This place is a lot of fun with over 300 flavors of sauces and rubs for your wings. I had the suicide and kicking Cajun flavors. I liked the suicide wings and for me the Cajun could have used a little more kick lol but over all great. The fries were good but after seeing the onion ring that will be what I get. The staff were great and fast especially with the amount of people in there. It's a nice cozy place which looks like it might have been a home or office at one time. Love the fact of keeping the older structures going read more

We've heard great things about the wings at Marley's Gotham Grill and we were not disappointed with the options. 402 different sauces. The wings come lightly breaded or not, boned or boneless or you can get falafel w/ sauces. I was pleased to see the full bar and happy they had my Leigenkugel summer shandy. Hubby got Diet Pepsi. He was thinking of getting food off the menu but we decided to see how hungry we were after the wings. 12 wings were plenty and we couldn't even eat those. The Jack Be Nimble w/ Jack Daniel's sauce were our favorites and came with plenty of sauce. We enjoyed the ginger garlic honey as well which seemed more like a rub, but the JD was wet and better. Plus they bring out fresh chips which are supper crunchy and delicious. The wings came out super quick and our server Crystal B was very attentive. The bar is very happening and features local brews as well as all the favorites. There are many options to sit and enjoy. There is outdoor in front of the restaurant and in the patio in the back. You can sit along the bar for a louder atmosphere or on the other side for a quieter more family oriented environment. Hubby wanted a coffee and opted for an Irish Coffee while I finished my beer. It was made with Jameson which is common but not his favorite. It was topped off with a light layer of whipped cream and green food coloring (not a fan). read more

See all

This is a composite and represents the lunch time experience. The burgers are good. The fries have been awful. Consistently awful. They came out and they were not very warm. I don't really care much about fries so it isn't a deal breaker but if I'm paying for as part of the whole meal... not acceptable. The French Onion soup was good. Their Reuben is okay. The potato skins... pass. Small, needed to be crispier for my liking. I have had better experiences here later on in the day. I'll go with busier is better for them. The staff is always pleasant. Whatever the other mis-steps the people who serve you are really awesome. Considering evening and the crew I'll go with 3 over the 2 stars my recent experiences have earned. I don't see lunch here again. Oh, make sure to put at least 2 quarters in the meter. Lunch was over an hour and though the meter guy was cool he didn't have to be. I'm sure I would have gotten a ticket had I not been walking to my vehicle. He gave a friendly mention that the time was up. read more

!!!!!food poisoning !!!!! I repeat do not order from here . my Husband and I ordered Marley's for the first football Sunday and 6 hours later we both were running to the bathroom simultaneously. I have heard rumors about the kitchen here and I didn't believe it , never again will I eat from here . Sucks because it is a great atmosphere. clean it up back there .... read more

This time sat in at the bar instead of ordering take out but wow what an experience! The bartender recommend some wings and they hit! This place was packed on Friday night and the service was seamless! There's over a 100 wing flavors so these are some of the ones that we tried- Garlic Parmesan - just OK Mango jerk Sticky crispy garlic - (yum and bartender recommendation) Chipotle BBQ- (yum) Banging chad (yes!) Smokey honey habanero - not that great Parking was easy- we came here after going on a brewery run on the street. Highly recommend this place if you're feeling wings! read more

See all

Enchanted Dining Experience at the Marley's Gotham Grill. I had an exceptional time at this sidewalk-side restaurant. The outdoor seating feels vibrant and open, yet thoughtfully roped off to give each party its own cozy space. I couldn't have asked for a more inviting spot to enjoy a meal. - Seating right on the sidewalk, perfect for people-watching - Clever use of ropes to define individual tables - Energetic urban backdrop without feeling crowded Cuisine The menu offers a wide variety of dishes, each executed with care: - Fresh appetizers to start - Hearty mains bursting with flavor - Innovative vegetarian and vegan options - Decadent desserts that cap off the meal beautifully Every plate I tried was excellent--ingredients tasted vibrant, seasoning was spot-on, and presentation was as appealing as the flavors. Service My server brought great personality and positive energy to our table. They were attentive without hovering, knowledgeable about the menu, and genuinely seemed to enjoy ensuring we had a wonderful experience. Overall Impression This spot delivers on all fronts: atmosphere, food quality, menu variety, and warm service. I walked away looking forward to my next visit. read more

See all

Amazing food and service. The wings are great. The chicken fingers with the kids menu is also great. The place is very casual and has great decore. 10/10 would recommend read more

My friends and I visited Marley's last night for dinner. We were blown away by the fact that they had 350 WING FLAVORS!!!! For the most part, we each ordered wings. We got different flavors and shared amongst ourselves. My two favorite were the Chipotle Mayo and the Blueberry BBQ! Yum yum! Marley's is otherwise just your usual bar with pizzas, hamburgers, salads, and fries on the menu. The waiters were nice. I would go again to try more wings flavors! read more

See all

This is a difficult spot to review in totality because I only tried 1% of their menu! With 400 wing flavors and a whole other menu, this place is impossible to accurately review. So just an FYI, I can only touch on what I had. Banging Chad Wings (209): I regret giving Chad a chance. Everyone talks about how dreamy he is, but what nobody warned me about, was how creamy he is too... These wings were soaking in a bowl of Chad's very own sauce, a mixture of mango jalapeño, and bang bang. Sounds like a good time, right? Oh was I so wrong. Chad stared me in the eyes, came close to my ear, its as if he tried to put me under a spell... A cover up, for the atrocities my body had to endure. My first bite had me, curious. I wanted more, but thats just it. I didnt want more! Chad was in my head. His voice was deafening as my ears felt like they were bleeding. I felt something on my shoulder, it was liquid. With a reach of my fingers, I looked down to see not blood, but Chad's sauce. He was filling me up with his creamy blend, as I was begging him to stop. All he could do was laugh at the sight of my misery. It was in my teeth, all over my face, and even under my fingernails. I screamed louder and louder until suddenly... it was finished. I looked into the bowl. One wing was left, swimming in the extract of Chad, it was an ocean of torment. What was once a curious bite, turned deeper and deeper into a slaughterhouse of disgust. I'll say it plainly, hopefully he won't find out. Chad's sauce was disgusting. Nashville Wings (290): Living near the Nashville area, I had to see how authentic the flavor was! These wings tasted more like a hot combos pizza flavor than nadhville hot. I couldn't put any expectations of having a legit nashville hot experience here because im not in Nashville, im in Jersey. Still a fine wing, but its obvious this wing has never been to the Music city. Creamy Cilantro Wings (316): These were wonderful! Chicken Bruschetta Wings (192): These were also wonderful! Marley's Gotham Wings does get bonus points here for having the largest wing menu I have ever seen. Our service was fine, and the building fit the vibe of Hackettstown perfectly! I want to come back and try more, just not with Chad... read more

See all

Recently came back to Marley's for a family member's birthday. Had a great lunch. I had the buffalo chicken salad, which came with a whole order of boneless wings on top. You can customize the flavor of wings, choosing from over 400 flavors. They had nice, cold draft beers, which were perfect for the 90° day. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Buffalo chicken salad - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

I've had great wings there and terrible wings there. I'm not sure why things seem so inconsistent, from the Marley's, Jr. fiasco and now to the main restaurant. Ordered takeout of a dozen garlic parmesan wings and there was more garlic in the box than on the wings themselves. Lukewarm and tough to eat. Maybe all of the better cooks were off for Fourth of July weekend. read more

I've wanted to check this place out since my co workers rave about it and it's overwhelming (400 different wing sauces!) but fun. We started with southwest egg rolls and the poutine (delicious). I didn't go for traditional wings but a buffalo chicken salad that could have served a family of 6, my husband got the mango habanero and stranger things wings (he said it was one of the best sauces he's ever had) and our son got the white pizza which looked good. Friendly service and a cute homey atmosphere. We are already planning our next trip (but looking at the menu before we go back!). read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - One side of the sauce menu - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

The wait staff was awesome. Cheese curds were good 2 out of the last 3 times I've come here my wings were over cooked. Like to the point my jaw was sore from chewing. They were drenched in the sauce. The one time when it was good the sauce and wings were perfect. That just makes me think they knew they overcooked them and were trying to hide it. Please do better. read more

So me and my partner went here because he saw a TikTok about this place The wings were pretty good, I tried the Coca Cola wings and the tortilla wings. The Coca Cola wings were fine, the chicken itself was pretty tasteless so it was kinda only the sauce, and I'm not really a fan of sweet sauces. Then the tortilla wings were just normal hot wings with crumbles of tortilla on top, which is what I expected but it was still a bit disappointing. read more

See all

Came here for the wings but left dreaming about the dessert . The service and ambience were great with plenty of seating, and everyone was super friendly! With over 300 flavors of wings it's hard to choose from and they aren't lying when they said "you'll leave here howling!"Insta: @thehungrysw Kamikaze Bone In Wings General Tso's Bone In Wings Marley's Favorite Treat Disco Fries Garlic Parm Bone In Wings Suicide Bone In Wings Kickin Chicken Bone In Wings read more

See all

Definitely worth a visit for their wings, that come in hundreds of different flavors to choose from! The wings are crispy and flavorful. I also enjoyed their cheeseburger which was a discounted price on Thursdays. They offer a different special every day! We sat in the bar area where service was quick and friendly! There was Bob Ross playing on the tv with a special tribute display at the bar that made me laugh. I'll be back for their wings!! read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

Discovered this gem while spending a fall afternoon at a local farm. This was a 15 minute drive but well worth it. They have over 300 flavors of wings! The wings here are huge and the perfect moist chicken inside. We opted for a teriyaki garlic flavor that was on the back of the menu. I cannot remember the exact flavor name but it was delicious. My boyfriend and I split 12 wings they were huge and filling. We ordered potato skins and pierogis as an appetizer. The potato skins were covered in bacon and cheese but could've been a larger portion for the price. The pierogis were truly delicious over a bed of caramelized onions and bacon. We also ordered the funnel cake fries for dessert. We were so full we ended up taking them to go for our long ride home! Service was friendly and very understanding how hard it was to pick a wing flavor from their extensive menu. Classic bar ambiance and interior, I enjoyed how well they decorated for Halloween. read more

See all

I always come here for the wings! Bonus on Mondays they have an interesting happy hour with them. The wings are big and juicy!! They have over 300 flavors!! You just want to try them all.. well almost all of them. Some I question.. mostly the dessert ones lol. Severs are friendly. They do have meter parking in the back, after 5/6 (I believe) it's free. One side of this place is a complete bar the other side has more of a sit down restaurant feel. So different but it works. read more

See all

Service and ambiance same as a I remember from past visits. Both good. We sat at the bar. However, the 'menu has changed'. Last time we were there the nachos were amazing. Today barely edible. The cheese was that liquid artificial tasting type. SALTY and soggy in its entirety and we couldn't even finish half. Should have sent it back. A tiny container of sour cream. Guacamole is $ extra. Half the portion as last time and very disappointing. Not sure what this 'menu change' means for the rest of the food but not willing to find out after this experience. read more

When asked which wings are which , I was told " I don't know I didn't cook them " Seriously, glad I do t have a food allergy or he had any integrity. Not coming back . The food runner , have some pride in what you do . Yup ! I said it . Didn't even follow up with my question . I ordered 2 different sauces . A 50/50 would've had better odds . Would've spent more money , but left after feeling less valued. read more

I always get dry rub wings. Went yesterday and got two different flavors. They were horrible compared to all the other times I got them. They were soaked in oil or not dry rubbed and I could not tell the flavors apart they were tasteless. Unfortunately, I will never get wings there again now. read more

So I have to preface this review by saying that I am a food snob and had never really understood the "wings" as a culinary masterpiece. Marley's has over 300 flavors for their wings and we tried 3. Some of them you can split and get 6 of one flavor and 6 of another. We got Mild, honey barbecue garlic and Thai Me. They were served hot, the Mild had the best sauce in my opinion and had the most moist chicken meat. The other two were like something you'd find at Panda Express or KFC minus the MSG - so the flavors were dull. Thai me was cloyingly sweet and the garlic one was like a tasteless Chinese type chicken dish. The service was decent and Julian took off the Thai Me because he had suggested it when I asked for something sweet and spicy and it had no heat. But I did ask him for a drink that he never brought. The place itself is a well-worn establishment reeking of history and screaming for a deep clean. It's iconic but also filthy. For me, it's the details: the celery sticks were thin, old wilted spears and they serve the cheapest packaged containers of ranch and blue cheese - the kind that taste like some amorphous congealed Mayo. The bill was only $30 for 2 people with 2 non-alcoholic beverages and 24 wings so that tells you everything you need to know! read more

See all

The so called smashed burger was actually two frozen patties that tasted like they microwaved them. Could not take a second bite. Some of the wings were okay. Too many flavors for any of them to be very good. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Jalapeño cheddar smashed burger - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

First of all let me say the poutine appetizer was very good. It all went downhill from there. Way too many wing choices, and not very well organized making it almost impossible to find what you're looking for. Presenting the wings in different categories would certainly help. We choose the garlic Parmesan and the bang bang wings. Both were drenched in some much sauce it was disgusting, like eating wings sitting in a soup broth! How does a place that specializes in wings and offers 300+ flavors give you prepackaged Ken's blue cheese dressing? How difficult is it to make a nice chunky home made blue cheese dressing? Very disappointing. To top it off we got a measly 3 small celery sticks to dip in our grocery store bought blue cheese. Very over rated, just because you offer 300 different wing choices doesn't make it good. read more

It was fine. I am visiting from out of state and locals raved about this place but I don't get the hype. I got the shrimp tacos. They were fine they had a decent taste but I literally got sour cream and salsa in the little individual packets like from the store. The server was nice, food was fast. The restaurant was pretty small and bland on the inside. If you have to go here it's fine but I don't recommended it either. read more

Wings were super good! All the wings were huge with lots of meat on them. So many flavors to choose from, really fun place to go as a group and try a bunch of different flavors like we did! We wished the staff was a bit more attentive but otherwise it was a great time. Everything came out quick and was exactly what we ordered. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Me and my beautiful fiancée came here for dinner one night and it was pretty good, The variety of sauces they had were insane, Only complaint was lack of service, waited awhile for a refill on my drink other then that place is great! read more

My wife and I have been wanting to try this restaurant for lunch, but what a disappointment! We were the second table seated and ordered two sandwiches and soft drinks at noon. The third and fourth tables came in after our drinks arrived. After 45 minutes of waiting and seeing the first, third, and fourth tables receive their orders, we left. Upon leaving the cook stated he was now working on our order. Because of the service or lack whereof, we will not return. read more

Nice place. Good food. This place has the best fish n chips in the area. Always cooked just right. I just wish they would have kept the same decor in the dinning area, which was much warmer and inviting than now. read more

Solid bar. Rueben and wings are excellent. Service at the bar was very friendly. Fried chicken sandwich very good as well. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bar - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Bartender service was great- but the food? What happened to this place? Used to be good but the last 2 times the wings are meh. Hubbys "smashed burger" was alright. Ordered my burger medium- unfortunately it was awful, questionable beef taste, low quality beef??? Lunch cooking crew really needs improvement. read more

See all

What a disappointing meal. I ordered a cheese steak sandwich which was supposed to be sliced top round. Looked more like a frozen minute steak. My wife had a pasta special that was to consist of "pasta purses stuffed with ricotta ". They were literally hard as a rock. We sent it back. No manager came by so before leaving we asked for one. None materialized. We used to come here often but the food has gone downhill considerably and we won't be returning. read more

Wings are DELICIOUS!!! Over 400 flavors! The restaurant is super cozy and we will definitely be returning!!

Bring back the mini sheet trays! While we love Marley's wings, we are not happy with the new plastic bowls. The delicious crispy wings are served swimming in sauce ruining the whole experience! We mentioned it to our server and she said we are not the first to object to the change. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

This place is incredible! They have over 300 different types of chicken wings which seems like a lot, but it's really not. I can taste something different every time I eat here. The staff are cool and there is a full top shelf bar without Fever Tree Ginger Beer unfortunately (why does every bar have that I go to insist on stocking Gosling or Q Ginger beer??? YUCK !!!!). I've been coming here since I moved to Port Murray in summer 2004 and have never been disappointed. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Honey Barbeque - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

I absolutely love their gluten-free boneless wings! My daughter who does not have any issues with gluten thinks they are even better then the regular boneless wings as they stay crunchy even when fully sauced. I hope they continue to add more gluten free options. We have used them for catering as well and the owner will make just about anything for you. Great experiences all around. read more

Attention all wing lovers, this is the place to be if you want a variety of flavors. Marleys has over 250 flavors, and man are they delicious! Usually I would be overwhelmed by the amount of choices, but they have a great guide on the menu to let you know what flavors are new, have won awards and are too favorites. You can also decide if you want to do bone in or out, which I really appreciate. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

The hot garlic chicken wings were huge and very tasty. The sweet potato fries were okay, could've been crispier. I went for the beat the clock promotion that they have every Monday. Between that and the beer special it was super cheap, definitely will be coming back. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Hot Garlic Chicken Wings Basket of Sweet Potato Fries - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

We loved our first visit to Marleys. We went for dinner on a Wednesday and we're quickly seated in the bar area. Their menu is HUGE. They have more than 300 wing flavors plus specials and a regular menu. It took us longer to decide than to get our food. Tip: look at the menu before you go! Everyone enjoyed their wing choices, burgers, sandwiches and pizza. Portions were large. Our server was the best. I think her name was Paige. Tunes were great and they had a bunch of TVs, including one featuring Painting by Bob Ross. Who remembers him?! Lol. Municipal parking available in the back so it's to find parking. We'll be back. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Boneless wings - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

New owners, new menu. Worst nachos I've ever eaten. Fake cheese, salty "meat", mini containers of sour cream, guacamole, & salsa. Absolutely horrible, will never eat there again.​ read more