The wait staff was very friendly and the service was fine. Unfortunately the cooks are unable to cook a steak. This place tried to serve me raw steak and I know better than to send back a steak but I sent my steak back and asked them to cook it. The waitress returned my steak and it was still raw. Very uncomfortable situation in fact I'm surprised they made me pay for a raw steak that I did not eat. Ekes methinks not I will not be back. Perhaps Gordon Ramsay can feature this place on Kitchen Nightmares read more

Village Pantry - Diners Near Me - Eureka, California

Good service and friendly staff willing to accommodate to requests but the food is mediocre. I only recommend it if you are staying in a hotel/motel next to it. read more

Yummy!!! The best food!!! They have the best cinnamon rolls and western bacon cheeseburger! You've also got to try the milkshakes!! Good service all around, nice family business! read more

As my favorite Washingtonian and I walked into the Village Pantry on Christmas Day I proclaimed, "This may well be the best Christmas of my adult life." I have, in part, this homely little restaurant to thank for that. The food's nothing special, in fact it's a lot like a Denny's or Carrows, though I've had better tasting food at both. Though rare, this restaurant's loveliness had nothing at all to do with the food which I was most happy to overlook. It was about enjoying Christmas on my own terms and drama-free! Finally! Our fabulous server, Melissa, must've been the most ebullient individual I've come in contact with recently. She swirled around the restaurant, filled mostly with Eureka locals, and made every single person feel special - I witnessed her hi-fiving people and she left us a couple of candy canes. If you're headed north on 101, you can't miss the Village Pantry. Five stars for renewing my Christmas spirit! read more

I come here all the time on Sunday after church with my family and they love it! Wish it was open 24/7 though so me and my husband can come here on a date! read more

On a whim I stopped by there today for a Patty Melt. This was by far the best Patty Melt I have ever had in my life! Loaded with cheese and onion and the Jewish Rye was toasted to perfection. There was so much food I couldn't finish it all. The whole bill was about $13.00 A deal! read more

Not the worlds best food or anything, basic diner. But the prices are great, the portions are good, and nothing ever tastes gross or sloppy. Wayyyyy better than Denny's. Staff is always friendly, place is always clean. Service is fast, unless it's packed then it's as fast as it can be. I never see any staff goofing off, but even in a rush they are kind and remember everything. read more

food was decent price was high service was fine why play the loud music? the crew seemed to like it, but not good for a weary traveler

Great service. Awesome food!! Perfectly sized portions for medium to large appetites.

This local coffee shop is great! Especially if Amie is working (weekend nights). She does it all. Hosts, waits, busses, and with a smile. The owner really should pay her extra. She runs that place for them. The food is good. Some excellent like the tuna melt and breakfasts. You just have to see! If it's busy, be patient, they'll get to you. Pick up a local paper, have a coffee, and relax! read more

I waited near the "please wait to be seated" sign . Directly in front of me was a cashier station and a man who had just answered the phone. He was taking a phone order. He glanced up at me then began writing down the phone order. After waiting for at least 5 mins, a gentleman who had already eaten walked up to the side of the cashier station. He saw me waiting so he waited to the side. The gentleman on the phone was still on the phone but concluded the call several minutes later. He glanced my way then back at the guy waiting to pay. He then proceeds to help the guy paying for his completed meal. I don't have a problem with the man being cashed out first. But take the time to acknowledge me and be polite enough to say something like, I'll be with you in one moment. Instead, I felt like I was purposely being ignored. I will spend my money at restaurants where I feel appreciated. Here I did not. read more

I do not understand the bad reviews. The food was delicious. The service was great. I will eat here anytime I drive thru Eureka. read more

Village Pantry - This place is absolutley delicious. - Diners Near Me - Eureka, California

I have to travel up there from San Jose CA every two weeks and ALWAYS have a meal here. It's located right next to the Holiday Inn(one of the better places to stay) so you can walk right over at anytime and get your party something to eat. The food is always on point and there seems to always be fresh coffee. read more

Not sure what the hell happened tonight, but the manager was more interested in talking to the cooks than seating customers that walked in. When the dishwasher tried to get his attention, he still ignored us, so the dishwasher seated us and got us drinks. Dinner took way longer than usual. Seemed to be only 1 waitress, but she seemed to walk every direction except past us. She is usually great!! She walked near us several times and never checked on us or refilled out water. Then when we were done eating, we probably sat there for almost 20 mins waiting for our bill. It really started to feel like we were being ignored and we always leave a good tip...20% or more!! With just 1 waitress the manager should have been hopping all over the floor checking on everyone. He even sat at a table of regulars and bullshitted with them. I'll give you two guesses where we won't be going anytime soon....and will spread the word!!! read more

This is an excellent family restaurant. They are open 24 hours! And the service is attentive and professional and friendly. I will come here every time I visit Eureka. read more

1. Atmosphere is very homie... 2. The bathrooms haven't been cleaned since 1973 and my shoes were sticking to the urine flavored tile... 3. The gentleman that was running the front and serving tables was very friendly. He seemed to really care about people... 4. The food was average diner food... No surprise there... 5. Probably the best food in town... read more

I happened to be in eureka for 24 hours, and was looking a a place to get breakfast. We stopped by in the evening for my cousin to a slice of pie, and me a beer,it was good. The following morning we came back for breakfast before heading into the tall trees. We had the same sever/host as the night before, he was very polite, and attentive. I ordered the oatmeal with fruit... my cousin got a huge breakfast that he had trouble finishing. The food , and coffee were great. It's an American diner style menu, looked like you could get breakfast at anytime. Not much in the way of food for vegans that I noticed , but the oatmeal and toast for breakfast was more than enough to hold me over until much later that day. They were very quick to sanitize the tables and keep up with the hungry people coming in, while observing the social distancing, and mask guidelines. I'll stop here again when I'm Eureka next. read more

I came here at 2 am with my friends and the service was amazing! We had good food and we were fed quickly. We had left Denny's because we sat there for 10 minutes without waters. And had our food in 10 minutes at the Pantry. Very satisfied! read more

HABANERO TOBASCO! BE MINE!! So if you look up Village Pantry in Arcata, CA, you can see all the great pictures of this little diner. I seem to have done some erroneous pic posting :) The habanero Tobasco is pictured there, in all it's glory. It was soooo late at night when we stopped in here. I wanted something to eat and can pretty much always go for a crispy hashbrown. Even though he'd just had hot chocolate at the casino, husband wanted MORE hot chocolate. Two amazing things happened while we sat here. First, I learned about Tobasco's new habanero hot sauce. F*kn awesome. It was good! I put it all over my hashbrowns and spoon. I felt it would be too hard to steal this since the place was empty, but the thought crossed my mind. It was the best thing about the hashbrowns, which were crispy-ish, but so greasy I actually took a napkin to them, and I NEVER do that until it hits a certain level of grossy greasy. The second great thing was the hot chocolate, which comes in a mini mug, has a free refill. He opted for a refill but just couldn't get the second one down. Too much chocolate! It was very rich and good. Whipped cream on top. Service was nice. I felt bad for the waitress who had to work such late hours. She did a good job! Total $11.68 - (husband had pancakes too but I didn't try these) read more

Great meal with quality food in large quantity, at a reasonable price. Must stop while in Eureka. read more

Village Pantry - Ground Sirloin steak mash potatoes, Cole slaw, grilled onions/peppers/mushrooms, Texas toast, and beef barley soup - Diners Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Went here for breakfast with a group of 7 before a graduation cermony. Typical diner atmosphere similar to a IHOP or a Coco's. Had a group of 7 and was seated right away. Wait staff was friendly and helpful. Prices were typical breakfast place prices and within reason. Food took a little long (but could be expected with a large group like ours). Food was hot and tasty. One plus I liked was they kept my coffee mug full. Never had to look around for a waitress to get more coffee, they were on the ball with the coffee here. Very family friendly restaurant. Talked with a local guy and he said this has always been a great place for breakfast read more

Basically, a local version of Denny's, with slightly better food. Diner prices ($7-12 per dinner, $4-8 per appetizer, cheap sodas, coffee, etc.) and booths make this a grandma and pop type eatery- I know my gramps would love it! I got a side salad and seasoned fries (*nooo vegetarian options!!*) and the salad was a little overpriced, but the fries were yummy. Nothing too special, but it's open late and serves edible food. Better than Denny's, at least! read more

The Village Pantry was a delightful place to eat a savory breakfast. Prices were a little high, but the portions were generous so it evened out. Service was very polite and quick to get us anything we needed. Overall a very satisfying meal and would definitely go back! read more

First time going the other day at around 11pm. We got baby back ribs and salmon steak. Worst food in humboldt. With a 40$ total it was trash. Everything was just dry and bland. Please just go to denny's or any dinner in humboldt other than this one and save the trouble. read more

I had the best breakfast I have had since moving to Eureka. My service was excellent. I always I've said in the past how can you go wrong with eggs but since being here I found out how you could possibly go wrong with eggs my breakfast potatoes were so flavorful and perfectly cooked I asked for my English muffin to be well done and it was well done without being burned which is rare and my omelette was fluffy and cooked to perfection great job thank you read more

Bought a chicken burger with onion rings to go and it was very fresh and tasty. I saw a lot of other things that looked appealing on the menu. I would stop by again if in the area. Recommended for a quality meal at a table or on the road. read more

Stopped for dessert late on a Friday night. The selection of pies was great. We had the Apple-berry crisp with ice cream & this should be your first choice, but the Marion - blackberry was also very good. The service was very friendly. read more

Seriously the best breakfast around food quality ,taste and price. I have not been to Village Pantry in many years now I remember why I always went there. I will be back for great food I have been missing out on. Great variety for kids also. read more

How do you stay open!? Ordered a steak (I'm a chef) and it tasted like meat that had soured. Didn't eat it...didn't even bring it home for my dog. Just plain gross. read more

Just had an order of chicken strips they were obviously previously frozen and seemed to be warmed up like something you get from Walmart. The fries were the same. The potatos were obviously power and were overly watered down and the gravy was straight from jar of Walmart again. I ordered the prime rib 5 minutes to 1700 "which is there serving time" so it would be fresh, it wasn't. The only reason why I have this place 2 stars is because of the service of the hostess. read more

Great food and doesnt break your wallet! Love that thet always get my order right the first time and they are always friendly. I never have to ask for a refill on coffee because the waitresses always top it off! If you want great honest food snd customer service eat at the pantry! Thank You, Phillip Hubbs read more

Always good food and good service...eaten multiple times there....nothing is ever done wrong and all of the staff are very friendly. The biscuits and gravy x2 is at an amazing g price and I highly recommend that. read more

Village Pantry - Mushroom swiss yum - Diners Near Me - Eureka, California

Our waitress Kim was a Shining star who rose over the top! EUREKA!!! The pie was yummy! A must try. read more

Today was my first visit. I'd driven 7 hours and it was walking distance from hotel. I had the rib eye. It was overcooked and topped with canned mushrooms. The toast that same with it had been soaked in butter and had a ton of garlic salt, making it inedible. The booths have rips and tears in them. I ordered a slice of pie to go (hearing they were homemade). I got back to hotel with no utensils. The pie was not very good. More like blackberry jam filled...there's no way it was homemade. read more

My boyfriend took me to this diner and I must say that the food was delicious! Ordered a hot meatloaf sandwich wasn't expecting it to be big and smothered with gravy and mash potatoes. Most importantly the service was superb! 2 waitresses collaborating and working well together was definitely the cherry on top. You don't see that too often especially in this hard time and at a restaurant. Courtney and Heather thank you so much you two were great, very sweet and courteous. Great service! read more

This place is open 24 hours!! you must try their vegetable barley beef soup its FANTASTIC. Their dinners come with a soup or Salad I recommend you definitely try a cup of their soup, if you're looking for something more simpler I'd go with a bowl of the soup it's really filling and it's super tasty. read more

Haven't had food this disgusting for a long time. The hash browns were burnt but mushy on the inside. The bacon tasted like it had been soaked in bacon grease for a while. The French toast did not even taste anywhere close to what it's supposed to. Then they wouldn't refund me bc "the food wasn't there". Yeah bc I forced myself to eat as much as I could, when finally I decided I didn't deserve that. What cooks do you guys hire If you want to be disappointed, stop in! read more

I just stopped by to get a " homemade" pie.the waitress told me that they freeze some of the pies after they make them.then o noticed when she was unrapping my "homemade" pie that it wasn't wrapped like a pie they made it was industrial wrapping like Mrs Smith or something similar. When we finished dinner, I broke out the pie and it was so obvious this was store bought. I've had pies at the pantry before.. This one isn't from there.Its terrible. You guys lied.then I called to see what they would say on the phone. This lady was honest enough to tell me that they don't make the pumpkin or the pecan in house.if this pie was decent I would not complain but give me a break......shameful read more

Only friendly to people they know. We live in the area (but don't wear camo) so I guess the regular bleach blonde waitress feels like she can be rude to us. 3rd time we've tried here and the last. We had to listen to her complain to the guy (she knew) in the booth next to us. How crappy her day was, is the wife back in town etc. We had some marginal chicken noodle soup served with no eye contact. At least at Denny's they aren't so snotty. read more

From midnight pancakes to mid day steaks I love going to the village pantry with friends I've always had good experiences there and the food is well priced and not hard to have bigger eyes then your stomach. read more