The food was delicious and the service great. Small so a reservation is a must.

It was delicious. I enjoyed the pasta and meatballs. Interesting menu. I would like to go back soon.

I can't say enough. Great staff, wonderful food and a terrific atmosphere. Their wine is on point and perfectly paired with their entrees. A wonderful addition to downtown York. read more

We had a great time at a local restaurant tonight--We took a friend out to Tutoni's for her surprise birthday dinner there. Not only was our server, Emily more than accommodating, but the food was amazing! I have a food allergy and a lot of restrictions and she made sure I got exactly what I wanted!! They brought our cake (which they kept in back for us) out with the candles lit, and everything was perfect. I'm so very impressed. Thank you for the fabulous service. read more

Wonderfully authentic farm to table cuisine in York City. Valet service. Cozy atmosphere. Engaged owners. Lovely wait staff. Interesting cocktails and a diverse menu. Three floors that cater to a variety of tastes and appetites; and, a fourth coming soon! My party of four will definitely return. I would highly recommend this restaurant for a lovely romantic night out or for a group of friends who enjoy great food and drink. read more

Just had our first meal at Tutoni's and it was outstanding!!! Reasonably priced with a great atmosphere. We will definitely be going back soon!!! A++ read more

Incredible meal! My wife had a version of chicken marsala and I had the braised short rib gnocchi...both phenomenal! The staff was knowledgeable and friendly...also we took the time to have a pre dinner drink upstairs, highly recommend their scratch cocktails! The owner Toni came around and shared her passion for the business and food with us...can't wait to go back again and again! read more

Farm to table is great if you're going to cook the dishes well. Nothing we ordered was seasoned at all. The people at the table next to us stopped eating until they were brought salt and pepper. This was an overpriced disappointment. read more

I took my wife here specifically for the gnocchi and when the server tells us about the menu, she regrets to inform us that they ran out of gnocchi. So that was a bummer. Otherwise, this might be one of the nicest and most authentic restaurants in all of York. read more

Gave my husband a surprise 70th birthday party at Tutoni's. Twenty four people unanimously agreed that their dinners were fantastic. From the steak to the gnocchi and the ravioli, I heard nothing but rave reviews. The service was excellent, also. Dealing with Amber to plan the event went smoothly and she was there to make sure everything went as planned! read more

The lobster ravioli is not eye appealing or tasty at all. The ravioli was all swished together in one bowl. We have been to other restaurants where the indiviudal raviolis were on a single plate separated from each other.{ It was difficult to taste any lobster.} Then a magnifisent sauce on top. The sauce on these raviolis was dark and not tasty at all. The artichoke pasta was disappointing. Too may black olives and very salty tasting. Staff was wonderful as well as the ambiance read more

The staff was wonderful. Very clean. Decorated beautifully but I was not pleased with how small my meal was. I did leave wanting more on my plate but I am a big eater. I will go back! read more

Love! Love!! Love!!! this place! Attention to detail is evident from the moment you enter the restaurant. From the charmingly eclectic decor to the attentive staff to the incredibly original menu, Tutonis hits the mark on every level. Our meal was well prepared and excellently presented. Every course was remarkable, the farm to table freshness evident in every delicious bite. Kudos to the talented chef and owners. You have something special here! I will return again and again. Sandy D read more

We loved it! Beautiful room, wonderful food, warm and friendly management and staff. The lamb tortellini appetizer is spectacular and we got the good news that they may be giving it entree status...we would have been very happy to eat three or four appetizer-size servings! To the reviewer who was so distressed at being asked if he wanted still or sparkling water and that it's BYOB...I actually thought you were kidding when i read your review! There's no need to respond to your first issue. As for the second, most people are aware that a liquor license is pending and many people even see BYOB as an asset. No worries...Tutoni's is here to stay. read more

Wonderful experience from the level of service we received from Sarah, our server to the quality of food and simply the ambiance of the restaurant. Both my husband and I were attending a concert and another couple joined us. This was their first experience and they enjoyed the restaurant as much as we did. Definitely one of our favorites in York, PA read more

Finally had an opportunity to eat here and it was fantastic. I enjoyed the house salad and beef tartare for lunch and both were amazing. Looking forward to trying dinner here soon! Ambiance and decor are awesome. Definitely recommend! read more

Wonderful service and wonderful food. The dishes were not out of this world, or particularly interesting, but they were yummy and just right for a nice (but not too nice!) night out. We had the Bolgonese and the Chicken Gemeli and were impressed by their quality. We were visiting from out of town and had a great time. Great Sangrias! read more

I went on a Saturday night with my wife. Exceptional experience. We sat at the bar upstairs and had a great time. The atmosphere is great with a butcher block bar with mason jar lights. The bar has a special cocktail menu, we tried the King George and PA Club, both were great. We had the Carbonara and the Meatball Bucatini and both were exceptional. If you are looking for an adult, upscale relaxed place, this is it. Bartenders were friendly and made great drinks. read more

Warm greeting by Toni is duplicated by her staff through out the restaurant. Molly waiting on us was excellent at customer service. You are not just a customer, you are family at Tutoni's. Food is amazing. Simplicity at its best. Love the idea of local products. Bar is a must to visit. Thank you for the wonderful five star experience. We will be back. read more

The experience was absolutely 5 stars!! The service was excellent-our waitress was knowledgeable about the menu and the ingredients and our courses were timed perfectly (Thanks Lauren). The food and cocktails were unique and delicious! Had the charcuterie platter, the grilled vegetable salad and the goat cheese manicotti with red velvet dessert. Went upstairs to the bar after dinner for one last drink. Such a charming decor with little details that make you say "wow"! We are already planning our next dinner there with our friends. read more

Went to Tutoni's on Saturday night. First trip there. Was very impressed with the decor/atmosphere. The staff appeared very welcoming and the place was full of class. Ordered an appetizer and had to ask for silverware about 8 minutes after receiving it. Later, found a lady bug in my delicious pre dinner salad. We informed the waitress and her response was...well I'm not surprised we get the produce from...(local farm). There was very little concern that the produce was obviously not washed thoroughly. She took my salad away at my request and took my silverware with her and said she would take the $8 salad off of my bill. Our food came out after a long wait and yet again I had no silverware. I am all about understanding that bugs happen and I know it is sometimes hard to keep them out of food. However, when there is a $30 meal in front of me, I expect my food to be bug free and shouldn't have to ask for eating utensils. It would have been nice to have more concern on the part of the restaurant . On the fence if I will return. read more

A York Classic. Very upscale and worth the wait on a Saturday night.

Tutoni's is my favorite farm to table restaurant in York, Pennsylvania located in walking distance to the Appel Performing Arts Center and easily accessible during first Friday events. The atmosphere is comfortable and upscale. One favorite thing that I rarely find elsewhere are very creatively concocted non-alcoholic drinks made with ginger and lime and other mixes. Once with my friends we went in just for dessert, but everything was so good we ended up eating an entire meal in reverse order. read more

Great food. The menu is has a good variety of food. The healthy portion of salmon was delicious. The wait staff was courteous and welcoming. The staff presented a classy setting - pouring water, towel over the arm, very polite, etc. Wonderful staff. The seating isn't very intimate. There may have been another are, but we were in a room behind the hostess area. All the seats were very close together. We felt like we were sitting with the group next to us. We made reservations about a week and half ahead of time. I struck out a few times with drink choices. One drink was on the menu, but they didn't have it in stock. Two drinks I requested weren't available, but I thought were pretty common. An extended bar menu would bump this up to a 5. read more

Delicious food and the atmosphere is outstanding! Great place for a wonderful dinner with your favorite person or a girls night out!

My husband and I went there tonight and we can't say enough good things about this restaurant. The atmosphere was nice. Our appetizers, entrees and desserts were all great. Our waitress was very patient with us and our dietary restrictions. The manager spoke to us several times as well. We can't wait to go back! read more

We went there for the first time tonight. The food was delicious! The service was awesome! The manager was very attentive to us as well.

We can't even remember why we stopped coming here but I am so happy we came back!! Both of our entrees were extraordinary! Dave got the sweet corn and lump crab fettuccine and I got the bolognese with gf pasta. We shared a gf calamari that was to die for. Really yummy Chianti, Querceto, enhanced a fabulous meal! Ask for Vanessa! Can't wait to come back! read more

I was there for lunch with a friend and worst service ever! My hamburg was great but my french fries must have been cooked the day before and someone forgot to nuke them. Cold cold and more cold. Sadly I won't go back because the service was just that bad. Too many other places to dine rather then waste my time and money there. Shirley read more

Finally had the opportunity to eat here, for a business dinner. Wine selection great, wait staff knowledgeable,food extremely fresh, to have Italian food accommodate gluten free diet, especially locally to this area, is rare. I will def be back with my family. read more

Never have I been impressed with this place. Way pricey for the service and food. The first time I went I ordered a specific beer. They came back and told me they were out. So I chose another. Then my son ordered scallops. Which they didn't have. I then ordered and they were out of that. Been there a couple other times and it has been better, but not a fan of the food especially for the price. read more

Waitress was slow and the food runners didn't know where orders needed to go. They're new so I'm sure this will change. Food was delicious. Portion size is small and a bit pricey. We had bread, an appetizer, main entrees and a dessert each and it wasn't much food. Plan on going for a snack after you're done. The decor is beautiful and they did a great job with creating an ambiance. Not sure if we will go back but glad we gave them a shot! read more

Our go-to for a drink or fine dining in York City. This gem has led the resurgence of high-end night life in York. The upstairs wine-bar is super hip with fine wines and creative cocktails. The cuisine is a contemporary takes on Italian comfort food. Service is decent but could be better for the price. Fun urban row home meets hand-scraped barn boards ambiance. read more

Celebrated my husband's birthday at Tutoni's on Friday night. Everything was lovely! The food was top notch and they had a few little surprises for him. I asked them to pick a special bottle of wine out for him and the choice did not disappoint. Perfect place for a special dinner! read more

Tutoni's restaurant is the most refreshing experience I have had since moving to York. The atmosphere is very intimate and authentic to it's Italian cuisine. I got the Steak meal and was very impressed with the taste of the meat. The steak was cooked perfectly. Also I could recommend the meatballs for an appetizer, they are amazing! The cork fee is $5 for wine, so our bill was much lower than would be expected for food of this quality. While we were there my fiance and I spoke with Toni and she was very happy to answer our questions and accept our praise. This is exactly the kind of restaurant York needs. Bravo Toni/y's. read more

It truly pains me to write this review because I've had a bunch of good experiences at Tutoni's before. However, the service my group received last night was literally the worst service I have ever experienced in my life and I simply can't remain silent after how we were treated. We arrived at 6:45 and were greeted by Toni and told there would be a 45 minute wait. We were fine with the wait and Toni told us we could go downstairs to King George (speak easy) and she would text us when our table was ready. King George was beautifully decorated with a great atmosphere and we enjoyed our time there. We noticed that two groups who came in after us had gotten up and left to go back upstairs around 7:45. One of our group members went upstairs to see what was going on with the wait time and interacted with Toni again. Toni admitted that she had sat two groups before us and didn't know that we were downstairs in King George. Keep in mind that Toni was the one who directed us down there in the first place and had our phone number. We don't receive an apology. Toni says, "I'll have a table for you in three minutes. and I'm going to take care of your appetizers." Great! We wait around and five minutes later (7:55), Toni comes back to tell us that it will be an additional five minutes. This time, she says, "How about you go upstairs and check out the bar up there? I'll take care of all of your drinks. I'll personally go up there and let them know." We head upstairs and get our drinks (which were delicious). As we were sipping on our drinks, we watched other customers be seated and Toni walked right by us (8:15 - 20 minutes after being promised that it would be 5 minutes) without saying a word. She finally comes over to our group and says to one of us, "I saw you giving me that look. You thought I forgot about you. I didn't." Toni walks away from the group and just stares at us while we waited there, unsure of what she was getting at. Turns out, she was trying to seat us but you never would have guessed that from her tone, body language, or actions. We were really tempted just to leave at this point but begrudgingly decided to stay. Our waitress was friendly and helpful with the menu since most of the group hadn't been there before. We ordered two appetizers and the server recommended a third so we went with it. I had to mention to the server that Toni had promised she would comp our appetizers as well which is an awkward conversation that no customer should ever have to initiate. Every time I've been at Tutoni's before, they always provided some bread and oils for the table but we never received those. I'm not sure if that's a recent change across the board or if it was just another part of our bad service experience for the evening. The appetizers came out in a reasonable amount of time and were absolutely delicious! We each ordered our entree and received them in a reasonable amount of time as well. Keep in mind that we were completely starving by this point as it was around 9:10. All our entrees were delicious. However, my girlfriend ordered the salmon and while it was cooked on the ends, it was raw in the middle. Our waitress didn't come back to check on us until about 15 minutes after we were served. When she asked how things were, I began telling her that the salmon was raw in the middle and she literally walked away right in the middle of when I was talking directly to her. All of us looked at each other, horrified and in disbelief at what just happened. Our server never returned until much later. We had to flag down the other server in the room who told us, "That's actually normal. We cook it that way here. I always tell my tables about that." Nowhere on the menu does it state that and our server never mentioned it either. If you're going to serve fish that is raw in the middle (pure pink), you need to communicate that to your customers up front. I've never been anywhere else and encountered such a practice. Again, no apology or anything from anyone. We were just talked down to like we were the ones in the wrong for not appreciating their style. It was straight up insulting that we had to argue with a server (who wasn't even our own) about raw fish. At this point, we were all beyond frustrated and just wanted to get out of there. We waited for about 10 minutes after we talked with the other server and our server never returned to our table to apologize or even check on us. At this point, I went downstairs to seek out Toni. I found her eating downstairs at a table and informed her of our experience. She apologized and said she'd be right up to take care of things with our table. While I was talking to Toni, our server finally returned to ask whether we wanted desert. Toni came up to talk to us and kept reiterating, "You were clearly the one table that got away from us tonight. We didn't take care of you at all. I'll look into what happened with server and the kitchen" See Facebook for the rest of the review! read more

Service was very poor, especially for a Sat night. We had a higher expectation for the quality of food.

One of the best meals I've had in York. Came with my fiancé for Valentine's Day and we shared a winter squash bruschetta appetizer which was so tasty and also quite a large portion size for a low price! Then he had Sardinian gnocchi which had a unique and lovely flavor while I had the Chilean sea bass which was cooked perfectly with a slightly seared and crispy crust. We finished with a homemade cheesecake which had a nice texture and pleasant flavor. read more

Great little restaurant. Authentic Italian food. Took my wife their for her Birthday. The food we had was amazing with the fresh pasta and sauces definitely will be going back! You can tell they take pride in their dishes! As a chef I can appreciate the hard work they put in to their dishes. read more

Everything was wonderful - from the atmosphere, to the food (which rivals similar eateries in New York, Philly and Baltimore) and the service...York is lucky to have a restaurant like this one! read more