Exciting to have an Udon Shin in Arizona! I hate to say it, but we were extremely disappointed. My group went on the Grand Opening Day- we were the second and third tables to be sat: I have mixed feelings, so I'll be sorting my review into three categories: Food, Ambiance, and Service.
-----
Food: The flavor of the food was excellent. We received our entrees before the starters, which I would not have preferred. The carbonara udon was EXCELLENT: the bacon was flavorful and the tempura batter was crisp. The egg and the butter tasted wonderful with the noodles. The udon had divine texture and flavor. I also enjoyed my partner's A5 Wagyu Bukkake- however, the portion of meat was small for the price (almost fifty dollars!) and staff forgot the broth part of the udon for about ten minutes. The Hamachi Crudo was very beautiful, but I didn't feel as though the amount or flavor were stellar for the price. The sauce was difficult to eat.
Our group also split the Wagyu Sandos- the meat was buttery, and the caviar added a perfect touch of freshness. I did feel as though the milk bread was a tad oily (this is a nitpick; it was still AWESOME). If the bread was less oily it would have been ABSOLUTELY perfect.
Ambiance: The interior was lovely. We did not feel like we were in Mesa, Arizona. The corridor to take shoes off was narrow and crowded- bring shoes that are easy to remove. I also appreciated the beautifully thin water glasses and elegant light fixtures. The presentation of the food was upscale. Beautiful craftsmanship!
Service: The service was, respectfully, awful.
Firstly, we came as a group of 8- I asked that the host seat us nearby our other half of the group, and they did not. We had the same server, so not sure why they did not just seat us at two tables next to one another- it would have been easier for all involved.
Upon sitting, we were asked if we would prefer sparkling or still water. Assuming it was complementary, we all chose still. We later found out each water was NINE DOLLARS (the soda was cheaper!) with no alternative initially given. After we had unknowingly accepted the premium water, only on our refill did the server conveniently mention there was tap water available- felt very deceptive. Especially after waiting for 3 hours in the heat, it should have been disclosed that the first offered option was not complementary.
Our server also repeatedly brought the wrong food out- firstly, our starters came out after we had essentially finished our udon. One member of our party ordered the kake udon with bacon tempura- first, they brought out the bukkake udon (he did not order that), and then they brought the kake udon with shrimp tempura (he does not eat shrimp), and then after a long period, the bacon tempura finally arrived, alongside a side of a sauce and grated daikon (staff did not explain why these items were also given).
My partner also ordered the A5 Wagyu Bukkake- and they forgot to bring out the pour over sauce for about ten minutes. At nearly fifty dollars, all components of the meal should be served together.
We were also charged for a beer and a cola, that the OTHER HALF OF OUR PARTY ordered, not us. Afterwards, a different member of staff said our paying party member that he would be refunded for the error, with no real apology or offer to compensate for any other issues, such as the lack of sauce, receiving the wrong order 3 times in a row, etc.
Finally, we felt as though the server was not prepared. For the grand opening, staff should be trained adequately. He appeared nervous, did not explain most items on the menu, repeatedly forgot items that we ordered (even with a notepad), and did not introduce himself. A different member of staff had to come and help several times, and then after that member had helped, our initial server came back and repeated the same info. It felt like staff were not communicating with one another at all.
Staff also seemed annoyed when we pointed out we were wrongly charged. The other members of our party on the opposite end at least had a dessert and their waters compensated- we were not offered anything.
-----
TL,DR: Food was excellent, but service was very bad for the price point. I understand first day jitters, but for the price point, the experience was horrendous. I had high expectations for the grand opening, but ultimately I and my group, were very let down. We were among the first customers in the restaurant- during a grand opening at a luxury price point, staff should be prepared to provide the best experience possible.
Furthermore, my friends who visited Udon Shin in Japan remarked that it was FAR cheaper for water and pricing was much more transparent. (I understand import fees, but 9 DOLLARS for water with no initial alternative disclosed is ridiculous.)
Honestly, we feel robbed. Two stars for food and ambiance. We will not be returning unless service improves. :( Disappointing! read more