Been loving the sandwich selections and the chicken noodle soup here. I'm a sucker for a good soup…read moreand this hits the spot, especially since it comes with toasted buttered bread - started having my husband pick up quarts of it to share. I've tried the avocado, fresh lox and capers on a sesame bagel, the Egg Salad wrap and the California wrap. My husband has gotten the avocado, fresh lox, lettuce, tomato, pesto mayo. All selections were great. Ironically though, for a bagel place, I was less impressed with the bagels. They're pretty tiny. We got my mom an untoasted whole wheat bagel with butter and she thought it was skimpy. Staff is friendly but be careful with the new cashier who seems unfamiliar with the menu. My husband said he caught him accidentally overcharging him on two separate occasions.

Quick and efficient delivery, reasonable prices and tasty bagels and salads. Their egg salad is…read morequite yummy, seasoned well and not too wet.

Let me just start this out by saying I am a lox fiend. I have a thing about lox-to-cream cheese…read moreratios. Bagel Boy does their toppings *the right way*. If you're like me and you want a standard lox bagel sandwich with all the fixings (tomato, capers, onion, cream cheese), this is the right place to go. When I casually mention how much I love Bagel Boy, Bagel heads may scoff that they are not "hand rolled" bagels like at H+L (oh heaven forfend!) but, respectfully, the bagels are made fresh on site, perfectly tasty, and, to be quite honest, I couldn't care less about the actual bagel--which, to be clear, is also delicious! What I DO care about is that their lox is buttery, smooth, and not too salty. I don't have any other order but the one I specified above. It's huge and you get a lot of sandwich for about $12.50. As for the bagel, I tend to go for an onion or an everything. This is my Bay Ridge Bagel verdict: spare yourself the headache of subpar lox and have the ideal bagel sandwich experience at Bagel Boy.

Bagel Boy at 8002 3rd Avenue is nothing short of a bagel‑centric marvel--an establishment that…read moresomehow manages to defy the laws of texture and physics simultaneously. Their bagels are puffy and fluffy, yet dense, chewy, and satisfyingly weighty, as though engineered by a team of carbohydrate physicists determined to perfect the Platonic ideal of a bagel. The Egg‑Everything bagel, in particular, should come with a disclaimer: "May induce sudden optimism." One bite and your entire day recalibrates itself toward hope, productivity, and the general belief that life, in fact, is good. The flavor selection borders on encyclopedic, and the cream cheese options feel infinite enough to require a tasting syllabus. Their sandwiches--excuse me, sammiches--are inventive, clever, and genuinely delicious, the kind of creations that make you briefly consider writing a thank‑you note to the chef. In short: Bagel Boy is a neighborhood treasure. Go once, and you'll understand. Go twice, and you'll start rearranging your morning routine around it. Disappointment simply isn't on the menu.

Bagels were great!! As well as cream cheese spreads definitely made fresh on house. Great find on…read moreour first day in New York

This spot is super busy in the morning and the line got so long. Probably because only a third of…read morethe workers are actually working. They also only accept cash which is inconvenient.

I stopped in last Thursday to grab a bite before heading home. I bought a lightly toasted…read morepumpernickel bagel with vegetable cream cheese ($4). I ate it when I got home and it was delicious. I may get it again. The service was good. I'm so happy this place opened up in this neighborhood. I don't have to venture far for bagels now.

Never go back again .. they charge me 13% credit card service fee without inform me .read more

I come to the Bagel Factory over and over again for the great service and egg and cheese croissant…read more The croissant is made in-house, and has just the right amount of flakiness and buttery flavor. The egg is fluffy, and the melted slice of American cheese ties everything together nicely. The staff is also friendly, and they get your order out fast- which is great if you're grabbing something quick on your morning commute.

Was in the area running errands. Family member was hungry. Suggested we stop in here and glad we…read moredid. We were definitely overwhelmed with so many flavors of dairy and non-dairy spread . Everything looked delicious! My suggestion is to look at menu and know what you want beforehand. The bagels were soft and chewy. I had one toasted with eggs and onions and I had the "spectacular". Both were good. The spectacular was refreshing! Lox, onions, capers, tomatoes and a scallion cream cheese on a sesame seed bagel! Delicious! They have a pretty big friendly staff. Bagels are made on premises. The place is for take out, but they do have two benches outside. The coffee was decent. They have self-service or they can prepare for you! If I'm in the area I would return!

I was doubtful I'd give a 5-star review when walking in - the line of pre-prepped food…read morerefrigerators competed with the bagel counter - but I'm pleasantly surprised. I ordered a bagel toasted with lox and cream cheese and it was perfectly prepared. I had a choice between sour and half-sour pickles, and their cole slaw was excellent as well. Service was slow, but maybe that's because genuine care was put into the order. It seems the lox is sliced to order, always a nice touch. There is a small seating area toward the back. And i likely won't purchase the prepared food from those refrigerators, but I suspect what is there is made with equal care. This is a bona fide good bagel place.

Great selection of breakfast food, salads and chips. Food is good, I just wish they would post…read moreprices on their wall menu for their customers. I got the pastrami Lox which had a nice smoky flavor, and was freshly fillet'd, but did contain a bone. The sandwich cost $10.50 which was an OK value. Bagels are fresh and good, and I like that they offered jalepeno. Just wish they toasted the bagels like I asked. I'm going to try the veggie burgers next.

I ordered delivery. I wouldn't give 1-star for no reason. Here is the breakdown…read more Food: I ordered bagel with cream cheese and tomato/onion/avocado. Bread was mediocre compared to pretty much every other local bagel shop and the avocado was not ripe enough, so badly that it was rigid and impossible to chew and had to remove it from the bagel. My roommate ordered a hot sandwich and complained that his food arrived cold, but said the flavor was standard. Service: Driver arrived 40 minutes later than the maximum estimated time, then had the nerve to disregard the delivery instructions. I live on a 5-story walk-up and asked him to at least ring my apartment on the keypad so I could buzz him in and meet half-way down. He refused to buzz in and made me come all the way down 5 stories to the front door while in my pajamas to retrieve my food. Overall: Will definitely not order from here again and will warn my friends as well.

These breakfast sandwiches are everything! These staff is nice and quick. I recommend the cinnamon…read moreraisin bagel with bacon egg and cheese.

These 3 guys orchestrate your order quite harmoniously; their best sandwich imho is the pastrami…read morefootlong sub! Ask for hot peppers on the side if u wanna personally dress the amount of spice your sandwich will taste! Mmm

Best food around! Everything is extremely fresh and cooked perfectly. Employee's are very friendly…read moreand take pride in every meal they make. I've had breakfast and lunch there numerous times, the burger,hot pastrami sandwich, Omelets/home fries are some of my favorites that i can say are the best around. If you're in the area and looking for a great meal be sure to stop by you will not be disappointed!