A J&#x27;s Lunch Box

Sad to see that Dave's has closed! We've had the sandwiches here a few times and although we're not…read morefrom the area it's always our top option when in the area. Their eggplant sandwich was just perfect - tangy, saucy and highly flavorful!

Hands down the best sandwiches in Caldwell--no question about it. Dave's Delicious Deli lives up to…read moreits name with every bite. The ingredients are always fresh, the portions are generous, and the flavor? Out of this world. You can tell they take pride in every sandwich they make. But what really made my visit unforgettable was the incredibly kind service. One of the women working there offered me a free can of soda, just as a thoughtful gesture. It's that kind of small-town kindness that makes you want to come back again and again. If you haven't been to Dave's yet, you're seriously missing out. This place is a gem.

Dave's Delicious Deli - Our MegaItalian sandwich. Ham, hot ham capi, salami, pepperoni, and provolone. This one is topped with everything, and roast peppers.

Our MegaItalian sandwich. Ham, hot ham capi, salami, pepperoni, and provolone. This one is topped with everything, and roast peppers.

Homemade white pasta fagioli soup. Seasoned with garlic and fresh herbs. Served with toasted bread for dipping.

See all

Eggplant, garlic roast peppers, red onion, melted mozzarella, and balsamic vinegar.

Cedar Grill & Pizza

4.3(50 reviews)

0.6 mi

This was my first time ordering from here & I decided to have it delivered, since it was freezing…read moreout and I don't drive at night. Delivery would be 45-60 minutes, so I set my timer for 30 so I'd be ready to put the light on in the vestibule for the driver to see. Before I knew it, I got a call that the delivery driver, Joshua, was at the door! It wasn't even 30 minutes! He must have cooked my food on the way over! Joshua was very pleasant and the food was very hot! I ordered a large half sausage pizza with a side of fried mushrooms, which were both delicious. The pie had a nice thick crust, which is how I like it. I never eat the bottom crust, but break off the thick crust and scoop up the toppings. It was perfect! The fried mushrooms were tender with a very crispy & tasty coating. They were a nice size and there were plenty of them...even had some left over. Everything from placing the order with a very sweet lady to my last bite was great! I definitely recommend trying this eatery. FYI: There is parking in the lot behind it (same as where Stephanie's Italian restaurant is, since there is no parking allowed in front on Bloomfield Ave.).

I'm not sure why Cedar Grill & Pizza has 4.4 stars. The staff was friendly and we didn't wait that…read morelong for our food but nothing else about this place warrants that many stars. The pizza, the chicken Parm hero, and the chicken Caesar salad were all average at best. Frankly, not much different than Domino's or Pizza Hut. I can't say anything about Cedar Grill & Pizza was bad but considering there's a pizzeria every block or so in downtown Caldwell, I think you could do better elsewhere.

Fat Koko Sandwich - Better than Rutgers!

Chicken parm sandwich

See all

Marguerita Large 16", Traditional Large 16", French Fries, Caesar Salad (L)

Staci's Sandwich Joint

4.8(61 reviews)

2.4 mi

Women-owned & operated

Catering service

Absolutely insane sandwich spot. Worth the hype in my opinion. The chicken cutlets and bread…read moredeserve all the praise. HIGHLY recommend the chicken Caesar sandwich - that was the star of the show. Be prepared to wait as it does get super busy, especially during lunchtime.

Ordered the chicken Caesar sandwich for takeout and honestly - holy moly cow!! This thing was…read moremassive, which definitely explains the price. I was a little hesitant when I saw the total. If I'm paying around $20 for a sandwich, it better be worth it... and this absolutely was! It was so so good - fresh, flavorful, and super satisfying. Honestly, this was lunch and dinner, and lunch and dinner again the next day. Leftovers can go in the fridge and can be enjoyed the next day just as much. Will be back to try the other sandwiches! Only thing to note is their limited hours, so plan ahead--but it's 100% worth it.

See all

Caldwell Marketplace

4.7(41 reviews)

0.5 mi

Excellent thin chicken cutlets and really not a bad price! Will be back to try other things! I…read morelooked around and saw really nice Italian specialties and the staff were friendly!

The absolute best! They have been our butchers since the day they took over the business, anything…read moreI need, special cuts and they bring my order out to the parking lot! Second to none for quality meats!

See all

Calandra's Italian Village

3.8(842 reviews)

0.8 mi

Came here as a party of 2 on Galentine's Day, February 13th. Previously made reservations via Open…read moreTable. We were immediately shown to our table upon entering the venue. Upon entrance, we were pretty surprised by the lovely Valentine's Day decor for the pop up restaurant. It was a set menu for $70 that included starts with a glass of champagne, appetizer, entrée and dessert. We ordered the seafood salad, calamari, lamb chops, filet mignon, chocolate moose and red velvet cake. Everything was super delicious and very fresh tasting, We had bread brought to our table with olive oil.

ONE STAR -- Heartbreaking Disaster for Our Twin Daughter's First Birthday…read more I am absolutely shocked and heartbroken by the way Calandra's Bakery handled our daughters' first birthday cake. We paid $400 for a custom cake -- and even had to supply our own candy hearts -- and the entire bottom tier collapsed. The cake was constructed incorrectly, the dowels were tilted, and it was sliding off the base. This was not our fault -- this was baker incompetence. The baker was Alida. When we called to report the disaster, the manager Tony was rude, dismissive, and nasty. Instead of helping us salvage the cake, he blamed us, said we should have paid extra for delivery, and then had the nerve to tell us we should drive 35 minutes away, wait 30 minutes while he "fixed" it, and drive 35 minutes back -- all while our twins party was happening. Absolutely unbelievable. After threatening a fraud dispute, Tony finally sent a replacement cake -- which was just a plain white cake with basic piping, looked nothing like what we ordered, and: * Arrived late (promised 2:20, showed up at 2:55) * Our event ended at 3 * Was stale, ugly, and poorly decorated * Had gray piping, not the promised rainbow design When we tried to get an ETA for the replacement cake, Tony did not answer any of our phone calls. When it finally arrived, his attitude was the same -- dismissive and rude -- telling us to "be patient" while the delivery men shrugged at the ruined original cake and tossed it aside. No apology. No compensation. When we asked for compensation, Tony yelled and blamed us, despite the cake being a complete failure due to their mistakes. We were celebrating a once-in-a-lifetime milestone for our daughters, and Calandra's Bakery ruined it entirely. For $400, you expect care, professionalism, and a beautiful cake -- we got disrespect, incompetence, and heartbreak instead. Do not trust Calandra's Bakery with anything that matters.

Paccheri Salsiccia

See all

Paccheri Salsiccia

La Famiglia Ristorante & Pizzeria

3.7(138 reviews)

0.5 mi

We ordered dinner and had it delivered to our hotel. When I placed the order it stated utensils…read morewould be sent. Also, under special instructions I put send utensils please. Order came 15 minutes later than promised. I called the restaurant to say no utensils were sent. I was told "we ran out of utensils and that's why I didn't send any". I asked how we eat lasagna and veal parmesan with our fingers. She said I don't know that is your problem. We are out of utensils-that's it". Very poor customer service. Their sauce was also very bitter.

We have been regular customers at La Familia Ristorante and Pizzeria for many years and have always…read moreenjoyed bringing family and friends when they visit. For Christmas Eve, with my daughter and two granddaughters in town, we made a reservation for five and paid the required $200 deposit. The restaurant was busy due to the holiday, which we completely understood. Service was slow but expected, and we were enjoying the live music and conversation. After receiving our entrées, a frightening incident occurred: my 15-year-old granddaughter was drinking from her glass when it suddenly shattered in her mouth. I saw it happen. Glass shards landed in her mouth and in her plate of food. We immediately brought the broken glass and plate to the staff and asked if the entrée could be remade. A woman who identified herself as the owner came over. She did not ask if my granddaughter was okay, offered no apology, and stated that they would not remake the food, even after I offered to pay for a replacement. At that point, we asked for to-go boxes and our check. The check arrived without deducting the $200 deposit, requiring me to go to the desk to have it corrected, and a refund was needed since the total did not reach the deposit amount. What was most upsetting was not the accident itself, those things happen, but the owner's complete lack of concern, empathy, and professionalism. We were treated as though we were trying to take advantage of the restaurant, despite being frequent patrons who had already paid for the meal. The wait staff has always been kind and professional, which makes this experience even more disappointing. Unfortunately, after this incident, we will not be returning and will be taking our business elsewhere.

See all

Uncle Jerry’s Sandwich Shop

5.0(7 reviews)

2.9 mi

I recently had the pleasure of coming across Uncle Jerry's Sandwich shop. The moment I stepped in,…read moreI was greeted by a vibrant and inviting environment. From classic favorites, to innovative creations, you can get anything you're craving here! I love how modern this spot is while being adorned with nostalgic deli memorabilia. The first time I went I got the Jersey burger which has Taylor ham, cheese, tomatoes, and ketchup (I asked for pickles and he enthusiastically added it to my burger!) Uncle Jerry is passionate about his craft as he provides fresh, flavorful, and affordable meals. His wife Lisa is so sweet, personable, and delightful. I felt so valued as a customer. If you're in the area, or even if you're not in the area, this spot is worth the trip!

Forgot my lunch at home and decided to order for Uncle Jerry's and it did not disappoint. I was…read morecompletely satisfied for sure.

Quadruple turkey club

See all

The Cutting Board Deli & Grill

4.2(91 reviews)

2.3 mi

We worked right next-door and went there all the time…read more Love their Taylor, ham, egg, and cheese, love, LOVE, love their chicken cutlet sandwich - my gosh amazing.- chicken salad is excellent. We've all ordered from there 100 times and we've always enjoyed their food and their service.

I pass by The Cutting Board often, as I work in the area, but have never stopped in until today. It…read morelooks like a dive from the outside (I say this with the most respect, because some of the best food comes from "dives") but it is a no frills essentially side of the road deli with quite an extensive menu. The staff I encountered were friendly & patient, which is shockingly not the norm these days! I ordered the tuna melt & fries & took a seat at the counter. I was the only one sitting along the counter, but there are also a few tables in the back that had parties at them. My food was ready relatively quickly & was served to me with a smile. The fries were of the steak cut variety, which aren't my favorite, but no fault of the delis - just my personal preference. They were cooked well & served hot - can't ask for much more! The tuna melt was actually a sandwich & not an open faced sandwich, as they tend to be, and I found that to be a pleasant surprise. Open faced tend to get soggy quickly. The tuna was aplenty & it was delicious. The bread was perfectly toasted & buttery as well. I do wish it was served with a pickle spear, though. Not sure if that's the norm & mine was forgotten or if it is not served as such. Either way, I'm obviously grasping at straws. Otherwise, it was a delightful lunch. I'm happy to have discovered The Cutting Board & even happier they are in the immediate area of my job, I will definitely be back to try more.

Grilled veggies

See all

Fresco Market & Catering

3.6(106 reviews)

0.9 mi

Attended an event catered by Fresco Market & Catering! Wide…read moreselection of sandwiches! Freshest bread. Loved the chicken cutlets sandwich! Full of flavor! Highly recommend!

Love Frescos. Been going here for 5 years since moving to the area. Love their pizzas and salads…read moreare always fresh. I decided this year I wasn't going to cook Thanksgiving and they had a Thanksgiving package to feed 4-8 people. It was so yummy. Everything was fresh. Turkey was spot on juicy. Love this place and the owners Chris and John are awesome!!!! Thank you!!!

Thanksgiving package

Orzo Salad and Pastrami's sandwich.

See all

Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

Belgiovine Delicatessen

4.7(222 reviews)

3.4 mi

Was only in town for a bit and needed to eat. Got the Fireman with chicken cutlet. It's one…read moreHelluva sangwich!!!!

What is going on here?…read more I ordered the First Avenue sandwich -- a cheesesteak with bacon and sautéed onions -- and it was an absolute salt bomb. Not "well-seasoned." Not "bold." Just aggressively, overwhelmingly salty. Every bite felt like a dare. Between the bacon and the cheesesteak, it was sodium stacked on sodium with zero balance. I genuinely couldn't finish it after two bites. At that point, it felt like I had just thrown money straight into the trash. The sausage stuffed peppers were decent...thankfully. Not mind-blowing, but at least edible and competently made, which is more than I can say for the sandwich. They saved me from a starving morning. Extremely disappointed. I'm all for flavor, but when the dominant note is "are they trying to preserve this for winter?" something has gone very wrong in the kitchen.