We've eaten at most of the popular places in Williamsport and I have to put this one at the top. While visiting our son at Penn College, this place will now be our "go-to". Service was great! Menu was unique and very tasty. read more

See all

ants crawling on food and in drinks, the chicken tenders were pink on the inside. My friend got food poisoning.

The Sticky Elbow had a big menu and even bigger portion sizes. My bartender and server was great. She gave generous pours, solid recommendations, and constant smiles. Despite being one of the few patrons in the restaurant, my order took quite some time to come out. Drinks were made instantly, but I finished two before my entree arrived. The bathroom was strangely the only sticky element of the establishment. *Ribeye: huge 18 ounce ribeye served with sweet potato fries and creamed corn. Although I asked for medium rare, the edges leaned closer to medium well. That said, the steak was thoroughly seasoned and tender throughout. The sweet potato fries were heavily seasoned with sea salt, though the potatoes themselves were sweet enough to balance it out. The creamed corn was the most pungent and watery component. I wished the sauce had been thickened more, as it pooled underneath the steak and softened the bottom crust. Overall, this dish was hefty and a steal for the price. *Frost Bite: one of the seasonal mixed drinks. The Malibu and pineapple juice gave this a pina colada style profile. The blue curacao added a striking snowy appearance, though the drink itself leaned quite sweet. *Jingle Juice: another seasonal option, though this one packed a stronger alcohol punch. The tequila was more prominent, while the peach schnapps helped soften the edge. However, the cranberry and orange juices were barely noticeable, so it did not quite deliver the spiked fruit punch profile I was expecting. I loved the generous portions and strong flavors. While the execution was not perfect, the large sizes and heavy pours still made this a jolly experience. read more

See all

Food was mediocre at best. I ordered the short rib flat bread and it was soggy. The service was good and the restaurant was clean. The menu was over the top. The combinations of dishes were too much. It appeared that they tried to create an eclectic menu, too many flavors. It is the only restaurant I have ever been to that you can order, sushi, Mexican, Italian, and American fare. Pick one and do it well instead of trying to make it unique. read more

Great food and service would recommend will be back soon !!! Place was busy too that says a lot read more

See all

Amazing service. Fabulous nachos even with ketchup we thought was chili sauce, cheesesteaks, sushi, junk burger.

The food and service was great! By it being a small owned restaurant, I did not expect the amount of food or the great taste from it. Just visiting the area, but I would go back again! read more

It's simply not what it used to be. The menu used to have some really interesting options that made it stand apart from other restaurants (rabbit, ostrich, etc.). And it was cooked and plated well. And the staff was friendly. The past few times we've gone it was because we were tired of the other few choices in Williamsport on a Sunday night so said "eh, let's try this again." The result each time was that we were reminded of why it's no longer a destination. The service we've had lately, the server couldn't bother to stay at the table long enough to hear the answer to the question they just asked. I'm really not generally hard on server...almost never. And i haven't complained, but this is a problem at Sticky Elbow. I gave this a second star for history, but right now it's a hard pass. read more

Wow what a gem!!! You have to try this place. What a menu!!! Sushi to Cajun and everything in between. It was almost to many choices. I cheated and asked the bartender for a suggestion. Seafood pasta it was. I was not disappointed I added red pepper flakes to kick it up a notch. The only disappointment was that I did not find this on yelp sooner. Would love to try another meal here. Got a French onion soup for a starter. Solid choice but remember to vent the cheese lol that first bite was hot!!! If I back in the area this will be getting more visits from me for sure. read more

The Sticky Elbow - Seafood pasta. Perfectly cooked shrimp and scallops - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

Food Service Ambiance Helpful Friendly Nice to get along with Have sandwiches and sushi read more

The Sticky Elbow - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

It was our first time at the Sticky Elbow which was highly recommended. The menu is eclectic with bison, elk, seafood, steaks, etc. a variety of sandwiches, appetizers, and entrees. We had the steak egg rolls and bbq meatballs over smoked Gouda grits. The bbq sauce was nice and the Gouda grits were outstanding. The meatballs had good flavor but could have been more tender. The steak egg rolls were just ok. The chili Mac was overpowering the chopped ribeye and the bernaise sauce was not the best pairing. Our entrees were the ribeye steak with creamed corn and sweet potato fries and crabcakes with dill potato salad and Gorgonzola sauce. The ribeye was cooked PERFECTLY and the garlic butter was a great touch. The creamed corn was really good and I'd love to see it made with fresh corn in the summer. The crabcakes had good flavor but a few too many vegetables mixed it for me. The potato salad was good and the Gorgonzola sauce complimented the crabcakes nicely. Finally, we had turtle cheesecake for dessert. It was really good with fresh whipped cream. Our waitress was really nice and the restaurant was nicely decorated with a relaxed atmosphere. The chef has an ambitious menu and has a really good touch but some of the items could be updated (steak egg roles, crabcakes). Give the Sticky Elbow a try and share your own thoughts. read more

My daughter and I were traveling through town and decided to stop and have dinner at the sticky elbow. Reviews were good! Our server was amazing, except the nachos with bbq sauce and some burnt chips, not a fan, great French onion soup and our entrees which were a filet and a stuffed ravioli were very tasty. The two things I would would give thumbs down is I asked for bread to go with my pasta, she said they do not have any bread. I said I see you make sandwiches can I have a slice of bread? I was charged $2. That is a little crazy. I was sitting in a back booth near the men's bathroom. Every time the door open I could see the urinals and the men standing in front of them. Not something I want to look at while eating dinner. i didn't think I would be getting dinner and a show with my $2 slice of white bread. A bit disappointed. read more

Well there is a lot they could do to make things better first thing is go and get some people skills you think you could make it in the food field and treat people like dirt you're wrong than you could work on you're service because that was completely horrible as well not to mention the fact that I found a cockroach in my meal ugh how trashy sadly read more

Had a fantastic Fathers day meal. EVERYTHING we ordered was fantastic! Service was great and portions are sizeable. Highly recommend.

We ordered the Bacon bacon Burger, The sticky burger, and an order of onion rings. The sticky burger that came with the french fries with gravy would have been better if there wasn't a heavy hand with the kosher salt sprinkled over them. I found the salt to overwhelm the taste of the burger and made the fries with gravy almost inedible. I did not enjoy the gravy, It had a strong onion and pepper flavor. The onion rings were good, nice and big and they were crispy. The bacon bacon burger was good, very unique with batter dipped bacon. read more

The Sticky Elbow - Sticky burger, french fries with gravy and cheese - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

We were seated by the bar for our date night but since there weren't that many people sitting around the bar, we were fine with that. Our seasonal cocktails were good but maybe a little light on the alcohol. We mentioned that to our fabulous server and I noticed the second cocktail was better. Their house salad is a wonderful start to any meal. The sushi is so flavorful and fresh, definitely a must have! My husband and I shared one of their delicious seasonal dishes and we could've finished it all but we wanted to save room for dessert- fried coffee cake with ice cream WOW!!! Everything was perfect: our server (Lindsey) was professional and helpful, service was quick and friendly, the food was fantastic! We can't wait to go back and try more of their exotic menu items! read more

The Sticky Elbow - Seasonal dish - Tagliatelle - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

The food here is great and the service is pretty good. It's more of a gourmet type of menu. I would recommend this for a special occasion.

Great surprise! Menu is extensive and very interesting. No one item is a "run of the mill" product. This chef is working for you to like the food! When you write a great menu you better make a good product. And it is very good. Well done chef! So is the service. We never once had to ask for refills on our drinks, because we were testing multiple entrees she never even blinked when we needed double setups of silverware. What a great finish too with dessert! The place is well lt, not loud, and it didn' t feel closed in. Loved it! Prices are fair. We had entrees of Crab Cakes and New York Strip Appetizers were also good. Bourbon Meatballs rocked. Thanks read more

Neat, modern-60's style vibe. Creative menu, great food, great portion sizes (come with an empty stomach!). I got a seafood pie, good mix of sea food and a delicious crust. Staff is on top of it! Friendly and hard working (our waitress was running high-tops and the bar flawlessly). read more

Ecletic menu which means everyones wants & needs are covered. We had: mashed potato gouda pierogies, fried broccoli florets, grilled scallops over fried rice, & steak pull apart bread & french onion soup as appetizers. Then the meals came out ... and the quesadilla entree went directly into a to go container. The house hamburger and ribeye were perfectly cooked. The seafood risotto was like a Thanksgiving dinner induced carb coma. Our meals were fabulous. Nature invaded our meal. Al fresco became dine in when the flies & bees found us. Ample free parking behind the restaurant. This meal was by far one of the best meals that I have eaten in Williamsport. Definitely worth a visit. read more

We were traveling from Ny state to Wilmington NC. Hungry and didn't want the usual fast food type of food. So while on Rt 15, I searched and found this great restaurant in Williamsport PA. I called ahead reserved a table for 2 and ordered our appetizers and mains saying according to GPS we would be there in 15 minutes. We were greeted and shown to our table as soon as we arrived. The appetizers immediately were placed on the table. Food was delicious, we got the house salad and the pierogie wontons filled with Gouda cheese in a Asiago cream sauce. Just delish. It is a cute local place that screams welcome. What a great place, this is the way to do it! We will be back next trip. read more

They have the most amazing food. Super nice.and will do what they can to accommodate if you want different sides. Love it

Food was ok , service was good place is a little on the loud side but overall a good experience we'd go back If we're ever in the area

We enjoyed our lunch here on the shaded private patio. The food was delicious and the portions were large. The young lady who waited on us was very friendly and efficient being the only server during lunchtime. read more

The Sticky Elbow - Grilled Romaine and Garlic Shrimp Salad - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

First, if I could give zero stars I would the service was so bad. I ordered a drink four times and I didn't get any drinks. I physically walk up to the bar to get myself a drink I do not know why it took so long and why my friends got their drinks before me when they ordered after me read more

I would have given 5 stars as the food was excellent, wait wasn't unbearable, prices were comparable, but the acoustics were atrocious. So loud you couldn't have a conversation with the person right next to you. I will probably have a migraine long before we leave. A few strategically placed acoustical tiles would solve this problem. read more

Overrated. Go somewhere else if you can. Mediocre food with too long of a wait. Free yourself

My fiancé and I went here for Valentine's Day and we really enjoyed it! A main course that I recommend would be the Mac and cheese stuffed meatloaf but you really can't go wrong with anything here. They have many options and are fairly quick with getting your food out. We definitely enjoyed it! read more

The Sticky Elbow - Creole Swordfish - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

My daughter took me to The Sticky Elbow today, after months of talking it up, and I am a happy mama! Ambiance is small but cool, our server was awesome, and the food... Oh my goodness! We shared Lil Piggy Eggrolls to start - 4 out of 5. My daughter ordered the Lobster Tsunami sushi roll and said it was great, especially subbed with the Dorito Aioli. I got the Sweet Chili Chicken with bacon fried rice and broccoli. The sauce makes it amazing, and bacon should be in fried rice for the rest of my life. Oh, and the portion was HUGE! 5 STARS!!! Will definitely be back. read more

The Sticky Elbow - Sweet Chili Chicken with Lobster Tsunami Sushi in the background - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

UGH DON'T EAT HERE....... My husband found them online & said let's try something different than Taco Bell or Red Robin's I sail ok dear bc the menu was vast it has everything on it..... Way to much now that I think about it. My husband had the Duck "I've made duck & he loved it". But not this it was tuff & rubbery Rubber Ducky your not the one---LOL He also had the lil piggie egg rolls they were ok but the dipping sauce was little bbq sauce & lot's of Mayo not good either I had the Seafood Dip to spicy & they gave you flatbread that was chewy???? Not impressed then I had the Seafood Risotto OMG it sucked my Dog Shiva~Blu wouldn't eat it & She'll eat on a stick really she's eaten a screen a tarp & the plastic roll to her bags but no Scallops for her. So then there was desserts & Coffee Yummy We got the Peanut Butter & Chocolate cake they used the cheapest peanut butter it was horrible & I got the Tiramisu the lady fingers were I don't know the cream was terrible but my puppy ate that. Not so Yummy We had take out bc of Covid not a napkin plastic silverware salt & pepper nothing---We we're staying in a hotel luckily they had it. Don't understand why these places don't put that stuff in there. Was really hoping this was going to be a good place WRONG. They're imposters Go to Burger King next store you'll like it better... I should've read all the reviews first. read more

Staff was very kind and welcoming. Service was fast. Nice ambiance. They have a great variety in the menu. Our waitress checked on us several times and made sure we always had refills of drinks. Food was reasonable priced too! I will definitely return! read more

I love the brisket chimichanga and the bad broccoli aioli sauce is amazing. Huge portions, they need a pizza box for the nachos. Service was friendly. read more

Service was decent, it's just that the spaghetti was dry and flavorless, burgers were VERY salty. I don't recommend and the waiters were a little rude not gonna lie. They kinda just came and gave us our food and then would leave and not come check on us for a while. read more

This was the selection for a team dinner and I must say...I was pretty excited when I started looking at the menu. Lots of interesting items caught my attention. So many that it was hard to make a final decision. That should have been a red flag. This menu had sushi, pasta, salads, burgers, tacos and more...just waaaay too much. I finally settled on the crab cakes. Mistake. I basically had a cornbread type thing with a hint of crab. I will say this...the portions are huge. Everyone at our table was wowed by how large the plates were. No one was wowed by the food on said plates though. Our sever was nice. The space was pretty cool. The menu and execution was a fail. I hope they revamp their menu and come back with things they actually do well and stick to that. read more

The best burger I have ever had in my life! Bacon bacon made with bison and dont medium rare. read more

The Sticky Elbow - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

Not the cleanest but the variety and exotic menu makes up for it. Highly recommended. Must try the Elk sushi

The Sticky Elbow was wonderful. The food and service were impeccable. Everything we ordered was served hot and delicious. The portion sizes were huge. You get a big bang for your buck. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

I stopped here for dinner while staying in town for work. It was quiet when I walked in with a table in the dining area and two couples sitting around the bar. The bartender was super friendly and took my drink order for a hakuna moscato which was strawberry infused vodka, lemonade, moscato and whipped cream. The menu has a few interesting options and it took me a while to decide. Once I ordered, it was quickly delivered. The 8 ounce kobe flat iron is served with gnocchi, peppers, and squash in a delicious cream sauce. I ordered the steak medium and it came out well done but otherwise the entree was very good. Nice little spot and Im likely to return when in town. read more

The Sticky Elbow - Hakuna moscato - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

Visited this place for dinner with a friend for the first time the other night. I got the ahi tuna in a pita and it was delicious! They asked how I wanted my tuna cooked - med rare, and it was beautifully cooked. The flavors were perfect together. The only thing I didn't care for was the wax paper/tinfoil wrap. I get why it was done but it was annoying to peel back as the foil kept ripping. My friend got a venison burger and the spicy duck wonton soup. I tried her soup and it was good and spicy and very flavorful. Her burger looked amazing too. She said it was the best burger she's had in a long while. I recommend trying this place out! read more

The Sticky Elbow - Ahi Tuna Pita Sandwich - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

This place was pretty busy. The food was okay. I would not recommend the stuffed meatloaf. I though it would be better based off other reviews I read. I would go back but I'd like to try a different meal. The staff was very nice. read more

The Sticky Elbow - Stuffed Meatloaf - New American Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania