My wife and I stopped here at about 7:30 on a Thursday evening. We were both fairly hungry and had never tried this place so... boom,. We were seated quickly and Anthony, our server, stopped by right away with menus, a bottle of water and glasses, and a tray of bread, olive oil, olives, and cheese. We hoovered up everything that he'd brought to us- the bread was fantastic. I mean- wow.... seriously good bread! We both ordered a pasta dish, I got linguine with bolognese sauce, my wife ordered a seafood penne dish. She had originally opted for the lobster mac and cheese- but they were sold out... :-( Being from Queens and transplanted to NJ as a kid, I'm very pasta savvy. The linguine was perfectly cooked- just a little bite. The Bolognese sauce was also on-point. So many NJ pizzerias think that mashing up a meatball and adding it to a ladle of sauce is ok.... This was the real deal. Both plates had huge portions, as well. We were both slightly disappointed- no bread, no spoon, no cheese. Anthony made his way back to the table and rectified those issues. More of that fabulous bread, ha ha! Look- I can absolutely say that i'll be back. Food was good... Place was nice... read more

Pizza One was an INCREDIBLE visit. The restaurant is nicely decorated, there are options to either place an order for take-out or enjoy a meal in their indoor/ seating areas. The ambiance was very relaxed and the service was quick and helpful. Our order were specialty slices of chicken/shredded spinach/cheese/balsamic glaze and a Chicken Francaise slice. Both slices were DELICIOUS, at the perfect temperature, and the slices were large. The chicken slice had a crunchy underside and I haven't had too many pizza slices this good. If you're in the Sparta area, do not hesitate to enjoy a meal at Pizza One. If that's too out of the way, there are other locations in Wayne, NJ, and in Scarsdale, NY. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious pizza! Love that you can get their speciality pizza in either regular or Sicilian style. I came here twice in one week, one to get a chicken Cesar panini, this was too die for. Service was great! Love that you can easily dine in or dine out. read more

See all

Enjoyed a nice lunch here. We sat in one of the booths which was very roomy & enjoyed some bread that came with a delish dipping oil, some cheese, & chopped olives. My husband got the small Stewie salad that came chock full of goodies. I enjoyed the coconut shrimp. Waitress was fabulous. We plan to come back for dinner. read more

Pizza One - Yummy coconut shrimp - Italian Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

my chicken cutlet was completely rubber. there was a droplet of mayo. and let's not discuss the hard as a rock bread. I didn't return it because I decided that I will just never return to this establishment. read more

The Buffalo chicken pizza is a little different both the celery and the blue cheese are on the pizza which seems like a pretty good mix, but the crust was a bit mushy overall not a great pie. The service is just OK. It almost seemed like the people taking the order, didn't know the menu. The ambience is also OK. I would try it again, but it definitely didn't flatter me. read more

The food and services are great . Atmosphere in Restaurant great and classy and reasonable prices.

I've been to pizza one about 2 times now and I just remembered to leave a bad review, I've came in twice now for slices and and I actually have to say it's embarrassing how bad their pizza is, I thought the first time maybe they just messed up and made me a cardboard slice, but the second time was just as bad if not worse, the owner is clearly not from Jersey and doesn't know a jersey slice, must be an out of stater, brought his shitty recipe into the state definitely recommend going to a real pizza joint when you want a good slice not cardboard with no sauce read more

Recently went to this pizzeria and went back today for a second run and i Work in manhattan, and I have eaten in many places , but this pizza is the best I have had outside of New York, and Is on so many levels compatible to the city if not better! The crust is outrageous and the sauce is perfect. The toppings are never ending and sooo many different types. the staff is unbelievably friendly and the prices cannot be beaten anywhere else. I highly recommend this place to anyone from anywhere to go here and try the limitless selections. Truly amazing. Van from PA read more

Cool vibes when you enter. Casual pick up on the right, and waiter service on the left dining room area. Vaulted ceilings. But flies everywhere inside. Nice service. Bland pizza. It was very late when we came Saturday night so maybe that's why. read more

Pizza One - Spicy Nonna - Italian Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

The food is excellent. It's as though grandma made it. The pizzas are unbelievable all kinds of toppings, including grandma and Margarita pies. I think my favorite is the chicken Caesar pizza Specials every week made by John who is probably the best cook I've ever met. Check their website to see what the specials are for that week Reasonable rates great food read more

Place is incredible!!! Been there many times.. food is awesome!!!! Being Italian only 2 places in sussex county it go eat. This is my #1 read more

Used to be our go to pizza place in Sparta but here is a good example of why we go other places now. We thought we would give it another try since we haven't been back in a while. We ordered the kids chicken bites and fries. The chicken bites are literally 4 very small pieces of Popcorn Chicken and a handful of french fries. I understand that costs are up but don't gouge the guests. $72 dollars for 3 kid chicken bites, a boardwalk wrap and two soups is a little aggressive. read more

Pizza One - Chicken Bites w/ Fries - Italian Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

This was our second time here with the same server Jordan. It is such a pleasure to have a great meal and outstanding service. We had a such a nice time. I will request him next time. Can't wait. Thank you. read more

I can honestly say the food is decent but I was so put off by the service recently.. I live in Vernon and about once a week me and my BF get salads from here .. I made some adjustments to the salads which they make easy on the site and there have been some issues in the past. which I have never called to complain but this time they missed a big change so I called to let them know about the mistake. They made me send images of the salad to prove the items were indeed missing even though I order using my account and they can clearly see I have been a long standing customer of not only Sparta but also wayne location as a work near there .. so dissapointing over such a small thing as a salad topping.. read more

I have eaten here so many times and this place is bomb. As a Sparta local I have probably eaten here over 50 times. There burger and fries is extremely good and needs some praise. If you looking for a quick delivery or takeout this is the place to go. Although if you are going to eat here with your family at a nice restaurant not the place to go as the inside isn't really nice but is nice. Overall, service is great and food tastes awesome. 5 Stars read more

So dissatisfied and disappointed in the business. My family, friends, and I all spend and frequent this location often. We will no longer be back. We drove 40 minutes to this location to get dinner and 40 minutes back. Only to find out we received the wrong pizza. When I called the location to explain what happened I asked if they could take my name down for a future pizza to be remade or even a discount on the next purchase if they couldn't accommodate a full replacement pizza. They told me to send an email and they could not help me unless I drove a whole 80 more minutes round trip the same rainy night of 12/9/24. I sent an email and didn't get a response until I made a review on Google where the business owner is lying saying I asked for credit back. I never asked for credit I asked for a singular vodka pizza for a future date because our pizza was wrong. I guess spending 1000s of dollars a year at this location means nothing to them it's not worth it for them to remake a pizza. Not to mention our garlic knots and onion rings were also super burnt! We didn't even care about that it was more so the pizza but they don't care about the garlic knots and onion rings either. Please don't waste your time with this business anymore. None of us will be back read more

Wow. I was not expecting such amazing service from what I thought was a typical pizza shop! I love the vibe and overall dining experience in the restaurant. The complimentary bread platter was so delicious, and the options are endless. Our waitress was also amazing! Calamari was deliciously crispy with a perfect amount of tentacle pieces. The drunken grandma slice was simple and sweet. The lobster bisque was deliciously creamy. The Caesar salad and eggplant slices were a little weird since the toppings were meant to be cold, however still good! I can't wait to try everything on this menu. YUMMMM. read more

See all

The food is different and very good. The pizzas are absolutely amazing. They have toppings I've never seen before. The people who work there are very, very sweet and very helpful and it's a nice warm atmosphere. read more

My family and I eat here often, and lately the service has gone down hill. We went for dinner last night, it took 15 minutes for someone to come take a drink order, luckily we knew what we wanted, and ordered when the drinks finally came out after another 15 minutes. Another 15 minutes for salad, then another for dinners. No one came back to check if we wanted more to drink. The place was clean, the music a decent level, but they did have some bulbs out in their chandeliers. Everyone's food was decent, my complaint was my soup was really thick and salty. Probably going to take a break from eating here. read more

Great pizza place with a great selection. Husband enjoyed the Stromboli. He is very fussy about Stromboli's

The obtuse young woman taking my order tonight, and crazy wait times make this strange place an absolute never return. Cheers to the manager for refunding the incorrect order, returned. read more

We have been to Pizza One twice now since their grand opening this summer in Sparta. Both times we have ordered pizzas (plain and mushroom) and garlic knots. The pizza is fantastic and has now become one of our go-to's for take out. The garlic knots are a great appetizer and served with a delicious marinara sauce. They do now have some seating outside right in front. Thank you again, Pizza One, for making my fiancé's birthday night with another awesome mushroom pie. We can't wait to be back when you're finally open inside. read more

Pizza One - A mouthwatering mushroom pie from Pizza One. - Italian Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

I rarely leave reviews but this place is AWESOME, to the point we ordered delivery twice in the same night! Was expecting run-of-the-mill pizza that is standard of pizza joints in Sparta, but you can tell Pizza One is higher quality than anywhere else here, with fast - and hot - delivery and reasonable prices. So glad they're in the neighborhood. First we ordered one of their specialty pies (vodka sauce and fresh mozz) .... YUM. Perfect toppings and crust. Also tried a cauliflower crust pizza and it was (surprisingly) SO good - give it a chance!! A rarity in Sparta. It was so legit that we ordered again and then got the Rodeo Burger, philly cheese steak egg rolls AND Nutella bites for dessert. I'm not exaggerating, each of them were amazing and delivered hot and fresh. It's like an elevated pizza place. So happy we found a new go-to in the neighborhood! read more

Pizza One - Nutella bites - warm gooey and perfect - Italian Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

I ordered grilled chicken Broiche sandwich from Speciality sandwich menu. It was a huge sandwich and I couldn't open my mouth wide enough to take a bite. It was exactly as pictured in the menu;. Full of flavorful sauces, coleslaw & jalapeños. Enjoyed every bite of it. I went to pick up inside and took a sneak peace of interior decor. It was lavishly decorated with electrical glass fire places mounted on top of every booth. Will certainly return back for a dine-in experience. read more

Pizza One - a half eaten sandwich on a checkered tray - Italian Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

See all

Food was great! I ordered the penne vodka was delicious I have not tied the pizza yet but will try it soon. I work close by so definitely will be getting a pizza pie from there soon . the service was friendly taking my order via phone. Not sure what the ambiance is like I have not had the pleasure of going inside the restaurant yet. read more

Stopped in because we missed dinner. Pizza One did not disappoint, staff was great, food was excellent. A place to try!!

Food was outstanding, service was very friendly! Some of the best pizza we've ever had. Will definitely be returning.

I really wanted to like these place because it is a convenient location but both times I have gone I have had issues. Service has been slow both times with just one server working 6+ tables but I won't fault them for that because I know there is a nationwide staffing shortage. I had a discrepancy in my bill last time where the menu price for the calamari was a few dollars more on my bill than the menu. When I raised this concern I was told that they were in the process of updating their menu. Had I not pressed the issue more I don't think they would have adjusted my bill. My latest visit the bathroom was not operational. I had to take my 4 year old to the Shoprite. They will need to improve their operations before I return. read more

See all

Very good customer service. If your address doesn't come up online call as long as you're under 8 miles and they'll deliver. Vodka pizza was very good. Cheese slid a little during delivery but that happens. Still tasted yummy which is what matters. Rice balls were good but the mini cheesesteak egg rolls were the bomb. I ate them so fast I forgot to get a pic. Looking forward to trying more things. They have quite an extensive menu. read more

See all

We had onion soup here twice and it was great. Been asking for it every time we come and are told " Not today... it's a random thing ". Bummer. read more

Food and service here is amazing! Definitely recommend!! Every time I come into pizza one I feel very welcomed. It's a peaceful atmosphere and they take time to check on how you are doing and if you need anything. Thankful for the kind service and will definitely be returning. read more

Great food, decent staff and warm atmosphere. Staff can be a little stiff. Idk maybe they don't like working there? But they seem unhappy every time I go to pick up my food- and not with just me either. read more

The pizza is great. We haven't gotten the plain pie but the gourmet pies are amazing and the app lets you customize. I love the atmosphere inside and out and the service has always been fantastic. The pasta sauce was not my favorite but still good. read more

Just got a sicilian pie, the worst I ever ate the bottom and the crust was burnt NEVER AGAIN !!!!!

By far the best Pizza in Sussex County ! They uses premium ingredients and it shows. All their other food is very good as well ! read more

Gluten free markings on food is critical as our dinners were not marked !! Spoke to the manager the next day and not ver comforting reply . read more

Pizza One - Which one is gluten free ? Can't tell ? The take out staff didn't know either - Italian Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

Came to get a quick bite, they gave me a water jug that i didnt realize was full of food particles until after i had already drank some, the did give us free bottled water after. Watched a delivery driver drop a 2L soda then roll it across the floor, catch it with her foot by stepping on it then proceed to put it back in the fridge without even wiping it down. On top of this, food was subpar and I probably wont be back. If you have ANY Italian heritage, dont disgrace your ancestors by eating here. The pizza is JUST okay. The pasta fagioli tastes like its from a great value brand soup can. read more

Nice restaurant in this Sussex shopping center... more than pizza with nice selection of salads, entrees, and some vegetarian dishes. Service is good and beginning bread, olive, and cheese board was a welcoming touch. High ceilings with black/copper decor is upscale. Reasonable prices also make it easy on your wallet. read more

The food isn't horrible, but most of the staff is completely incompetent. The menu is loaded with incorrect grammar like apostrophes all over the place where they don't belong. This evening we ordered pasta with vodka sauce in which you can choose your pasta, and we chose cavatelli, as that was an option- but it appears we got capellini/angel hair. The girl who took my order over the phone had zero clue about the food she was working with, calling "sopressata" "sa-presto" which is unfortunate, since it could be so easily fixed with a few minutes of training. Their weekly specials are never updated on their online menu, co you can't view or order them online, and unless you subscribe to their email and call in, you'll never get to try them. Unfortunately, the pizza is probably the worst thing on the menu, very inconsistent. Most of the issues boil down to poor management. I don't blame the employees for their lack of knowledge, I blame the establishment for not training them appropriately. Tonight was not our first time ordering from Pizza One in Sparta, we have ordered many times since they were first opened, and given many chances read more

Pizza One - "Cavatelli" with Vodka sauce (pretty sure that's capellini/angel hair, and not what I ordered) - Italian Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey