This was my first time ordering from here & I decided to have it delivered, since it was freezing out and I don't drive at night. Delivery would be 45-60 minutes, so I set my timer for 30 so I'd be ready to put the light on in the vestibule for the driver to see. Before I knew it, I got a call that the delivery driver, Joshua, was at the door! It wasn't even 30 minutes! He must have cooked my food on the way over! Joshua was very pleasant and the food was very hot! I ordered a large half sausage pizza with a side of fried mushrooms, which were both delicious. The pie had a nice thick crust, which is how I like it. I never eat the bottom crust, but break off the thick crust and scoop up the toppings. It was perfect! The fried mushrooms were tender with a very crispy & tasty coating. They were a nice size and there were plenty of them...even had some left over. Everything from placing the order with a very sweet lady to my last bite was great! I definitely recommend trying this eatery. FYI: There is parking in the lot behind it (same as where Stephanie's Italian restaurant is, since there is no parking allowed in front on Bloomfield Ave.). read more

Love cedar grill. Owners are real nice people. Food is always on point and hits the spot. Happy to see they have fat sandwiches. One of my guilty pleasures. I love the fat cat. Minus the tomato. But all in all. Well done :) read more

See all

I'm not sure why Cedar Grill & Pizza has 4.4 stars. The staff was friendly and we didn't wait that long for our food but nothing else about this place warrants that many stars. The pizza, the chicken Parm hero, and the chicken Caesar salad were all average at best. Frankly, not much different than Domino's or Pizza Hut. I can't say anything about Cedar Grill & Pizza was bad but considering there's a pizzeria every block or so in downtown Caldwell, I think you could do better elsewhere. read more

Customer service is always excellent Friendly staff. Always clean. Food is always fresh and delicious. Friendly staff. I've tried the italian cheesesteak, and chicken parmigiana sandwiches. The Italian cheesesteak is so delicious always made to order with generous amounts of meat. The chicken parmigiana sandwich is delicious and flavorful. I like that the chicken is not thin and the cheese is abundant. read more

Cedar Grill & Pizza - Chicken parm sandwich - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

I've been trying out every pizza spot in the area and this one really stands out. Orders are always accurate. Ingredients are fantastic. They go wild with the amount of toppings. The staff is nice. What more could you want from a local pizzeria? If you don't like your pizza paper thin, this is the place to be on Bloomfield ave read more

My family and I stumbled upon this pizza shop when we got into town. My boys and husband are super picky about their pizzas so I was a little nervous, but we were all hungry after getting off a 5hour flight. I'd have to say, I was pretty happy they were satisfied with the pizza. I'm not really a pizza person, but this supreme pizza was so good! The crust was nice and crispy just the way I like it. I mean, it's true, pizza is better in the East coast! I'd also like to mention that the employees are very accommodating. We wanted to eat indoors and they made room for us even though the shop was pretty full with local kids. read more

Cedar Grill & Pizza - Supreme pizza slice - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Freaking Rediclous!! Ohhhhh! Fantastic! People and food are off the yellzabuffs!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Cedar Grill & Pizza - White Pizza! - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Got wrong food on Uber eats order. Received meatball calzone which cheese wasn't even melted. I ordered i gyro. Didn't feel so great after eating it. read more

Cedar Grill & Pizza - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Amazing. Always a surprise. Have you had the grilled chicken salad? Amazing Cheesesteaks. Go eat. Get fat. read more

We order from often when visiting family in West Caldwell. The people here are incredibly friendly and eager to please. Nothing fancy but a solid pizzeria with excellent sandwiches and pastas. They are known for their fat sandwiches. Just like the Rutgers original they have got busting combos. Cheesesteaks are really good here too. Hell even the breakfast sandwiches rock. I've had a sausage park hero here and it's filling and delicious. Pizza is pretty good too. I also dig the mozzarella sticks with a nice crunch to them. Chicken park and Caesar wraps are family favorites too. Parking in back can be a challenge but is well worth it. Give these guys a try! read more

I neglected to take pix. We were celebrating my hubby's BD by my son's in-laws pool that was just opened. Needed festive food. Giant 24 inch pizzas, fabulous Italian subs and turkey subs to the rescue. Easy curbside pick up. The Italian subs were as good as any Philly Italian subs we have ever had. And as a Philly suburb-born person, I demand fine cheesesteaks, Italian subs, and pizza. Will have to see if this place makes good cheesesteaks in near future. read more

Stopped in here for an eggplant parmigiana sandwich last week and thought it was very good. While I got the sandwich to go, the place has the charm of an old fashioned pizzeria. Only issue I had was parking. There's a lot in back, but difficult finding a spot (at least at lunchtime). read more

The pepperoni pizza is my go to , always reliable , hot and fresh . Service is friendly and people are local , very accommodating service . Small and quaint store , makes you feel right at home . read more

Cedar grill is my go-to takeout spot. Their pizza is consistently amazing and I always order a couple pies with their grilled chicken Caesar salad - delicious and they are super generous with the chicken. Definitely try the fries with a side of cheese & their sandwiches are a hit with my family, specifically the "Fat Mom" among the boys in the house. Food is ready fast whether pick up or delivery. When I pick up the staff and owner are the most kind and friendly. I recommend to everyone!! read more

Cedar Grill & Pizza - Marguerita Large 16", Traditional Large 16", French Fries, Caesar Salad (L) - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

I ordered a Gyro yesterday. It was hot and delicious! Great sandwich made by great guys. Thank you! read more

I've ordered a bit here. Have to say their food is really good. The fat sandwiches are amazing! Club sandwich also another good choice. Also fast delivery, which is great. read more

Cedar Grill & Pizza - Lunch veggie boli with chicken. - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Hands down best pizza!! Love everything on the menu but their pizza and delicious and the slices are huge! Definitely recommend Rodger is super friendly and just the best! read more

I have to say, the cheesesteaks from this place is AMAZING. I came here because the restaurant down the street was closed. This wasn't my first or second choice, but my third. I came here without expecting much and came out with complete satisfaction. The guy at the counter was helpful and extremely nice. The price isn't too expensive either. Definitely my go to spot from now on, if I'm craving a cheesesteak. read more

Excellent food and even better service! The staff here was so kind to us when we needed a place to rest and refuel after our car broke down nearby. Couldn't recommend more! read more

Outstanding sandwiches and pizza! Love the Falafel and Hummus! Meatball Parm - yummy! Turkey Sub - mouth watering! Keep up the great work! read more

Been ordering from here for a few years now and the food and service is always top notch. Pizza is delicious, so is the Italian sub and the cheesesteak. Always friendly as well. read more

Honestly......It was hot trash. It didn't taste very good and I did not like it..... at all

Our Go To lunch place. If we could eat here everyday we probably would. Lol. They say "get Tiffany" when I call now. Lol. Nice owner! You can tell he appreciates his customers! Need more businesses like Cedar Grill. read more

Cedar Grill & Pizza - The menu! - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

I love how they make Pasta Fazool soup there ! It is the best Italian soup I ever eaten . The pizza are pretty good too, as well as ser read more

I've never had the pizza here, but the "fat" sandwiches are incredible. Yes, they will destroy your waistline, but they will simultaneously change your life for the better. The guy behind the counter is really sweet and knows my order whenever I walk in (which means I probably need to cut back... It's just so good!) read more

Just a quick visit for 4 slice of pizza for 2 people on the way to an event. But delicious, filling, pizza (wonderful crust), friendly service. I'll definitely go again if I'm in the neighborhood. Curious about the fat sandwiches! read more

I just had a great high volume workout with the boys and we decided to stop by this place we recently heard of. This place definitely knows how to fill their customers stomachs. I left the place really content with my California Cheese Steak. It's safe to say this place is a 5/5. read more

I just moved back to the area and the food is as great as I remember it. I have to be honest, I've never had the pizza. For me, their big draw are the "fat" sandwiches, made popular at the Rutgers grease trucks in New Brunswick. Being a Rutger alum, I have had many of these fat sandwiches in my day, but I actually think Cedar Grill does it better. In my opinion, the size of their roll is perfect, not too bready, which I often found the Rutgers sandwiches to be. Cedar Grill's fat sandwiches certainly are "fat", but not overwhelmingly so. Excellent stuff! read more

I absolutely love this place. I always get the fat night. It's amazing. Best place in Caldwell hands downs.

Really great pizza and super nice people! Stopped in on a whim and had a wonderful chat with the owner. Ordered one plain slice, and it was perfect. A little crispy, super cheesy, and a huge slice. Definitely would come back or order delivery. Next time I wanna try one their fat sandwiches. read more

I'll keep this short... We moved to the area about a year and a half ago. Tons of pizza in the area and we have tried them all. Coming from Brooklyn, I am picky with my pizza and Cedar Grill and Pizza is the closest to home. I've ordered pizza, fat sandwiches, chicken parm, and calzones, and all were delicious. I stopped by the store a few times and everyone is extremely friendly. Delivery is also fast. I highly recommend you try out Cedar Grill and Pizza. read more

Just moved to the area and stopped in for lunch. Very friendly owner and young men working today. The fat sheriff was excellent and I will be returning again soon! read more

Food is amazing and Roger is the best! Fat sandwiches are insane and the pizza is delicious. Highly recommended!

Our first time ordering from here. Two of us got the Fat Sandwiches and they are absolutely delicious. My coworker got an Italian sub. We did delivery and got it in 45 minutes (for lunchtime in Fairfield, that's good!). However, they forgot the marinara on my Fat Sandwich, the dressing on my coworkers Fat sandwhich (i think ranch? cant remember), and the O&V on my coworkers Italian sub. So it's a tad... dry. read more

Cedar Grill is awesome! Call up and order your fat sandwiches!!! The owner, Rodger is very friendly and always accommodating to the customer's requests. Definitely recommend Cedar Grill! read more

We have been regular customers at Cedar Grill for over 10 years. Our neighbor got us into them. The owner, Roger is such an awesome guy. Talk about NICE, welcoming and actually cares about his customers. He makes us feel like family. His food is unlike anyones in town. His pizza..never a disappointment. When I tell you his pies are cooked to perfection, believe me! The cheese NEVER falls off, never greasy, never burnt. You can pick up a slice without having to worry about it flopping all over the place. The fat sandwiches are amazing (he does them the best) wings are awesome too! We dont order anywhere else. We love Cedar Grill! Do not walk by this place without stopping by. I wish I could give more than 5 stars!!! read more

Fat sandwiches! Need I say more? Roger is the best. Love this place, friendly staff and they make a great pizza.

This is my family's go to place for take out pizza. We always get the Casanova pie with prosciutto, fresh tomatoe slices, and black olives. It's just really good thin pizza. Also a plus that they're open on Sunday evenings! A few other pizza places in the area are not and that's always the day we want to be lazy. read more

This is my go-to spot. They have everything and almost all of it is solid. The pizza is my favorite in town; the crust is crispy without being hard. It can be a little inconsistent based on who's working. The subs and fat sandwiches are good. The burger is a good value. read more

I love the food and have been ordering from here for years. But the new girl who answers the phone is completely incompetent and has messed up really expensive orders (70$+) many times. If you want to keep customers it would be best to not mess up their orders (especially for long time customers). If she cannot handle big orders please put someone on the phone who can. read more