I've been coming here since 2017, and it's a spot that I just really enjoy going to. -David the owner is great. -Place is great. -Meatballs and caesar salad are vastly underrated. -Pizza is very good, pending on which you get, not all of them travel well though (also depends how far you're going with it) -Huge fan of just sitting at the bar -Drink beer and whiskey -Have a great time This place can get VERY crowded, so if you get there and have to wait, grab a drink, stand near the windows, watch people pass by, and enjoy once you do. read more

Do they order in their crust? Ordered pick up last Friday, 3/6/26 and got home, right around the corner, very excited to eat--- and was met with a cold, wet, soggy crust. Yuk. $44 disaster. Not the first time I've experienced a bummer experience--last time I ordered pick up and got home with the wrong pizza. Gah. Composed a text to interact regarding my experience and never received a response. Thanks, no thanks, DAVID. 1 out of 10 stars. DO NOT RECOMMEND. For product and response. Avoid. read more

The most amazing pizza, a friendly and delightful staff, and always a lively vibe. Love the mustard pizza special! read more

Have to admit that I didn't have a great experience my first time. I think it was the Caesar salad's extremely rich and salty anchovies that ran right through me (tmi!) I remember the New Haven and cobble hill pies were pretty decent, but something ultimately didn't sit right after that meal. I had wanted to give them another shot since I heard such great things and saw that it made the NYTimes list (!) so over a year later I finally returned. I was much happier this time around with the arugula salad, the Bay Ridge pie and even the passionfruit ginger house soda - everything was fantastic. Service was also great. read more

See all

Loved this place! It is small and was quite crowded when we went on a Saturday but it was worth the wait. We tried a couple of different pizzas and the Cesar salad. I really enjoyed the pizza with vodka sauce, and I appreciated them having an option for 100% beef pepperoni as that's hard to find and my friend has a pork allergy. They have a lot of options, and the dough of the pizzas is tasty and very fresh. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Great pizza! I love a good tavern style pizza and this place we did definitely delivers. The crunchiness of the sourdough crust with the cheese and amazing marinara sauce, definitely pairs well with some pepperoni if you want that little meat kick. Great space and service is amazing. Has a full bar and some fun drinks on the menu. Definitely will be back to try out more of their amazing pizza combos on their menu. read more

Wheated - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Me and a friend split a caesar salad and a pie half Bensonhurst half Sunset Park. It was really delicious! The servers were also very attentive! I would def go back to try some of their other pies! read more

They're not joking when they tell you to line up before their opening time: we got here on a Saturday at 5:03p (they open at 5p) and there were just a handful of seats at the bar left. Within 15 minutes, there was already a line outside the door. The place is TINY. We got a Sunset Park and a Ditmas Park. They have two sizes to choose from, so it's perfect for any sized group. The pizza is very crunchy all throughout, with the crust slightly burned, and it's very filling. Plan on under ordering, or you'll have to bring some home. I don't find it to be life changing, but I guess people love this place. For me it was just an average pizza. read more

See all

Great local pizza shop for elevated pizza option. They use a sourdough crust/dough which really sets them apart. They have seasonal/weekly special that are very "diffrent" but in a good way. I'd definitely recommend try them. They also have New Haven style pizzas as well. read more

Wheated - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The setup at Wheated is the classic neighborhood spot--bar up front, tables in back, open kitchen so you can watch your pizza go into the oven. It's cozy without trying too hard, and the vibe is welcoming whether you're here for a quick slice or settling in with drinks. Wheated nails the thing that matters most: the crust. They make it with sourdough starter instead of commercial yeast. There's this tanginess and depth you don't get elsewhere, plus it's got the perfect crispy-yet-chewy texture that holds up all the way through. All the pizzas are named after Brooklyn neighborhoods. That doesn't really tell you what's on them, but that's part of the fun. The Brighton Beach is my perhaps my favorite: bacon, garlic, black pepper, mozzarella. It's essentially carbonara pizza and it works perfectly. The bacon gets crispy, the pepper cuts through, and that sourdough crust ties it all together. The Bay Ridge vodka pie is dangerously good--creamy, rich, the kind of thing you'll randomly crave a week later. If you want a fully loaded pizza, the Supreme has everything: sausage, mushrooms, onions, olives, pepperoni. There are also some interesting combinations like the Red Hook (white pie with mortadella, potato, thyme, pistachios) and the Coney Island 2.0 (pineapple and chorizo instead of the usual Hawaiian). I think pineapple on a pizza is a crime against humanity, but maybe worth trying if you like Hawaiian pizza and you're feeling adventurous. They also do solid meatballs, a good Caesar salad, and the cocktails are affordable with a solid bourbon selection. Weekend brunch adds bagels, biscuits, and sausage gravy to the mix. Bottom line: this is the kind of place that adds minimal value to your neighborhood. That sourdough crust alone makes it worth going out of your way for. read more

Food, service, and atmosphere were all phenomenal. Meatballs (appetizer) were life changing and the sourdough pizza is worth traveling for. THE destination to hit if you're going to a show at Kings Theater. read more

See all

I've turned this place into my regular Saturday night stop. 2 of the best mixologists/bartender/ therapist in the city work at this smaller bar. Yes there's table seating. But I'm a bar person. The menu has some great pizza options/ combos. I've settled on The Flatbush lately totally delicious. If you're adding a salad and there's 2 of you get the small, same with the pizza.. a few other things - meatballs are baseball sized and if your into bourbon it's everywhere! One of the biggest selections/ collections around. read more

This place is fantastic! Such a homey feel and amazing staff. Everyone was helpful and friendly. The pizza is fantastic! Also must have the bacon slab! This appetizer is so yummy and could be a side for salad! The drinks are amazing! And if you have a chance, do come for breakfast and try the bagels ! read more

Really delicious pizza and amazing quality and topping ratio for the price. I've been to other pizza spots that have the same price but half the flavor and quality that Wheated has. Love this neighborhood joint and the service was impeccable, staff was so polite and kind despite some customers being rude and antsy. Just remember it can get real busy, folks! If they can't get to you within 3 minutes then just wait, no need to be mean to them. read more

Wheated - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I would put Wheated up there with all the pizza titans in NYC - it's that good! Always solid no matter what pie you get. The staff are all super friendly and knowledgeable. It does get pretty crowded so I always order for pick up. Now the bagels and biscuits - holy moly! So good how can the same spot make solid pizza and solid bagels?! A true NY unicorn! read more

Wheated - Bagel options and biscuit - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The best pizza in New York! I know...that's a crazy claim. Always great service and good vibes. Get the New Haven pizza and Canarsie!

We got the vinegar hill pizza with bacon added and it was absolutely phenomenal--every bite was delicious and the crust was honestly chef's kiss! The meatballs with ricotta were also delicious and a really generous serving with fresh cheese shredded ontop! The service was great and very fast--5 stars there without a doubt. The drinks were where we lost a star here honestly--great ingredients and I wanted to love them but the cocktails were just a little on the sweeter side for my liking. If you like sweet though? Definitely a place for you! The restaurant itself is smaller without a HUGE amount of seating and they don't take reservations either. My advice? Get there when they open or after the dinner rush if you're wanting to sit down for a meal and you won't be disappointed. They fill up quick which is no surprise because they're one of the best slices I've had in the city! It's a can't miss place if you haven't tried it. These guys really know what they're doing when it comes to pizza and I will be back! read more

See all

Lovely service at this hip spot near Prospect Park. I just got a Cesar salad to go and it was delicious. Excellent dressing! I would definitely go back to try the pies. It's super cute inside and the pizza I saw others eating looked great. Tiny place, I can see why it fills up so quickly, I was there early and it was already pretty crowded. read more

See all

Amazing pizza place in Brooklyn. We had to make reservations beforehand as the place was packed by 530pm. We got a few different New Haven style pizzas. Of them, the vodka sauce and NY slice pizzas were the best. Service was excellent. The F.U.B.A.R cocktail was delicious. Overall great experience. read more

Wheated - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Quality pizza and when you're there definitely try the bacon. Service was good and friendly. It can get pretty full so try to go earlier. Ambiance is a bit cramped though as seating is limited. Also they're closed on Monday and Tuesdays. They have a well stocked bar and you can see them making the pizza. Overall a good experience and will def come back. read more

See all

Absolutely amazing experience. The GM/main server was absolutely incredible. Made us feel at home and was super accommodating. The food was delicious. We started with some drinks and there pieces of thick cut bacon. We shared three smaller pies to try a few, and were given some of there house chili crisp which was an excellent topper for the white pie.The next time we are in the area we will definitely be back! read more

See all

Server was a little slow- there was also a basketball game and all the staff were a little too excited about it (slamming tables and screaming), but the atmosphere was nice! Food was delicious. read more

Great pizza, sourdough crust and quality toppings. Cosy vibes with a rounded bar and amazing whiskey collection.

I visited this establishment to place a takeout order. I ordered the Canarsie Pizza and while I waited I ordered a drink. The drink I ordered was called Horses Neck. It was very good and had the right amount of alcohol. The waiter was very nice. He offered me water while I waited for my pizza. The restaurant was very busy. It wasn't very noisy just crowded. All of the employees were very attentive. Once I received my order I paid and left. The pizza was really delicious. I'll definitely come back and dine in. I would like to try other pizzas on the menu. I may choose another night to go besides Friday because it was crowded that night. read more

See all

Came here on a late Friday night with a friend. Was in the mood for Italian/pizza and found this spot via Yelp. Read the reviews and checked out the pics and wanted to give this spot a chance. Was seated promptly at the bar. I started with a Hatch Mezcal cup ($14) which was a solid cocktail. Ended up ordering the supreme pizza ($31). This was really good and very filling. The pie is more than enough for two people. The whole experience here was great. I highly recommend this place if you are in the mood for pizza, good cocktails and a chill vibe. Would def come back here again. read more

Wheated - Supreme pizza ($31 as of 09.09.2022) - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I finally got around to trying Wheated's weekend-only sourdough bagels. They are a little pricey but at the peak of freshness with a good chew and present a nice alternative to Terrace Bagels. The burnt scallion cream cheese was on point as well. They are serving Coffee Mob on weekend mornings, and they appeared to be doing a big business. Service was friendly, and pickup went smoothly. read more

One of the best Cesar Salads in NYC. The owner is Pizza (and whiskey) obsessed-- he hates bad food so will never serve you anything but the best NYC style pizza. read more

Many different styles. We got New Haven and NY style. Both excellent. 8.5 pizza. Worth the trip read more

Wheated - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Stayed with family in Brooklyn who told us it was a favorite. We all went for a last-minute Sunday reservation. Our host was wonderful about seating us. Drinks came out promptly and were all delicious. Two salads for the table were fresh and flavorful. Pizza was outstanding--we ordered a variety but I loved mine with roasted eggplant and garlic. I hope we can come back again. The atmosphere is warm and friendly, with excellent service. It was a welcome place on a cold, rainy night! read more

Wheated - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Wheated has been on my list forever and it didn't disappoint. Once they reopened for indoor dining (they were doing takeout only during Covid), I headed over for dinner with friends and tried: + Rum old fashioned + Golden hour cocktail + Classic Caesar + Sunset park + East Williamsburg + Bay ridge + Chocolate cake The salad was perfect, and my favorite pizzas were the sunset park and east Williamsburg (mmm, mushrooms). Chocolate cake from Love, Nelly was great too. 4.5 stars. read more

Wheated - Golden hour - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This place has everything I love about my Brooklyn neighborhood. Cozy charm, unexpected magnificence in a simple package, and just this genuine Brooklyn humanity. My sister and I shared a Williamsburg pizza subbed with vegan cheese and added vegan sausage. It was absolutely wonderful. The chewy yet crunchy crust had just the right amount of char on the edges. Great toppings and the sausage was really tasty - I *think* it was Field Roast sausage, or something similar. My favorite style because it has its own texture that isn't trying too hard to be meat. Great neighborhood atmosphere, quick yet casual and friendly service, and though the dining area and bar were both packed, it's an easy place to be and I can't wait to go back. read more

Wheated - Williamsburg Pizza with vegan cheese and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I first tried coming here after work on a Friday; they were closed. I then tried coming here midday on a Saturday; they were closed. I lastly tried coming here on a late Sunday afternoon; they were open. Talk about confusing business hours. However crazy the business hours are, it is not so crazy to get here, as it is a 5-10 minute walk off the Church Ave station on the B/Q. Pretty straightforward there. But you did not come here to see me ramble about crazy store hours and subway jargon, you came to read about the food! I ordered two things, the meatball appetizer and the Bensonhurst pizza pie (sorry folks, no slices here, only whole pies). The meatballs are a trio of softball sized roundies smothered and covered in a marinara sauce and a blend of ricotta and parmigiana reggiano cheeses. They are soft, with a char all over the outside. I guess this works more as a meat sauce appetizer then a meatball appetizer. My server, Craig, suggested I keep the remainder of my dish to dip the crust in. Great idea Craig! Except someone else took the dish to create more room on my table. More on Craig later. In what seemed like an eternity later, my pizza arrived. It looks sharp, with all the tastings and makings that say, this is a Margherita pizza. The pizza tastes good, but the crust, made with a sourdough starter (I had to ask, though I pretty much figured it out), really is the star here. Most pizzerias I have been to make their sauce or their cheese the feature presentation. For once, it is nice to see someone choose to make their crust take the lead. It delivers a solid performance. After a while, the density of the crust gets too much, which is why I could not finish the whole pie. Before going in, my plan was to try to leave at least two slices behind. Unlike me, a pizza slice should not be left alone. Now, back to Craig. He is a super server. Genuine, engaging, colorful, and intelligent. I really liked talking to him. This is a guy who knows his pizza. I guess he knew I did too, but maybe that is because I was wearing my pizza shirt to the restaurant. Like the pizza, he too delivers a solid performance. Thanks Craig. I can only hope that next time they can be more consistent with one thing, knowing when to come here, open or closed. read more

Wheated - Bensonhurst Pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza is amazing. The whiskey selection is the best I've ever seen. Everyone who works there is very knowledgeable, helpful and fr read more

Wheated - Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I finally got my hands on Wheated pizza after 2 years in the neighborhood. Somehow it has been closed every time I've walked by. Does no one else look for high end pizza on a Tuesday at 4pm or Saturday at 10am? Anyway, the wait was worth it and the Bensonhurst pie I gobbled down was delicious. You could taste the high end ingredients and I could see why they make bagels out of the same type of dough. The service was top notch and the rose on the menu was really really good. There were so many delicious looking pies all around me that I'll have to keep coming back and make my way down the menu. While I ate every last bite of my pie, I did wish the crust wasn't as burnt but it clearly isn't stopping me from wanting more. read more

See all

Amazing food and service! We are so happy to have this restaurant as our neighborhood pizza spot.

Despite spending many weekends of the last decade in the Ditmas Park/Flatbush area, I didn't visit this long standing ode to pizza in the neighborhood until recently. I always kept this spot in my back pocket, noting how they adorably name each pie after a Brooklyn neighborhood (shout out to Bensonhurst!) and have an extensive whiskey list. After many years, the night came when I needed to pull out a back pocket restaurant, and we were lucky enough to be met with barely a wait on a recent Thursday night during primetime dinner hours. Even though they tout one of the largest whiskey lists in the city (according to them, I have not substantiated this), they don't point this out anywhere on their menu or at their restaurant. Once upon a time they bragged about this large whiskey collection on their website and I even confirmed with our server this was the case to make sure I was remembering correctly. I know Wheated is now wading into the bagel making business and so I'm guessing they are rebranding away from being whiskey aficionados and more toward being dough aficionados. This makes sense-- the dough is great. I recently sampled some of their bagels at BagelFest and loved the addition of furikake on theirs. Each pie at Wheated is pretty sizeable and large enough to feed two diners, maybe with an appetizer. Unfortunately this means the menu doesn't favor those who like variety, because you don't have the option of dividing your pizza into two halves with different toppings, so we went all in on one flavor-- the Flatbush. My dining companion is a meat eater, and I am not-- I could tell they would've liked one of the pies with meat, but we weren't in a position to take home leftovers and could only stomach a single pie. I thought the pizza was great, though after a couple of slices I would have liked a little more variety on my plate. I did get to try some excellent wine and one of their many whiskeys though. If you're unlike me and don't mind a dinner of just pizza, Wheated is a cozy little neighborhood spot that has a lot of fans for good reason. read more

Always great service - always best pizza - always amazing cocktails. So glad for such a solid place so close.

Two years after my last review (with a few visits in between), I'm thrilled to report that this place is still incredible. Some places do one thing very well, but this place does at least 2 things exceptionally well: make pizzas, and provide the most incredible whiskey selection. The service is exceptional as well. It's clear that they take pride in what they do. Last night in the outdoor section was incredible! Thanks, Wheated! read more

I want to start off by saying that I WANT to like Wheated. It's close to my apartment and the energy you feel when entering the restaurant is great. That being said, I think I received a burnt pizza last night. I ordered the Flatbush, so I understand that the skin of the eggplant can darken quickly. But I couldn't taste the eggplant at all since it was burnt and the pieces were dried up.The sauce was still good though, I would stick to the classics next time. read more

Wheated - Flatbush Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Yummy! Bacon Salads Pizza What more do you want? The place is small service is good. read more