It had been quite a few years since I'd been to this diner in Sparta. Since then, I believe there was a fire and it was rebuilt. Well it's much nicer now than it was back then. Modern inside but still has that classic Jersey diner feel to it. I ordered the traditional breakfast of 2 eggs over easy with bacon, hash browns, and toast. Plenty of bacon and the hash browns had a nice crisp to them. Multi grain toast was a nice option. Good place to stop if you're around Sparta. Large menu, good food! read more

See all

Went here for breakfast and food did not disappoint. We ordered the Florentine omelet with mushrooms and the Texas breakfast bowl. Portions were huge so we both left with leftovers. Atmosphere was nice with retro style booths and bar stools. Waitress was pleasant and attentive. Will definitely be back to try their lunch/dinner menu read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Florentine omelette, Texas Breakfast Bowl - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Solid Jersey diner fare. What made it great for me is that they have a TON of gluten free modifications available for those of us with celiac. Also, the shakes are wild. I was too full to order one but will be back for the Nutella milkshake with, like, six other family members so we can actually make a dent in it. Utter madness. read more

Happy Taco Tuesday in Sparta, New Jersey! I told my friend that we should have tacos for dinner. She knew that Sparta Classic Diner had tacos on their menu, so she drove us there! The interior was really cute with an old school, country feel... and an indoor (artificial) fireplace! Service was efficient and friendly. Our server had down-to-earth hospitality! She knew to offer us takeout containers at the end of the meal because we were so full! I got the Fish Tacos, grilled. They came with a side of rice and beans - and sweetly tart, fried plantains. The moist fish was topped with fresh veggies and cheese! Very yummy! I finished all ofthe leftovers when we got back to the house! Great midnight snack! Hope you had a Happy Taco Tuesday! read more

See all

Great layout and seating options. Diner style of course. Service is always very nice. We have been here many times. Today is st pats weekend so for breakfast I decided I am going to try the Irish skillet.... And it was pretty good. Good change of pace. As far as diners go this is about as good as it gets. Enjoy I know we will again. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Came here over the weekend to enjoy a lovely meal with my wife. The food was excellent albeit I wish I got one of the desserts! Food: we ended up getting the breakfast burrito (my wife) and I got a firehouse burger. The burger was made well and a unique aspect was that they provided you chili fries with them! Service: the young girl was nice that helped us, albeit a bit slow (only saw her three times the entire time), but she was super patient with us when she was with us and double checked everything. Aesthetic: real clean diner with two sides for seated eating plus a bar-styled seating when you walk in read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

See all

One of the best diners around--great food, friendly staff, and that classic hometown atmosphere that keeps you coming back!

The grilled steak tacos were the worst I've ever had. The meat tasted spoiled, and I almost vomited after one bite. The kind server took it back, but I won't return. The service was amazing, and the staff were lovely. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Grilled Steak Tacos - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Been here many time and always love it! Today I had a spinach Cobb salad with grilled salmon and it was so fresh, tasty, delicious. Nice people, easy to get to and park. Very enjoyable diner. read more

Food is great and good vibe inside the restaurant with cool lights and stuff, but the food is very overpriced for the portion and quality of it, if they can lower the price here this place would be flawless read more

Typical Jersey diner. Their food was good! Got the thanksgiving sandwich special. It's been one of the better ones I've had this season as I like to try them wherever I go since I love thanksgiving food. However, the service was kinda slow in the beginning that we had to go ask for a waitress. When our waitress finally did come over she wasn't the friendliest and it felt like we were bothering her. Towards the end of our meal she seemed to become more friendly. read more

See all

I've lived in Sparta for 25 years and do not come here anymore, the food is unbelievably expensive and mediocre, owner must know his food is bad and overpriced, blame inflation? Na greedy owner read more

Here's the deal... After a fire closed this place down for a year It's good to have this upscale diner back and better than before. read more

See all

Some dishes I've gotten I have absolutely loved (the bandito burrito and the skillets) but other dishes are just a bit plain. Overall, like it enough to come back and try new things. Good service and plenty of seating including an outdoor area. read more

Met some old friends here for lunch. The diner looks very new on the inside and is very clean. Service was friendly but it was a struggle to get the orders in as there was a bit of a language barrier. I ordered a classic reuben and it was quite good. Others ordered tacos and other sandwiches. Overall the consensus was that it was above average. Definitely worth a visit but don't expect to be blown away. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Classic Diner Reuben with pastrami - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Came for dinner and the food took a while. Not too big of a deal but the dressing was wrong and my steak was not hot at all. They had to remake the salad and by the time it came back out the steak was cold. We had to ask 3 times for butter on my daughter's "Butter" noodles. When the server brought it out she said "it's because they had to melt it". It doesn't take 15 minutes to melt butter. Take some accountability and admit you forgot twice! We were done eating by the time she got her butter. Finally, we wanted dessert and when we asked for the menu she said "that's the shakes menu, the rest is pies we have on a tray". So we expected her to come out with a tray to show us the desserts. After a few minutes we flagged her down again and she said "did you decide what you wanted?" We said we don't know what you have! We haven't seen the menu/tray. THEN she finally explained we're supposed to get up from the table and walk over to their pie station to see what we want. We got the check and left. Never coming back. Waste of money. Servers name was Autumn. read more

food was not enjoyable and the waitress was extremely rude to me while clearly trying to flirt with my boyfriend. this was one of the worst diner experiences i've had! read more

Terrible service. Horrendous manager. My party of 5 got coffee from cloveberry and came here for food. We were sat at a table and ten minutes later the server came in asking for our order and ended with "also the manager is not happy because you came in with outside drinks" we were not told anything until after our orders were taken. The server continued " do you guys want to order anything to drink because you will be charged for coffee if you don't". So the manager was going to charge us for the drinks we paid for at a different store... stingy and unethical read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Being charged for drinks we bought from another store... - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Food was excellent, device was great and it was classic diner food! Definitely recommend 10/10 read more

See all

Would go again - This diner is a gem in a quiet neighborhood in comparison to suburbs closer to NYC. Sparta is a very relaxing town and Lake Mohawk near this diner is such a good R&R place to visit. In addition, you have this diner that has many menu items fit for foodies. My friend and I ordered the buffalo mac and cheese, southwest chicken sandwich, and BBQ burger. Gosh...all 3 of these foods were delicious! They have so many other unique foods and their milkshake looks insane...given the amount of food we ordered, we had to skip it. The buffalo Mac and cheese was some of the best I ever had. Creamy but cheesy and it did not get dried up as most mac and cheeses do. Interior is very clean for a diner. It has a old school but modern vibe to it. Parking lot has ample spots. Visit Lake Mohawk after a good meal at this diner. read more

See all

First time coming to this diner. First impressions were good! It was the cleanest and most modern I have seen in a while and service wasn't the best but also was not awful. My issue was when my food came out. I ordered a pork sandwich. You know the string that chefs use to tie the pork and keep it together while cooking? Yes i found several of those in my food. Needless to say I was excited to bring family here but now I'm looking for better options. read more

Pretty good food, amazing service and pretty amazing ambiance ! The service is always great the 3 times I've gone. The milkshakes look beautiful but they're not as tasty as they look. It's all sugar and level Chocolate or whatever flavor. The diner looks beautiful and very clean read more

Been here 3x in the last 2 months. Brought large groups of family members and the food quality it top notch! Best quality diner food in the area! Their hot cocoa is not Swiss mix or hot water or hersheys syrup, no sir, it's the real deal with hot milk and premium Ghirardelli cocoa. Their oatmeal is with hot milk and no sugar so perfect for a healthy person. Their teas are all organic. This diner has spoiled me as no other diner can compete. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Oatmeal - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

See all

service was good but the food was horrible. I cannot believe we were charged full price for meals we did not eat! we will never return to the Sparta Classic Diner! UPDATE: The owner has reached out to me regarding my experience and is attempting to make things right. I commend him on his efforts and will give the Sparta Classic Diner a chance to redeem themselves. Once I visit again I will update this post again. read more

Good spot for good food, good service, and clean. Had the corned beef skillet, chicken fajitas omelette, and chocolate shake. Loved that the chocolate shake was chocolate icecream and milk instead of syrup with vanilla. Definitely would recommend. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Carrot Cake - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Holy milkshakes!!! This place has the BEST milkshakes. They looked so good we had to order one and it did NOT disappoint. We got the cheesecake one, topped with a slice of delicious cheesecake with vanilla ice cream, gram cracker crumbs, and totally worth the extra calories. The food was great too! I had a chicken wrap and my fiancé had a burger. Everything was excellent and I was thrilled to be able to get my disco fry fix while visiting New Jersey. This place offers a huge menu, right on the placemat, which is typical of a diner up there. There is definitely something for everyone. My sister, who is vegan, had no trouble finding an option for her to eat. If you're in Sparta and craving some good food and a milkshake- definitely check this place out! read more

See all

Everything here is always delicious! Down to the lemonade. Very freshly made food. Melt in your mouth French toast. And not to mention the wonderful milkshakes. read more

Just not impressed. I know y'all are crazy about the elaborate shakes... but... not me. Decor is nothing special. It's a smaller place than I expected. Service was good. Food was too. But nothing to justify the price! Lots of on site parking. It's all below average. IMO read more

Monday night visit just for their milkshakes which are really several desserts combined. Each dessert individually was great but together was amazing. Had the funfetti shake. There's a piece of cake under all of the whipped cream and sitting on top of the milkshake class My friends ordered the equally mammoth Oreo shake and chocolate peanut cheesecake. Bravo for theses treats read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Family waited for almost an hour for food. Everyone's food was ice cold and my burger wasn't there. Manager said he would take care of the cold food. When they finally brought my burger this is what it was. Raw.manager offered free desert and comped the burger. Still gave us a bill for bull price though. Never coming back. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Raw Brunch Burger - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

I've been here half a dozen times, usually for dinner, since they reopened, and give it 4 stars for the food quality. Burgers and eggs are good. Peeves - 1. the coffee is too strong. I really cannot enjoy it. 2. pricey. At least a buck or 2 more than comparable area diners. 3. always an upcharge for a substitution. What happened to accommodating the customer? 4. Efficiency of wait staff could be hit or miss. Honestly, I prefer a diner in the neighboring town. read more

First time I went after they reopened following the fire. I was served a completely raw burger when ordered medium. Other than removing the item from the bill, the owner stated that the kitchen was getting use to new equipment. Sorry, but anyone could see that it never touched the grill. Today I gave them a second chance. I ordered eggs Benedict. The eggs came completely hard boiled. Told the waitress and again nothing was done. I paid and will not be back. read more

Atmosphere: Since we didn't go to the Sparta Classic Diner, I can't say for sure, but I've seen photos of the exterior and it looks like the Classic Diner feel. I will say our delivery service was perfect and safe. The delivery driver made sure we received our food and we felt safe and comfortable while doing so. Milkshake: Instead of ordering coffee, I went with a brownie milkshake. I was also eying the black forest milkshake. It was a vanilla milkshake with brownie at the bottom and extremely good. Plus, there was plenty of whipped cream on the top. Food: The Sparta Classic Diner many has everything you could want or need in a diner. There is all-day breakfast, plus lunch, and dinner specials. There are plenty of healthy options, too, if you're craving a salad or something lighter. They also have a gluten-free menu, and it looks like accommodate any dietary needs. I don't see tacos very often, so I decided to order the fish tacos. They came with grilled or fried cod, rice, and fried plantains. I haven't had fried plantains in quite some time, and I like them, so I was excited for them. The fish tacos were delicious.  There was plenty of guacamole inside too. The fried plantains and rice met my expectations, and you would never guess you were getting takeout from a diner. Service: You can easily order your meal online. One thing I do wish was if there was a way to have an option for delivery that isn't "ASAP." It's a minor issue, but it would be nice. The delivery driver brought out food and made us feel safe. Cost: $ The Sparta Classic Diner is one of the more expensive diners out there.  Most entrees cost $20+. For the milkshake, tacos, and delivery, it was $26.50. It was high-quality food, so it was worth it. Would I Go Back? I'm happy we got takeout from the Sparta Classic Diner. It was delicious and I would love to go back when restaurants are open again. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Takeout fish tacos - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Excellent Diner! For those that haven't been since reopening, I highly suggest giving it another try! Incredible Positive Change!

Wow! The food was tasty, well proportion and the service was great. I love dinners and this just made my top 5 favorites. The environment was welcoming and the food was delicious. The indoor area was well spread and they also had the outdoor area! Overall enjoyed having a late breakfast here, will be coming back soon! read more

See all

What an amazing breakfast love the service admosffio nice I really enjoy it thank you

Food was ok, when it finaly arrived correctly. Our server Autumn had many chances to make are visit better but failed every time. No knowledge of the menu, wrote down order wrong, had no understanding of what taking a correct order means. Embarrassed us for not knowing there was no desert menu printed. We had to ask 4 times for a side of butter for my daughters dry "buttered noodles" 25 minutes later it arrived after multiple requests. At that point her food was ice cold. I could go on with even more incidents but im honestly over the whole experience.I will never step foot in this place again, I suggest you avoid it as well. read more

Reopened in June 2023, I was glad the service and food met all my expectations. The interior was redone with updated facilities.

Our family loves the Sparta classic diner. It has something for everyone and all the food is well prepared. It's our go to for those busy kid sports nights. read more

For many years this was our favorite diner to get breakfast or lunch. Thus after the fire we looked forward to its reopening. Unfortunately our recent visit was a major disappointment. My wife ordered the the spinach Cobb salad with chicken - price was an astounding $19.90. I ordered the Italian chicken panini at $14.95. My wife's salad was good but at almost $20.00 was terribly overpriced. My smallish chicken sandwich was also good and came with a small side order of fries. With beverages and tip the bill was slightly over $50.00 which is ridiculous for a lunch. All the food is now very over priced. We will not be back - so sad. And based upon recent reviews so will many other people. read more