Hands down the best sandwiches in Caldwell--no question about it. Dave's Delicious Deli lives up to its name with every bite. The ingredients are always fresh, the portions are generous, and the flavor? Out of this world. You can tell they take pride in every sandwich they make. But what really made my visit unforgettable was the incredibly kind service. One of the women working there offered me a free can of soda, just as a thoughtful gesture. It's that kind of small-town kindness that makes you want to come back again and again. If you haven't been to Dave's yet, you're seriously missing out. This place is a gem. read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Chicken sandwich - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Sad to see that Dave's has closed! We've had the sandwiches here a few times and although we're not from the area it's always our top option when in the area. Their eggplant sandwich was just perfect - tangy, saucy and highly flavorful! read more

Dave's Delicious Deli in Caldwell is hands down my go-to spot for chicken cutlets. They make the juiciest most tender cutlets I've had anywhere around here. You can get them plain or buttermilk style but the buttermilk is the move. Crispy on the outside and always moist inside. Never dry never bland. The prices are fair for what you get. Portions are generous and the quality stays consistent. They do sandwiches wraps bowls and more and everything can be customized. Ordering through their site is easy and lets you add or remove ingredients without confusion. No need to call or explain anything just click what you want and how you want it and it gets made that way. One thing I always tell people to check out is the bottom section of the online menu. That's where they list customer creations. I don't know the backstory but clearly some of these combos made an impact because they've been kept on the menu. You'll find things that go way beyond your standard deli sandwich. Loaded bowls spicy wraps things you wouldn't think of but somehow work. If you're new to the place that section is a good starting point. You'll get a feel for the style of food and what regulars keep coming back for. Everything is fresh made fast and full of flavor. No gimmicks just solid food done right. Place is small but efficient. You order online and pick up when it's ready. No waiting around no mess. If you're in the area and want a real deli sandwich or something a little different from your usual lunch run this is it. Easy five stars from me. Just try the buttermilk cutlet once and you'll get it. read more

Do not eat here if you don't want to waste gas sitting around waiting for your order to be brought to your car, because there is no other option. The order said it would be ready in 20 minutes, we showed up after 30 and still had to sit and wait - and same for the car in front of us. Do not eat here if you want friendly service on the phone, because it's a long time before you find out you just needed to press 1. And then they hung up on me while I was trying to talk to them about making this easier. I poked my head in to ask them to just pick up the phone. Unfortunately nothing is worth bad service to me. And that's a shame, because there is some tasty stuff to be had. I custom built a buttermilk chicken hot ham sandwich with mango habañero bleu cheese and yes. All the yes. Fresh bread brushed with garlic oil. Meat piled high, filling at even a half 5" sandwich. My sister loved her hot honey chicken bun. Drunken Mimi was rather ordinary by comparison, tasting pretty plain like a regular chicken parm. (Vodka sauce was not distinguishable, chicken was breaded vs. buttermilked.) So, to recap: Build your own, leave later than you think, and PRESS 1 as soon as your phone call goes through. And don't plan on this being a dining experience. Would I ever eat here again? Sure, as long as it's someone else that has to deal with all the trouble of getting the food home. Caveat consumptor. read more

Can't go inside. They don't appear to want you to order on the phone. No patience for new customers and it was offensive. Food was ok. Not worth the hassle of dealing with the odd set up and weird way they serve you through a back alley. You can't enter the restaurant. They obviously don't want to have any customer contact. After interacting with her, I don't want to have any contact with them or their business. Obviously , they don't find a need to get new customers or keep them. read more

The hype is true. This tiny place on Bloomfield Avenue serves an absolutely delicious chicken cutlet sub. I ordered two. They were larger than I expected. My husband and I ended up sharing one for lunch and the other for dinner. I took Yelp advice to call in order. They need about 20 minutes to prepare your sub because they cook the cutlet fresh. And that makes the taste difference. I have been wanting to try but was even more motivated when I saw the owner couple in The New York Times as supporters of Andrew Yang. Perhaps he did drop from the presidential race but I love when hard-working people take a political stance. That makes democracy work. Politics aside, these people know how to make a chicken sandwich. I didn't know what toppers to get as they have 20 plus options. Went with mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, Italian dressing. Delicious. We are eager to return! read more

See all

This place is no joke. The owner is a sweetheart. The food is delicious and very fresh. Highly recommend giving it a try!!

Great place all around! They are currently only doing carside service meaning you have to place your order on their website ahead and wait in your car for them to bring it out. Sandwiches are reasonably priced and loaded with chicken! Personal favorites include the Chicken "Salad" sandwich and the Italian Christmas. Don't let the name of the chicken salad sandwich fool you- this isn't your typical chicken salad. It's essentially chunks of chicken with lettuce, sauce and red onions. As someone who hates traditional chicken salad, I can tell you that this sandwich is anything but usual. The Italian Christmas is garlicy goodness - chicken cutlet or grilled with broccoli rabe, mozzarella and roasted red peppers, oooh and lots of garlic! Definitely a small business you want to support read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Chicken salad sandwich - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

True to its name, Dave's is serving up some delicious food. Their chicken cutlets are perfectly crispy and juicy. Their chicken salad is not your average chicken salad, and is made with chunks of chicken cutlet. My husband ordered it and loved it. I ordered the MugSlawsuit Pickles n Cheddar sandwich and it was so, so good. Everything from the Russian dressing to the bread to the sliced pickles made it a 10 out of 10 sandwich. Reasonable prices and easy online ordering seal the deal. I can't wait to order from Dave's again! read more

I stopped in at Dave's today for a delicious sandwich! It was my first time here and I decided to try the Dolce Eggplant. The eggplant was cooked perfectly with mozzarella and red peppers (I skipped the onions). I was going to get it to go, but while the place is very small, it's a nice set up with tables and I decided to stay. The owners are very pleasant and the prices reasonable, especially since the quality of the food is high. I'll definitely stop back to try some of the chicken specials! Give Dave's a try! read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - New lunch stop! - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Love their sandwich, good flavors and potions, fries are good as well. One of my favorite lunch spot easily.

All I have to say is the Chicken Salad Bowl is so friggin good! I crave Dave's all the time, great job!

Can't go inside the store!! Ridiculous Covid was over long ago. Store looks dirty from the outside, If I am ordering I want to see where it's coming from and that it is clean No thanx read more

Dave's Delicious Deli has the best chicken cutlets around. We have ordered several times and the quality and taste are always on point.

You would be hard-pressed to find a place that makes a better chicken cutlet than Dave's. All sandwiches are great. Easy ordering system they tell you exactly when it's going to be ready ...highly recommend. read more

Today, I ordered the Dave's Standard chicken cutlet sandwich!!! I usually just eat half of a sandwich, but this sandwich was so good, I HAD TO EAT THE WHOLE THING!!!! I read a review on how good this sandwich is but it was so much better than I could have imagined! I had recently ordered Kim's sandwich, on her recommendation, and that was a winner also!!! Kuddos Dave & Kim! I had a delicious lunch thanks to Dave and Kim!! read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Dave's Standard Chicken Sandwich. Need I say more?? - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Before we arrived we were between a 4.5 in Fairfield and Dave's that had 55 reviews and a 5 star rating. Make this 56. The Giant Brian was off the chain. Not because i was hungry either. Well done! We will be back!! read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

It's not often I roll out 5 stars for a sandwich, but man was this satisfying on all levels. The Nicco original chicken salad sandwich is the (messy) way to go. First off, the portion is ridiculous. It's literally overflowing out of the already large hero, and will continue to do so with every bite. I know, first world problems. Wah wah my sandwich is too full. Anyways, the sandwich itself is diced up chunks of their chicken cutlet in their "awesome sauce" along with lettuce, onions, mayo, and vinegar. The end result here essentially tastes like your classic Italian hero but with crispy fried chicken on a soft Italian hero. I loved everything about this. Some advice... extra napkins, a plate, and a fork to eat what will inevitably fall out. This place is awesome, and the Nicco classic chicken salad sandwich is just straight up deliciousness. read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Nicco classic original chicken salad sandwich. Absolutely excellent. - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

This place gets really busy at lunch and it seems it's just a husband and wife running the place. They need to hire some help and not discourage people to leave by saying it's a 30-40 minute wait. Got the Dave's Standard. Great bread. The ham Swiss & peppers go well together. Nice crunchy lettuce. I'm not a fan of Dirty brand chips. I wanna go back and try the soups and a different sandwich. Support local businesses. read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Great deli, a lot of pride in their product with a really polite staff, I'll be back. Had the chicken cutlet, rabe and melted provolone, excellent, a little salty however a ton of flavor. Great and unique chicken salad as well! read more

The crispy chicken salad sandwich(the famous one) is out of this world. No substitutes needed-we have gone out of our way many times to get this sandwich -worth the drive! read more

This will be short, at first, as I am still eating! But I'm so excited (by the food) that I want to start this now... When Jackie suggested something with a chicken cutlet, I first thought of "parm," and she said that of course they could do it, but also pointed to four customer favorites at the top of the electronic menu. I'm so glad that I got the one with roasted sweet peppers, melted mozzarella, red onion, and a dash of balsamic vinaigrette. It is awe-some! A good-sized portion that I thought I might save half for later, but so tasty and juicy and tender that I now have finished the whole thing, and I'm so glad. Now I can say that I have met (the) Dave, who is as hospitable as Jackie is. As It was after the lunch rush hour, we all chatted about many things. This is a now a destination place for me, if I'm going to be anywhere near the neighborhood. I might even try something else, after a few more "#4's". Like the #1, which is an upgrade, swapping the mozz out for Swiss, and adding ham. read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Welcome! - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Tried the Chicken Parm and Garlic Pasta Fagioli soup. The breaded chicken cutlet is amazing. I would definitely try any sandwich that has the chicken in it. The chicken parm would've been perfect if it had more marinara sauce. The soup was good too. I definitely would come back to try other stuff on the menu, like the chicken salad. The service was good, despite only having two people working at the time. It took a while for my order to be ready (about 15-20 min) and I ordered in. To be fair, it was during lunch time and they had multiple phone orders. But I could see how beneficial it'd be if they had additional employees working. They also provide limited parking in the back of the building so I didn't have to look for street parking. Overall, I would definitely come back. But maybe instead of ordering in during lunch time, I would call to order. read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Chicken Parmigiana & Garlic Pasta Fagioli soup - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

I have to show this place some love. An old friend from my hometown of CA came out and I always make it a point to show him east coast cuisine. Glad I chose this place. Hands down the best sandwichES we have ever eaten (we got an assortment). Unfortunately, the day we went, they were not serving cold cuts (maybe COVID related). Doesn't matter, the chicken cutlet sandwiches were absolutely phenomenal. Start yourself off right with the Dave's Standard. Perfect crunch you want, bread was soft in the right places, flavor profiles of each sandwich was on point. I live about 30 minutes away but have no problem driving out of my way to grab a sandwich here. Honorable mention to the French fries. They have every kind of fry in the book, so we got an assortment. They have a special sauce that at first glance looks like ketchup and mayonnaise mixed together. We thought, these guys ain't foolin no one. But there's something more to that sauce. One of those taste's that every bite made it more addicting. Delicious combo and great food. Eat here. read more

Love chicken sandwiches. Have tried most of them esp Dave's standard, Mediterranean-Rex, and Italian Christmas. Friendly staff and food always good!! read more

I had to apply some Math in order to provide an accurate review of Dave's Delicious Deli. 5 stars for the sandwiches but only one star for service so Dave gets 3 stars. Dave should seriously consider firing the woman who takes your order. She has the potential to wreck his business by telling customers they are too busy to make you a sandwich. If I am turned away one more time... I will never come back. If he fires the woman at the register... I will be a customer for life. read more

Fairly priced, amazing taste. Can't ask for much more! Everything I have ever ordered from there was delicious. Can't wait to go back.

I really liked Nicco's and I'm so happy Dave's is there to continue things. I took my Dad and brother to get sandwiches today so I could share the awesomeness. We got 2 chicken cutlet sandwiches, chicken tenders (which are giant) and mozzarella sticks. This place is special because it's so simple and familiar and just good. read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

I recently started working next door at the salon and the girl introduced me to Dave's deli. They recommend that I get the chicken salad and it was hands down, the best chicken salad I've had. I've been hooked! I had the chicken salad twice so far and now the "basic stuff" sandwich is basically like the salad but with bread and I loved it as well. Dave's Deli knows how to do chicken cutlet right!!! I highly recommend!! read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - The famous chicken salad - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Damn.....I'll say it again.....Damn.....Why did it take me 45 years to find this place? Sick Chicken Cutlets! I got a Chicken Cutlet, American Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Red Onions, Banana Peppers, & Spicy Mayo on Toasted Garlic Bread. What a masterpiece! You can't go in right now so order through their webpage. Sandwichs are very customizable. ton of options. read more

I don't normally send in reviews but this fine establishment stole my heart. The food is in fact delicious the chicken cutlet is super tender and fresh you can tell that the food is made with Love. I have been here twice and each time the owners provided great service. I'm happy I was told to check this place out by my coworker cant wait to try everything else they have on the menu. Btw thanks for letting me try those crystal shrimp dumplings soooooo good! read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Chicken salad sandwich from my first visit the picture does not do it justice... delicious! - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

The name is quite fitting - the Chicken sandwiches are beyond delicious. Chicken is cut, breaded, and cooked perfectly. I drive and hour round trip just for a sandwich from this place. My boyfriend is a regular here when he's on job sites near by and was constantly talking about it so I had to try it for myself. HIGHLY recommend, as they will not disappoint! read more

Dave's Delicious Deli - Delis Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Yummy. Everyone always says to go. I've gone in late afternoon closed. Bummer Finally got to go. It was awesome. Zucchini sticks. Perfect. The chicken sandwich was awesome. Great fresh flavor. Go in with a plan. They are busy. The girl behind the counter was great. read more

Fantastic sandwiches and creative menu. Do not sleep on their fish and chips either ! I'm

Great neighborhood deli. In an area with plenty of options Dave's is a cut above. The sandwiches are spectacular and the service is friendly with some personality and heart. Assuming you like good food and are tired of corporate drones (so...everyone), Dave's is the spot. read more

This place makes the best hot sandwiches in town!!! The bread is fresh and the chicken is made to order so it's not sitting out all day plus the owners are always present so you know that's a good sign. I usually get the chicken salad sandwich. it's the best I've ever had...my kids decided she's now a vegetarian so someone recommended the eggplant parmigiana sandwich at Daves and there's no doubt she loved it ! read more

Love the chicken sandwiches here. The long hots and other peppers elevate every sandwich. I was a bit disappointed with the Philly cheesesteak as it was just average and the chicken parm sub could have used a little extra sauce, but this place is amazing. I'll stick to the chicken salad sub and the other amazing chicken cutlet sandwiches. read more

Dave's is amazing! They made me a grill cheese with bacon and tomatoes it was orgasmic! Another favorite is the Giant buttermilk chicken tenders, soooooo yummy. The soups are all very good as well. I highly recommend this place. read more

Had the Kim's Style fish sandwich. It was delicious. Can't wait to go back next Friday. They were busy and all the food I saw looked tasty. read more

What can you say about this place except it delivers quality sandwiches. The chicken is always moist and delicious. And the owners are very accommodating. Excellent lunch spot. read more