BEST WINGS IN AREA - when it comes to wings i really don't play. it's hard to find the right wing spot. marley's been my to-go wings spot for the past 2 years and they never disappoint. Dining in is a dope option too the atmosphere is cool for both dates, hangouts or just dinners with family. if your going i'd get the mammas chicken sandwich it's amazing. can't stress it enough. if your deciding in between marley's and some other spot i'll save you the time and money. GO TO MARLEYS. read more

The food is fantastic!!! Huge portions and the wings are to die for! I usually do take out, but the waitstaff are friendly and the service attentive!!! You feel like you are in a old time neighborhood cottage with food, drink and good people read more

I wanted to love this place. My friend I went with is a vegetarian so he had ready about their tofu nuggets. There are 250 flavors and they cater to wing and vegetarians! So we thought this was the perfect place to hit up after our hike. The place is pretty tiny but the staff and service are quick. The tofu nuggets were just pieces of tofu cut up, they weren't breaded or anything which was a disappointment to my friend. The wings were heavily battered and oily. But I did enjoy the sauces. I think I selected some pretty good ones. On the way to the bathroom, the grease buildup from the kitchen is pretty slick! So just be careful! read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

The place is very nice and have a dozen on tap beers to choose from. And the wings are amazing

PROS: Place was amazing! More sauces than any other place I've been to. Staff was nice and the food tasted fresh unlike other places that sell wings. They turned over tables quickly and were very clean. One room had the bar in it while the other was primarily restaurant. CONS: The bar was cramped in a small room making it tough to move around in if a game was on. Only street parking and one person bathroom made it inconvenient as well. OVERALL: Absolute amazing place to get wings at. I already showed this place to a few of my friends and they will be visiting soon. I suggest you do the same read more

They are know for their wings for a reason. They are DELICIOUS! Every one of their flavors pops but especially love the Hot and Naughty- a Buffalo wing with a Garlic Parmesan sauce. Seriously good and then even better hours later when the sauce soaks into the breading. They must use fresh wings- never feels overdone and the wings are juicy. Great presentation and super value even when delivered. Try their food trucks at the Rutgers games as well! read more

See all

This place is incredible! They have over 300 different types of chicken wings which seems like a lot, but it's really not. I can taste something different every time I eat here. The staff are cool and there is a full top shelf bar without Fever Tree Ginger Beer unfortunately (why does every bar have that I go to insist on stocking Gosling or Q Ginger beer??? YUCK !!!!). I've been coming here since I moved to Port Murray in summer 2004 and have never been disappointed. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Honey Barbeque - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

@BigDudesBigFoods had the pleasure of meeting @MarleysGothamGrill 's Chef/Owner Bruno Pascale today and boy did he feed us well. There are 300 wing flavors on Marly's menu so it wasn't an easy decision. Joe stayed conservative with garlic parm and I got a combo dozen 1/2 Cap'n Crunch and 1/2 PB & Pepper Jelly. So good! Bruno also surprised us with a Buffalo Chicken pizza which was, of course, delicious. Bruno joined us and chatted about his multiple business ventures, including two restaurants and two food trucks, while we enjoyed his deep fried bread pudding bites. There so many great choices on Marley's menu besides the 300 wing choices. If you are ever in #HackettstownNJ and you are hungry, #MarleysGothamGrill should be at the top of your list!!! #BigDudesBigFoods #CelebrateEveryDay #globaleats #shenanigans #BDBFCertified #ThePhoneEatsFirst #Forkyeahfoodies #BDBF @forkyeahfoodies #YouDontKnowJersey #TeaseTheDay #ClearEyesFullBelliesCantLose #ABigDudesGottaDoWhatABigDudesGottaDo #HaveYouHuggedABigDudeToday #Wings #ChickenWings read more

See all

go there often, but last visit wasn't good, drinks were way to strong we coulndt drink them, waitress wasn't attent of us, didn't ask if we were of even when he saw our drinks untouch, food was ok we asked for take out containers and she bought them with the check, at that point we decided to have dessert somewhere else we felt rush to get out of there, thats a shame we like going there read more

My favorite restaurant in Hackettstown, and my favorite wing place ever! Have never had a bad flavor and service is always pleasant read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Roller Coaster, bang yaki, chipotle honey aioli - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

I've been wanting to try this place for a while - mainly because of the 250 different wing flavors. The place is small and cute from the outside. We got the naked wings in flavors rueben, garlic teriyaki, nuclear and pb and pepper jelly. The rueben was a showstopper!!! soooo good. For boneless we got sour cream and onion and pepperonis pizza (if you order boneless they give you like double the amount for no extra charge!) The only downside was that some flavors had more sauce than others, but overall I loved it and would totally come again to try more flavors. read more

See all

Excellent excellent excellent Great wings and other items on the menu Would highly recommend read more

Delicious wings and pretty good service. Not all of the flavors are great but with so many choices, you're almost guaranteed to find a flavor you like. My favorites are the chipotle bbq and honey bbq. Onions and burgers are great too! read more

Awful experience. As senior citizens, we can't do high top tables. Had the worst table in the house, right in front of the kitchen pick up window. To ad insult to injury, the dang table was unbalanced. Every time I moved my drink spilled. Order the onion soup, it was rancid. The server agreed with me. Suggested it be thrown away to the kitchen. I saw it being served AFTER this was disclose. She saw Ian commented not serve this. AFTER she told them it was rancid. I will never go back. read more

My friends and I ordered from Marley's for the first round of March Madness on 3/19. The wings were awesome! Obviously you have the ridiculous amount of flavors which is very good. But the biggest thing to me was how much meat was on every wing. A lot of times wing spots will send you some pretty small wings with very little. But Marley's were all filled out and still crispy/cooked to perfection. We ordered 14 dozen on a busy day and had not trouble. I recommended submitting larger orders online. We were able to pick them up in a reasonable amount of time and had no issues. Everything was super smooth. I certainly recommend ordering with someone who has gone before because 250 flavor options can be pretty overwhelming! Kick'in chicken is an absolute must! The flavor was great. Not too spicy at all. We got this both dry and wet. Just can't go wrong here. Garlic Parmesan is a classic flavor and Marley's certainly does this flavor justice! Bang Bang chicken was really good in my opinion. It is a bit heavy on the Mayo which may turn some away but I was perfectly fun with that. We tried Coca Cola because us sounded interesting but no one was particularly high on this flavor. Devil Wears Prada were also awesome. Added a little extra kick. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Wingssss - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

It is hard to go wrong at Marley's. The service is great. The servers are friendly warm and from professional. The food is fantastic! Marley's has all the usual bar fair, kinda! The menu is unique, intriguing and tempting. The ingredients employed are fresh and top grade. Marley's wing sauce are incredible shame that don't have more. ( if you know you know bro). Before you receive your meal you will be planning your next visit to try the menu items you discover after you already ordered. That's right "Order Envy"! Did I mention they have something for every from that misguided soul in your family, we all have one, that has worn off the flesh of the living to the unapologetic carnivore, whose arteries are hardening of while simultaneously digesting the magnificent offerings form Marley's kitchen. ( Aren't never ending run-on sentences fun!). Yo Marley! When is the Green Goddess Salad returning to the menu! My Goddess is impatient for her favorite salad. The staff, patrons, atmosphere, all come together along with the amazing food to make Marley's a fantastic place to become a regular. read more

Quality or quantity? Well, with over 300 flavors of wings, plus a full menu, which is Marley's going for? Wings are disgustingly over breaded and tossed in your choice of over 300 nonsensical, bizarre flavors. They are often served soggy and barely warm, all within 45 minutes. Want a burger? Salad? Sandwich? All equally as lackluster, and within the same 45 minute time frame. Just goes to prove that more isn't better. I highly recommend that this establishment go back to basics. They've clearly bitten off more than they can chew. read more

This is a friend-favorite! Perfect for large groups as well. There are a crazy amount of different wing flavors, you really can't go wrong especially if you are an adventurous person. Pictured here are the Hot Honey Garlic wings as well as the Screamin' B**ch wings (darker red). If I had to recommend one, the hot honey garlic were INCREDIBLE. Seriously amazing! I also got the Rainbow Falafel Wrap. Took some home because you really do get a great amount of food. It was absolutely delicious. My friend got the Nashville Hot Chicken sandwich and loved it too. The fries are amazing. It was a quieter afternoon, so the staff was also a bit quieter but very kind and helpful! Our food came out quickly. The place itself is very homey and I loved the music choices. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

With 250 different sauce types for their wings, perhaps i went wrong on my decision. Perhaps an off day, and perhaps their menu offers more excitement then what i experienced. Being in the area, I decided to try for the first time. No issues with my server. Real attentive and nice guy. Tried the raspberry chipotle bone in wings, as well as the bang bang chicken wings. Apparently the Star Ledger had rated the latter wings as winner for best of something. I call b.s. on that. The wings themselves are large and pretty meaty, and although crispy on the outside, they were a bit dry. The wings were however swimming in sauce. The bang bang chicken wings were SMOTHERED in the mayo aioli and quite frankly, this was disgusting i tried one and that was it. Used one of the 3 napkins provided to rub off that sauce, but didnt matter. The wing was still gross. The sauce was pretty much all mayo, and although i love mayo on a sandwich, i don't want a chicken wing drowning in it. So, bad call on my part for even trying this, yet why couldnt the wings be lightly tossed in the sauce after frying, and then served in a basket without the additional pool of liquid. 3 napkins didnt cut it, nor did the up charge for blue cheese and ranch dressing. Prepackaged Ken's dressing might i add. This place seems to focus on wings, and i am not impressed. Nor will i be back. At least for the wings. Would entertain trying something else from their menu, but for now, i will focus my appetite on other establishments. And please, bring your own blanket to wipe your face, if you plan on trying the bang bang chicken wings. I hope your luck is better then mine. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bang bang chicken wings. Unfortunately, the heavy hand of mayo/aioli sauce made these inedible. - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Went to a Rutgers game and ordered 6 wings and fries from their food truck. After 30 minutes and seeing people that ordered after me get their food I asked the girl for a status, immediately she copped an attitude with me, I told her to give me my money back and she refused. At the end of the day their wings were terrible and the customer service is worse. I hope this helps some people. read more

I've been to this place several times. They are all about their wings with something like 300 variations. The wings are excellent. I recommend the garlic Parmesan, bacon BBQ, or their classic wings. Their pizza is just okay. Also know for their burgers which are very good. Definitely will keep conning here. read more

See all

I have been wanting to come here for a very long time and finally made the trip out. Boy was it worth it! With over 300 flavors of wings there is something for literally anyone. You get to mix and match flavors and each one that we chose had really amazing flavor and they give the wings a healthy amount of sauce! Highly recommended! read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

The service at this establishment was sub par to say the least. No one really caters to you when eating there and The food doesn't even make up for the service either!! If you find your self eating here I suggest you leave and save yourself the money! read more

Stopped here for lunch and left without even ordering. Our waitress was openly complaining to us and other tables about how customers were "bitches" and that they didn't tip her. She was calling herself a "queen bitch" saying how the customers weren't getting "laid" completely unprofessional behavior. read more

I moved into the area about a year ago from Hudson/Bergen County and I'm trying to get my food bearings for Morris/Warren. I have been generally disappointed with the food around the Long Valley area with some exceptions. Marley's is no exception. From word-of-mouth and some reviews I was expecting this place to be exceptional particularly in regard to wings. I give every place a second chance when they're bad or even good for consistency's sake, and I even gave Marley's three chances. Dear Marley's, how about going from 300 wing varieties to about 10 and get these right first? Then move up to 11. I've tried about a dozen varieties and the only ones that came close to acceptable were the Doritos, which my 10 year old son makes better without being sarcastic. And by acceptable I mean Applebees was closed for renovations and all you had was Marley's wings. Their "dry rub" wings are one step above an Amazon cardboard box but without flavoring. The only reason I didn't give Marley's 1 or 2 stars was because some of their menu items are decent if not inconsistent. My favorite item that Marley's does right are their disco fries. You think it's easy but it's not. They are some of the best I've had outside of many Diners out east for those who know what I'm talking about. The fries weren't the correct size but the gravy-mozzarella ratio and taste were spot on. My family and I have shared about a dozen items off the menu here and they were decent. But folks. The wings really stink. Regardless of what you may think. read more

heard good things about this place but to be honest it was way over priced and i've had better wings at apple bees.

Party of 13, everyone ordered different flavors and wings and NOONE was disappointed! Definitely a must!! Great services, funny waitresses, and amazing wings!! read more

First time at Marley's. They have 300 flavors of wings. We had 2. Only 150 more visits to go. BTW, the Black & Blue burger was outstanding. Good beer list. read more

Previous reviews of this place stopped me from visiting sooner. Thankfully my son went here with a few friends and said he thought they had the best wings in the area. We decided to take the family here after a party one day. They did not disappoint! We were a party of 8 and ordered wings and a lot of other appetizers and Maine courses. Everything was amazing. They were busy so service was a little slow but our waiter was aware and kept us updated. Overall a great foodie experience. Don't miss out! read more

We had this terrible waitress Stella who complained about any modification we made on our meal like no mushrooms and we asked for separate checks and she complained about that She never checked on us and when it came time to pay my friend put it all on his card because we had cash and he put no tip bc we were tipping in cash Stella goes this is my thanksgiving dinner so you better tip So we gave her $18 which was a 15% tip because she was obnoxious and she goes to my friend on the way out holds up the cash and goes sh*t tip. read more

We eat here frequently when visiting Czig or Jersey Girl breweries. The choices for wings are unmatched and I have never had a flavor that wasn't good. I keep wanting to try other menu items but there are so many wing options that I always end up trying a new flavor. They always have a local craft brew on tap. Cocktails are good. Service is quick and friendly. read more

Came here on a Monday afternoon. Our bartender Miquel was top notch with service and cocktail mixing. Chicken wings were perfect. Great selection of tap beer. Will be back read more

250 sauces to choose from. It is freaking intimidating. Reading the menu takes longer than eating your food. There is no order or rhyme or reason to this list of sauces... its maple bacon to death by tobasco to oreo... MAYHEM, its like picking up a dictionary that is not in alphabetical order. Please Mr Marley... for the love of buffalo.. put the spicy flavors together, the savory ones together, the sweet ones.. you get it, right? At present your menu is like reading Frankenstein's DNA.. yea there are some really great stuff in there..... but its hiding between Gilbert Gottfried and Charles Manson, help a fat kid out! I was very lucky to have a scholar of a server who has read the entire menu.. I pleaded for the Cliffs notes version, debated waiting for the movie... but then she looked me dead in the eye, took a deep breath and said "I'm here to help". I was counseled properly and together we selected the HOT BBQ and Kick'n Chick'n. The wings arrive crispy and hot, the Hot BBQ was not particularly spicy, sweet smoky and a twang of spice. The kickn' chick'n was like a chicken wing scampi. Umami garlicy goodness.. I have not had anything like it... I imagine there are some truly amazing wing flavors up in that encyclopedia.. I am going to come back, with rested eyes an empty belly. 2 down 250 to go. read more

Marley's Gotham Grill - Kick'n Chick'n - Bars Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

Been coming here since we moved to area two years ago. Really great service, orders to go are done fast also. My fav from the menu is the fish tacos, burgers (any) and there wings soooo delicious and packed with flavor. Great place to have a awesome burger and drinks on Main. read more

So, I've been coming here more lately after not visiting for some time. The last few experiences have been fine, but today - not so good. My order was simple enough. Burger, medium, sautéed onions and American cheese. The burger comes out with lettuce, tomato and raw red onions. I tell the young man with the ponytail and glasses behind the bar that I ordered it as I stared above. He says, "look under the cheese, the sautéed onions are under there". I pause, and say, "OK". I was hungry and not in the mood. First time here with this crew behind the bar with him and the blonde young lady. Advice to management- this is not the A team. They are not welcoming and provide for a much colder experience than I've seen before. After fixing my cheeseburger it was good. read more

Gathered up the guys to watch a football game and enjoy some wings with beverages. We were able to score seats at the bar right in front of the TVs. The TVs were smaller than expected but whatever...no big deal. Ordered a Miller Lite to start and it was tasty. The wing menu is overwhelming to say the very least. Bruno has more than 300 wing sauces and flavors to pick from aside from regular menu. Pro tip is to take a look at the menu online before you go so you don't have a panic attack when you're there. For me a chicken wing is a chicken wing but I know some of you guys like exclusively flats or drums but they will not honor it your request. I like my wings "Naked" without the breading so they do not get soggy as quickly with mild sauce. The wings come over sauced and not as crispy as I would like but the flavor is still great. There is street parking available if you're lucky as well as a municipal metered parking lot in back of the business. Alcohol selection is plentiful. If you're in the area and want a decent chicken wing make sure to check it out. read more

See all

This place is such a major gem! Lots of amazing menu items and drinks to choose from. I wish I could have stayed longer.

A great find on the main street of Hackettstown. We love wings and this place had been on our to try list for ages. Nice looking bar and dining room in what must be a very old building. The wings here are the star attraction. A completely overwhelming list is supplied. Each order is 12 wings and the wings are very large. We each tried two flavors. I had Chipotle BBQ and Orange Ginger. My son had Old Bay and Hot Garlic. Our server advised we could have a basket of fries and onion rings. Sounded good to us! The wings were spectacular. Our favorites were the Old Bay and Orange Ginger. Jumbo wings, very crunchy, great sauces. No complaints. So much better than many other spots we have tried. Fries and rings were terrific also. Although not practical, I'd like to spend a week here trying different flavors. Can't wait for our next visit. read more

See all

Great burgers, wings, and fries. The dinning area isn't too big. The staff are welcoming. The food comes out fast.

Drove here to see what the place was all about and it did not disappoint. Miguel the bartender took care of us and the owner Bruno was extremely friendly. Food was delicious. Beer was cold and refreshing. Wings crispy and very flavorful. Mango habanero wings had a nice kick to them and a nice sweetness. Asian zing were a nice mild spicy, but very flavorful. Also had some of the Buffalo wings, and they were amazing--a classic. 10/10 definitely coming back. Highly recommend read more

See all