Food is good but I feel I was robbed. I was charged $83 for 2 grandma pizzas with hot honey peperoni and vodka sauce. If I went to pick it up, I would have told them to keep the pizza, that is a ridiculous price!! read more

I love this place! The pizza is just so good and the staff is always friendly and happy to see you when you walk in. The booth benches may need a little TLC. Did I mention the pizza is soooo good? Have never had a cheesesteak there but hear that they are really good. read more

We happened to be in the area and decided to stop in and grab a quick slice before our next appointment. We settled in the white pizza with do outta and mozzarella and split a round deep dish sausage and pepperoni. Very casual ambiance and the service very friendly. Very good pizza, a hit for sure and 'An offer you can't refuse!' read more

My MIL had heard that Joe's Pizza was rated as one of the best in the state and kept asking if we had tried it since moving into the area 18 months ago. I needed to run to the Shop Rite to pick up a few things so I decided to swing by Joe's and order a large plain pie. The guy behind the counter greeted me as though I was a regular and have been there a hundred times. There are roughly 6-8 tables if you choose to dine in. The ambiance inside is your stereotypical pizza place. They're also on DoorDash and Slice, though not everything on their menu may be found on DD/Slice (e.g., the garlic knots are on Slice but not DD). read more

Simply the best! The food is always spot on delicious! The service is great both ordering on the phone and in person. They are always upbeat and helpful. Ordering for delivery is easy but the wait usually an hour or so to receive your order bcz they are so busy, indicative of their popularity! Totally worth the wait! It's a little pricey but again very worth the money! We have been ordering from Joe's for a couple of decades and will continue to go there. It's unfortunate they are closed on Monday! The only time we use another pizzeria is when they are closed. Best pizza and Italian food in the area hands down! read more

The first thing you'll notice about Joe's is the great service. Always asking the kitchen how long for an order, not just giving you a number. Always asking how your day is going. And then there's the food. The cheesesteaks are bangin! Lots of meat, on a homemade roll, for a great price. Enjoy! read more

The best pizza in Flemington! Hands down, nothing else need be said... When I visit from Florida, it's always a safe place to grab amazing pizza and cheesesteaks, pasta, and more! read more

On my way home from work I would sometimes stop here for several slices when my husband and I didn't feel like cooking. Great variety! Recently we've become hooked on their yummy spinach rolls. read more

Ordered veal franchise to be delivered. Easily the single worst meal I have ever tried to eat!!!! If I could give it zero stars I would read more

Joe's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

Great local pizza spot. Really good pizza. Regular weekend pizza spot for our family.

I originally founded this As NEIGHBORS PIZZA and eventually sold it . The food is excellent staff excellent what more can be said

Very tasty cheesesteak and spaghetti and meatballs. Very small dining area inside as they do mostly takeout. There is a nice outdoor seating area. read more

This pizza is not worth $25 for a large 1 topping pie. I know we're close to NYC but come on! If you're gonna change NYC prices at least make good pizza! read more

GREAT FOOD. Good people. Great prices. Family owned. Always fresh. Brian, Lou and Sal always helpful at the counter. John makes GREAT PIZZA Fausto makes great hot sandwiches and dinners read more

cheap ingredience perhaps consider stock pot to cook your pizza sauce other than raw out of the can, if your going to boast about 21 years operation bring back the quality like real cheese other than sub grade the analogue stuff incase one doesnt know its vegatable oil with additives ! not real dairy which might explain why you product is so greasey its not olive oil !!! read more

Delicious and fresh pizzas. The sauce and crust are so on point! Ordered several pies to host a holiday party and the service was excellent. Looking forward to returning again. read more

We have just discovered Joe's, and wow! Excellent food! We have tried 5 or 6 pizza places- this is the best. Cheese is not like leather! And sauce and crust is great! Friendly, fast and amazing salads! Gotta have a good salad. read more

The food is always top notch, whether ordering a full meal to eat in, pizza for stay or go, or you are starving for a great cheese steak. The larger cheese steak sandwich is definitely enough for two, but if you are starving and have the room in your stomach, go for the whole thing yourself. I love most of the pizza that they offer, and I don't think I have ever had a bad slice. I'm not local, but do go to Flemington quite a bit, as most of us in Hunterdon County do, so I simply call ahead and order, so it is ready once I get down there. Great employees who have a knack of making you feel like a regular. Now closed on Sunday, but not a terrible thing as long as you remember to stop by on Saturday to take it home. I drive the 25-30 minutes because it is predictably just as I ordered, and hey, the people down there remember my name. There is seating to eat in, but if it is supper time, you may find all seats taken. I have eaten Italian all over Hunterdon County, but this is the best at what they do - good food, great flavor, fair prices, and wonderful staff. When it is good, don't try to fix it! read more

I ordered the grandma pie with pepperoni and onions and their chicken soup. The grandma pie is the best! My first time trying this restaurant and it won't be my last. Pizza was cooked. Perfectly crust was perfect sauce was delicious just the right amount of all the ingredients. I have not tried the soup yet, but I'm sure it'll be just as good! Why don't you lay with Batman? read more

See all

Love the atmosphere here, no complaints on any of their food. One of the best cheese steaks you'll find in Jersey. Everyone always is upbeat and just an enjoyable place to eat. read more

Update - recently retried Joe's again and the pizza was perfection! So delicious. Not sure what happened the time prior to this one but it was hopefully in the past. 5 stars again. Keep up the great job! read more

Outstanding pizza!!! Thin, crispy crust, plenty of cheese....Had a mushroom slice & plain cheese slice. Perfect NY style!!!

elite family is great I love it the son Cj is so nice I love pizaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa read more

Best pizza on the planet. Plain pie, Grandma pie and buffalo chicken are top tier. Monday cheesesteak are to die for! read more

Best cheese steaks around by far, and the bread is amazing,good size too.next going try spaghetti and meatball pizza

Amazing service. Friendly people, delicious food. Cheesesteaks are the best around, and the ambiance is very welcoming. Highly recommend!

Best Pizza Shop in Flemington. The staff is super friendly. The prices are great and the food is amazing. I've tried quite a few items there and it's always good and fresh. My favorite is the Sausage & Peppers hero. If you are looking for good food then this is the place to go. read more

They are always on the mark. Pizza,cheesesteaks,hot or cold heroes ale top notch. Service from efficient smiling personable staff too!

I am a cheesesteaker from south Philly to Delaware County. This is my first time at Joe's. Delicious!!!! The rolls are amazing and so is the meat. And, they do not skimp on the amount of meat. My husband thought I had ordered extra meat. I will be coming here any time I drive through. read more

Great pizza and great service Prepared in reasonable time Great Caesar salad Cozy place to eat read more

Excellent pizza I know they are trying to be safe, but the current furniture arrangement inside the restaurant makes it difficult to be socially distant while ordering and waiting for your order. read more

Joe's Pizza & Restaurant - The staff is friendly and patient. They remembered what this woman ordered last week (she wanted the same thing today). - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

This is my only favorite pizzeria in town, they always have the best pizzas, subs,wings and much more. John and Sal and Lou are so great they make you feel like you're family. Known them for a few years now and I'll forever always come here. I recommend everyone to come in and have a bite of real Italian food. Thank you for so many years of wonderful amazing service and food!!! read more

Joe's Pizza & Restaurant - Stuffed Penne Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

I'm a big fan of Joe's Pizza. I've had their pizza on a few occasions and have never been disappointed. The staff is very friendly and the service is always quick. The plain pizza and the penne vodka pizza are two of my favorites. The penne vodka pizza is fully loaded with excellent vodka sauce, a crisp base, and crunchy-crisp crust. The plain is fantastic and features a salty, buttery cheese and an amazing sauce. Joe's is definitely one of my go-to's in the Flemington area. read more

Hands down the best pizzeria in Flemington, possibly the entire state. From the pizza, cheesesteaks and dinners everything is top notch. The atmosphere is one of a kind. Top rated cheesteak: California Top 3 slices: margaritas, plain, bbQ Favorite dinner: penne vodka read more

Nestled in a strip mall I saw pizza. Something quick and easy. Plenty of slice choices too appease anyone's palette. Quaint joint with outdoor seating available. Best Sicilian slice I've had. Crunchy outer crust soft middle. Just plain good. Come check it out. Across the street from Dutch county farmers market read more

Great pizza and Cheesesteak! I don't like the fact that they have a lot of pizza to choose from as it makes me buy more then i need! Not more than I want. First choice for me when in Flemington. read more

After coming back from vacation,,I was 2 tired to cook. Thankfully they delivered ! Pizza and a huge buffalo chicken salad!! read more

Joe's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

Great service with good, tasty comfort dishes that far exceeded our expectations for a pizzeria. Portion sizes were ample and the reviews of Joe's home-baked bread, the cheesesteak sandwich, the chicken parmigiana turnover, and the penne with marinara (good choice for vegans) were enthusiastic thumbs up. The spaghetti and meatballs was completely devoured by the 8-year old in our group, while the 7-year old - usually a very fussy eater - ate his spaghetti with Parmesan cheese willingly ... no prodding to do so! Our only regret: we live too far away to frequent Joe's more than once a year. read more

Yum. Somehow, I have never stopped into Joe's, despite living in Flemington for years. I always knew it was there, but generally just stuck to the pizza places we knew! Ever since my favorite place shut down (miss you, Dominick's!), I don't have a go to pizza spot in Flemington. Joe's might have just snagged the title of new go to jam! The interior is really nice for a pizza joint, with a cool rock surface counter. Decent amount of tables inside, which quickly filled up on a Friday night. Big menu, with lots of single slice options. We grabbed a whole pie to go. They told us about a 10-15 minute wait, but I think it was probably 8! It smells fantastic in there too, so it was not an unpleasant place to wait! Checked in and got a coupon for 10% off the bill! Prices were cheap and the pizza was mouth watering. You know it's a good slice when you eat it cold later on and it's still killer! read more

John, Lou, Sal and crew have a great pizza (and more) establishment. This is the place to go in the Flemington area. I highly recommend the mushroom as well as the Buffalo chicken specialty pizza slice as well. Their meals esp. Chicken Cacciatory over Linguini, my favorite, are the best especially if you are hungry. Great thing for spring/summer, is they have an outdoor patio with umbrella tables to eat outdoors (no indoor tables currently since pandemic). read more