Me and my local buddy along with a Canadian acquaintance of mine were craving some food and decided to try senator sandwich we dialed up an order with some cheesesteaks and club sandwich's and they were phenomenal along with the services, The owner even tossed in a jumbo dog no bun which my Canadian acquaintance had the luxury of throwing down a 1 bite challenge on solid spot read more

Senatore Sandwiches - Jumbo Hot Dog Canadian boy - Sandwiches Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

So happy we stumbled upon this place. We live close by never went in and I'm so glad we did this time. We got the original cheesesteak and the steak BLT and both were so good. The quality of the food was 10/10 and the steak BLT is so delicious. Service was great and the place is really clean and cute. read more

Senatore Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

See all

This was a pit stop for us on the way back from camping. We didn't know this place was right across the street from a lovely lake and grassy area to chill at after our meal, so that was a nice surprise. This is a small restaurant, it kind of feels like you're in someone's house. You order at the front. We got the senatore cheesesteak and a mushroom Swiss burger. I'm not a huge fan of cheesesteaks and enjoyed my burger more (it was a smash burger with nice horseradish sauce on it) but the cheesesteak was also one of the better ones I've had. I would come back if I'm ever in the area. read more

Senatore Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

If you're looking for a small local sandwich shop with authenticity, this is it. The owner, Nick is very down to earth, and so was the service. Not only was the burger flavorful, you are allowed to substitute for a veggie burger, so this is a great place for vegetarians like myself. While you wait for your order, you try and one there arcade games (PAC-Man & NFL Blintz) for FREE! read more

See all

Here's the deal. Senatore is located across from the lake Mohawk boardwalk plaza. There parking on the street and side lot. Ordering at counter and the meal is brought out to your table. In addition to inside seating there is a side covered porch with plenty of seating options! As for the food! I came for the cheesesteak(s)!!! The "Senatore" & the "Italian" were make to order and the meat was tender and had a great meat/cheese/bun ratio!! The Italian cheesesteak was definitely better!! The fries are crispy and fresh!! Little too much salt (maybe someone had a heavy hand in the back). My only issue was ....sticker shock.... 2 cheesesteaks & fries and 2 soda was $50+ bucks!!! While the beautiful chalk board clearly shows prices. Just seems a LOT to pay for cheesesteaks! They do have a 1/2 sandwich options, perhaps that's the way to go!! I'd definitely come back and try other items!! read more

See all

Should've taken a pic of my loaded cheesesteak, took one bite and just tore it apart. Bread, meat, cheese, onions and peps all came together perfectly! This place is clean, the food is outstanding, prices are fair the staff is awesome!! read more

Why did I wait so long?! If you are looking for a solid sandwich in the Sparta area, this is it! It's small, but comfortable with a little outside space. Honestly, a great option for anyone out in the lake for take-out. The BLT was crispy (the good kind that scrapes your mouth) and the cilantro lime sauce was a perfect surprise. Hubs got the cheese steak which came in a sesame roll that had a perfect chew, and the poblano peppers that didn't overwhelm the sandwich. Fries were reminiscent of a good boardwalk fry. Yes, we'll be back for sure! read more

Senatore Sandwiches - Menu options - tough choices to make, it all looks delish! - Sandwiches Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

Delicious CHEESESTEAK very friendly staff . I would definitely return. Right near Lake Mohawk and Sparta New Jersey. Yum

Best Valentine's Day ever. Ribeye cheesesteaks, smash burger, a footlong do(n)g, cokes, cheese fries. Great music, ample seating. Friendly proprietor. Parking lot. Planning to return very soon! read more

Senatore Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

Delicious, kid approved! Like most teens my son loves a burger and fries we had been meaning to try for a while and this summer we finally made a stop. This is now his go to anytime he's craving burger and fries. My husband and I shared a cheesesteak which was hands down the best in the area. Our daughter a fry lover gobbled her fry order up. We also got a fancy soda which I didn't know what it was so gave it a try, I had the pineapple grapefruit and it was tasted like a naturally sweet seltzer. My kids got their favorite Jarrito drinks, they had many optional flavors. Best of all prices are reasonable. While we waited they played on the old school games. This is the perfect little spot. My son and his friends will definitely be regulars I'm sure when they are out in town. read more

See all

11/10. This place is a classic brick & mortar small business that's dishing out unreal burgers and steaks. Food comes out quick and the staff is super friendly. Came here after seeing their smash burger on social media and I'm kicking myself for not discovering sooner. BE AWARE: Due to the high volume of people coming in for their cheesesteaks, you're going to want to come early. We came at 5:30 and they had to tell 6 different customers that they ran out of steaks!! They are selling out daily! Come eat one and you'll know why... read more

Senatore Sandwiches - Decor - Sandwiches Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

We stopped in for lunch and had a great sandwich. Nice little spot near lake Mohawk. Service was friendly and everything was delicious; definitely would stop in again!! read more

Senatore Sandwiches - Steak Sandwich "Senatore" - Sandwiches Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

Absolutely delicious. Got a patty melt and fries, patty melt had it all, great taste, great crunch, not too greasy, perfect. Got cheese fries with it, fries were tasty, cheese was pretty standard. Will def be back. read more

Food was incredible! Quick service. Waited less than 5 minutes for 2 cheesesteaks with fries and a turkey club. Definitely the best cheesesteak sandwiches around. Perfect amount of seasoning and the peppers and onions were the perfect amount. Fries were great tasting and fresh. Wife had the turkey club and she said it was the best in the area that she has tried. This place is definitely and must stop at if in the area. Cozy Little tables if alone or a couple. Definitely can be put together for lager crowd. Nice music to listen too and it's not to loud. Highly recommended if I didn't say so already lol. read more

See all

Had the 10oz Cheesesteak with provolone & sautéed onions. The BEST cheesesteak I've ever had. Delicious shaved Ribeye, perfect roll.... It was insane. Just go. read more

My sandwiches were not as stuffed like the pictures. There wasnt much mushrooms. The spicy sauce is good but they need to give more.

No photos..too busy eating my delicious cheesesteak and fresh cut fries. Just go, don't think about it. Quality food.

My husband & I love cheesesteaks and have been known to make the hike down to Philly (more frequently than I'd like to admit) for authentic steaks. We're always on the hunt for a good one up north, and we're so glad we tried Senatore's! It may not be Jim's South Street, but my was it tasty! Extra bonus- the service was great, our cashier/server was sooo nice & welcoming. We're excited to come back & support this local business! read more

Senatore Sandwiches - "Senatore Steak" cheesesteak & cheese fries (cheese on the side) - Sandwiches Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

Found this place several months ago. It has become a weekly stop for us. The food and portion size is always consistent . You can easily taste the " Better ingredients" used in preparation . Have had the burgers , cheesesteak , fries and chicken tenders and they never disappoint. Owner is engaging and proud of his business . Once you try it , you will be coming back . So different then the other "burger and chicken places" in the area read more

I truly have not had anything below a 4/5 meal from here ever. Owner is really friendly too. Everyone talks about the cheesesteaks (for a reason) but the loaded friends are so amazingly good. read more

The cheesesteaks are the best! A nice, thick sandwich on tasty bread, and the shoestring fries with the peel are extra tasty. The service is always fast and friendly too! read more

The place is very good. Had the spicy mango burger with cheesesteak loaded fries. Fantastic burger. Can't wait to come back and try the cheesesteaks next. read more

One of the best cheesesteaks I've ever had in my life, and that's coming from someone who has tried Angelo's in Philadelphia and Danny & Coops in NYC. Prices are very reasonable and workers were super friendly. Will definitely be back soon! read more

Senatore Sandwiches is easily one of the best - quality and ingredient driven- spots in the area.

such good chesse steak !!! but i wish the toll was toasted and it woukd have been so much better ! mine was a little hard to chew but the steak and cheese on the inside was to die for ! read more

Had the the Italian Cheesesteak sandwich here. Tasted great and one of the best cheesesteaks I have had. The only thing I was shocked at was the price of $22.00 and fries were extra charge. If the price was around $16.00 - $18.00 I would have given this place five stars. read more

Stopped here for a bite, and was extremely happy I did. My wife and kid each got a sandwich and it was exactly what we wanted: perfect full flavor, delicious textures, and very accommodating for my family. The service was extremely fast, and the ambience was simple and comfortable. Halfway through the meal, the owner himself came by and spoke with us to ensure we had everything we needed. It was a really nice touch that shows how they went above and beyond. Very grateful...will be back asap when I go through Sparta again! read more

Awesome cheesesteak, best I've had in a long time. Will go back next time I'm in the area.

The food and service were beyond excellent. If you are in the area and in the mood for exceptional comfort food, this is your place!