Anthony's Cheesecake

This is a great spot to go because they have outdoor seating and I can eat with my dog in peace…read more I ordered the Cobb salad, which my fault but I should have asked for dressing on the side because it was definitely overdressed for my liking. The fries were nicely cooked and salted, but $8 was a lot for the amount given. $4 would have made more sense. And then yes, I'm even going to mention the iced tea. Because there are not very many restaurants I go to that offer a freshly brewed iced tea, which is one of my favorite drinks. It really makes the meal perfect and I appreciate a freshly brewed tea vs a canned one. Staff is nice and brought water for my dog too.

First the good: the food was cooked just as we ordered it with good portions....my husband just…read morehad a BLT but he said it could have had a pound of bacon on it?! My daughter and I split the French toast which was excellent and the Eggs Benedict (with salmon instead of Canadian bacon) also excellent?! My grandson just had scrambled eggs with toast and potatoes. Now for the not so good?! Horrible acoustics!! It was soooo loud in the dining room that we had to yell at each other and repeat ourselves to understand each other?! The coffee was forty forevers coming to the table after we ordered....and then our meal as good as it was took forever to come out. A couple seated next to us came in after us but had their food and finished and were leaving when ours FINALLY came out of the kitchen :( IF we go again we will eat outside and only in good weather.

Restaurant view

Mexican Burrito Bowl

See all

Outside eating area

The Saint Clair

4.0(69 reviews)

My group ate outside on Church Street for brunch, and we absolutely loved it! We peeked inside and…read morethe decor is modern and attractive. Our waitress was fantastic and made some great suggestions. We shared two orders of the Biscuit with butter and jam. This was heaven! So buttery and moist. The jam made it next level. I had the BLTA with Fries. The first bite was a flavor explosion in my mouth! These people know how to properly season food! Crispy bacon, juicy tomatoes, ripe avocados, all on a perfectly soft grain bread. And the fries were excellent as well! My friends all enjoyed their meals as well. They also have very fun mocktails. My friends and I tried three different types and they were all delicious. This was a standout meal. Now I can't wait to try it for dinner!

My friend and I stopped in for brunch, bottle of Prosecco in hand since it's BYOB. The space is…read morethoughtfully curated, with just the right amount of décor and whimsy. See Leo coaster. If you order anything here, let it be the duck fat tater tots! The presentation was beautiful, and the combination of salmon roe and lemon crème fraîche was simply delectable. My friend and I both ordered the market hash skillet with seasoned vegetables and burrata. Needless to say, we were very pleased with our food selection and our mimosas. The staff were welcoming and patient with all of our questions. I'm already excited to come back for dinner.

Ambiance

Avocado toast

See all

Bar nuck

Faubourg Montclair

4.2(922 reviews)

1.8 mi

This place has been on my radar for a few years but I never had a reason to go. I recently decided…read moreto come here for a wedding anniversary dinner and was blown away by the service and the food quality. Started off with oysters, wine and fresh bread. I could tell that the butter was house made and asked for extra because it was that good. Had the beef duo as the main course. I found it to be satisfying and also much better value than the steak frites. All of the items I received were very detail oriented and as well as fresh. We were seated on one side on the restaurant that I believe was blocked off for more special occasions. The other side of the restaurant seemed to have tables placed more closely to one another. Our server consistently checked on us throughout the night to make sure we were okay. Overall I was very satisfied with the service that I received here as well as with the food.

I was walking to a Japanese restaurant down the street and simply couldn't walk by. The vibe pulled…read moreme right in and after a long, busy work and travel day, it was exactly what I needed. Cool atmosphere, great energy, and good food! I also got super lucky with Hailey as my waitress. She sold me on just about every item on the menu... to the point where I completely handed over the decision-making to her. Yup, that's right, I told her what I liked and trusted her to pick my three dishes. And listen, when your name is on the menu for crafting a cocktail, I'm going to trust you to pick my meal too! Now for the food: the grilled octopus was amazing. Great flavor, perfect texture, and a really nice balance with the lentils. The shishito peppers were delicious, and the sauce that came with them added the perfect pop of flavor. The beet salad, however, was a little underwhelming. Unfortunately, it didn't have much flavor, so that one left me a bit disappointed. And then there was dessert. Oh man! Hailey did it again. She brought out the sweet corn cheesecake. Sounds weird, I know, but I had to try it. And yes, it definitely had sweet corn! It was a little too weird for my taste buds, but I'm glad I tried it.... Then came the Madeleines. Bite-sized, warm, and absolutely delicious. Fair warning: if you don't tell them to take the bowl away, you WILL eat the entire thing. Man oh man...so good!!! Overall, a really fun experience with a great atmosphere, good food, and a waitress who genuinely made the experience memorable. Kudos to Hailey for the great service and for knowing exactly what to recommend! She definitely made my night.

Inside

Side of fingerling potatoes and French fries! Always get these!

See all

Flatbread with bacon

De Novo European Pub

4.2(592 reviews)

3.4 mi

Excellent! We moved up the street not too long ago and have been meaning to check this spot out -…read morewe've been 2x already and honestly never regret it! Service, food, ambience all excellent and consistent!!! We love the sushi options (Mets roll/shrimp tempura) and the salads (pear / strawberry so good!) we also like the mussels, short rib pasta, burger and seafood risotto. Everything is excellent!! Would absolutely recommend!!!

I've been meaning to come here for years. I took the girl I used to babysit out for a dinner date…read morethis past Saturday. The menu is huge. The specials menu could have been the full menu in itself! The cocktail menu also had a lot of good options; had a hard time choosing. We started with a Shirley temple, thyme out and calamari. She had the pesto bucatini with an added burrata and I had the truffle tagliatelle from the specials menu. The thyme hot cocktail was delicious. We also got complimentary bread and marinara. The bread was soft and tasty. The calamari was light and ok. My date enjoyed her pasta; said she always gets it when she comes here. My tagliatelle pasta was DELICIOUS. The restaurant is cute and all the staff are so nice. Plenty of parking but unfortunately it's paid parking (not a deal breaker though!) Some of the options are on the pricier side but normal for the area and worth the price. Told my husband we have to come here so he can try!

Bar scene!

See all

Smokey something: mezcal lime agave

Diesel & Duke

4.4(394 reviews)

In love with thier food options. I don't feel terrible after…read moreeating here and I enjoy the ambiance and visibility of the cooks in the back. Prefer over places like 5 guys for sure

I've been wanting to try this place for awhile and was happy to stop by recently to try their…read morePistakio shake and some food items. The burger was a little over sauced for my liking but I can always tell them less next time. The fries are the way to go, beef, cheese, onions, sauce, pickles! Such a great combo and tasty. The star of the show, the milkshake was even better then I expected- would go back just for that

See all

NEW LOCATION

The Brookdale

4.0(254 reviews)

2.5 mi

The Brookdale 1099 Broad St…read more Bloomfield NJ 07003 The Big Cheese A member from my group page tipped me off about this location because I am currently working on a compilation reel about oversized menu items. This one pound mozzarella stick definitely fulfilled that criteria. It was so gigantic it was almost like getting a workout in just to lift it. The outside was heavily breaded with bread crumbs and the top was sprinkled with parmesan cheese and chopped scallions. Even the dipping cup was supersized to accommodate the diameter of the stick! Typically, I would have posted until after my I finished my oversized food compilation project. However, it's being posted early because The Brookdale is permanently closing its doors. I am truly sad to hear they will no longer be in business, but their three sister restaurants at 1109 Broad Street will still remain open. #thebrookdale #thebigcheese #bloomfieldnj

If you've seen their giant mozzarella stick online, yes it is good and worth it! I ordered the big…read moremozz and a shrimp vodka pizza ; Both were real good but too much cheese for the two of us!!! Maybe a salad with the mozz stick woulda been better! Service was good and the restaurant with low lighting was a good vibe! Its split into a half bar and half dining area which i liked. Only complaint i can think of is they didnt have many options of beer on tap as they advertised on thier menu. Overall good experience would recommend!

Rainbow cake

Tuna poke tostada

See all

Lobster tortellini

Turtle + The Wolf

4.2(391 reviews)

3.4 mi

First off, our server Larry was phenomenal. Genuine, funny, and gave us thoughtful recommendations…read more My partner and I came in for a 7pm reservation to sit at the bar area - one vegetarian, one vegan. Larry was very accommodating, and helped compose a vegan dish from the setup of another dish. He was considerate to recommend something that would feel "substantial" - something that I really appreciated. It's already a bit inconvenient to come up with a dish on the spot, but to go the extra mile by caring that it would be satisfying as a main dish was really very kind. And it turned out fantastic. This restaurant has so much going for it in the quality of its ingredients and dish compositions. I would encourage the chef to consider how the can apply their creativity to a dedicated vegan dish as well. There's a big world to explore in creating modern, high end, plant-based dishes and I think this restaurant would hit it out of the park ! :)

Had been meaning to try this establishment for some time and when i found out they did a fried…read morechicken special I booked so reservations. We were promptly seated and had our wine opened. We opted for the cucumber salad and pate which were both very good. We then split the chicken as it five pieces and comes with shishitos, biscuits and coleslaw long with several sauces. The chicken was nice and crispy with plenty of flavor, and I found the biscuits to be quite good. For the price of $50 this is an amazing value. Service was excellent and very engaging.

Shishito Peppers bbq rub | fresh lime | sea salt

See all

*Spinach and Cheese Tortelloni with Mushroom ragout *New menu item

Montclair House Grill

4.0(152 reviews)

Great Food and Service! Everything was wonderful. Perfect place to go before a show at The Wellmont.read more

Stopped on here on a Sunday morning while in the area. Beware the parking here is atrocious…read more Drove around for 25 minutes before finding a spot that was would probably have gotten me a ticket if I got caught. Montclair has horrible parking. The place itself was very nice. Standard breakfast spot with booths and tables. Very clean. Service was great. Food came out as if they read our minds. The food itself was very good. Good eggs and the omelette was very nice. The price was very reasonable for Montclair. Will definitely be back if I am in the area.

Bacon cheddar wrap with a burger

See all

Turkey bacon club

The Parkside Social

4.2(136 reviews)

3.8 mi

I love the Parkside social! They never sail to have good vegan options and wonderful drinks. The…read morestaff is all professional and good at what they do. The bartender especially! I've enjoyed meals at the bar, in the dining room, and in the side room, everywhere is nice and comfortable with good lighting and cozy seating. Thanks!

The burger was well made with a nice char. I liked the chipotle bacon jam, had a good bite. But…read morethey serve it on brioche, not pretzel bun. And there was no leek aioli. That was disappointing. The kids tenders and fries were ok. Didn't come with the honey mustard. All in all, it was ok. I ordered delivery via DoorDash, might've been better if I went in person

Inside seating

Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich

See all

Sweet nothings mocktail

Black Rabbit Saloon

4.2(173 reviews)

13.0 mi

Locally owned & operated

Casual dining

Upscale tavern with elevated bar food…read more Wings with Alabama white bbq sauce. Petite wings with a tangy white sauce. Excellent. Chopped salad - a variety of mixed greens and veggies well chopped. Nicely prepared. Blackened Mahi Mahi Tacos - 3 tacos with large chunks of fresh Mahi Mahi. Garnished with red cabbage slaw and guac. Served with a side of rice. Top notch fish tacos that I highly recommend. The exterior is adorned with beautiful plants and flowers. The interior is bright and contemporary with a farmhouse vibe. Plus plenty of perfectly positioned screens to watch your favorite game. The service was on point for the most part. Our server was great but I think he was working too many tables bye himself so we kinda missed the opportunity to order a second round of drinks. We are definitely adding Black Rabbit to our regular rotation. Give it a try.

The outside of this place- adorable. The selection of beers they had on draft and the hoppy hour…read moreall day thursdays- LOVE. The staff were super friendly and accommodating too! We got wings, which were delicious, but I'm so sorry to say, but we didn't love the food overall. With the steak dinner we got, the steak was over cooked and the fries tasted like burnt oil. The pizza also tasted like cardboard with sauce on it and the caesar salad tasted solely like anchovies. I really wanted to love the place and I do for the happy hour and drinks, and I would come back to try it again & order a burger/wrap, but I left a bit disappointed.

See more unrecommended reviews

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

27 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Annie Z.

Elite 18

109

8 years ago

Aside from Anthony's stellar, fantastic cheesecakes, they also served amazing savory pasta for $9.95 a dish on "Italian Dinner Party" nights. We ordered the fettuccine alfredo with grilled chicken along with the rigatoni pasta with sausage and tomato sauce. Both were well-seasoned and I tasted just the right hint of pepper and salt which brought out the flavors of the cheese. We finished off with two cheesecakes because we can't just have one if we're going to go now. There's something about a classic New York style cheesecake done right that really satisfies my palate. It has just the right amount of softness for the graham crust and the cheese itself was melt-in-your-mouth texture. We also got the Cookie Butter cheesecake which was a little bit rougher but also just as good. By far, caramel pecan piece trumps all with its amazing flavor profile of pecans scattered on top and drizzled with caramel glaze. Surprisingly, it is not too sweet and that is how cheesecake is done right. read more

Chris C.

13 years ago

So I had heard of Anthony's through a story on Baristanet and decided to go with my girlfriend for a Valentine Day Dinner. The restaurant is small and decorated nicely. I ordered the Chicken Dumpling Soup and Cuban pork sliders to start and for entrees we had the Veal Napolitano and Pork Osso Bucco. The meal started with a complimentary house salad which had a nice balsamic dressing. The soup was very tasty and the Cuban sliders were a great start. I am very picky with my Osso Bucco and many restaurants do not make it. The pork was so tender, fall off the bone. Great sauce full of flavor. My girlfriend loved her veal with Proscuitto , spinach, mozzarella and peppers. The place was jamming by now and the service was on point. Dessert we had the Raspberry Chambord Cheesecake and a Belgian chocolate bread pudding. WOW!!! is all I can say. We are so glad we found this small restaurant and will come back many times. Sad that they only do dinner one night a week read more

Ali B.

166

10 years ago

I had an amazing experience at Anthony's Cheesecake; one that deserved a review a lot sooner then I am just now getting too. I went to Anthony's on Mother's Day. We had not made a reservation, so of course it was packed full. I met Anthony himself who had a warm, welcomed smile and solution. He graciously offered me, my bf and mother-in-law a table outside which we did take. The accommodations were beyond nice considering what day it was. The food was delicious and the service was tremendous. I was able to get to know Anthony a bit more, finding out that he was originally from Brooklyn and you could tell his passion for his customers and business just from the way he lit up to hear that we enjoyed our visit at his restaurant. That day, Anthony's also gave all the mother's who ate at the restaurant a sweet heart shaped cake to remember their visit by. Very sweet. Thank you, again for providing my family with a great Mother's Day! Highly recommend this place. read more

Patrick C.

217

10 years ago

Came here on a Friday night for dinner ( FYI - they are open for dinner on Thursdays and Fridays). They are closed Mondays, and also open Tuesday-Sunday for breakfast/lunch. Everything about this small cafe was great.The food , the service, and the whole vibe. Really friendly staff,very personable as well.They don't make you feel like a customer, more like a friend stopping by for delicious food. They have an awesome dessert selection that they freshly make themselves everyday, nothing is frozen it's all fresh... I will definitely be coming back here for their breakfast menu,and again for dinner... Its BYOB, which is just the cherry on top of this fine family owned establishment.. read more

Dominick D.

13 years ago

There is really no better place for breakfast, lunch or dinner (Thursday night) in the area. Super friendly staff and tons of options for everyone, healthy, savory, fresh ingredients plus if you have a sweet tooth you'll be in heaven with all homemade desserts. I love coming here and alway say I can't wait to come back when were finished eating. read more

Joseph D.

10 years ago

I've found this place after moving close by and find the cheesecake as well as the lunch menu quite nice. I agree with other reviews as I had the pork empanadas as well the chicken cutlets, which were both very good. I usually go here for cheesecake which is always spot on, but great to have the option for a great and unexpected delicious lunch. read more

Veronica B.

13 years ago

The name says "cheesecake" but that's only half the story. The cheesecake at Anthony's Cheesecake is fantastic, but so are the meals. He's open for breakfast and lunch every day, and dinner on Thursdays. Everything is made to order, so be prepared to wait a bit, especially when it's busy. But the food is worth the wait - generous portions,... read more

Dan R.

15 years ago

Once you eat here you will never want to eat at another establishment ever again. The menu changes daily, and everything is homemade. Portions are generous and all this comes at a cheap price. read more

Alessia B.

5 years ago

Bueno, bonito y no tan barato..platos abundante y ricos...buena atención...y el cheese cake no se si el mejor pero estaba bien bueno...los de la foto sn el red velvet y el 30 anniversary read more

Justin P.

251

8 years ago

Honestly, the food is really good but the wait is unacceptably long all the time and the service is slow as hell. Maybe if you have a lot of time to burn on a slow Sunday, check it out. read more

Jose R.

11 years ago

Perfect place to have a good dinner and finish w a great dessert ! The service is great owners and staff the are very nice pleasant people !

Sami P.

325

11 years ago

We ate create your own omelette , french toast and chococate chip waffle. They were all very good presented , and the food was very good

Victoriya V.

14 years ago

Good customer service, always friendly. Food is delicious. What more can you ask for? At time the waiting is long, but its worth it.

Ken S.

126

10 years ago

Arrived at 8:33 on a Saturday - not open . Called no answer or answering machine. Disappointment and still hungry.

Scott W.

10 years ago

Terrific cheesecake and even better service! Definitely check out their dinner specials for hidden gems! read more

Johnson A.

8 years ago

I had a really bad experience in this place. I used to come here a lot but it's not the same it changed

Fernanda S.

218

9 years ago

I love Anthony's BLT! The cheese make a world of difference. I would absolutely bring a friend here.

Mia W.

5 years ago

Amazing quality desserts! Lovely staff ..always accommodating and helpful for last minute requests

Lillian T.

9 years ago

Great place to go for Breakfast and Lunch! They do have Sunday Brunch which is very nice.

Laila A.

9 years ago

Presentation perfect Family friendly BYOB What more can you ask for!! Friendly staff read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - tradamerican - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Coffee near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Restaurants near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Breakfast near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Desserts near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Brunch near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Things to Do near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Cocktail Bars near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Parking near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Shopping near Anthony's Cheesecake

BEST of Bloomfield, New Jersey Wineries near Anthony's Cheesecake

Best of Bloomfield

Things to do in Bloomfield

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Anthony's Cheesecake also viewed

The Corner

4.5

(1.3k reviews)

Coffee is weak. Order a cup of coffee to go they give you a small shot of espresso fill it with hot…read morewater then add some milk, coffee is weak and watery

One word... WOW. The…read moreCorner in Upper Montclair has that rare mom-and-pop feel that immediately makes you feel welcome. It's cozy, genuine, and the kind of place where you can tell there's a lot of love going into what comes out of the kitchen. And speaking of that kitchen--you can see it from pretty much every seat in the house. Watching several cooks navigate what looks like an incredibly tiny space is almost mesmerizing. Somehow, they move around each other seamlessly, and the best part? The food comes out FAST. My wife went with the hummus, and it was creamy, flavorful, and delicious. But the surprise star on the side was the salted dried kale chip--such a simple little addition, but ridiculously good. Then came my pancakes. Out of this world. Small in diameter, but super thick, with a beautifully crispy exterior giving way to an interior that was fluffy, light, and airy. I've tried making this style of pancake at home countless times, and I still have absolutely no idea how to get that texture. The syrup and berries were the perfect finishing touches. Everything just worked. I've made and had soooo many pancakes in my life, and this is easily top 3 best. The Corner is the kind of place that makes you start planning your next visit before you've even left. I'll be dreaming about getting back to this Corner.

La Fontaine Cafe

4.6

(29 reviews)

Can't speak to the food but their latte is fantaaastic!! I got the Biscoff cookie butter latte with…read moreoat milk and WOW!! I was worried it would be too sweet but the espresso comes through beautifully with that nice graham cracker cinnamon flavor in the background. If I lived nearby I would get this all the time. The lady that helped me said their lavender white chocolate latte is her fave so I'd definitely try that next time. Inside is whimsy and cozy which I love. Fast service. Really glad I got a chance to try this place during my visit.

The cutest cafe! I only stopped in for a hot Matcha oat latte & I am glad that I did. The small but…read morecozy space feels warm, spiritually protected & clean. I would definitely return when I'm back in the area. They offer a restroom along with a variety of eats & beverages. But no parking. And you do have to pay for street parking through an app service. Thank you for the pleasant experience this past Friday.

The Brunch Box

3.7

(14 reviews)

Placed order for delivery and was promised delivery before I left for work and Uber driver dropped…read morethe food off 49 minutes after I left for work. The food sat in the heat and had flies around it. I threw it out because of the likelihood of getting sick. When the chef told me Uber had not come, I told him to keep the good and he could have given it to someone else who needs to eat. I had to pay and had to throw out the food.

A small little lunch place that has been many places over the years and now it's this place…read more The ambience is small but friendly I sat at the counter so I can eat in peace the waitress was very friendly and took my order the owner was also behind the counter fixing a lot of to go orders The food was very good and fresh it took a little while because only one man cooking and he had a lot of to go orders but cooked mine fresh Since it is a very local place there was that one loud obnoxious customer that was talking to everyone very loud so could not eat in quite but what can you do Next time if he is there will get to go

Turtle + The Wolf

4.2

(391 reviews)

Artazu Bakery Cafe

4.4

(9 reviews)

I came here to get some desserts for celebrating my wife and friends birthday a few weeks ago. So…read moremuch to offer here! Food: they primarily focus on small pastries offering dulce de leche and cream filled goods. They also had a dulce de leche Napoleon style treat, which was out of this world, albeit a little messy. Service : I did not get the gentleman's name who helped me, but he really really polite and very patient with me as I was trying to understand what each pastry had to offer. Aesthetic : there is very few bakeries that I have gone to that have had so much stock in their display casings, and everything looks freshly baked. A few small seats and a lot of room.

Delicious Biscotti's, good coffee, and a variety of treats! Friendly welcoming staff. Cute cafe…read morewith a few tables and counters at the windows to watch the goings on outside.

Whisk It All

4.6

(21 reviews)

My 13 yr old and I went here for sandwiches and lattes. The restaurant was very clean and the…read moreservice was excellent. My child had the avocado toast with a fried egg and I had the tuna sandwich on a croissant. Both sandwich sandwiches were delicious and reasonably priced. We also had a Matcha latte and mocha latte. Those were amazing as well. There were convenient charging stations at each table but you have to bring your own charging cable. I would absolutely recommend this restaurant!

I love exploring cafes to work/study from! Whisk It All is a local family-owned bakery and cafe…read more It's easy to miss since it's on a quiet residential street in Glen Ridge. There's free street parking right up front. I've been here twice and both visits were positive experiences. The cafe is small, but cozy. The greenery and natural lighting make it a welcoming space to meet up with a friend over coffee and pastries or to study. There's a few tables, a couch, and stool seating facing the window. There's also free wifi and outlets. The tables are on the smaller side and the cafe isn't that big, so it's probably not best for large groups. Their menu is simple and a bit limited. Honestly... I prefer it that way! They have your core espresso drinks and a few paninis and croissant sandwiches. They bake their own pastries fresh on the premises. I recommend trying their cookies - they are huge, soft, and chewy! They also specialize in custom cakes for special occasions. Everything is reasonably priced. Baristas are sweet and efficient. They make some tasty iced lattes! The espresso is strong, but not too bitter. It has just the right balance of coffee and milk. I recently tried the Ham Solo sandwich ($10) which included scrambled egg, ham, cheddar, and avocado on a croissant with a side of chips. It wasn't bad, but I wouldn't order it again. The egg was dry and the ham and cheese tasted like those cheap, pre-sliced ones from grocery stores. If I lived closer, I could see myself stopping by more often. Check them out if you're in the area!

Brandon's Coffee Shop

4.1

(24 reviews)

The staff is very kind and welcoming and the Chicken Noodle Soup is the best I've had in years!…read moreVery tasty, full of vegetables, chicken and noodles and not too salty. I will definitely be a regular customer.

Cozy place, friendly. Some interesting dishes with Spanish or South American flair. Not your…read moretypical American coffee shop. Good sandwiches.

The Salty Cow

4.9

(20 reviews)

The sandwiches were amazing! We got the Salty Cow and the Fig and Pig. The Salty Cow is super…read morecheesy and the Pig and Fig is delicious but quite sweet. Will definitely come back another time.

I'll admit it: I was skeptical. Greg kept telling me to come down and try his mootz, that it was…read morethe best around, period. I've been in kitchens long enough to hear that claim a lot. So I finally came in with my fiancé, and we both walked out agreeing -- this is the most tender, well-seasoned, melt-in-your-mouth mozzarella you could imagine. Also his stupid cow mascot has a monocle. A MONACLE! It's a sandwich SOCIETY. And you need to join. I'm a chef. I've worked with just about every cheese under the sun and more mozzarellas than I can count -- retail, commercial, local. Nothing compares to the quality and freshness coming out of this shop. It's also remarkably versatile; I've used it across a wide range of applications in my own cooking and it holds up beautifully every time. Now the sandwiches. I am a sucker for a Thanksgiving sandwich, and The Pilgrim -- turkey, stuffing, cranberry, gravy -- was the most delectable one I've ever had, and somehow the mootz worked perfectly in it. My future husband got The Salty Cow, the hot roast beef with mozzarella, which was an absolute banger. I told him right there in the shop that he could get away with just about anything in this marriage, so long as he walks through the door with a sandwich from here. I'm using Greg for all my future events. And one more thing: if you took the time to read this whole review and you still haven't put Salty Cow in your maps app to take you there right now, you're messing up.

Petracco & Sons

4.1

(48 reviews)

•$

Excellent neighborhood Italian deli in Nutley. Feels like you're stepping back in time. Great…read morefood and neighborhood friendly service. Hot and cold sandwiches, hot meals or cold ones you can reheat. Italian cold cuts and salads. Plenty of drinks, sweets, and chips for lunch time. They also cater which looks very good as well. Nutley specializes in Italian Deli's and this is a good one. They have newspapers too which isn't a guarantee anymore. If you need lunch or a pre made or hot meal this is a great place.

On my rare day off, we went on the hunt for a new Italian sandwich joint. Today brought us to…read moreNutley, NJ. Plenty of parking on the side street. Old school Italian Deli, which I totally love. They got everything from your traditionally Italian cold cut sammich to the Hoboken (roast beef, mutz and gravy). Service was pretty swift. We got 3 sandwiches. My wife and myself got a chicken based sandwich and the kid got a meatball parm. If I didn't see it for myself, I would've never known, but it threw me back. They warm the chicken up in a microwave. I'm not sure why when the meatballs they brought in the back to the ovens to make my son's sandwich. I just found that very odd. I got the chicken cutlet, with provolone and broccoli rabe. Sandwich was excellent. I was really in the mood for crunchy semolina bread, but this was still very good. My son loved the meatball sammich. So all in all, a very solid spot. You can dine in or take home. (We brought it home).

Raymond's

3.8

(1.5k reviews)