I had high hopes for this place after seeing great reviews, especially since I had booked a spot a month in advance for a special occasion--Valentine's Day. The experience started off well enough: I arrived on time and was quickly seated in the back area. However, it took a few minutes for our server to greet us. When she finally did, we ordered a bottle of white wine and some water. The wine arrived a few minutes later in an ice bucket with two chilled glasses, but unfortunately, it wasn't properly chilled. Despite being on ice, it was still warm, which was a letdown.
After some time, our server arrived, she informed us the Omakase was running slow that evening, which we were fine with. The Omakase experience is a 16-course meal. While it's a bit pricey at $165, I didn't mind that, and I think the experience would've been better at the actual bar, though no seats were available.
First Course: Ceviche
We started with the Peruvian Ceviche, which is also available on the regular menu. It was tasty and reminded me of crudos I've had before. Our water finally arrived just as the dishes were cleared.
Item count: 1
Second Course: Appetizers
We were served a Parmesan Scallop (also available on the menu) and a shrimp dish that I believe was unique to the Omakase. The scallop was delicious and different, while the shrimp was flavorful but a bit chewy. At this point, I realized that the 16 courses meant 16 individual pieces of food, not necessarily 16 separate courses.
Item count: 3
Third Course: Tiraditos
Another shrimp dish came out here, which I found odd. An Omakase is supposed to take you on a journey, so back-to-back shrimp felt out of place. The dish, called Pulpo Shrimp, also confused me--"pulpo" typically refers to octopus, not shrimp. While the flavors were good, the shrimp was again quite chewy.
Item count: 4
Fourth Course: Traditional Nigiri
We enjoyed three types of bluefin tuna--regular, toro, and otoro (all available on the menu). These were all very good, though smaller than most Nigiri I've had. The server recommended not dipping them in soy sauce, which wasn't an issue as there was none on our table, nor was there any wasabi or ginger.
Item count: 7
Fifth Course: Nikkei Nigiri Selection
In an odd turn, this course came out of order, much later--like, after the check was already dropped. So, we'll revisit this one in a bit.
Item count: 7
Sixth Course: Handroll
A Blue Claw Crab handroll was served, and with it came soy sauce (finally). It wasn't especially exciting, but I did enjoy it, both with and without soy.
Item count: 8
Seventh Course: Soup
This was a fish broth with corn and minced shallots. It was flavorful, but not particularly impressive.
Item count: 9
Eighth Course: Dessert
This is where things got a bit strange. I had been looking forward to more sushi, as we had been dining for about two hours, and I was still hungry when the dessert course arrived. It was confusing, but we ate the ice cream and churro. While decent, I ended up going to Somi Somi for Ice cream afterward.
Item count: 10
Just as we finished dessert, the check was dropped. I was puzzled, as the meal felt incomplete. I wondered if they were offering a shortened Omakase for Valentine's Day, but the bill was charged at the full $165 price. When another server came to grab our check, I asked for clarification about the Omakase, as it seemed we were missing something--not just 16 courses, but not even 16 pieces of sushi. She quickly realized the mistake and went to correct it.
A few minutes later, another server arrived with an item I didn't recognize--served in a little tostada cup on a bed of beans. We were told not to eat the beans, but the item itself was tasty. Not sure where it fit into the Omakase, but it seemed like a "sorry, we messed up" offering.
Item count: 11
Afterward, our original server passed by, looking confused that we had the check while still getting food. The server who went to fix the issue returned with a single salmon hand roll and apologized for the mix-up. It was odd that they only brought one for two people, but at least the apology was appreciated.
Next, the missing Fifth Course--the Nikkei Nigiri Selection--arrived. This time, we received four pieces of Nigiri. But we were still short if you're counting, even if we include the salmon hand roll. The four pieces we received were tasty: Scallop Truffle (available on the menu), Salmon Parmesan (also on the menu), Unagi (good, not on the menu), and one I didn't catch the name of, but it was probably the best of the bunch.
Item count: 15 (Grand total: 15)
Was it a terrible experience? No. Could it have been better? Absolutely. Warm wine, missing courses, and food delivered out of order definitely dampened the evening. In the end, I'd recommend skipping the Omakase for better value. I think you'd get more food and spend less by ordering directly off the menu.
Other reviews are similar for 2/14 read more