Caldwell Marketplace

Sad to see that Dave's has closed! We've had the sandwiches here a few times and although we're not…read morefrom the area it's always our top option when in the area. Their eggplant sandwich was just perfect - tangy, saucy and highly flavorful!

Hands down the best sandwiches in Caldwell--no question about it. Dave's Delicious Deli lives up to…read moreits name with every bite. The ingredients are always fresh, the portions are generous, and the flavor? Out of this world. You can tell they take pride in every sandwich they make. But what really made my visit unforgettable was the incredibly kind service. One of the women working there offered me a free can of soda, just as a thoughtful gesture. It's that kind of small-town kindness that makes you want to come back again and again. If you haven't been to Dave's yet, you're seriously missing out. This place is a gem.

Dave's Delicious Deli - Our MegaItalian sandwich. Ham, hot ham capi, salami, pepperoni, and provolone. This one is topped with everything, and roast peppers.

Our MegaItalian sandwich. Ham, hot ham capi, salami, pepperoni, and provolone. This one is topped with everything, and roast peppers.

Homemade white pasta fagioli soup. Seasoned with garlic and fresh herbs. Served with toasted bread for dipping.

See all

Eggplant, garlic roast peppers, red onion, melted mozzarella, and balsamic vinegar.

A J's Lunch Box

4.5(39 reviews)

0.5 mi

Called and placed an order for Cheesesteak Plain and a Slam Dunk. While running around in Jersey on…read moreerrands. Really enjoyed the sandwiches from A J's Lunch Box. Something about the bread when it is fresh, soft and chewy. Filled with meat and gives me the feeling of being in Philly for one of their CheeseSteaks sandwiches. Reasonably priced and have been ordering from them for the past two days via the phone and picked up the food. Will be back again.

Came in for the first time from out of town for breakfast and decided to give AJ's a chance. Hands…read moredown one of the best spontaneous decisions made. Walked in and we were greeted with a chill vibe - guys working were super friendly and welcoming. Ordered a platter with eggs and home fries (super tasty potatoes that were well seasoned and had a slight crunch on the outside), and a breakfast bagel. The staff were very accommodating and kind. The prices were also quite reasonable. Will absolutely visit again if we're in the area. Overall, it was an eggsellent find

See all

Friendly small town feel!

The Cutting Board Deli & Grill

4.2(91 reviews)

2.4 mi

We worked right next-door and went there all the time…read more Love their Taylor, ham, egg, and cheese, love, LOVE, love their chicken cutlet sandwich - my gosh amazing.- chicken salad is excellent. We've all ordered from there 100 times and we've always enjoyed their food and their service.

I pass by The Cutting Board often, as I work in the area, but have never stopped in until today. It…read morelooks like a dive from the outside (I say this with the most respect, because some of the best food comes from "dives") but it is a no frills essentially side of the road deli with quite an extensive menu. The staff I encountered were friendly & patient, which is shockingly not the norm these days! I ordered the tuna melt & fries & took a seat at the counter. I was the only one sitting along the counter, but there are also a few tables in the back that had parties at them. My food was ready relatively quickly & was served to me with a smile. The fries were of the steak cut variety, which aren't my favorite, but no fault of the delis - just my personal preference. They were cooked well & served hot - can't ask for much more! The tuna melt was actually a sandwich & not an open faced sandwich, as they tend to be, and I found that to be a pleasant surprise. Open faced tend to get soggy quickly. The tuna was aplenty & it was delicious. The bread was perfectly toasted & buttery as well. I do wish it was served with a pickle spear, though. Not sure if that's the norm & mine was forgotten or if it is not served as such. Either way, I'm obviously grasping at straws. Otherwise, it was a delightful lunch. I'm happy to have discovered The Cutting Board & even happier they are in the immediate area of my job, I will definitely be back to try more.

Grilled veggies

See all

IL Panino Italian Deli

4.2(80 reviews)

2.6 mi

Sooo good. We go here every chance we get. Have yet to find a menu item that we dont like…read more Extra special sandwiches. Great prices generous sandwichea and extremely tasty. I always make a point to leave a review for stand out food. Very good place. Doesn't diassapoint.

Bread was fresh, service was good, place was clean! Got a simple salami sandwich and it was pretty…read moregood, next time going to ask for more meat, but all good!

See all

Chicken park sandwich

Il Classico

4.5(46 reviews)

3.0 mi

il Classico is absolutely fabulous, the food is great, the team is beyond compare! Our lunch…read moreorders are always correct, delivered on time, and a great value. The team there work with you to get what's needed, really just a fantastic establishment!

Always gotta make a stop in whenever traveling to this part of the neighborhood. They put together…read moresome seriously super delicious Sub Sandwiches here. Their version of a Classic Italian Sub is definitely worth checking out as it's generously loaded with fresh sliced Meats and Cheeses on the perfect freshly baked Long Roll plus they don't skimp on extras either. Whenever I ask for more Banana Peppers, I always get exactly what I ask for and you can't beat that. Now that's a Killer Sandwich!! First timers need to just follow the signs and order at the back end of the counter so as not to cause any confusion. I always find Service here to be friendly and efficient even during peak lunchtime hours plus prices won't kill your budget either. Do yourself a favor and bookmark this place, You're Welcome!! Come And Get Your Munch On!!

Where The Sandwich Magic Happens!!

3. Roasted Turkey Classic Sandwich Added fresh mozzarella and balsamic glaze.

See all

Millburn Deli

4.3(924 reviews)

8.2 mi

Over the weekend I made my at least 5th order here. Every time it is very predictable no matter…read morewhat I get., excellent!!! They have to put a lot of thought and love into everything that they put out. Home of the best Sloppy Joes!! From sandwiches to salad to iced tea and desserts I highly recommend this place. I had to take the time to leave a review this time because I felt it was very overdue. The gobbler sandwich is yummy, The Godfadda, The Gossip Girl, I also have had an egg salad with layer of tuna salad Sloppy Joe-that is amazing! The Cobb salad is also a fave. My friends rave about all the sandwiches they have tried. They are very friendly behind the counter and the order takers are fast and efficient. It gets crowded but moves fast.

Sandwiches are really fresh and tasty. The gobbler can be a little skimpy on turkey but still…read moredelicious. The sloppy Joe's are great and don't forget the chili basil bowtie salad. My go-to is the make your own salad with chunks of turkey. They don't skimp on the protein or your choice of veggies and the salad is huge!

Wild Bull

See all

Old school exterior

Eppes Essen Deli & Restaurant

3.5(334 reviews)

3.5 mi

These folks know what they are doing. If you're going to complain about spending a few extra…read moredollars on a pastrami sandwich, clearly quality doesn't matter to you. Everything here is excellent. You get what you pay for - and you get a throw back deli experience here. Did take out tonight to treat my elderly parents to some pastrami and tongue. Order ready when promised. Everything fresh and tasty. Successful Friday night dinner. Five stars well earned, Eppes Essen.

Ridiculously overpriced for terrible service. Slow beyond explanation with only 3 other tables of…read morepeople and with zero communication at the pickup counter. This place has no shot of attracting customers from younger generations as it currently operates. Millburn deli has equivalent food with a great experience.

Sloppy joes

Gorgeous

See all

The Classic

Sam's Bagel & Deli

3.6(91 reviews)

1.1 mi

Sam's is a small but sufficiently solid Deli that bakes up some seriously delicious Bagels having…read morefirm shiny exteriors and fluffy flavorful warm interiors that offer a nice overall chew to them. They also offer Brooklyn style "Flagels" here too which are essentially flat bagels for those who crave the crunchy golden crust of a Bagel more than the soft chewy center. To each their own, but whatever the case may be I'm "officially" a fan of this place. First thing in the morning the Freshly Brewed Coffee is always on point and I like that customers get to make their own cup exactly how they want it. Never too much sugar or creamer - nope, it's always a perfect cup of Coffee each and every time. Service here is awesome the Girls at the Counter are always friendly, fast, efficient, and even when there's a long line they keep it moving along pretty quickly. Plenty of parking out in their shared lot with easy in-and-out access to either of the Avenues. Come And Get Your Morning Munch On!!

Great bagel sandwich. Kinda messy line up/ordering/pickup situation. Place gets busy but they move…read morethings along in a reasonable amount of time. Not much space to hang out or sit and eat, so plan to take it elsewhere!

A roast beef sandwich

See all

Violante & Son

4.7(57 reviews)

2.6 mi

Great sandwiches and friendly staff! Knowledgeable and all their sandwiches and sub in a tub…read more Favorite is the Tuesday special the chicken parmigiana sandwich.

This is the best choice you can make for a butcher. I've been a customer of theirs for about 30…read moreyears. Unfortunately I moved to Florida, and they are the business and food I miss the most - hands down. Anthony is very helpful in every way possible, there's nothing like this place anywhere else that I've ever seen in my time !!!

Groceries

Flank Steak

See all

Cheeses

Belgiovine Delicatessen

4.7(222 reviews)

3.2 mi

What is going on here?…read more I ordered the First Avenue sandwich -- a cheesesteak with bacon and sautéed onions -- and it was an absolute salt bomb. Not "well-seasoned." Not "bold." Just aggressively, overwhelmingly salty. Every bite felt like a dare. Between the bacon and the cheesesteak, it was sodium stacked on sodium with zero balance. I genuinely couldn't finish it after two bites. At that point, it felt like I had just thrown money straight into the trash. The sausage stuffed peppers were decent...thankfully. Not mind-blowing, but at least edible and competently made, which is more than I can say for the sandwich. They saved me from a starving morning. Extremely disappointed. I'm all for flavor, but when the dominant note is "are they trying to preserve this for winter?" something has gone very wrong in the kitchen.

Yum! So delish! I loved everything I had here! From the sandwiches to the salads, everything is…read morefresh and tasty! The customer service is great too! You can stop by and pick something up to go or order it for pick up!