I am unsure why this place got such low reviews. I honestly will say they made the best bagels I've had. Huge and lots of flavor with amazing texture. Sure it doesn't offer a dozen different types of cream cheese spreads but I am a traditionalist when it comes to these things. Plain cream cheese or even low fat cream cheese is enough. They do offer cream cheese with raisin and maybe one or two other flavors. I find that sometimes it's best to not fix what is not broken. I also feel this bagel place is much better than the popular tourist traps like Utopia bagels and Liberty bagels. This in itself is a chain and I do find it interesting that each and every single one of their stores look different from one another. But anyways, come get their bagels. It's huge, affordable and most of all delicious! read more

I really like to stop here for bagels and coffee. Always a friendly atmosphere and quick service. I can always count on fresh delicious bagels and coffee that brightens my day. I need to remember to take a picture. I get so excited I forget, lol. read more

Given my location, the overall taste, and the value, I'd say this is my favorite bagel place in Fort Hamilton. Service is usually quick, though at the usual busy times there can be a bit of a wait. The BEC is always nicely filled, and when I ask for hot sauce (as I usually do), they put a good amount, unlike some other places nearby. Also, they toast their bagels just a little more than others so the outside has a nice crispness, while the inside was still soft. I feel like this place costs maybe 25 cents more than others in the area but it feels worth it. Ambiance is what it is: there are a few tables for people to sit at, but the vast majority are there to order and go. Great local spot. read more

I ordered a sandwich and a banana smoothie from Bagel Supreme. When the order arrived, the smoothie was missing. I asked the delivery lady about it, but she couldn't speak English, so I called the restaurant directly. When I asked them what happened, they said, "Oh, we canceled it and called you"--which was not true; I never received a call. I asked why they canceled it, and the guy just said, "We canceled it and gave you a refund." When I asked if they could still send the smoothie, he responded in an angry voice, "I canceled it, and I gave you a refund--what don't you understand?" Extremely rude. I will not be ordering from this place again. read more

FOOD POISONING second time in 2 months after eating the bacon in a sandwich. Idk if it's the pork or contaminated uncleaned utensils used with again with cooked food. It's a shame It happened twice to me now so Im leaving a review. read more

The bagel was nice, no complaints there. But paying was fairly easy UNTIL I went to my banks website and found they charged me $10.82 even though my receipt said $10.50. I don't know why there was a difference. It doesn't seem correct to be tax. And I left a cash tip. And whatever it was, I believe it should have been stated on the receipt. I wonder how many others have had extra money show up on their receipts. read more

This small and seemingly hidden bagel shop sells some decent bagels. Stopped by at around 1:30 pm for an everything bagel with lox and scallion cc. Since their bagels weren't as fresh at 1 pm as they would be in the morning, we asked them to warm them up lightly. A light warming made them taste just fine. The bagels had a nice crisp exterior with a chewy interior, were large, and nicely seasoned. Bagel sandwiches are filled generously but perhaps a bit too much? While their bagels themselves are worthwhile, I personally didn't like their cream cheese. It was so stiff and sat on the bottom of my bagel like a block of cream cheese rather than a smear. I had to remove most of the cream cheese to actually enjoy the sandwich. We also ordered two bagels with bacon, eggs, and cheese but they seemed to forget the cheese. While service is friendly, they are slightly slow. To be honest, if you'd like to dine from here, I'd suggest a bagel with butter and no further. For a bagel sandwich, I'd visit another bagel place. read more

Bagel Supreme - Everything bagel with lox and scallion cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

First time trying it here and I called ahead to order a sandwich and when I arrived it was ready to go barely any wait which was great and kind workers. When i opened the sandwich the ham was 1/4 inch thick. I didn't see this until after I brought it home. I usually don't have to specify thickness when ordering a sandwich at a deli but here you need to if you like your cold cuts thin read more

Quick, friendly service with good bagels and coffee. Not sure what else you need from a neighborhood bagel spot!

Great little spot for a quick and yummy breakfast. Staff is always friendly and orders come out in a timely manner. My favorite is a toasted sesame bagel with lox spread but we've also tried their breakfast sandwiches and breakfast burritos and been happy with what we got. It's my go to bagel spot in Bay Ridge. read more

Bagel Supreme - the inside of a bagel sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is trash. I ordered from them, and they messed up my order several times. I went to buy a parfait, and it had mold all over it, I checked the other ones, and they were the same. My sandwich was ordered with cheese, and they gave me no cheese. I call, and they have the nerve to tell me they put cheese. When I'm sitting there, eating a dry ass salami and egg sandwich. Like, excuse me, I know what the he'll I'm eating! DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY read more

Stopped by to get a bagel fix! Got a toasted plain bagel with lox cream cheese spread. I love the bagels here, they're so fluffy on the inside and have a nice crispy crunch on the outside. Also enjoy that this place does sandwiches, wraps and has a large beverage/snack section to compliment your bagel. read more

Decent bagels, decent prices, good coffee. What more do you need? Cash only! Friendly staff, egg sandwiches for under $5.00 (hey it's bay ridge) come grab yourself some food quick breakfast. It's better than most in the area. read more

Crazy out of control new guys charging unjustified prices for example: toasted bagel with lettuce, 2 eggs and bacon for $7 and toasted bialy with lettuce and tomato also $7, are you kidding me? The lady who was always there with the previous crew, they were the best, no wonder the store was empty when I walked in today. Will not be going there soon read more

This is my go-to spot for bagels! They carry a great variety of bagels. The bagels are chewy, loaded with toppings (except for the plain ones) and a decent size. I've gotten a dozen bagels from this place before and they keep well in the fridge. Each bagel is $1 each but I think if you buy them by the dozen they are cheaper. read more

Stopped here for a quick late breakfast on a Sunday morning. I'm not really a huge bread person but I had just ran the United Airlines NYC Half Marathon so I was down for anything. I saw the bagels with white powder all over them and asked what flavor they were. They were the French Toast bagels. I, of course, only got one because they are huge. It was the best bagel I had ever had in my whole entire life. I know... sounds extreme right? I'm not kidding though. I got it toasted with butter and killed the whole thing! I'm glad I don't live close to there or I would definitely be eating too many bagels in my future. read more

Bagel Supreme - French Toast Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I mistakenly came here Sun 12/10 for a too good to go pick up order (that was actually at a place a few blocks away). The employees tried to kindly and patiently explain to me that something must have been wrong, but I was still waking up and easily confused. I acted like an a**, and they were very kind and nice, as they always are. I couldn't make it back to apologize in person, but I can definitely confirm that the employees are nice and try to be helpful. And the coffee and food we've gotten have always been good. My kid a big fan of the muffins. read more

This Place Sucks!!! I live in the neighborhood...In the past month I have gone in there 3 different times around 1:30 PM....each time I asked for a tuna hero...I was told they have no more Tuna until the next day. I don't understand..maybe because they close at 3PM... they put it away..I have no idea.. .and don't want to be bothered!! I was in there today 1/05/24...How can they not have tuna everytime I went in there??? Plus today..I'm standing there and just being ignored for close to 10 minutes!!! One girl in there is cleaning equipment. The other guy that was sweeping finally helped me...I am a senior citizen 62 years old!! In all of my life I was made to feel absolutely HORRIBLE!!! If these people don't like there jobs they should quit!!! NEVER WILL I WALK IN HERE AGAIN!!!!! ABSOLUTELY DISGRACEFUL!!! read more

This place has amazing workers. Unfortunately the new owner/manager is horrible. He never wears a mask while all his workers do. He also treats them with a disgusting and demeaning matter, talks down on them with no respect. read more

The bagels are good but the service is horrible! Three times we ordered in person and they did not get our order right. Check your orders before leaving! And why do they still have grade pending for 2020? read more

Awesome bagels and friendly helpful staff.Lots of interesting flavors of cream cheese.The veggie cream cheese and jalapeno cream cheese are delicious and fresh. read more

Bagel Supreme - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'm not sure what the history of this place is, but it sure is good now! You can see it has been renovated, even the name has changed to Bagels Supreme. A bagel store most present itself in a way that makes you feel you can pick any bagel from the batch and get a good one, this place does that. The bagels are separated but in a neat way, and you can tell which ones are fresh because they are in open air and visibe and not hidden in a glass case I ordered an egg bagel with cream cheese and an arizona iced tea, came out to $2.99 which is fine by me considering what other places charge. The bagel was chewey just the way i like it and the cream cheese was cool which makes it taste better. They have boars head deli meats and other items like gourmet muffins. Staff was friendly and multi-ethnic with an Italian guy, an Asian woman and a Spanish woman. I really like this store and i will take a trip back when i'm in the area. read more

Bagel Supreme - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been here many times and it's still the best place in bay Ridge for bagels They renovated and have a huge selection of quick food items to go Bagels and now offer a wide range of baked goods My go to is the Dozen Bagels with a couple of sandwiches and some specialty cream cheeses for the bagels Check it out and leave the credit card home or you will checkout way over what you really need read more

A great neighborhood shop with excellent bagels. No frills -- just a good local shop. I am required to stop there whenever I travel to visit out of town relatives. If I don't show up with a dozen bagels they send me away! read more

They delivered very fast, my sandwich was perfectly made and was delicious. I ordered a toasted multigrain bagel with bacon egg and cheese. It was superb. read more

Last week bought a few bagels and they were good. This week they taste like mold , throwing them in the trash. Will never go Back again. Disgusting!!! Cashier was extremely unfriendly to add to the insult I of wasting my money. read more

Terrible terrible store. So expensive ( 5$ ) for an egg sandwich. I ordered a bacon, egg and cheese sandwich on a plain bagel. The bagel was undercooked & stale. This store was my favorite spot to go. I am not going there any more. I guess it's new owners. And their service is too slow. read more

Place used to be fantastic. Bagels are still good, but they do not use real butter. I asked for butter, menu states butter, charged for butter but it is a substitute that leaves an oily pasty grit on your tongue. Go back to butter, you can't be saving that much. read more

On the corner of 94th Street and Fifth Avenue, between Staples and the subway. I hadn't been in that area in a while, and it was the first time I noticed the shop. They missed on all counts. Self-serve coffee in the front was cold. The bagel tasted like ordinary bread. Butter on the bagel was barely detectable. Prices were high. There was no liner in the trash can, so I carried out my trash with me. I'll stop somewhere else next time! read more

I love to go and get a fresh bagel every now and then but sometimes when u see something like the lady there using one glove all day long than u asked if she changed it before giving what you need she goes mad its very simple just change the gloves you can't touch meat and bread with the same glove. I asked for a bagel than she went grab the bagel with the gloves she is using making hamburger for someone else am like please change the glove she goes ok than wait am the only one working all day .... its simple people read more

Came here for the second time both times horrible....why I tried it again.. I have no idea. Asked for a grilled Cesar chicken wrap got a salad with chicken on it way to much salad dressing and soggy lettuce. I even pointed to the picture. My fault for coming here again after the water down coffee i got the first time. I learned my lesson never again.. read more

Whole wheat everything with regular cream cheese for $2 total. Bagel was fresh and tasty. Will come back the next time I take the R train from here. read more

Bagel Supreme - Whole wheat Everything (1/4 of the bagel) - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

When the owner is there, everything is great. Food is great tasting if only they can get my order right!! I've given them the courtesy after they messed up my order 3 times but now it's every single time I go in I've never left with my order right. And when I let them know they just say oh but this is what you ordered.. I'm sorry. Any other place will correct it instead of saying I'm sorry and not even admitting to their wrong. I wont accept it anymore. I pay expecting to eat what I ordered, not what THEY ordered. Fix this read more

Waaaaay rude. The cashier didn't communicate clearly for an order and instead of offering what I'm PAYING to order - a toasted bagel with butter, she just looked at me dumbfounded and asked if I wanted to microwave my bagel. Lady. Get a clue. read more

Best bagels in Bay Ridge, possibly Brooklyn! So fortunate they are just a couple blocks from me and really close to the subway. A super convenient spot for on-the-go breakfast and coffee. I recommend the sausage, egg and cheese sandwich on plain or sesame, or, plain bagel toasted with butter. Only downside is they are cash only but it's worth planning a trip to the ATM for Bagel Supreme! read more

This is a newly renovated, family run bagel business at the fork of 4th and 5th avenue in Bay Ridge. The new layout is spacious enough to allow for a line formation with visible digital menus and about 3-4 tables. I think they could have benefit from furniture that is more inviting. Nevertheless, my experience is always a bagel breakfast to go comprised of delicious and decorated sesame bagel with vegetable cream cheese ($3.00.) This may sound weird, but because these bagels are so filling I usually have half left which tastes better the day after!? Maybe the cream cheese is too fresh and the flavor of the veggie bits have a chance to seep into the cream. Don't get me wrong, too fresh is never a complaint! Stop by for a bagel or what look to be delicious wraps, a carton of OJ and get your day rolling. There is diagonal metered spots across the street, but you will probably be in and out within 5 minutes so if you like to live life on the edge, save your quarter ;] One thing I'd hope they improve upon is their hot coffee which is usually a bodega style small cup with a gross amount of milk and sugar though YMMV. read more

Great fluffy BIG and fresh bagels. I am a big fan especially after having sub par bagels next to my apartment. I am willing and wanting to walk the extra blocks for this bagel place. The only reason I don't give it five stars is because they're cash only which is a minor inconvenience besides that awesome bagels and awesome customer service! read more

While the place might have two or more names (the sign says "Bagel Supreme" but this Yelp listing doesn't), I can honestly say these are some of the best bagels I have ever had, and I've lived in Brooklyn my entire life. Each bagel is handmade, and it shows. No two bagels are the same shape. The flavor that is embedded in these bagels is perfect. Each bite is doughy by not too doughy, slightly sweet, fluffy, and well-balanced for whatever spread you happen to choose. I have had their egg, everything, whole wheat everything and poppy seed bagels, and I have not been disappointed on any of them. I almost always get their tuna salad, which also happens to be delicious and not over-dressed. You actually taste that it is tuna, as opposed to mayo with a little but of fish thrown in for good measure. Few things will get me to take the trip all the way to the end of the R line in Brooklyn just for the hell of it. These bagels are one of those things. HIGHLY recommended, 100%. read more

I've often gone to Supreme Bagel on my way home. After today I'm very concerned and will never be back. I stopped in around 5:30pm on Feb 27th. The employee was vacuuming and **took out the trash** before taking my order. I told him what I wanted and he went behind the counter and immediately started making it without washing his hands or putting on gloves. I was appalled and told him he just took the trash out and needs to wash his hands. He rolled his eyes. Turned on the sink, got them wet and turned the sink off. He never used soap. I was horrified an employee was so cavalier about handling trash and then serving a customer food. He needs to be fired and all employees need to be reminded the importance and THE LAW to wash hands. read more

Nice and fresh bagels...make your coffee the way you like it... Staff are lovely and so friendly... Place is clean... Environment is amazing for a good breakfast.. I tried cinnamon raisin bagel with olive cream cheese...and it was really good.. read more

Bagel Supreme - Turkey bacon, egg and cheese ;) - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York