In a world that relentlessly pursues extremes, the Average Pizza stands humble yet proud, asserting that consistency and familiarity also have merit. Isn't it comforting to know there's something that won't surprise or disappoint but consistently deliver a usual, familiar taste? Lenny's aims to shift the perspective, to encourage appreciation for 'ordinariness,' and to sing praises of our trustworthy, average pizzas that do not aspire to be spectacular but remain steadfastly satisfying. Less than average: Gen Z's answering the phone. read more

Lenny's makes delicious pizza. It has thin crust with delicious sauce and good ingredients. The service there is really nice.

Gluten free pizza is the frozen type with no taste. Toppings were good but the crust tastes like cardboard. If you're not gluten free the menu seems great . Probably won't order again, if I do I won't get the pizza. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Gluten free pizza - added on tomato , basil and ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Kind of an average pizza spot. Service has always been excellent, friendly guys. Good for a quick lunch or dinner and not too pricey.

Something has changed. Last year close to a 5 star joint but lately very hit or miss and delivery this last time very much a miss. Never know what you'll get whenever order fried calamari for delivery- often not crisp - but this was easily worst ever had. Dessicated. Packing and sending something this mummified to a customer is pretty terrible. May try them again, but definitely for calamari. read more

Lenny's Pizza - a bowl of noodles and a lemon - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

There PIZZA IS incredible They have exceptional service and there dishes are even better Delicious read more

Not A big fan at all! There much better pizzerias. But they are open later than most. So I still go in a pinch for a late night snack.

Since moving to the area I have searched for a good pizza place. After trying many places I thought I found a good one in Lenny's. Unfortunately this place has really gone downhill lately. The quality of the food has greatly reduced and you will be lucky if they get your order right. Multiple times in the last month I have picked up an order only to get home and realize they completely messed it up requiring me to drive back again. I will be going elsewhere. read more

We really like white pizza with tomatoes from Lenny's. But, anything we order from Lenny' is really great. Our local favorite. Great job !! read more

mmmmm yes ! came in about a half hour before closing to grab some slices & they had buffalo chicken pizza that was STACKED. it was so delicious and had so much chicken on it. it wasn't super spicy but had amazing flavors. the plain slices were good too ! read more

Have ordered from Lenny's two or three times now for delivery- I believe Lenny himself has taken my order every time... THE MOST ACCURATE ORDERS EVERY TIME! Not only accurate, always sooner delivery than expected with friendly drivers. If you live in Flemington, give these guys a try... Very worthy‼ read more

I have eaten pineapple pizza for years... and this is incredible... never have I ever had this much extra pineapple put on a pizza. I pay extra money for extra pineapple at every pizza place I go too, and usually they put a few extra piece....BUT LENNY'S put a whole extra pineapplethank u for a great slice! Will be back read more

Lenny's Pizza - Extra pineapple pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

We really like the pizza thin crust. I love the chicken cheesesteaks. It's fast and good!!!

This is our go to pizza place because it's close and convenient. Garlic pie is delish, as is chicken Caesar pie. Also does a great buffalo chicken cheesesteak! read more

Ordered delivery at 5 to Locktown. They brought it to Rocktown. Counter girls fault not the driver Nbd mistakes happen. finally got it at 6:30. Got ranch dressing but no salad. Chicken parm sub is still gas tho. read more

Serviceable hotel delivery. Showed up warm enough in a reasonable amount of time. Tastes okay, a bit better than average. Light on sauce, heavy on grease. If I were to order another pizza while still in the neighborhood, I'd probably shop around. Pretty good, but nothing amazing. Has more of a factory vibe than a fresh vibe, but certainly better than the chains. FYI, order thru Yelp and it's a $15 minimum. Call direct direct and the delivery minimum is $10. read more

Lenny's Pizza - A pretty personal cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

This is my favorite pizza place in Flemington, and whenever I'm home I make a point of coming here at least once. My family moved to Flemington almost 12 years ago, and I think this location had about 3 different pizza places in it for the first 6 of the years we lived here. Then Lenny's came, and as far as I can tell they're not even thinking about closing their doors. These guys get pizza right. The bread is perfect, first of all. Just the right thinness and crispiness, with enough flavor to stand on its own but not so much that it overshadows the toppings. Now, I'm not a crust-eater. Yeah, it's weird, but usually I give away my crusts. At Lenny's, though, I eat the crust. My personal favorite at Lenny's is the broccoli and tomato white pizza. It's totally bougie, but, my friends, it is DELICIOUS. I'm getting hungry just thinking about it. It's got lots of ricotta and lots of veggies in all the right proportions. Their plain, of course, is good too. The sauce is nice and somehow they make it so that when you take a bite you can actually break the cheese. It won't all slide off your pizza and onto your shirt, and I appreciate that. Lenny's has at times been inconsistent. The pizza used to be better, though it's still really good. And they don't always have my beloved broccoli tomato. Sometimes you will walk in there and it will be clear that you're getting the last slice of a particular pie that has been sitting out for hours. It's always good, though, and I can't say I've ever been disappointed. Lenny's does have non-pizza food, but I've never tried it. I've also never had anything delivered from there, so I can't speak to the quality of their delivery. Sorry, kids. read more

We ordered pizza from here last night to fulfill a craving. Usually we go for Virami's, but we wanted to try something different since we have only lived here for a few months. We ordered a large plain pie with mushrooms. It was alright. I thought the crust was a little bit too thick and chewy. The ends were fantastic though. Also, I think that the mushrooms were a bit scarce, although they weren't overwhelming, I was shocked to see only a few sprinkles of them, especially for paying almost 2 dollars a topping. We'd probably go again, but it wouldn't be our first choice. read more

This is our favorite in Flemington. We make a point of crossing town to get Lenny's. My family comes from out of state and they want a trip to Lenny's to get Jersey pizza (next best to NYC!!). The staff here are pleasant. We suggest the buffalo chicken pizza (totally YUMMY), plain, pepperoni, ziti, hawaiian - ham and pineapple, sicilian... okay, any of the pizza here is GREAT. read more

Come here and eat this!!! I wish you could save smells with your review. The chicken francese was spectacular. Lemony, eggy and fresh. The angel hair was perfect. The pasta fagioli soup tasted like a grandmother made it, old world and rich. I had the meat lovers slice with pepperoni. Crispy and delicious. Friendly and chivalrous. Please check out my pics. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Chicken francese and meat lovers slice - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

This is my favorite pizza place for a plain pizza. The crust is crisp and I have NEVER had a burned pizza- which I have found to be rare among pizza places. The fried calamari is great. They also have an additional menu of "fat" sandwiches (like those from the Rutgers food trucks). They are decent but could probably use a little more filling. Overall, I have been pleased with everything I have ordered. read more

My favorite pizzeria in the Flemington area. Wide range of Italian entrees as well as Americana staples. Excellent prices and lunch specials. read more

Lenny's has great pizza and eggplant parmesan and they deliver though it is best to call early because they get very busy especially on weekends. The owners are very nice and the man who usually answers the phone has a real Italian accent. How can you go wrong? read more

Have worked in the area for years and just discovered this place, so glad we did. Very good food and reasonably priced, chicken cheesesteaks and paninis are delicious. Delivery is quick and service is friendly, we will definitely be ordering from here more often! read more

This Pizza place fucking sucks! I ordered a Calzone they give me a Donut! I swear I called the place and this guy who's name by the way ISNT EVEN LENNY! He tells me " Aye buddy I made your sandwich I can't take out the tomato at this point in time " Then! This guy shows up, tells me Arizona ice tea is for tourists and offers me this peace tea non sense. No sir! I will not accept your peace. You rather can get a piece of my mind YOUR SERVICE SUCKS! read more

I order a bacon cheeseburger mediumwell&Ialso had sweetpotato fries on a roll&it also came with picles that Ireally enjoy my burger.

Was really good and extremely fast for pick up and delivery. Not sure if new way to prepare pizza dough, the last 5 times we ordered tasted stale or frozen. Understandable as a time saver but not really what you would expect when ordering late night or early dinner. One of the better buffalo chicken and fra diavlo pizzas around town and a good amount of options for sandwiches and wraps. read more

So happy to see that Eat 24 has so many more options this year. This is how I found Lenny's. The best pizza I have had delivered in my life. All the reviews are right it was delicious and can't wait to try other food entree's from here other than the pizza. Got the Brooklyn pie & was so fresh & amazing. Delivery was prompt and food came hot. read more

Have always loved ordering from here, but was extremely disappointed by the wait time. I was told that my Nona pizza would be ready in 15 min, like it usually is, but waited over 40 minutes for it to finally be ready. Will not be ordering from here anytime soon until they fix this. read more

Great local pizza place. Can't go wrong with anything there. The staff is very friendly and they quick with all orders.

First of all, this is my first Yelp review. I am an avid pizza fan! I have had the best pizza up and down the east coast and even in Italy. We just moved to the Flemington area and have either dropped in or ordered delivery from Lenny's 4 nights in a row. I am trying to set a record, but my wife does not know about this. The food and service is amazing. I would highly recommend it! I even asked my wife for a gift card from Lenny's for my upcoming birthday! read more

Was stuck in Flemington for the day and based upon the previous five-star ratings (3 of 3 reviewers) decided to give Lenny's a try. Maybe my Brooklyn roots have screwed up my pizza expectations, but this place was simply OK. (From a Brooklynite, that's a rave!(?)) I had two slices-one regular (cheese) and one Sicilian. Again, they were OK but both lacked something in the flavor department. The mozzarella was fairly bland and the sauce was barely noticeable. Service was adequate but not friendly. The place was clean and parking in this strip mall is no problem. If I were back in Flemington, I would look around for other options first, but given the plethora of available big-box restaurant chains, would consider coming back here if "OK and cheap" was what I wanted. read more

Lenny's is the best in Flemington! Especially for catering now that Alfonso's changed to Alfresca's and their food quality and service went down. Lenny's is also there to meet your needs for a big party or a Friday night pizza. Their special pizza is awesome and their owner is so very accommodating. Their pasta and platters are so good. They actually keep your info on file so a frequent host like me is not constantly spelling my street name over and over. Great quality, good price, and big portions. read more

My experience at this restaurant was absolutely terrible. I ordered a Stromboli (pepperoni sausage & peppers) specifically asked for no onions (allergic) and a few plain slices. The pizza was soggy & almost inedible. By far the worst I have had in the Flemington area. I was also unable to eat the Stromboli because it consisted of onions which specifically asked them not include because of my allergy. & they did not even include sausage. BE WARNED employees do not seem to care about your order at all if it is the least bit customized, or even a basic plain slice. They are opening a new location in Clinton, NJ & I hope they put more effort into that restaurant than the past because this was just sad. read more

Easily the best buffalo chicken pizza around town. My family's go to since Dominicks closed. Even though it's a little more pricey, it's worth the money. We always get buffalo chicken pie, wings, and their special pizza. Never a complaint. Also have great cheesesteaks. read more

Forgetable. We order from them becuase they deliver, but it isn't anything special. The pizza is ok, sauce could use flavor and pizza is occasionally over cooked. Sandwiches are ok, nothing special. I have also tried a couple pasta dishes and again the sauce could use more flavor. read more

Awesome pizza, salad, garlic knots, subs, sandwiches, fries. Lenny is a great owner and is very accommodating. Their catering menu is really good as well. read more

Super great food will order again thanks so much keep up the good work. They deliver to my office and are really nice people.

I went to this place yesterday for the first time for lunch, and the food was definitely not very good. When I went inside the place: the place felt empty and lifeless, and seemed to drain the energy out of you as if there was some kind of void located in the back of the kitchen (weird feeling). I ordered some garlic knots and a slice of pizza to go and left, as I didn't want to stay in this place. After I got home and ate the pizza and garlic knots, the garlic knots were ok, but the cheese on the pizza was kind of strange tasting, it reminded me of the cheese that is used at Chuck-e-Cheeses (not good). After eating: I felt tired, drowsy and irritable. I have no idea what was in that stuff, but they either had it sitting out too long (I was there around 5:30pm so that's a possibility) or used some low quality ingredients. After a few hours passed (after I later had dinner), the 'side effects' from the food wore off and my head cleared up. Whatever was going with that stuff, I'm not going there again and I don't recommend it as a good place to get pizza. The food is very cheap though: the four garlic knots and the one slice of Siciilian pizza totaled to $3.99, but for me it's not worth it if I'm left in a bad state where I don't feel like doing anything. read more

Not very good. Frozen pizza is better. My Family and I all got ill from the food there. My daughter on her way home from school eat there 2 more times and had an upset stomach. read more