I ordered a fried shrimp, taco and potato and cheese pierogies sautéed with onions that is not what I got first the shrimp was not fried. Secondly, the pierogies was wrapped with bacon in a barbecue sweet sauce. The worst thing I've ever tasted and wasn't anything that I ordered from their menu never got an apology just an excuse and it seems like this is the norm when I patronize local businesses which I try to do, but after this experience, I'm gonna be very leery about ordering from local businesses in Williamsport at least the franchises respect the Customer and know that the Customer is always right if they want to stay in business read more

505 - supposed to be potato and cheese pirogies with sautéed onions. - American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

Worst experience. The food was served in small portions, almost like a kids meal, and the wait took forever. Never coming here again. Rude waitresses that only are nice if you personally know them. The interior of the restaurant looks better than any food I saw there. read more

First time here. Walked in and the atmosphere had a nice, chill vibe. The menu had some great options that I would have loved to try but I had already been dead set on a cheese cosmo so that is what I got. We also ordered onion straws - these were really good, well flavored and came with a spicy ranch. There were just enough for 2 of us to share. The cheese cosmo was delish - and I'm not sure if they put any type of seasonings on the french fries or not but they were so good and almost tasted like there a small hint of some flavoring. Our waiter was so friendly, genuinely friendly and we were talking about how impressed we were with him when we asked for the manager (wanted to share with them our good experience) but we then found out he was the manager! Overall it was a great lunch, no complaints ts at all and will be back!! read more

505 - Cheese cosmo with hand cut fries - American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

Good food, great service, and decent prices. Fun atmosphere on the Wednesday that we went. Trivia night was a blast.

Had the brisket and queso burger best food I've ever had all the food was amazing will definitely be back

505 is the best restaurant in downtown willamsport everything is good its like bar food and chicken fingers and french fries and they have a lot of soft drinks and they even have water and wines and even alchohol and it's like good for people two go their after a show at the community theater league or after the show or like going two the movies read more

We where just there on a Saturday night for a Christmas Party and had the slowest worst prepared food I've had in a long time. The place was empty when we left, now I know why! read more

Heidi was our server/ bartender and she was absolutely amazing! She was very personable, we well as the head manager of rivals (505's brother restaurant, which happens to be our other favorite restaurant/ bar) who was sitting next to us! Food was great, and although the steak was a little too done, they managed to make a great impression by discounting the meal, AS WELL AS accepting the extra discount from Spotluck. Definitely a great way to gain returning customers!! Will definitely be back soon to this amazing new local restaurant!! PS: The first/ last time we were here, the head chef was sitting at he bar and happened to hear me say I am allergic to all types of seafood, but really wanted the spinach artichoke dip (which had crab) and came over and talked to us for a bit, and then made a special serving of it, without crab, just for me!! Although that specific chef is no longer with them, I get such a great vibe from the people who run the restaurant. read more

505 - 505 dip without crab, freshly made - American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Ordered the fish and chips special - was delicious!! Great service. Good ambiance. Will definitely be back.

Ordered the crab stuffed flounder with sweet potato waffle fries and fried zucchini. Flounder was ok but not better than a chain restaurant. Waffle fries were ok nothing special. Zucchini was slime and flavorless. My older son ordered lasagna and couldn't eat a second bite. The sauce was brown and smelled like canned. My younger son ordered the chicken and waffle sandwich. The waffles were ok but the chicken had one of the worst batters I've ever tasted. The texture was almost like burnt flour, which I believe is what it was. Service was average. Won't be returning. Rivals is better for sure. read more

Better than what it used to be, nice atmosphere and nice staff. I'm a steak guy, this isn't the place for that meal. I ordered the $21 Ribeye, it was a 1/2 inch thick and very underwhelming. It came with lobster mashed potatoes and bacon wrapped asparagus. I couldn't taste any lobster and the five pieces of asparagus were wrapped in a single slice of bacon and not seasoned at all. To be fair, I had the tuna steak entree and the entire dish was delicious. read more

505 - $21 for a 1/2" Ribeye and unflattering sides. The tuna steak entree is delicious. - American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Nice place inside. Got the sirloin tips with onions and mushrooms and they were not edible. They had a funky smell like liver and I took it to go and put it right in the dumpster. Nice place and nice people but that taste I couldn't get out of my mouth for a day or so and I won't be back. read more

Only putting one star because our waitress was very nice and respectful. I got a turkey burger and French fries. Burger was good. French fries were Burnt to the crisp couldn't even eat them without cracking a tooth. Do not recommend took unnecessary amount of time to just cook a burger and fries. Will not be returning in the future. read more

505 - two pieces of bacon on a table - American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Had lunch here as we were in a serious search of the Hershey's Yuengling beer. They had sold out of the beer but had lunch anyway. My sub was very good and fries had a nice seasoning on them. Spouse also enjoyed his meal as evidenced by the fact that he finished every last scrap then reached for my leftovers. Will return!!! read more

I was very excited to visit 505 after hearing it was owned by the same owner as Rivals. I've been there twice since it opened. I don't intend on returning anytime soon. I was delighted to see that they had updated the seriously 80's looking decor that Joey's Place kept as a legacy from times of better food. Sadly they opted to keep the equally dated flooring. I suppose the budget had to be cut somewhere. The staff all seemed to be extremely friendly on both occasions I visited 505. All of our orders were correct and we never had to wait long for drink refills. Unfortunately it's the food that suffers here. At best the food is bland and fairly nondescript. At best the food was dry and over cooked. There are firsts for everything and the second visit I experienced a culinary first. By some hand of dark sorcery the cooks managed to make a medium rare steak, medium well and dry as if it was done well and reheated the next evening. While impressive in its own right, I can't say that I enjoyed my dried out miniature version of a NY strip steak. At least I wasn't the one that ordered the overlooked salmon or the salad with essence of avocado. read more

505 is lackluster at best. Waitress told a friend the special was a "pork demonico"?????? Food was terrible, waitress had no clue what was going on. Wouldn't go back if you paid me. Steer clear. read more

Went for lunch on a Saturday. It wasn't very busy, service was good. I ordered a salad, which was fine. The bruschetta was a bit off, it wasn't horrible, but there could have been more care taken. I'd go back. However, there was no changing table, so leave the baby at home. read more

505 - Cobb salad - American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Delmomico is a hit, the southwestern salad is excellent. The dining room is full of booths, more of a bar really. Beer selection is great and so is the service. There is a large dining area in the back and would be nice for a group. We would make a return trip for sure. read more

505 - a man standing at a bar with a television in the background - American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

I keep hearing from the workers that this place is supposed to be 'fine dining' but it isn't whatsoever. Calling french fries 'fried potato' doesn't make a place fine dining, the food does. The menu is an extremely stripped down bar menu with few options, mostly sandwiches. Which would be fine if they were good. The cheese steak (not fine dining by the way) was a massive piece of bread with hardly any steak on it, the 505 dip was cold, and the 'fried potato' (= french fries) were tiny scraps like you'd expect at the bottom of a bag. I was very disappointed in this place because I am a huge fan of Rivals. It looks very nice inside and our server was nice as well. It just seems like they should make more of an effort to make good bar food instead of pretending that they are fine-dining. Hopefully I will have a better experience in the future but I don't think that will happen until they realize that their current menu falls short of their 'fine-dining' goal. read more

I've eaten here a bunch of times, and pretty much everything I've had here is really good. They have weekly specials, so it's always great to check in and try something new. They have delicious burgers, some really good pasta dishes, and a variety of other different American style dishes and sandwiches. I also love their dinner rolls and Italian peppers. Most of the time I'm too full, but they have a bunch of different deserts too. The bar/restaurant has a nice and comfortable casual atmosphere, and the staff is always friendly. I'd definitely recommend 505, one of my favorite locally owned places in Williamsport. read more

They have fired the chef who put them on the map the food will be a huge disappointment

Well I have always liked this place but I ordered sliders from the burger menu and got three stale blts with no burger menu when asking where the burger was I was informed that it's chefs choice.. read more

been going to this place back with Joey...subs were great, went their 2 weeks ago..ordered a sub..the bun was big....really big with hardly anything other than lettuce.....smothered in oil and vinegar....just telling you my experience at 505.. read more

The updates to the restaurant are amazing. The place looks fantastic. However, the service was very slow and we had to wait forever for our food, which was okay because we were not in a hurry. But my major problem was that the food was mediocre and expensive for what you got. It's not much different from Joey's (former restaurant in this location) food, but again more expensive. I loved the atmosphere and hope the food quality/time of service will get better as the newness wears off. read more

Was excited to see what they did with the old joeys place loved the updated decor and really friendly staff but that's all they had going for it. The beer cheese sauce had the weirdest consistency that I've ever seen the salads looked like it was sitting for a day or two and the main course was way over cooked with mushy pasta chicken that was overdone road kill and no flavor whatsoever. Also ordered two of there specialty drinks one tasted like flavored water and the other was nothing but straight up vodka. read more

They are trying to be a bit upscale but are missing the boat. My wife and I went on a Friday evening. I ordered the Stuffed Flounder which came with a salad and only 1 side for $15.00. The salad was ok but no bread or rolls were served. The Flounder was not good at all and I have no idea what it was stuffed with, probably a frozen restaurant entry. The mashed potatoes where fresh, plentiful and only luke warm. My wife had the Eggplant Parmesan which had a side of Linguine.which was good but the Linguine was cold with a small amount of sauce. Her garlic bread tasted stale. Nice to have cloth napkins but no side plates on table so you had to lay your used dinner knife on the table after cutting salad before dinner arrived. So either raise the quality of the food and ambiance or go back to a Joey's Place atmosphere (the previous owner). read more

My boyfriend and I came here from out of town, and immediately loved it here. The atmosphere is amazing and the service was great, everyone was so friendly and quick. The food itself was reasonably priced and prepared so well. We were both very impressed and would definitely recommend. The restaurant was clean and well maintained as well which made the experience even better. read more

Sad food here... Had the Cheesesteak was not good very bland and crest was limp ... The staff were kind and attentive but the food... Wow Guys.. you really thought this was good place for Cheesesteak ? Not good and this place is expensive read more