Another stop to fill a long-needed empty space: diner sausages. I had the River Star Special. I chose pancakes and added a sausage to the 1 already offered. Eggs over medium. All done to perfection. Service was exceptional. Beth was very nice and on the spot. We didn't have to ask for anything, she asked us if we needed it. We got our much-missed cokies as we left, too. We may have to stop back in before we go back to Wisconsin. read more

See all

I came here with my two friends and her mom i ordered the orange jucie it was spicy, warm, with an odd olive juice taste. food was aight, finished it in about 3 minutes. might just be because i'm obese but i don't think so, i weigh around 244.87 lb and inhaled it. was debating on asking for more but price was to high. read more

What a great spot to stop in for a lovely breakfast! Ended up this side of NJ and needed to kill some time and fill up - picked the right place. The service was excellent and everyone was kind and polite. Not to mention the food came out very quickly which I appreciate! Next time I'm around I'll definitely pop back in and try lunch! read more

River Star Diner - Sausage Omelette with mushrooms, jalapeños and cheddar - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

The food here is pretty good for a diner, there isn't many a wide variety of items available on the menu. Almost all the servers are nice and kind, and the atmosphere is very good. read more

I came here for lunch today. I had chicken noodle soup, which was sour because it was bad. Turkey club I had had lunchmeat turkey on it, which is no good . This is my second time recently coming here and both times I had violent diarrhea afterward. I won't be back. read more

This place NEVER disappoints. Food is plentiful and good. Large selection with so many options. Our waitress was attentive and helpful with suggestions. Typical diner ambiance and we got a table with a view of the river. Will definitely come back. read more

See all

A friend suggested stopping in to River Star Diner today and glad we did. Great staff, comfortable seating and omletes, Waffles and coffee! Perfect way to relax on the banks of the Muskenetgon River. No complaints here and will return. read more

See all

The food was pretty good and the service was excellent. Only issue are the drafts coming in through the window. Had to eat with my coat on. read more

Excellent service, food and the most beautiful atmosphere. The menu is long and everything is delicious. Heaven in a diner. read more

See all

Awesome diner on 57 with tons of parking and lots of seating. You never have to wait to be seated and the place is always packed. Service is fast and the food hot and tasty. A great place for 3 meals a day. read more

Worst meatloaf I have ever had. Only good thing was the waitress was good. I qouldnt go here ever again.

The food at the River Star is great. One of the last true New Jersey Diners operating today. I dare you to find a bad option on there extensive menu. Best disco fries in North Jersey. If you don't know what disco fries are, you're not around here. And our property taxes are low. But you should find out. Seriously, the food at the Riverstar is consistently good, and if you order one of their specials either for dinner or whatever you're gonna be more than pleasantly surprised. Their prices are reasonable in an unreasonable world. The service, however, is outstanding. The experienced waitresses, well they got you, hon. They will make you feel like you're at your wise Auntie's table. You know what I'm talking about the one that knows you were out all night when only the devil and emergency rooms are open. Younger waitresses here serve well beyond their years. They all honestly want you to be happy and are more than willing to keep your drink full, even if you drink like dry storm drain, like I do. These serves always make sure any of your special orders, arrive as desired. Now make sure to tip your waitresses and waiters before you leave. At the classic diner counter you will observe the regulars who found a second family and home. Behind the river star is the sometimes raging Musconetcong River, that compliments, the chrome and pleather perfectly. In the spring, my advice would be to sit in the back of the dining area and watch the mama and baby ducks swim bye. In short, the River Star Dinner is everything a New Jersey diner is supposed to be. Friendly reasonably priced in a place where you're not only get a great meal but you may make a friend. read more

Great food, amazing service, and affordable with a classic diner ambiance. Will be back read more

River Star Diner - Pastrami & Two Eggs - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

We eaten breakfast & lunch here several times & always enjoyed our food. The omelettes are always delish & the large greek salad with chicken is spot on! Lots of goodies in the salad including pita & stuffed grape leaves. Service has always been fine here - they will always check to see if you need a refill, etc. My only complaint is that the parking is tight & a little difficult as you have to back out onto Rt.57 but don't let that deter you from stopping in & getting some good food! read more

Overall, I like the Diner. Today I ordered the roast beef French Dip. Never again. Totally disgusting roast beef ( at least thats what they call it). I'll just say that it was some sort of grizzly mystery meat . read more

I don't think I've ever been so disappointed by food Gnats In my iced tea, and they refilled using the same cup so they were still there when I finished my second glass. Cheese burger overcooked and without cheese chili was just sloppy joe mix. Ruben came without Russian dressing, chicken Marsala tasted like gravy and the chicken was loose. Saw the waiter maybe twice the whole time. But seriously you think something would be right here but even the atmosphere felt hostile. I've never eaten anything and lost my appetite, it ruined our whole night coming here. read more

River Star Diner - Gnats In my ice tea - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

The food is tasty and the staff is friendly and attentive, however the place could use a facelift. This place is in a gorgeous location and the food is decent. The score would definitely increase if they put some money back into the business. New dinner ware and maybe glass cups instead of plastic would go a long way. The furniture should be reupholstered due to wear and tear in most of the booths. I'm hopeful to see some of these updates being done! read more

See all

This has got to be the worst pastrami sandwich ever, the meat is tough and sliced thick too chewy, the coleslaw is soggy and please look at the pickle looks like it has mold. Not to make mention of the disgusting plate the food is served on!! Won't ever be back here!! This placing is disgusting don't eat here save yourself the trouble!! read more

See all

First time here so I opted for something simple and I must say I was pleased. Ordered breakfast. It comes with toast. Service was great. Can't complain. Will return. read more

River Star Diner - Sausage, eggs and potatoes. All cooked perfectly. - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Screwed up my order big time. Ask for meatball park and order of fries. I get meatloaf parm. Called them and the lady that sounds like she smokes 5 packs of cig a day said oh well you can come back if you want. And they charged me 19.95 for something I did not order. They should deliver the rite food and the money they owe me. Because of the wretch on the phone I will no longer go back. I've been going there for the last 15 years read more

Food is fine, and service is usually fine, but one waitress in particular should not be working here. On a slow day, it took 15 minutes for her to take my order. It took some time for a refill on my coffee - usually the servers here are on top of it - and the refill tasted very watered down. I pointed that out, and she just gave me a new cup of the same batch. Finally, her shift ended and told neither me, nor anyone else to at least ask me if I need anything else or if I needed the check. She's been my waitress the past two trips here. It's unfortunate that I need to try to plan my visits around when I do not see her working. read more

Another Friday. Another adventure with my Dad. We've passed this place many times on our way elsewhere. We finally stopped in. Had my usual Onion omelette, well done home fries and english muffin. Dad had tuna salad. Prompt service. No complaints with the food. Probably the first diner where I was not offered a refill on my coffee, though. What keeps this review at three stars is the condition of the place. We were seated in the back. The booths are in awful shape. The ceiling has water damage and is unpleasant to look at. The place needs a substantial rehab. So, a decent place but I won't be hurrying back. read more

Come here a few times a month. Tonight was definitely the last time. Ordered an Italian omelette. Did not have Italian sausage as advertised. Like they took one breakfast link and cut it up. Home fries soggy, salty and full of grease. Really bad. Wife got chicken finger wrap. Chicken was bad. Almost as if they reheated in the microwave. Charged extra to substitute the cheese out. The hostess was very nice but the waitress seemed like she didn't want to be at work. Started complaining that people were calling in to order before picking up. read more

Very disappointed with the quality of the food after loving it for many years. Ordered a meal that had fruit added to it and what came out was defrosted bagged strawberries. A) gross B) soggy C) expected fresh berries which other diners serve. Waitress didn't notice that they were all pushed to the side when she asked how our meals were. It was quite obvious too. We did tell her that the berries were gross, she properly adjusted any added cost but, QA of the served product and standards that the restaurant wants to set should be discussed. read more

We really used to enjoy going here and we used to be regulars but haven't been in a long time because of cleanliness issues. We tried them again recently and the issues still haven't been resolved. I had a lipstick stain on my coffee mug - nasty & disgusting - and another time white goop in my coffee mug which I managed to spit out. I just don't think their dishwashing is efficient enough, as the waitress commented that it's happened before. I've had bad experiences with sodas from their soda fountain too. The booths look like they've seen better days and the floor is always dirty. I know they had a renovation a few years back but they need another one. The place looks dirty. Some items on the menu are good like the salads/breakfast but others are just OK, sub-standard fare. I feel uneasy about eating there now as the place is so dirty and I don't know what goes on in the kitchen. Most of the servers are very nice but that can only go so far. I hope they can turn it around so we have a local diner to go to again. read more

Nothing exceptional to report. Service is usually friendly and efficient. I have been surprised when I tried some specials at how tasty they were. It's a diner so if you stick to the regular diner fare you'll be pleased. I had a salad with salmon once that was not my typical order and I was pleasantly surprised at how tasty it was. read more

Outstanding food and terrible service. Out waitress was sick tonight and was coughing up a storm and using her hand to cough into. Then she was carrying our food. She also forgot my coffee. read more

Overall, I liked my experience. Restaurant is clean and fairly updated. We were seated right away. Portions are HUGE. Server was on point. She could've been more amicable but she did a good job so friendly or not, I'm not going to make complain. My ONLY gripe was that the chicken in my Greek wrap was rubbery. It was almost as if it wasn't done enough. I even spit it out & broke it up to make sure the chicken was done. It looked okay but the texture was strange. Nevertheless, I recommend this place. Everyone should try it at least once. read more

River Star Diner - Steak & 4 eggs for him and the Greek wrap with curly fries for her. - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Had breakfast here this morning. The Atlantis Eggs Benedict with home fries was outstanding! Service excellent!

Great food! the portions were HUGE!!! My niece had the chocolate chip pancakes and i ate half of them!! Plus, the eggs were really good! the only downside was really bad/slow service! ugh i hate having to wait for coffee refills and i think it would be great if they gave you a coffee pot for the table (saves down on them having to walk by and refill it!) other then that great food and my family frequents here all the time so next time i am in town we will be back! read more

I've come to the River Star Diner a couple of times seeing as I live in Hackettstown, between this one and Budd Lake diner I could honestly say I've had more satisfying experiences here. This diner is an honest hands down diner, the wait staff are friendly, the food is genuinely tasty, and the portions you receive for the price you pay is AMAZING Some diners I have been to either jack the prices or squash the proportions, and River Star does neither, for the price I pay and the meal I get I am incredibly satisfied. I will continue to bring my business here as it is closer and in my opinion more delicious than the Budd Lake Diner. read more

River Star Diner - Chicken and Cheese Quesadilla, Pizza Fries (My Fav!), and Mozzerella sticks!! - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Not fresh ... got sick from their breakfast and I was so disappointed it was decent/good but then I immediately had to use the restroom

Love This place !! Friendly staff and good food definitely coming back often! Way to go to the entire staff!!

My first review was very unfavorable but it was based solely on their pancakes. I've been back a few more times for breakfast, each time ordering bacon, eggs, hash browns and a toasted bagel and I've enjoyed it every time. read more

Dirty, dingy, and rude!!! Went to a show at Centenary College that ended late...10:30. We wanted to get some coffee and dessert and The River Star Diner was the only location open at that hour. Got there at 11:00ish and was greeted by a lovely young lady who took our order and took pretty good care of us overall. 4 desserts...4 dirty plates. Old dry almond cake, blueberry pie, apple pie, and cherry pie. Cold stale coffee. Was told at 11:45 that we had to leave because they were closed...by older woman/manager/waitress. Diner is open until Midnight and we were literally thrown out... Tipped young waitress well...she was sweet. Tip- Go to Wawa after hours. read more

Just not good! Place a bit tin down in inside. Broiled salmon shriveled up and over cooked. Had a very limited desert selection for a diner- didn't even have apple pie. Husband's dinner was bland and tasteless, so I wouldn't recommend this place for dinner. Maybe breakfast or lunch wouldn't be so disappointing. read more

Stopped in for lunch. The service was good but the food was terrible. I ordered a cornbeef omelet and it came out as an omelet with slices of corn beef on top of it. The omelet was over cooked as well. The other meals were overcooked as well. read more

This place is gross! GROSS!! It is filthy, dingy, and the food sucks, and the waitstaff are not that good. Everytime i get a cup of coffee, the cups are dirty. I finaly just stoped going there. With so many choices in Hackettstown, why would you ever want to go there? read more

Came here with my husband for a late lunch and the server forgot our coffee after waiting 10 minutes to get up and ask. The hash browns were dry and slightly burnt. The restaurant was pretty empty but the food was ok for diner food. I would rather go to ihop. read more

Been here many times and at one point was coming here almost every week. This last time I was there was my LAST. Overheard the owner making Anti-Semitic comments in causal conversation with a customer. It's shocking that an owner of a business would so freely make such discriminatory remarks out loud for his customers to hear. read more