored cream cheese. It's totally up to you. Let's be honest. I don't know why these other well known bagel spots around the city get so much play. My recommendation is for you to avoid the tourist traps and long lines for a fresh lox bagel. Even a regular toasted bagel with cream cheese will not break the bank at $3.50. Save your money and come on down to Bay Ridge. Your culinary dinning experience will be worth your journey. read more

Came here on early Saturday morning 7/25 (around 7am) to grab quick breakfast because our friend was going to give birth. Her water broke and we know that once you enter the hospital, it'll be a long wait and awhile before she can eat. She wanted a bagel and juice so we came here to get what she wanted so she can eat in the car on the way to the hospital. We ordered: 3 bagels (2 with cream cheese/ 1 with butter) 1 hot tea 2 OJ 1 Apple Juice My butter bagel didn't have alot of butter (the initial spread already melted into the bagel and now is dry). Overall quick and great service! Good fast breakfast. read more

This is the best bagel store in Brooklyn the breakfast is delicious but the best part is the cashiers. They are the most pleasant and helpful team I have ever seen. Makes my morning even better. Highly recommend this place. Kudos to the owners for running this type of service. read more

The best tasting bagel in NYC. That is all. But yelp requires more than one sentence to consider it a posted review. Even their salads are good. Love their cream cheeses. Food is always fresh. read more

I use to like this spot; however I have been there a few times in the last month, and my orders are always wrong. I will not be using this place again. read more

Amazing food. Amazing service! The people were so kind and locals raved about this place! All for good reasons read more

Bagel Boy - THE BEST BAGEL I HAVE EVER HAD!!! Visited New York and locals recommended it. Amazing people amazing food - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Some of the best bagels in Bayridge! Huge variety, great taste, good and friendly service. My go to is toasted sesame seed bagel with scallion cream cheese. Always perfectly done and at a decent price. read more

Came here a few weeks ago while my friend from Montreal visited to settle who has the best bagel. We had friendly and quick service and ended up getting an everything bagel with regular cream cheese. The bagel is absolute heaven. The bagel itself is warm and fluffy and has a nice salted and buttery taste to it. Okay, I'm salivating so I'll stop now, but wow. New York is clearly the one with the better bagels, definitely will be coming back! read more

Bagel Boy - lightly toasted everything bagel with cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Was craving a chicken salad and stopped by since I always hear nothing but good things from this place. Ordered an iced coffee and my sandwich and I'd give it a 3/5. The chicken salad itself was too sweet ... never had anything like that I honestly did not like it. Iced coffee wasn't my favorite either. I've had panini's from here before which were really good but I honestly would not get what I got today again. read more

Yum! These bagels are perfectly Brooklyn. Hit up Bagel Boy for a fantastic (and v tasty) experience! I highly recommend it. My visit was during a COVID: The staff are all rocking masks, which is great, but the social distancing is non-existent. Part of that is because the ship is just too small for it, but I found myself wishing that it was being enforced by the staff members. I still recommend this shop, just be aware of the amount of time you're spending in here and how close people are. read more

Bagels are always fresh and perfectly made. The coffee is good too. There sandwiches are tasty. read more

- VERY! busy in the mornings - the turnover is fast tho - for as busy as they are, they are sure to maintain a standard of service It could be very easy for them to be assholes - The chick of the chicken sandwich was fresh and soft - the bagel was perfectly crispy on outside while being soft on inside - the inside of bagel was soft without being under done - the chicken sandwich could use more vinaigrette the vinaigrette was good tho - as was the coffee read more

Really expert service. Always fresh. Pricey but it good quality. There are lots of kinds of cream cheeses and bagels. Old fashion cups of pudding and jello bring me back to time with my grandparents. The lox cream cheese onion sandwiches are a fave of ours. read more

Super clean store ,delicious bagels , and super speedy friendly service what more can you ask for ?

Bagel Boy always has fresh bagels and an excellent assortment of Bagel toppings, beverages and other snack food too. Their lines are ling,Ling, good reason- but because they're extremely organized and have a great team behind the counter, it moves rather quickly. read more

1. Really good bagels! Soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside. Perfect balance. 2. Lots of spread options. 3. Quick and efficient. Maybe five minutes in and out with a short line. 4. Service was friendly 5. I got an everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. My go to. It didn't disappoint. My friend got bagel and lox and she said the salmon was fresh. read more

Bagel Boy - Everything bagel with veggie cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Bagel Boy's bagels was perfect!!! I can't believe how great a bagel can be! I ordered the Everything Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese one morning for breakfast. One bite into the bagel, this was the best bagel I have EVER HAD! The spices on the everything bagel had a pleasant aroma that makes you feel like you're in a spice store. The dough of the bagel was super soft and easy to chew on. The scallion cream cheese's texture was so smooth and it definitely dominated your taste buds. The mix of scallion and cream cheese really worked well together as it brings out the fresh taste! The bagels do tend to come with a lot of cream cheese so if you can't handle much dairy like me, make sure you specify. The prices are very fair for it's delicious taste! They have a wide variety of cream cheese options such as Strawberry, Scallion, Lox, vegetable, and etc. The bagel choices are your everyday - Everything, Pumpernickel, Sesame seeds, etc. This is located in a very quiet neighborhood but it's easy to find since it's in the corner! read more

Bagel Boy - Bagel with scallion cream cheese! Coffee as well! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Being a born and raised SoCal girl, I wasn't blessed with daily fresh bagels as every native New Yorker has. My take on the best bagels were the packages of Sara Lee's from my local grocery store LOL. So after being here in recent years, I've been addicted to fresh bagels-- trying local delis here in Brooklyn and Manhattan and trust me, Bagel Boy is DEF the best in town!! Totally tops Pick a Bagel in the city. Been to both locations-- Avenue Z where you can actually sit down with friends and family (although it does get really crowded on the weekends--but hey it doesn't take long to eat bagels and sandwiches so the seat turnover time is fast). The 3rd avenue location has no seating and it's on a busy street, but like most say, if you can't find parking-- just quickly double park and go in. It's quick to get your food even if there's a line. They have the biggest selection of bagels, cream cheeses, and their heroes (the big blue)are delish too! read more

Bagel Boy - The 3rd avenue location - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Loved their bagels but $21 for veggie cream cheese is abut excessive! Get the bagel an shop over to Brooklyn market for the spreads. Dozen bagel with two flavore cream cheese for $47 is over the top. Even plain cream cheese is $10/lb! read more

Bagel Boy - 2lb Vegetable Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been impressed with a certain counter person's ability to creatively screw up my order. I say poppy seed bagel, not toasted. Little bit of scallion cream cheese, and lox. I get a toasted sesame with a pound of vegetable cream cheese and lox. I say pastrami on a hero, with mustard. I get roast beef with muenster. This last time really cinched it for me. First I check to see if they're there, and I was genuinely happy for a whole two minutes that my order might come out correct. But then they pop out of the side of the counter. That person is really short, but I swear I think it was like they were hiding. I gave my order, italian hero, easy on the mortadella extra vinegar and oil. They showed me as they were making it. But it didn't register what they were doing. So when I got home, I threw it in the fridge handled my stuff for the day, and when I opened it up... There was nothing in the sandwich. Just mortedella, making it completely inedible. It was also past their closing time so I couldn't even call to get my money back. I like this place, but if I see that counter person there, I'm just going somewhere else. I also knocked off a few stars for closing too early. Come on, guys 6pm? You used to be open 24 hours on the weekends. read more

we ordered very delicious bagels from here. a wide variety of options, fast service, and nice bagel boys (and other bagel folk). would recommend! read more

There isn't much to say ... they do have very good bagels. I can't decide which I like more bagel boy or bagel Schmagel (probably spelling it wrong) read more

Bagel Boy - Blueberry Bagel With Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great bagels, always consistent. Service is fast even if the line is long. Pretty good coffee too. Everyone in the neighborhood knows bagel boy! read more

Don't bother going to this place, the store was empty and I was the only one waiting to be served. The employees were to busy playing games to ask if I needed help. I definitely will not be back to this place. read more

They were fast and the bagels were huge I have not tried the cheeses yet but they looked fresh read more