A lovely couple serving up some mighty fine sandwiches!! Don was such a gem. He chatted with my mom for a bit after she explained we drove over. a half hour to try his shop. So sweet of him to give us that time of day on a saturday. The sandwich was delicious. We got a sloppy joe, of course. I would love to come back here if I am in the area Amazing people great food and we even got parking right out front read more

See all

What's not to love about an old school deli. Straightforward no frills but HUGE sandwiches. I ordered a large and it basically was 3 meals. Massive. Fresh cut deli meat, crisp produce and served just how I liked. Right there in downtown. Great spot for lunch or an easy dinner. read more

Don's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Boonton, New Jersey

See all

This is one of the best spots in town without question. You will never feel ripped off when you visit. the sandwiches are stacked. The coffee is probably the least expensive on Main Street. Ice cream and chips are only a couple bucks. As a local, I'm there more often than not. No matter what your experience is when you visit, I guarantee you will always feel better than before you entered. read more

They were extremely accomodating very nice people nice family business. Will definitely be going back

I've read reviews of Don's Sandwich Shop and have wanted to get here for quite a while. Yesterday, I had the opportunity to stop in to pick up a sandwich for dinner. The storefront is located on Main Street in Boonton. There's street parking, you just need to search for a space. There's a drum set in the window. (I didn't ask but believe there's some affiliation with music lessons at the local school). I've read the Sloppy Joe's were very good, so I ordered a roast beef, turkey, and Swiss. When I got home and opened it, it was massive! The sandwich was excellent. It was so large, I saved half for today. The cold cuts were high quality and the Cole slaw on the sandwich topped it off perfectly! The woman behind the counter, who I believe is one of the owners, was very friendly. If you're in Boonton looking for a sandwich, Don's is the place to go! read more

See all

What a Great spot! Great people and AMAZING sandwiches! Huge portions too and very good prices. Can't say enough good about this place. read more

Don's Sandwich Shop - This is "Half sandwich". It's massive! - Sandwiches Near Me - Boonton, New Jersey

See all

#Latergram. #FirstTimerAlert. Don's Sandwich Shop. Situated in the center of Boonton, NJ, this shop is run by husband and wife, and they make the best team. Parked on the street and walked up. Deli includes a section for drum sales, and music lessons. Outfitted with all the 'Joes' fixings, I walked into my advertisement, two other first timers walking to their table, hauling their sandwiches. Ordered the Sloppy Joe (Housemade Roast Beef, Turkey, Provolone, Cole Slaw, and Russian on Rye). Took it down with a Joe's Peach Tea and Salt & Vinegar Chips. Wow. What a Mammoth of a Sangwhich! Def will be back. Check it out! read more

Don's Sandwich Shop - See Corresponding Review. - Sandwiches Near Me - Boonton, New Jersey

Best of best in Boonton and surrounding area. Tried them for the first time and it won't be my last time. Owners are super sweet and welcoming. Finished my sandwich in one sitting and that's an accomplishment just on the size of the sandwich. Definitely get your monies worth here. Will be a frequent customer. If your looking for a a bite to eat in Boonton. Stop by Don's. Don't trust me just try for yourself. Can't wait to try them again. Probably this weekend! Sooo good!!!! read more

I work in the area and this is the perfect spot for a sandwich, wrap or anything in between! The owners are so friendly and great with a plenty of options to choose from! Their prices are so affordable too! read more

Delicious subs and fresh bread and Ingredients. I don't like my cheese sliced on the same slicer as the meat so the owner cleaned it before he sliced the cheese. Really nice people and good business practices . Will be back and the price was also very good read more

Don't sleep on this mom and pop deli. This place knows how to make a good sandwich. The welcome you get from the friendly staff was just fun and nice. I got the chicken salad club. And it was so good. I can not remember the last time i had chicken salad and did not need to add salt or pepper. This was so good. The crispy bacon was a good touch for sure. There is only street meter parking and depending on the time you go. You may have to take a nice walk like I did. And believe me, it is very much worth the walk in the light rain. If you get the time and in the area. Give this place a chance to please your stomach. read more

Don's Sandwich Shop - My sandwich makers. They know what they doing for shooo - Sandwiches Near Me - Boonton, New Jersey

See all

I've been to visit Don's several times. Great sandwiches, stacked and reasonably priced!!! gGreat conversations with the folks that own the place. Want some drum lessons from a great guy who is a pro drummer? Need a used drum kit? How about a set of sticks ? One stop shopping!!! read more

Roastbeef, turkey, and swiss sloppy joe! They say a picture is worth a thousand words, so I'll try to be be brief as possible. Don's is located on Main Street in Boonton and is one of Boonton's many hidden gems when it comes to quality food and great customer service. Far from being a chain sandwhich shop, Don's is a must stop whenever you are craving a good sandwich in the area. Stop searching for other lunch contenders and stop in or call in your order. My sandwich was spectacular and very filling. Give them a try. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Simply amazing. Prices are downright nasty (cheap). Don and his wife were super friendly and made me a monster of a sandwich. I'll definitely be back! read more

Don's Sandwich Shop - Turkey , Pastrami , Bacon & Swiss - Sandwiches Near Me - Boonton, New Jersey

I'm not a sandwich guy, which is why my first trip here is years after moving into town. But my friend is, so I decided to give it a try. We ended up splitting a full pastrami sub with Swiss and mustard, potato salad and cole slaw on the side. The deets: * Top of the potato salad was a bit underdone. Potatoes slightly crunchy. Got better as I dug in. I don't think it was old at all - they appear to make everything fresh. Good flavor, just have to knock a star off for that. * Cole slaw was fine, not remarkable, no real flaws but not earning that 5th star. I think it was too creamy without enough vinegar bite to it for my taste. * The sub... The meat was good quality. It wasn't overflowing like some have suggested, but there was a decent amount of meat on decent bread. Bread wasn't really that special. Plenty of cheese to go around though! And a bit light on the mustard - I'll take the blame for that, since most people don't like their condiments as slathered as I do. * Desserts: Disappointed. Their menu suggests cookies and other sides, but the only things homemade appear to be the salads and slaw. The cookies were just Famous Amos bags. Someone mentioned "local" sodas - no, just "off-brand" is what you're going for. In the end, I'm not much of a sandwich guy, but there have been a select few places in my life that have compelled me to return. This was not one of them, as much as I wanted it to be. It's a 3.5 star review, but it's just not my bag, baby. read more

Don's Sandwich Shop - Potato salad, Cole slaw, pastrami sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Boonton, New Jersey

I needed Italian Subs cut into pieces to feed 20 firemen. I ordered by phone and Elizabeth and Pat had them all set up on two trays at pick up time. The guys raved about them and there wasn't any left! read more

Don's Sandwich Shop - One tray with onions, one without of Italian Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Boonton, New Jersey

AMAZING!!! Service with a smile every time. This is my go to for my sandwiches. The roast beef with their fabulous horseradish sauce is the Bomb!!! read more

Best chicken focaccia sandwich I've had in years. Prices are reasonable and people working there are so personable.

Food is great . service is great too. the ambiance is good old American classic "with all the works" sandwiches, in a small friendly town right on Main Street. great sandwiches! I love the Kaiser rolls read more

Nothing mind blowing or life changing about this place, in fact they got my order incorrect but the vibe here (old school sandwich shop with local products, pickles are definitely homemade or locally sourced) and welcoming atmosphere gets the stars here. Happy to support a local business that charges less than Jersey Mike's, I definitely would give them another shot. read more

Simple place that makes a heck of a sandwich. Loaded with fresh sliced cold cuts and all the fixens you could ever want.

Love this place! The pastrami sandwich was to die for! We lived everything about this place. The kind kind hospitality. They let us have our dog with us too. Just a perfect sandwich shop the way you want it. read more

The people are nice and my sandwich was great! I will definitely come here again! Plus they have drums!

I called today (4 days before Christmas). Family emergency and a ton of family at my house. I said I need catering for 20-25 people. They said no problem! Not only did they accept my last minute order they had everything ready in 30 minutes!!!! The best subs and potato salad I've had here in Jersey. I'm one happy customer i'll tell EVERYONE I know to support this business. read more

Don's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Boonton, New Jersey

Best sandwich shop in town! The owners are adorable and so sweet. The sandwiches are huge and prices are really good for the amount that you get. Don't sleep on Don's! read more

Boiled ham turkey and cheese sloppy joe The portion size was very large- could definitely split this sandwich between two people or keep half for leftovers, which makes it a great value for the price! Was delicious. I was expecting a different kind of sloppy joe and was pleasantly surprised and enjoyed eating this one! The focaccia bread was great. read more

Holy cow these are the biggest, most generous helpings of meat on a sandwich. Great variety of choices. Owners are very nice.

This is a great grab and go lunch, I stopped in and definitely couldn't attempt to eat this as I drove on. The small is large and the large is to be shared! I really liked the pepper and mozzarella, excellent sandwich! read more

Great sandwiches with really good sized portions, I like the sloppy Joe with roast beef. I hope this place never closes, it's been open 40+ years for a reason. It's so chill and laid back, but not pretentious with Instagram twenty-something's taking photos. Couple who own it and work at the counter making sandwiches are really nice. read more

You have not had a decent sandwich until you have had one from Don's! The owners ... Pat & Elizabeth are the nicest and caring couple!. We drive up from Barnegat for one of their sandwiches! Try the sloppy joe... trust me! You'll be back for more Bernard & Celia read more

First off I want to say the customer service here is excellent. I called close to closing and they still took my order, very friendly as soon as they answered. I was so relieved because we really wanted a good genuine sub and most delis are closed by 5 but they close @ 8 which was fortunate for me, did not want Subway or Wawa. I walked in and was greeted just as friendly. My family loved the sandwiches, done exactly the way I asked. The portions were huge and the quality of meat snd bread were excellent. A cute Mom & Pop sub shop I would definitely go to again and recommend to anyone. read more

I always get a crispy chicken caeser wrap with mozzarella. The only issue is they don't wrap it right. It's a mess when I try to eat it.

We ordered sandwiches from here during COVID-19. The sandwiches were good (really big) and the woman working when I picked up was very sweet. The shop is small with a very unique concept and overall the experience was good read more

I've been going here for years. Friendly, family run sandwich shop. The subs are packed with meat and always deliver the goods.

Great little sandwich shop that I've been going to for years. Family run with a music studio downstairs. Sandwiches are always great and made to order. Our go to is the roast beef with horseradish sauce. read more

Ordered a rueben sandwich was half hot and half ice cold like it was microwaved then served. The cold sandwich's might be better but not sure if i want to go back to find out. read more

I have been eating at Don's Sandwich Shop for the past 40 years. The sandwiches are fresh and delicious -- and Don and his wife are divine hosts. This is the ultimate Mom & Pop eatery -- and I hope it stays in Boonton forever! read more

Mom and pop type of sandwich shop Main reason that pushed the over from 4 stars to 5 is they have locally made soda and chips and not from giant corporation. Huge bonus. I got a turkey club, the sandwich was loaded with meat and the turkey was very tasty. Not dried out. The woman behind the counter reminded me of my mother making me a sandwich (so she was just about the sweetest woman in the world) This is a great quick and cheap stop for lunch. Even if it may be a bit out of the way read more

This place was clearly an old staple of Boonton. We were starving & needed to stop for a sandwich, so stopped here. We ordered the special, which was a turkey & swiss sandwich, with Russian dressing and cole slaw. Sounded delicious, but the cole slaw made for a very messy sandwich which spilled everywhere. This was made more difficult by the fact that we decided to eat in the car, because the shop itself had a sort of creepy-atmosphere. I would suggest a little decor update to make this place feel more friendly. read more

Great local place. Old school. Clean and very nice owners. Very fair prices. Feel like a kid again with the vintage deli signs and Starsky and Hutch on the tv. Don't judge the place by the exterior. read more