Went here for my mom's b-day dinner on a Saturday night. Everyone in our party was pleased with their meals - the eggplant parm and calamari dishes were especially praised. Service was friendly and prompt, and BYOB is a plus! Our main complaints related to the ambiance: we all felt that the lighting was unnecessarily intense and "glarey," and (our biggest issue) the restaurant was simply too hot on a winter night to be comfortable for an extended period of time. All in all, we'd recommend this place for a family dinner and will probably be back! read more

It kills me to not give this place 5 stars. We came here for years and the food was spectacular with excellent service. But this was about a decade ago. Currently the food was bland. Tasted like it was just microwaved. Pizza was decent. I was disappointed after a decade of craving Angelos. Please get back to your glory days. I will always recommend this place but now its just a mediocre restaurant. But trust me their food was 5 stars for years and years. Please figure out what made your restaurant great and get back to it read more

I ordered for a small Xmas eve party. The Penne w Vodka was dry, the Chicken Franchise had no flavor and the lasagna was completely dry and tasteless. I am utterly disappointed and was completely embarrassed. The only saving grace was the Eggplant Rollatini which was good. Sorry to say, I won't be back. read more

I always have to find things out for myself, but today I learned that many of these poor reviews were warranted. I ordered a margherita pizzette, a cheesesteak with peppers and onions, and an order of hot wings. The pizza was below average--crust had nice chew, but lacked flavor; sauce was weak; cheese was plasticy; and the chunks of garlic were overwhelming. Threw the leftovers out. The cheesesteak was also mediocre--the bread was too soft, the meat was stringy, and like another reviewer said, there was barely any cheese. The wings were the best part, but they aren't the saucy wings most people think of. They were crunchy and just a little spicy. They were however small. I won't be eating here again--there are better places in town! read more

Great Italian food. Pretty much everything we get there is amazing. All the vodka pasta dishes are wonderful. Great service but can be a little slow at times depending on how busy they are. read more

Very nice Italian Restaurant. Large portions and very nice food. I love the Pizza shop with the restaurant in the back and this is a classic example of that. Reasonable prices with great dinners and a BYOB. read more

You can't go wrong here if you're in the mood for italian food. Their pizzas are great, whether you like thin crust, stuffed or sicilian. Big portions on their cheese steaks and grilled veggie sandwiches. During lunch, you order at the pizza counter as they don't have a lunch time wait staff. The only thing I thought was weak were their french fries. Then again, it was an italian restaurant. It's nicely decorated inside, and a casual environment, but not your typical pizza joint. read more

Despite the recent reviews, I headed into Angelo's anyway. I kept it simple and ordered a meatball parm sub, figuring they can't mess that up, which I'm glad they didn't. The best part about this sandwich was the tomato sauce. Extremely good. Other than that, the atmosphere is nice, service was decent and I'll be back for that sandwich. read more

The food was really good . The service was great, our waitress was Isabella she did a great job. Couldn't be happier

Excellent pizza, got the veggie pizza and you really get what you pay for. It is a bit expensive but the pizza is jam packed with veggies. They said it would be ready in 20 mins and it was ready in exactly 20 minutes. read more

Noticed a recent review and couldn't agree more. I just ate here and was going to review the pizza as subpar but decided on 1 star because of the poor management. Completely unprofessional behavior from the owners. Not like the other restaurants in Flemington. Thought the renovation would improve the business. I couldn't have been more wrong. read more

I have eaten here several times over the past few months and have always enjoyed my meal. The staff is very friendly with the exception of the owner. The man seems to be friendly only to the regulars and everyone else be warned. I really wish that this stubborn man would lighten up, because I love the place. Dishes to try (Tortellini Soup, Chicken Caesar Salad, any of their Pizza). read more

Gum in waterbottle. Grossssssssssss. Pizza was pretty good. Pasta stuffed pizza good. Hit the spot.

We just wrapped up a birthday dinner for 20 people at Angelo's and I have never been so reluctant to part with my money. When I called to make the reservation the owner was rude and out of line. I looked passed it based on convenience, but after our experience I know I should have followed my instinct. They didn't set tables for our group. Instead they scattered us across the restaurant. And when we suggested a better way to arrange the tables that would keep the adults together (large table for adults and small table for kids), my suggestions was met with 1000 reasons why they couldn't accommodate us, the best one being "table real estate is very expensive." I don't how anyone who owns a business could say that to a customer with a group of 20 people who all ordered full meals. And to add insult to injury, when the bill came I was told an automatic gratuity of 20% was added, but when I looked at the final bill 25% was added to the total (including for tax). With the terrible customer service we received tonight (coupled with expensive, mediocre dinners) we won't be coming and I will never recommend this place to anyone. read more

The food here is excellent with some of the best thin-crust pizza around. The restaurant is small so crowding may be an issue for some people. Very affordable for a family trying to budget a night out. read more

I've been coming here for 20 years now and love everything about it - the food, the value, the staff, the family and the beautiful dining rooms. Hint: try the California Grilled Chicken sandwich or the Chicken Francaise dinner. Thank me later. read more

I've been twice now and although it's a nice place with friendly staff the food I've had is just OK. Believe it or not I think it's the tomato sauce. The marinara with my calzone was like tomato soup. The pizza is OK, but not the best by any stretch. I had calamari and the marinara with that was better because I asked for the hot marinara sauce. Anyway, just OK. read more

Best Italian restaurant ever. Kitchen is spotless!!! Food is fabulous. I have had some of the best appetizers at ANGELO'S There are so many great meals to choose from I can't recommend just one. Owners are the best. Very warm and family friendly atmosphere. Very relaxing to eat there. Their staff are very friendly, accommodating, professional and courteous. Definitely a five star restaurant. read more

I LOVE THIS PLACE!! First of all its a BYOB and they have awesome Italian food. Its a bit of a drive for me now that i live close to New Brunswick, but its well worth the 45 minutes when I know what kind of meal and service I will be getting. Anything on the menue is great and very affordable and you will have enough for the next day. Check them out and try it--you wont regret it... if you like pie--try their margarita pie. Mmmm read more

Angelo's has excellent food and their portions are huge! We have eaten their many many times and have never had a bad meal. They also have an outdoor patio for the appropriate weather. read more

Great pizza. Friendly service. WB pizzas are awesome and perfect for 1. Calamari app was really good.

My family goes here a lot, so by default, so do I. They just did a renovation/addition to the front of the restaurant and it looks very nice. I am not a big fan of the pizza or sandwiches here. I think the pizza is average at best, but I do think they make great meals here. I would like to think that I have had most of, if not all, of the meals on the menu over time. You pretty much can't go wrong with one of the pasta dinners - tortellini bolognese is my favorite. They also have great chicken parm, chicken francaise and lasagna dinners. If I am not in the mood for a filling meal, then I will go with the runa salad which is very good. Angelo's has been a staple in the Flemington area for almost 30 years. read more

I really hate giving bad reviews especially when I've only gone one time (which was a few months ago) but don't live near this place. Was working this day in area and YELP'ed places to eat and decided on Angelos for the pizza. I ordered the individual pie and it was so tasteless for the first time in my life I actually added some salt and pepper just to get some flavor. It seemed like the sauce was made from tomatoes but not seasoned and the mozzarella was even bland. Just NO flavor at all. read more

Angelo's is a wonderful Italian restaurant. The pasta dishes are tasty and cooked to perfection. The brick oven pizza's are worth the trip to try out. Something about cooking in a brick oven really adds a lot of flavor to a pizza. My favorite is the Margherita (fresh basil and tomato). read more

The pizza is very incosistent here. Sometimes it tastes good and is cooked right, other times it tastes like cardboard and is burned black. Sometimes the pizza will have lots of cheese, other times barely any. Its a crapshoot, you never know whats going to come out of the oven. The pasta dishes are pretty good, and they have a nice selection of them on the menu. I would go here for pasta, but not pizza. read more

First let me say that they did a great job renovating the place. It stops there. If you want terrible pizza this is the place for it. I was very disappointed in the quality and offended that they would serve such crap. I only gave it a one star because the staff was friendly and because I couldn't go lower. It was tasteless, the dough was chewy, the sausage had a bone in it, and it was cooked unevenly. I hope the owner takes a little more pride in making a better pizza. read more

This place has both nice siting area in the back and pizza front. We tried both and I found general non pizza food very good. Not great but definitely worth an occasional trip. Portions are enormous and will leave you full to the brim and totally happy. Now we come to the important part of this review. This place have brick oven and they use it. I ordered several types of pizza here but nothing can beat their famous Margherita brick oven pizza. I mean it is GREAT. Did I mention that it is awesome. Whatever else you do make sure to get one to try for you and your family. Other brick oven pizza is good and not brick oven one are ok but not very remarkable. Other italian specialties are good: try Calzone and/or Stromboli. This place also have a very good marinara sauce. read more

I frequent Angelo's when im in the area and every time i have a great experience. The food is fantastic and the service is just as great. It's BYOB which is nice when I have dinner with the in-laws and want to have some wine with dinner. Pizza is good, entrees are good, heck, everything is good. They have these garlic rolls that kinda resemble a cinnabun, that are to die for. Perfect amount of garlic and cheese and the sauce is outstanding. I highly recommend anybody looking for a great Italian restaurant to come here. Friday nights are very busy but well worth the wait. read more

Good food, very reasonable prices, table service mediocre to good most times, owners and management always very pleasant and helpful, good takeout as well. Excellent sit down pizza place with extensive menu of Italian dinners. Eat here often - never a complaint other than service on occassion. Highly recommend for a quick sit down meal. read more

By far my favorite restaurant! Generous portions with delicious sauces. Every bite of the chicken Pavarotti or Fantasia is to die for. Angelo's sherry cream sauces are the best. The mozzarella carrozza and calamari have always been excellent. read more

My family has been eating at Angelo's for 30 years (back then, it was Doughboy's!). Always a good experience. Nice place, GREAT food. Angelo has always been a great guy, and this year, helped support the Susan G. Komen Ride for the Cure this year. read more

Had a fantastic dinner on a recent Sunday evening with a large group. Service was great and the place was very busy. Our food was served Family Style and it was all FABULOUS! Eggplant Parm was delicate and not greasy, salad was perfectly dressed, and Vodka Penne was rich but not too heavy. Everyone in our group was very happy! read more

I have gone to this resturant since it opened in 1983. Back then it was simply known as Doughboys,now as Angelo's it has an expanded from a mere pizza joint to a delightful dining expierence. Angelo's offers lots of variety from pizza to complex pasta dishes. They have the ability to accomodate small parties and also allow you to bring your own. The highlight of this resturant is the brick oven pizza as with the other reviews,the margherita pizza is by far the best. read more

I love Angelo's! I would always go here for a quiet meal or even to celebrate a special event. I miss their gnocchi sorrentino with all my heart. I hope they reopen soon! read more

I feel bad whenever I have to dis a local place but this was the worst pizza I've ever had. Frozen pizza from the supermarket is better. We had a very nice server who was not slow at all. BUT then the pizza came. I got the margherita and my fiance got chicken and basil. His was dripping every time he bit into it. Watery stuff. Not sauce that's for sure. I can give Angelo's the grand prix medal for having served me the worst margherita pizza I have ever had. The crust was thin, but rather flavorless, there was evidence of tomato sauce however it had no flavor at all. They used regular cheap pizza mozzarella so the pizza was covered with grease. I placed a napkin over one slice and it took up enough grease to soak the napkin. There was a wad of dried oregano in the center. When I unknowingly got a piece it was not a pleasant experience. There were 4 1" basil leaves placed on the pizza. There was also an overwhelming taste of raw garlic. From what I know of margherita pizza, and I have eaten a lot, it is tomato sauce, slices of FRESH MOZZARELLA, and a recognizable quantity of basil. It is the best test of whether a place knows how to make pizza because it's so simple, cheap ingredients stand out like a sore thumb. It was dreadful. You will be served a basket of pizza dough masquerading as rolls.Don't be fooled. It's pizza dough. It dining room was pretty depressing and dated and in need of an upgrade. But if I were them I'd start by upgrading the quality of the products they put on a pizza. In two words: NO FLAVOR. Our server noticed I hadn't eaten the pizza and I didn't want to take it home. She asked if it was ok and I just didn't have the heart to complain. It had nothing to do with her, and the damage was done. I'll just never go back there again. read more

!!!!!!! avoid this place!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!! !this is not a pizza place you can make better pizza at home or buy a frozen and you will be much happer!!! my wife and i got there on a sat nite early our watiress was a ditz .and there were all these little kid haning around with aprons on. working(child labor ?) seemed a little strange . we ordered the calamari for a apitizer big mistake!!!!! it was like eating card board freezer burn,sauce was out of a can.not good at all,my wifes salad nothing special my 6 yr old makes a much better one at home,then came the pizza, no sauce very dry,very little cheese not even covering the edges ingredents were very stingey,my wifes lasagna,was terrible.it was drowining in sauce you could hardly find it and when you did there was all cheese and very little meat.i do not know how this place. has stayed in business so long ? i do not care all i know is that with all the places to choose from this will not be mine even if they offer me a free meal.i will never never never never never ever ever ever!!!!! recomend,or go back to this place, my suggestion would be pizza hut with there $10;00 pizzas and great wings,you will be much happier and leave with money in your pocket!!!!! read more