We ordered take-out pizza from here filled with great hope, based on the other reviews. The Brighton Beach, which features bacon, had perhaps one slice of it spread over the small and stunningly bland pie-- indeed, a couple of slices had no bacon at all. At $15, it was an insult to us and to all the far better "greasy spoon" pizzerias in this neighborhood. The cocktails may be great, but if you're a pizza restaurant, you have to do better than this. read more

Hands down best pizza and condiments combo in all of BROOKLYN. The spicy honey always does the trick! But please, D.S. Bring back the OCTOPUS :) read more

Fantastic pizza, great cocktails, MEH bartender. Have had same AA female bartender for each of our several visits. She should spend an evening at Clover Club to see how to be a welcoming bartender. No engagement. Pretty good mixology skills but it is clear that she has no enthusiasm for the craft or the patrons. Get the bearded guy to be the face. He's got the natural skill. Maybe she can learn it. read more

I'm really excited that this place is so close to my new apartment. My boyfriend and I work late and not too many places are open. We were really just looking for a decent meal late at night that wasn't too far. Our meal and drinks turned out to be much better than we were even trying for. We sat at the bar and found both bartenders to be attentive and friendly. We shared the shaved brussels sprouts for an appetizer and shared the vinegar hill pizza for dinner. He had the drink special of the night and I had a dirty martini. Both were delicious and exactly what we needed. We also met who I think is the owner. He came over to see what we thought of everything. He was nice and clearly cares about his restaurant and customers. read more

good pizza, good drinks. Salad combinations sound good but are just ok. sometimes you can have dessert and sometimes you can't. Bar drinks are good most of the time and pricey all the time. liked this place a lot at the start but have had some service issues that make me want to spend my money elsewhere. Yes this place has good pizza but this is Brooklyn I can get good pizza at those prices at many places. read more

After seeing yelp reviews went and was greatly disappointed. Pizza was OK, our party of 4 ordered the brussel salad, grilled octopus, 3 pies, and later a warm Brownie Sunday and ice cream. Salad was different but lacking. Octopus meh. As for the pizzas (3 different ones don't remember names), first one was soggy and burnt, other 2 were ok but no crispy crust. Brownie Sunday was ok, tho we did get a small size of a peanut butter and sesame ice cream that we all agreed was the best part of the meal. They have happy hour from 9pm and we were seated at 8:45. They claimed our first round didn't qualify, but second did. Not worth the trip. read more

The pizza here is really good, the portion size is modest. I would say it's more individual size, definitely not enough for two ( 1.5 would be perfect!) the drinks are really delicious, whiskey selection is quite impressive, staff is polite and attentive. The place is small, we got there on Thursday night and all the tables were taken, sat at the bar read more

Great food. Amazing cocktails and the best service!! Went there for a date and was treated like a king. The servers knew the menu in and out. Even advised a dish for us to try. Will definitely be coming back. Thanks! read more

Best pizza!!! EVER!!! When ever I crave pizza I want Wheated!!! Cocktails are great too. Fast service. Only wish they delivered so I could eat Wheated pizza more often! ;) read more

My family and I call them and pick up our pizza from time to time. No matter what type of pizza you order, it is always fresh and tasty. As one who has lived in Kensington my entire adult life, I must say it is a nice addition to the neighborhood. read more

Probably the best pizza I had, Superb place to eat. I had to order two instead of one because of the taste. Will most likely recommended this place to a friend or family members read more

Been here a few times for dates and with friends, and it's always a great experience. I love their cocktails and trying new whiskeys, plus the pizza options are creative and delicious! read more

Tucked away on a street in Brooklyn, Wheated is a small haven for delicious pizzas and drinks. To begin, Vincent, the Friday night bartender, is definitely meticulous and masterful when he makes your drink. The Horse's Neck had just the right amount of ginger- light and refreshing. But once you drink two, you're already on your way to enjoying Wheated a bit more (if you know what I mean). The pizzas look big, but believe me when I say that your stomach can handle all of it! The thin crust and fresh ingredients complement the drinks well. read more

Amazingly shagfully tasteful yet sexy pizza. This place is truly one of the greatest, most satisfying pizza joints in all of NY. The fresh ingredients, cold brews and friendly service keeps wheated in my fave-fives. Move over Robertas, wheated has knocked you out. Okay fine Robertas is still great but wheated is tied or a thin notch better and it's less of a hike for anyone trying to avoid the seedy part of Barwick Robertas is in. Wheated, always stay please! read more

It's really nice to have yet another foodie haven grace our nabe and add to the burgeoning hip street that is Church Ave. What's cooler than brick oven gourmet pizza? The rusty rustic storefront is a cozy and inviting view of the bar. Dining is mostly located in the back. The pizzas are named after surrounding neighborhoods and streets. Not very heavy on the meat which is nice but I hope they broaden their selection to more adventurous fair, maybe? And they don't offer dessert. My suggestion of a Nutella pizza was quickly shot down by the owner :.( apparently it has too many carbs? The pizza was finely cooked chewy and crisp. Expected a bit more truffle on one of them but it was truffle salt and not oil so its expected. The prices are more than what you would pay at the dollar a slice joint but its gor-met! I ordered the house special New Orleans Cocktail which was so strong I couldn't order another I was breathing fire! The bathroom is located behind a secret door that has been wallpapered over. And although the restaurant is warmly furnished I'm still wondering wether the buck head we sat under was paper mâché or another wallpapered over thing. The staff were very polite and attentive. It was nice to see so many young families enjoying a night out as well as couples and the noise wasn't loud at all, pleasant and ambient. I really hope more young families frequent this joint they are a welcome sight over those pretentious hipsters boozing up this fine neighborhood. read more

See all

This is a great spot for some food and drinks with friends. It's usually crowded in the front with people hovering over each other with drinks in hand, but there are a few tables in the back to enjoy your grub. The pizza is terrific. The crust is just right, not too thick or too thin. The portion may be perfect for those who aren't looking to eat a large pie, but for the price of a pie here, it's on the smaller end if you're sharing (more like personal pan size). I ordered the Bensonhurst and I have to say it's good, however, for my palate, it's a generic taste. I've had this exact taste elsewhere. I tried honey, sriracha and the chili powder on my pizza and wow, it's another level of flavor. Who would've thought honey or sriracha on pizza would taste amazing. I would definitely return to try another option that isn't very generic tasting. One negative I really did not appreciate is the strong alcohol odor in the restaurant. As soon as you walk in, you are overwhelmed with the alcohol smell, and it leads into the back seating area as well. Overall, bit pricey for the size, establishment is small with little wiggle room, strong odor for those sensitive to alcohol, but really good pizza in the area. read more

A good friend of mine says that if she knew she was going to die tomorrow, she would want to go to Wheated for dinner. That's right, this place is Last Supper good. Pizzas are spectacular, both the meatball and octopus starters are delicious, and the brownie sundae is to die for. But what puts this place over the top is the cocktails. I have never had a drink here that I didn't love. And while most of the cocktails are already affordable at $10 or under, they also have a great late-night happy hour during the week! There's really no place better. I hope Wheated stays in our neighborhood for a long, long time. read more

I'm fairly new to the neighborhood and people kept raving about this place. I'm a pizza addict, and decided to try it tonight. Very pleasant wait staff. I *only* had the pizza.. I ordered the Bensonhurst (cute that they name the pizzas after different neighborhoods in Brooklyn). It was superb. Next time I will try some other dishes and update this review. By the way, I lived near Grimaldis and Patsy's for many years.. this place puts them to shame. read more

A few years later still good pizzas, love their caesar salad. Very good drinks (and happy hour) and no more weird attitude.

A hidden gem. Try the mixed greens salad and borough park pizza.

Innovative toppings but prefer the thinner, crispier crust on a classic nyc pie. We ordered two pies and one was near cold. Will request that they bring them out as they are ready. Very crowded in a Friday night, so arrive early. read more

Really excellent Neapolitan pizza. I had a white pizza and was very satisfied. The pizzas are very big and could be split with a salad, which also looked huge. Only complaint is slow service, but it's because their wait service is far understaffed - they're all working very hard. read more

This place is awesome. Really enjoyed our pizza and my cocktail. The ambiance is super chill and the service was great too!

This is arguably some of the best gourmet pizza I've ever had! You can customize your pizza and add unusual toppings (spicy thai curry, spicy honey, etc - sounds like it will be disgusting, but is surprisingly delicious!) They also have an intimate backyard space when the weather gets warmer. I highly recommend giving this a try! You won't be disappointed read more

Great place to have pizza, love the atmosphere and eveything. But stop by to have a drink and bartender pretend not to see me, like she didn't wanted to serve me but she was making drink for employees sitting in the bar. Very disappointed this time. read more

The beer was yummy and the pizza crust was certainly very good, but the price! The selection of pies was not so great and a small pizza was $15. The place is essentially a bar with a pizza oven - not a real restaurant. It wasn't for me, but seems like a good option for locals. read more

Amazing pizza and service!!!! Get the Windsor terrace !!! It won't disappoint. Owner is a sweetheart and will go out of his way to help you!! Will be back soon! read more

Every pizza is delicious and there is always something new to try with their seasonal salads or add ons to the menu, like the porchetta and calzone. Yummy yummy! And absolutely delicious cocktails too! Looking forward to the back patio opening up (which I hear should be very soon) read more

Great drinks, awesome pizza. My favorite neighborhood spot.

pizza is out of this world!! came here twice with friends and it is just amazing. drinks are surprisingly strong. cozy atmosphere, what are you waiting for? ... just go. read more

Great pizza, good wine, fine cocktail menu, relaxed local vibe. Simple, straightforward quality.o

Not the best pizza in Brooklyn, but very good. The service is always excellent, and the cocktails are great! One of my favorite places in the neighborhood. read more

Wheated is fantastic. The staff is professional, accommodating and friendly. The pizza is fantastic (especially the Borough Park. I dream about this pizza. I want it right now.) The salads are great too. The drinks are delicious and generous. The space is warm and cozy. I have no complaints. read more

Went here for pizza early Friday night with my son - it was wonderful! The crust was perfectly crispy on the bottom, but chewy on the edges... delicious! And the sauce was great too. My kid is a total pizza snob, and he kept announcing this was among the best he's had. We got a salad too, very generous portion. And the decor is simple, but very tasteful. I'm just sorry it's taken this long for us to get here! read more

this place is indeed vegan-friendly, thanks to the owners for explaining that. so far as I can tell, they still don't have it on the menu but they in fact have a vegan crust, vegan sausage, and vegan cheese. Your vegan friends won't go hungry here. I can't believe I said in the original review that their pizza is not to do for. It IS actually to die for -- I hadn't had their vodka sauce pizza yet when I wrote that review. (I'm not vegan, just have a lot of vegan friends). that pizza is INCREDIBLE. some of the best pizza i've had in the city anywhere. ever. at certain times, they get super crowded and their waitstaff seems a little overwhelmed. but i guess that's anywhere in ny. service is always friendly and helpful. i wish they had that chili-infused olive oil that some pizza places have. but they'll bring powdered chili if you ask for it. read more

Love this place, come here often with friends. Wish the kitchen would stay open later. One thing i have notice lately is they have a big turn over in the kitchen so the quality of the pizza keeps on changing. But not only is the food really good also the drinks. Great variety of drinks and they also know what to recommend. Can't go wrong with any drink you order. Everyone behind the bar seems to know what they are doing. The serves can be better. But still have so much love for this place, just to good to stay away from. read more

I am so excited to welcome Wheated to the neighborhood. We really enjoyed our three pies - a simple mozz, one with sopresatta, and a third with arugula and prosciutto. The service was very friendly and professional. I think they are still working out a few minor kinks - but overall this place is really a keeper. Only cons: I found the servings of wine to be quite small, they kept forgetting to take away empty glasses even as new drinks came to the table and the A/C seemed weak for how hot it was. But again, the pizza was awesome - and that's what really counts! We'll be regulars for sure. I'll also be excited to see what they add to the menu as far as salads, appetizers and desserts. If they eventually deliver, I'll be in heaven. read more

So I went to wheated last night food was excellent. Pizza makers were amazing made some of the best pizzas I ever had ! Waitress was very attentive and very professional. The place look awesome they had very cool animal head decorations. I only wish they where playing better music. It's Friday night ! They need some lively music not sleeping music ! But over all great place ! read more

Lovely cocktail and whiskey selection. The personal pizzas are creative and really tasty. The Red Hook is off the hook!

Best not to go with a group of friends on the weekend. If you do it should be as soon as they open or near closing since it is a small place. But there bartenders know what they are doing. They make some amazing cocktails. All the kitchen staff seem to of change, they don't seem to enjoy what they do. But the pizzas are still very tasteful. Top drink is a new york sour. Top pizza all. Can't go wrong with anything you order. Defiantly love coming here with friends but when its not rush because then I feel like they rush you out. read more