The pizza here is delicious. It was just what we were looking for. Very yummy and big slices!!

We were staying in Vilano for the week and decided to get pizza for our last night. Worst decision ever to order from here! We ordered two salads, 3 pizzas, and mozzarella sticks. It came out to $91. Thought that was a little pricey and checked it against the website prices. When we arrived to pick it up, we questioned the girl at the front about the discrepancy. Immediately the manager came out from the back and responded with "Well, that's the price!" He shoved the bill and menu at us with no other explanation and wanted to argue instead of act in a professional and courteous manner. Apparently they raised the price on the salad, but didn't update the website. Too bad he couldn't just tell us that. The pizza itself was ok, not much cheese and overcooked. The salad had tons of olives, peppers, and feta. The mozzarella sticks were under cooked and not very good. We will definitely not be back due to the way we were treated. read more

It was near our hotel and delivered. The best part was that the food was amazing! We tried the chicken parm, stuffed shells (with pesto YUM) and Ceasar salad. Garlic bread came with it. After a day of driving, it was great to eat real food. read more

Always great food. Nice assortment of menu items. I've had pizza, dinners, salads, and subs there. Only reason I knocked off a star is because they don't honor the coupons on their menu. The chicken gyro salad is so good. Fresh and light. read more

Food was average if that prices were outrageous pizza and wings for 5 was 120.00 for take out never again little Ceasars is better

Chose to order from here because two reviewers complained about the owner's stringent policies during Covid. Two thumbs up to the owner for that. Ordered Spicy Chicken Caribbean Pizza. Timely delivery but the pizza be unedibly salty. ‍ read more

Listen, garlic knots are the way to any woman's heart. This place has the most amazing garlic filled garlic knots I have EVER had. I mean I could drown myself in all of the garlic they drown them in. The calzone was eh, but honestly I was okay with just filling up on those knots! read more

Most pizza places don't have the variety of toppings I like to try but this place had some of my favorites. Tonight I ordered an eggplant and meatball pizza. It was the best pizza I've had in a long time, right down to the crust. Would definitely eat here again! read more

We stopped by Vinny's Pizza today after a long day of travel and while the trek was long and a little concerning since Vinny's is a bit out of the way from downtown St. Augustine - boy was it worth it!! First off the staff was congenial and friendly and so so helpful in making decisions about what to order. We got the Veggie Deluxe and the the Cheese pizza - both 18" - and the complimentary order of garlic knots for 6 people. We had the equivalent of one pizza left over and half the garlic knots, if that gives you any idea of the size and amount of food given. It was all so delicious though, totally worth it. The place, when we went, only had three staff working, so it was a bit of a wait, but the place busy even for a Sunday, usually with locals. As a tip, order over the phone before heading over, as the joint does steady business. And I can see why- they didn't skimp on anything from what I can tell - from the quality and quantity of the ingredients (real garlic on the garlic knots! Two types of olives!) to the generosity of them giving complimentary plates and seasoning packets, I wholeheartedly recommend Vinny's pizza. read more

If your looking for good food and great service then don't order from here. The pizza was not very good. The wings were terrible. We had it delivered to our hotel room. When we called to complain about missing condiments because bill was 42$. Another delivery person brought his condiments. When my husband tried to talk to him about how bad it was. He was leaving and flipped my husband the middle finger. So my husband called to establishment three it four time. They kept hanging up on him. At one point the man told my husband f ck you. We took food to Vinny's 11 am next morning. Told them. Nothing was done. We're told that the owner would contact us. But alas. Never did. Don't waist your money or time read more

We caught them right as they were closing and the chef threw us in a large pizza last minute! Delicious!

I'n bummed that Vinny didn't come through for me this time. Had chicken parm & the chicken was spongy & obviously reconstituted commercial drival. Worst quality chicken I've had since the 8th grade lunch line. Why would they use that when all their other standards are much higher? Sandwich & pizza ingredients are great. I'm not giving up on Vinny but I have to advise against their chicken parm. read more

Best pizza I have had as a yinzer. I have never had NY Style pizza from New York to compare it to but this has to be it. The crust is crisp. Toppings juicy and flavorful. Cheese gooey but solid after it cools a few minutes out of the oven. Vinny's is doing it right give them a try. You won't regret it read more

Not bad pretty good pie. The two slice special is a good buy highly recommend it. About the only bad thing I can say is you will have to sit outside as it is way to hot inside. Good pizza for a to go order. read more

Really small and hard to notice but the food is great and tastes authentic. Great deals just like a fast food chain like Pizza Hut but with the real deal Italian food to back it up. I recommend taking a couple dinner entrees or a pizza home to the family or while on vacation. read more

Ugh this was horrible, please don't eat here!!! We ordered manicotti and a gyro. The gyro have almost no tzakki sauce and was mainly the wrap material. The manicotti, I ate two bites and tossed it. read more

On a spontaneous road/camping trip (aka no packed food,) Vinny's was a lifesaver! Only five minutes from our campground, & their pizza was fantastic! Their small is the size of a "normal" medium anywhere else (ask for it double sliced.) The staff was friendly & made sure our order was right every time. The only reason I didn't give it five stars is because of their pasta, it was extremely bland (& I got the cajun style.) Aside from the pasta, you can't go wrong with Vinny's! read more

Visiting St Augustine for the weekend. We ordered through Grubhub and let me tell the experience was fantastic. Hand cut sausage was what the Dr ordered. If you want NY style pizza without the high NY bulls@*t taxes. This is it. Delivery was on time and courteous. read more

It was late and we needed to eat so we decided to try this place. We ended up getting two cheese pizzas with garlic knots. The owner was cooking and was very friendly and nice as was the lady who took our order. The pizza was really good with tons of flavor. The garlic knots were great and the salad was great. This is definitely one of the hidden gems in Saint Augustine. read more

We were here from out of town and tired from a solid weekend of eating, drinking, and doing touristy things in St. Augustine. I chose this place due to proximity and of course fellow Yelp reviews :) We ordered pasta (ravioli and chicken alfredo), a super deluxe pizza and cajun ranch wings. The ravioli was solid, cheese ravioli with marinara sauce. I really enjoyed the chicken alfredo, but I ordered it 'cajun style' and it seemed kinda 'normal style' me. The cajun ranch wings were probably just a bad call on our part, I would get a different sauce if I were to order again (which I still would). The delivery was quick and best of all the food was HOT! Like, really hot. Thank you Vinny's for your quick delivery! read more

Horrible service! Forgot food. Food was cold. Took over an hour to get! Dude on phone was clueless! I'd give 0-ZERO STARS if I could!

Pizza was edible which is why I'm giving 2 stars. Otherwise skip it. Pizza was "drippy" basically a soft crust. The cheese and toppings just fell off. The Greek salad was loaded with onions. I paid almost 40 bucks for a large pizza with only half pepperoni and a Greek salad?? No thanks. read more

The pinwheels are the best thing ever! Cheesy and buttery! We love to pick some up on the way to Vilano Beach. The pizza is great too!

After ordering from Vinny's a handful of times, I've realized that there is little consistency to their pizzas. Sometimes the taste is spot on--delicious and flavorful with loads of garlic and seasoning. Other times, there is barely any flavor despite the 10 or so toppings on the Ultimate Pizza. It's truly a hit or miss with this place Furthermore, I've also experienced the poor communication that's mentioned in previous comments. I live in Vilano, right down the street from Vinny's, and so if I am told that the pizza will be ready in 30 minutes, I leave my house after that 30 minutes. Yet, oddly, the pizza always takes an additional 15/20 minutes at least. I'd love to have a reliable, local pizza place but Vinny's is just not that. read more

If I could leave less than 1 star, I probably would. Granted we didn't order the pizza, but what we did order was disgusting. First, the chicken gyro: Over-cooked chicken inside of an under-cooked pizza dough "gyro". Then, the turkey sub: let's start with the DNA (hair) that was found inside. I don't think I have to go any further. But I will...finally, the tiramisu: frozen like a block of ice. Was it supposed to be tiramisu ice cream??? Sometimes convenience isn't always better. Steer clear. read more

We ordered food for lunch delivery. Wait Time was reasonable. Food was good pizza was a bit saucey. I'm sure you can order a lighter version. Wraps were fantastic. read more

Vinny's never disappoints! Fast and friendly service always! Our faves are the pinwheels, the buffalo chicken pizza and their AMAZING garlic knots!! read more

We ordered pizza yesterday for the first time. Let me tell you, it was absolutely incredible!! Our friends from NY who've been in the south for 15 years said it's the BEST they've had since moving here. Just wish they were closer to Savannah!! read more

Pizza wasn't great! Sauce for the pizza was horrible I wouldn't recommend anyone to eat or order from there.

We ordered pizza here when vacationing in St. Augistine. We ordered the deluxe. It was a little pricey, we thought - but after it was delivered we discovered it was well worth it. Great pizza and timely delivery! The person who delivered had a mask on as well. Well done! read more

Wow! Love their pizza! The Greek is so yummy! A must try if you haven't yet. Now we just need a good taco pizza added to the list. customer service is outstanding as well! Thank you!! read more

Came to this city for vacation and stopped by here. This was the best pizza i ever tasted . The workers have great customer service and got my pizza in a very quick timely manner. I definitely need to go back for more read more

Best little pizza joint outside of New Jersey. IMO. Never had a bad slice or pie. Other food on the menu is great. Service with a smile and food is always fresh! read more

I have never written a bad review for a restaurant until tonight. Maybe we caught them on a bad night but this pizza was legit bad. I have only had bad pizza twice in my life and this was one of them. I ordered the "steak melt" and there was not a single piece of steak and the cheese was barely melted. I will say, that I ordered this through Uber eats so I am not complaining about service or staff. I work in the service industry and do not complain easily. I would like to give this place the benefit of having an off night because I know things happen but it really didn't taste good. Order at your own risk. You might have better luck ordering something else off the menu but I will not be back. read more

Decent pizza at a decent price. Vinny's is conveniently located, and they're usually pretty fast and friendly.

One bite everyone knows the rules: Lunch special, 2 slices and drink $4.99 First glance you notice the seasoning, garlic, and butter. This slice had a lot of sauce and I believe the ratios need to be proper for a good bite. With the amount of garlic butter, the rest of the flavors are lost. This is the first slice I've had that has a lot of potential but minor tweaks need to be made. 1. Little too heavy on sauce. 2. Lighten the amount of garlic butter. It was almost as if I was eating a big garlic cheese knot, not a fan. New York City flop. You can tell the sauce is homemade and the slice was cooked through. Although, I did not care for the crust. It didn't have the crunch with the pillowy inside. Decent slice and the sauce is the star here, but not too bright. Overall, lots of seasoning and a bit too much at times. Lighten on the garlic and sauce and you have a lot of potential to be the go-to slice recommendation. 5.8/10 That's a review. read more

We placed and paid for an online order. Showed up 45 minutes later and the store is closed for cleaning. Great that they are cleaning but would have been nice to update your online order system. Luckily it seems we haven't been charged but one more thing to worry about. read more

The pizza was not bad, the garlic knots were GREAT BUT.... the baked wings were horrible. They were not baked long enough you could still see the yellow skin on the under side of them...! I got the Cajun flavored but they were pretty bland. Overall it was OK... but stick with the pizza or the garlic knots! read more

This place might have the best pizza, but we'll never know. Middle of October and all the restaurants in St. Augustine are open for dine in, but not this place! Self restricted no dine in? Business genius? We drove 3 minutes and ate at Borrillo's. read more

Seriously delicious. The calzone and gyro salad were exceptional. Would recommend to anyone who enjoys fresh, tasty food.